86th Street station (Second Avenue Subway)

History

Background

The Second Avenue Line was originally proposed in 1919 as part of a massive expansion of what would become the Independent Subway System (IND). Work on the line never commenced, as the Great Depression crushed the economy. Numerous plans for the Second Avenue Subway appeared throughout the 20th century, but these were usually deferred due to lack of funds. In anticipation of the never-built new subway line, the Second and Third Avenue elevated lines were demolished in 1942 and 1955, respectively. The Second Avenue Elevated had one station at 86th Street and Second Avenue—right above the same intersection where the subway station is locatedSee:

• {{cite web |access-date=January 25, 2009 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20090127041414/http://nycsubway.org/lines/2ndave-el.html |archive-date=January 27, 2009 |url-status=live

• {{cite web |access-date=January 25, 2009 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20090130064659/http://stationreporter.net/2avl.htm |archive-date=January 30, 2009 |url-status=dead

• {{cite web |access-date=January 25, 2009 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20090127041419/http://nycsubway.org/lines/3rdave-el.html |archive-date=January 27, 2009 |url-status=live

• {{cite web |access-date=January 25, 2009 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20100609061601/http://www.stationreporter.net/3avl.htm |archive-date=June 9, 2010 |url-status=dead

Unrealized proposals

The Metropolitan Transportation Authority proposed a full-length Second Avenue Subway as part of its 1968 Program for Action. The line was to be built in two phases—the first phase from 126th to 34th Streets, the second phase from 34th to Whitehall Streets. The line's planned stops in Manhattan, spaced farther apart than those on existing subway lines, proved controversial; the Second Avenue line was criticized as a "rich man's express, circumventing the Lower East Side with its complexes of high-rise low- and middle-income housing and slums in favor of a silk stocking route." There was to be a station at 86th Street, but the next station north would be at 106th Street and the next station south would be at 57th Street. In a planning report, a possible 86th Street station had already been confirmed.

All Second Avenue Subway stations built under the Program for Action would have included escalators, high intensity lighting, improved audio systems, platform edge strips, and non-slip floors to accommodate the needs of the elderly and people with disabilities, but no elevators. Space at each station would have been used for ancillary facilities. The stations were to be made with brick walls and pavers alongside stainless steel, and would have relatively small dimensions, with 10 ft mezzanine ceilings. Gruzen & Partners received a contract for the design of the 86th Street station.

A combination of Federal and State funding was obtained, and despite the controversy over the number of stops and route, a groundbreaking ceremony was held on October 27, 1972, at Second Avenue and 103rd Street. Although work on the 86th Street station never commenced, three short segments of tunnel in East Harlem and Chinatown were built. However, the city soon experienced its most dire fiscal crisis yet, due to the stagnant economy of the early 1970s, combined with the massive outflow of city residents to the suburbs, and in September 1975, construction on the line stopped, and the tunnels were sealed.

In 1999, the Regional Plan Association considered a full-length Second Avenue Subway, which include 86th Street as one of its planned 31 stations. The main station entrance would be at 86th Street to the north, with additional exits between 86th and 82nd Streets to the south.

Construction

In March 2007, plans for the construction of the Second Avenue Subway were revived. The line's first phase, the "first major expansion" to the New York City Subway in more than a half-century, included three stations in total (at 72nd, 86th, and 96th Streets), which collectively cost $4.45 to $4.5 billion.*

Its construction site was designated as being from 105th Street and Second Avenue to 63rd Street and Third Avenue. The MTA awarded a $337 million contract—one that included constructing the tunnels between 92nd and 63rd Streets, building a launch box for the tunnel boring machine (TBM) at 92nd to 95th Streets, and erecting access shafts at 69th and 72nd Streets—to Schiavone Construction, Skanska USA Civil, and J.F. Shea Construction. The line's construction commenced on April 15, 2007, though planning for the station was finalized in June 2007, when the station entrances' locations were confirmed.

On September 15, 2011, the contract for building the station was awarded to the joint venture of Skanska USA and Traylor Bros Inc. , the cavern stretching from 83rd to 87th Streets was 57% excavated. By July 2013, construction of the station was 53% complete. The final blast for the 86th Street station was completed for an escalator cavern on November 22, 2013. Skanska/Traylor were still installing waterproofing and steel reinforcement, as well as putting concrete around the cavern, entrances, and ancillaries. , entrances 1 and 2 were being built, and excavation was 100% complete; , the station shell was complete, bringing the total Second Avenue Subway project progress to three-fourths completion.

The station was scheduled to be completed by May 16, 2016, but the estimated completion date was pushed back to October 2016. In October 2016, concerns arose that the station might not open on time because workers had only installed 10 of the station's 13 escalators. However, the 86th Street station passed all required systems testing by December 18, 2016. The station opened on January 1, 2017.

Station layout

The 86th Street station is served by Q trains at all times, some N trains during rush hours, and one northbound R train during the AM rush hours. The station is between 96th Street to the north and 72nd Street to the south. It has two tracks and an island platform. The station is built so that it is more wide open than most other underground stations in the system; its architecture, along with two other Second Avenue Subway stations, was compared to a Washington Metro station by Michael Horodniceanu, President of MTA Capital Construction. The deep-level platform is 93 feet (28 m) below ground. The platform for the 86th Street station, like the other Second Avenue Subway stations, is 27.8 ft wide. As with other stations on the first phase of the Second Avenue Subway, it was designed and engineered by a joint venture of Arup and AECOM.

The station has air-cooling systems to make it at least 10 F-change cooler than other subway stations during the summer. This requires the station to have large ventilation and ancillary buildings, rather than traditional subway grates. The station is also compliant with current fire codes, whereas most existing stations are not. Additionally, the station is waterproofed with concrete liners and fully drained. In early plans, the Second Avenue Subway was supposed to have platform screen doors to assist with air-cooling, energy savings, ventilation, and track safety, but this plan was scrapped in 2012 as cost-prohibitive. According to an internal study prepared for the MTA in 2020, the 86th Street station could theoretically accommodate half-height platform edge doors. Full-height platform screen doors would be possible but would necessitate the installation of structural bracing and relocation of several mechanical systems.

Artwork

In 2009, MTA Arts & Design selected Chuck Close from a pool of 300 potential artists to create the artwork for the station. His work consists of a series of twelve portraits of the city's cultural figures, spread over 1000 sqft of wall. Each 10 ft piece is made with tiles that are painted to create a mosaic-like effect. The pieces cost $1 million and were installed near the exits and in the mezzanines.

Close's portraits at the station, titled Subway Portraits, fall into two main categories. The first category of portraits comprises artists whom Close is familiar with. The station contains portraits of composer Philip Glass in his youth; musician Lou Reed; photographer Cindy Sherman; painter Cecily Brown; artist Kara Walker; and painter Alex Katz. The second category is composed of portraits of younger, more ethnically diverse artists including Zhang Huan, Sienna Shields and Pozsi B. Kolor. In these portraits, Close aimed to highlight the cultural diversity of New York City. He also has two self-portraits within the station.

Exits and ancillary buildings

There are 3 entrances and exits, which comprise 10 escalators and one elevator.

There are also two ancillary buildings that store station equipment:

• Ancillary 1, NW corner of Second Avenue and 83rd Street
• Ancillary 2, NW corner of Second Avenue and 86th Street

Originally, Entrance 2's escalator entrance was to be located inside the Yorkshire Towers apartment building at 305 East 86th Street, on the northeast corner of Second Avenue and 86th Street. In 2009, a Finding Of No Significant Impact by the Federal Transit Administration (FTA) found this to be unfeasible, so the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) revised the plan to two separate sidewalk entrances in front of the building. During the planning process, it was determined that building a new entrance within the Yorkshire Towers would be too expensive and logistically unfeasible. The apartments directly above the entrance's location would have had to be structurally underpinned during construction, and the Food Emporium supermarket location would have had to close to make way for the new entrance. Of the three alternatives presented for moving the entrance, the MTA chose an alternative in which there would be two new escalator entrances on the north side of 86th Street, both flanking the semicircular driveway of Yorkshire Towers and facing away from the driveway. There was also a proposal to move the sidewalk escalator entrances to the south side of the street, as well as another proposal to build a new structure containing five elevators at the southeast corner of Second Avenue and 86th Street, in a manner similar to Entrance 3 of the adjacent 72nd Street station.

Controversy emerged over Entrance 2's location in February 2011, when a lawsuit was filed by the Yorkshire Towers over the location of Entrance 2. The entrances, planned to service 3,600 people an hour, were alleged in the lawsuit to be destroying the quality of life for building tenants, if the entrances were to be built in the location. The lawsuit was later dismissed because the suit had been filed two years after the FTA's FONSI was published, which was past the statute of limitations. A new lawsuit was filed on March 15, 2013, after the MTA started construction on the entrances. In June 2013, that lawsuit was also dismissed.

In May 2017, all three escalators in Entrance 1 were damaged by sprinklers activated by faulty sensors, causing the entire entrance to be temporarily closed.

Effects

Since 2013, construction of the station has caused the value of real estate in the area to rise. Although the surrounding area's real estate prices had been declining since the 1990s, there had been increases in the purchases and leases of residential units around the area, causing real estate prices to rise again. Some businesses near the station's construction site had also lost profits. With the opening of the new station, business owners hoped to see an increase in patronage.

Second Avenue Subway Community Information Center

The Second Avenue Subway Community Information Center, which gave information about Phase I construction to community members, was located nearby, at 1628 Second Avenue between 84th and 85th Streets. It opened on July 25, 2013. On May 23, 2014, a new exhibit about the construction techniques used to build the Second Avenue Subway, titled En Route: The Techniques and Technologies Used to Build the Second Avenue Subway, was launched at the center. Throughout the process of construction, the MTA also gave intermittent tours of the construction site to Upper East Side residents with reservations. The center received over 20,000 visitors in three years. In 2017, the MTA opened a similar center outside the 125th Street station in East Harlem for Phase II.

Second Avenue Subway Community Information Center vc.jpg|Facade of Second Avenue Subway Community Information Center Second Avenue Subway Community Center Exhibit (14097315349).jpg|Video exhibit Second Avenue Subway Community Center Exhibit (14097317319).jpg|Sign exhibit Second Avenue Subway Community Center Exhibit (14097317559).jpg|Subway car exhibit Second Avenue Subway Community Center Exhibit (14097339128).jpg|Video exhibit

Nearby places

• Carl Schurz Park and Gracie Mansion
• Doyle New York
• The Jeffersons Apartment building at 3Rd Avenue and East 85th Street
• Municipal Asphalt Plant

References

References

1. {{NYCS const. riderref
2. (1972). "www.nycsubway.org: Second Avenue Subway: The Line That Almost Never Was". nycsubway.org.
3. {{Cite Routes Not Taken
4. "IND Second System 1929 Plan". nycsubway.org.
5. (October 19, 2002). "Second Avenue Subway Project – History".
6. "Last Train Rumbles On Third Ave. 'El'; An Era Ends With Final Run of Third Avenue 'El' LAST TRAIN ROLLS ON THIRD AVE. 'EL'". The New York Times.
7. "The New York Transit Authority in the 1970s".
8. (August 1971). "Draft Environmental Statement, Second Avenue Subway, Route 132-A". nycsubway.org.
9. (May 2004). "Second Avenue Subway Final Environmental Impact Statement (FEIS), May 2004 Appendix B Development of Alternatives". Metropolitan Transportation Authority.
10. Moran, Nancy. (August 28, 1970). "2d Avenue Subway to Get Just 3 Stops North of 57th". The New York Times.
11. (February 16, 1973). "Notice of Public Hearing Southern Extension of the Second Avenue Line for the New York City Transit System". New York Daily News.
12. {{cite New York 1960
13. [http://www.nycsubway.org/wiki/Second_Avenue_Subway:_Timeline "Second Avenue Subway: Timeline"]. nycsubway.org. Retrieved April 7, 2014.
14. "Second Avenue Subway - History". Metropolitan Transportation Authority.
15. Jewler, Sam. (July 24, 2004). "The Long, Tortured History of the Second Avenue Subway".
16. (1999). "Manhattan East Side Transit Alternatives Study (MESA): Environmental Impact Statement".
17. Burks, Edward C.. (September 26, 1975). "Work is Stopped on Subway Line; City Lacks Funds to Finish Part of 2d Ave. Project". The New York Times.
18. [http://www.rpa.org/pdf/metrolink.pdf Metrolink] {{webarchive. link. (August 2, 2010 , p.20)
19. Neuman, William. (April 9, 2007). "Is That Finally the Sound of a 2nd Ave. Subway?". The New York Times.
20. (February 4, 2011). "Excavation of West Tunnel for Second Avenue Subway Complete". Metropolitan Transportation Authority.
21. "The Second Avenue subway explained". am New York.
22. (September 16, 2015). "Drone takes tour of NYC's 2nd Avenue subway line".
23. Nonko, Emily. (January 30, 2014). "Updates on NYC's Biggest Subway Projects: Second Avenue and East Side Access". NewYork.com.
24. (February 8, 2017). "Top Projects". NY Construction.
25. (February 4, 2011). "Excavation of West Tunnel for Second Avenue Subway Complete". Metropolitan Transportation Authority.
26. Rubinstein, Dana. (October 23, 2013). "Where is the Second Avenue Subway going?". Capital New York.
27. (June 26, 2007). "86th Street Station Entrance at 86th Street". [[Metropolitan Transportation Authority]].
28. (September 15, 2011). "MTA Awards Contract to Build 2nd Ave Subway Station at 86th St.". MTA.info.
29. (September 15, 2011). "Skanksa JV set to build Second Avenue's 86th St. station :: Second Ave. Sagas". Second Avenue Sagas.
30. Zimmer, Amy. (September 15, 2011). "Construction to Start on Second Avenue Subway's 86th Street Station".
31. (February 2013). "February 2013 Newsletter". [[Metropolitan Transportation Authority]].
32. (July 11, 2013). "VIDEO: Construction of Second Ave. subway at 86th St. chugging along in NYC". NY Daily News.
33. "MTA | news | Second Avenue Subway Reaches Major Milestones". MTA.info.
34. Hawkins, Andrew J.. (December 18, 2014). "Second Avenue subway's first phase is 76% done". [[Crain's]].
35. (December 18, 2014). "Second Avenue Subway Hits Key Milestone With Completion Of 86th Street Station Shell". [[CBS New York]].
36. (December 18, 2014). "Second Avenue Subway Station Shell at 86th Street Complete". [[Metropolitan Transportation Authority]].
37. (May 2014). "May 2014 Newsletter". [[Metropolitan Transportation Authority]].
38. (April 2015). "April 2015 Newsletter". [[Metropolitan Transportation Authority]].
39. (March 2015). "March 2015 report from Transit & Bus Committee". [[Metropolitan Transportation Authority]].
40. Fitzsimmons, Emma G.. (October 26, 2016). "2 Stations on New 2nd Avenue Line May Not be Ready by December". The New York Times.
41. McCowan, Candace. (December 31, 2016). "Decades in the making, Second Avenue Subway set to open to the public".
42. (January 1, 2017). "Second Avenue Subway Opening: What to Know".
43. (July 29, 2016). "SUB-DIVISION B TRAIN OPERATOR/CONDUCTOR ROAD & NON-ROAD WORK PROGRAMS IN EFFECT: NOVEMBER 6, 2016". New York City Transit.
44. {{NYCS const. map
45. (May 14, 2010). "Tunneling Begins Under Second Avenue". Metropolitan Transportation Authority.
46. Hession, Michael. (May 2, 2014). "A Subterranean Stroll Through NYC's Newest Train Tunnel". [[Gizmodo]].
47. Rivoli, Dan. (May 1, 2014). "Second Avenue Subway progress: Dec. 2016 end date on track". AM New York.
48. Metropolitan Transportation Authority. "Second Avenue Subway March 2014 Public Workshop Follow-Up Report, page 23".
49. (September 21, 2015). "A Tour of NYC's Newest Subway Station With Its Architect".
50. "Second Avenue Subway — Past, Present & Future". [[MTA Capital Construction]].
51. Thorpe, Harriet. (2017-01-19). "AECOM-Arup completes the first phase of New York's Second Avenue Subway expansion".
52. Donohue, Pete. (August 4, 2006). "Cooler Subways Coming Eventually". [[New York Daily News]].
53. Roberts, Sam. (September 30, 2013). "No Heel Hazards (or Gusts) as Subway Expands". New York Times.
54. Nolan, Caitlin. (May 16, 2014). "Second Avenue subway line construction is progressing: officials". [[Daily News (New York).
55. "NEW YORK CITY—Second Avenue Subway: MTA's Second Avenue Station and Tunnels Project". Society for Mining, Metallurgy and Exploration.
56. Neuman, William. (April 5, 2007). "2nd Ave. Subway Platforms May Get Glass Walls and Sliding Doors". The New York Times.
57. Rubinstein, Dana. (December 7, 2012). "No Seoul-style platform doors for New York subways, even in new stations". Politico.
58. Stv Inc.. (February 2020). "New York City Transit System-wide Platform Screen Door Feasibility Study Summary of Conclusions". [[Metropolitan Transportation Authority]].
59. Kennedy, Randy. (December 19, 2016). "Art Underground: A First Look at the Second Avenue Subway". The New York Times.
60. Ben Yakas. (January 22, 2014). "Here's What The Second Avenue Subway Will Look Like When It's Filled With Art". Gothamist.
61. Malone, Noreen. (May 14, 2012). "Chuck Close Will Make the Second Avenue Subway Pretty". [[New York (magazine).
62. Mondkar, Bushan. (January 22, 2014). "Subway Art on the Future Second Avenue Subway Line Revealed". Untapped Cities.
63. Warerkar, Tanay. (July 7, 2016). "Chuck Close will bring mosaic portraits to the Second Avenue Subway".
64. "MTA - Arts & Design {{!}} NYCT Permanent Art".
65. (February 2012). "Newsletter February 2012". [[Metropolitan Transportation Authority]].
66. (2016). "MTA Neighborhood Maps: Upper East Side". [[Metropolitan Transportation Authority]].
67. (December 30, 2016). "Introducing the Second Avenue Subway Make Second Avenue Q subway service, your first choice". Metropolitan Transportation Authority.
68. (July 2015). "July 2015 Task Force Presentation". [[Metropolitan Transportation Authority]].
69. (August 2015). "August 2015 Newsletter". [[Metropolitan Transportation Authority]].
70. (October 29, 2009). "Finding Of No Significant Impact (FONSI): Second Avenue Subway: 72nd Street and 86th Street Station Entrances". [[United States Department of Transportation]].
71. (February 17, 2011). "Upper East Side Building Sues MTA Over Planned Subway Entrances". DNA Info.
72. (February 17, 2011). "Owners and Tenants of Yorkshire Towers Sue to Relocate Planned 86th Street Entrances to Second Avenue Subway". Anderson Kill.
73. Brown, Stephen Rex. (March 25, 2013). "UES residents sue MTA over Second Ave Subway entrance".
74. {{cite court. S.D.N.Y.]]. (December 1, 2011). link
75. Weaver, Shaye. (May 16, 2017). "2nd Ave. Subway's 83rd St. Entrance Closed Due to Broken Escalators".
76. (January 7, 2014). "Shops along Second Ave. subway line construction sites want big bucks in 2014". NY Daily News.
77. Acitelli, Tom. (March 1, 2014). "Upper East Side sees boost from Second Avenue subway progress". The Real Deal.
78. Hughes, C.J.. (April 8, 2016). "Yorkville Bets on the Second Avenue Subway".
79. Schlossberg, Tatiana. (October 2, 2014). "Promise of New Subways Has West Siders Excited and East Siders Skeptical". [[The New York Times]].
80. (December 20, 2016). "Businesses hope for boost with 2nd Avenue subway launch". ABC7 New York.
81. Barone, Vincent. (December 20, 2016). "UES community, officials excited for 2nd Ave. subway". am New York.
82. "mta.info | Capital Programs Second Avenue Subway". MTA.info.
83. (July 25, 2013). "MTA | news | MTA Opens Second Avenue Subway Community Information Center". MTA.info.
84. (July 26, 2013). "MTA Opens Second Avenue Subway Community Information Center". DNA Info.
85. (July 25, 2013). "MTA Unveils Second Avenue Subway Information Center On Upper East Side". CBS New York.
86. (May 23, 2014). "MTA Second Avenue Subway Launches New Exhibit: En Route: The Techniques and Technologies Used to Build the Second Avenue Subway". [[Metropolitan Transportation Authority]].
87. "670 Feet Under: The Second Avenue Subway and 5 More Mega-Projects – Architizer". Architizer.
88. Kanno-Youngs, Zolan. (June 19, 2016). "Sneaking a Peek at the Second Avenue Subway Line".
89. (April 25, 2017). "Information center opening in May for next phase of Second Avenue Subway".
90. Martinez, Jose. (September 22, 2017). "New center gives glimpse of Second Avenue Subway's future". Spectrum News - NY1.
91. {{Cite NYC neighborhood map. Yorkville