Zeugma and syllepsis

Definitions

In current usage, there are multiple and sometimes conflicting definitions for zeugma and syllepsis. This article categorizes these two figures of speech into four types, based on four definitions:

Type 1

Grammatical syllepsis (sometimes also called zeugma): where a single word is used in relation to two parts of a sentence although grammatically or logically applying to only one.

By definition, grammatical syllepsis will often be grammatically "incorrect" according to traditional grammatical rules. However, such solecisms are sometimes not errors but intentional constructions in which the rules of grammar are bent by necessity or for stylistic effect.

• "He works his work, I mine."

This quote from Alfred Tennyson's poem "Ulysses" is ungrammatical from a grammarian's viewpoint, because "works" does not grammatically agree with "I": the sentence "I works mine" would be ungrammatical. On the other hand, Tennyson's two sentences could be taken to deploy a different figure of speech, namely "ellipsis". The sentence would be taken to mean,

• "He works his work, [and] I [work] mine."

Interpreted in this way, the conjunction is not ungrammatical.

Type 2

Zeugma (often also called syllepsis, or semantic syllepsis): a single word is used in two parts of a sentence but must be understood differently in relation to each. Example: "He took his hat and his leave." The type of figure is grammatically correct but creates its effect by seeming, at first hearing, to be incorrect by its exploiting multiple shades of meaning in a single word or phrase.

• "Here Thou, great Anna! whom three Realms obey, / Dost sometimes Counsel take and sometimes Tea." (Alexander Pope, The Rape of the Lock, Canto III)
• "Miss Bolo [...] went straight home, in a flood of tears and a sedan-chair." (Charles Dickens, The Pickwick Papers, Chapter 35)
• "They sought it with thimbles, they sought it with care; / They pursued it with forks and hope." (Lewis Carroll, "The Hunting of the Snark")
• "And he said as he hastened to put out the cat, the wine, his cigar, and the lamps... She lowered her standards by raising her glass, her courage, her eyes and his hopes... When he asked 'What in heaven?' she made no reply, up her mind, and a dash for the door." (Flanders and Swann, "Have Some Madeira M'Dear")
• "They covered themselves with dust and glory." (Mark Twain, The Adventures of Tom Sawyer).
• "He watches afternoon repeats and the food he eats." (Blur, "Country House")
• "You held your breath and the door for me." (Alanis Morissette, "Head Over Feet")
• "I took the podium and my second trophy of the evening." (Samuel R. Delany, "Racism and Science Fiction")
• "My blood sugar fell dramatically and so did I." (Elaine Stritch, "Elaine Stritch at Liberty")
• "Quand les Français à tête folle / S'en allèrent dans l'Italie, / Ils gagnèrent à l'étourdie / Et Gênes et Naples et la Vérole." (Voltaire)
• :"When the scatterbrained French / Off to Italy went, / They gained in their foolishness / Genoa, Naples and the pox."

When the meaning of a verb varies for the nouns following it, there is a standard order for the nouns: the noun first takes the most prototypical or literal meaning of the verb and is followed by the noun or nouns taking the less prototypical or more figurative verb meanings.

• "The boy swallowed milk and kisses," as contrasted with "The boy swallowed kisses and milk".

The opposite process, in which the first noun expresses a figurative meaning and the second a more literal meaning, tends to create a comic effect: "and she feeds me love and tenderness and macaroons." (The Stampeders, "Sweet City Woman")

Type 3

The Oxford Dictionary of Literary Terms offers a much broader definition for zeugma, defining it as any case of parallelism and ellipsis working together so that a single word governs two or more parts of a sentence.

• Vicit pudorem libido timorem audacia rationem amentia. (Cicero, Pro Cluentio, VI.15)
• :"Lust conquered shame; audacity, fear; madness, reason."

The more usual way of phrasing this would be "Lust conquered shame, audacity conquered fear, and madness conquered reason." The sentence consists of three parallel clauses, called parallel because each has the same word order: verb, object, subject in the original Latin; subject, verb, object in the English translation. The verb "conquered" is a common element in each clause. The zeugma is created in both the original and the translation by removing the second and third instances of "conquered". Removing words that still can be understood by the context of the remaining words is ellipsis.

• Histories make men wise; poets, witty; the mathematics, subtle; natural philosophy, deep; moral, grave; logic and rhetoric, able to contend. (Francis Bacon)

Phrased more pedantically: "Histories make men wise, poets make them witty, mathematics make them subtle, natural philosophy makes them deep, moral [philosophy] makes them grave, and logic and rhetoric make them able to contend." (Because ellipsis involves the omission of words, ambiguities can arise. The sentence could also be read as, "Histories make men wise, make poets witty, make mathematics subtle, make natural philosophy deep, makes moral [philosophy] grave, and make logic and rhetoric able to contend.")

Zeugmas are defined in this sense by Samuel Johnson in his 18th-century Dictionary of the English Language. Johnson, Samuel. A Dictionary of the English Language."Zeugma". 1755. Retrieved 24 January 2013.

Type 4

A special case of semantic syllepsis occurs when a word or phrase is used both in its figurative and literal sense at the same time. Then, it is not necessary for the governing phrase to relate to two parts of the sentence. One example is in an advertisement for a transport company: "We go a long way for you." This type of syllepsis operates in a similar manner to a homonymic pun.

Other types and related figures

There are several other definitions of zeugma that encompass other ways in which one word in a sentence can relate to two or more others. Even a simple construction like "this is easy and comprehensible" has been called a "zeugma without complication" because "is" governs both "easy" and "comprehensible".

Specialized figures have been defined to distinguish zeugmas with particular characteristics such as the following figures, which relate to the specific type and location of the governing word:

Diazeugma

A diazeugma is a zeugma whose only subject governs multiple verbs. A diazeugma whose only subject begins the sentence and controls a series of verbs is a "disjunction" (disiunctio) in the Rhetorica ad Herennium.

• Populus Romanus Numantiam delevit Kartaginem sustulit Corinthum disiecit Fregellas evertit. (Anon. Rhetorica ad Herennium. IV. xxvii.)
• :The Roman people destroyed Numantia, razed Carthage, demolished Corinth, and overthrew Fregellae.
• "We shall pay any price, bear any burden, meet any hardship, support any friend, oppose any foe to assure the survival and the success of liberty." (Inaugural address of John F. Kennedy)

Hypozeugma

Hypozeugma or "adjunctions" (adiunctio) is used in a construction containing several phrases and occurs when the word or words on which all of the phrases depend are placed at the end.

• Assure yourself that Damon to his Pythias, Pylades to his Orestes, Titus to his Gysippus, Theseus to his Pyrothus, Scipio to his Laelius, was never found more faithful than Euphues will be to his Philautus. (John Lyly, Euphues)

Prozeugma

A prozeugma, synezeugmenon, or praeiunctio is a zeugma whose governing word occurs in the first clause of the sentence.

• Vicit pudorem libido timorem audacia rationem amentia. (Cicero, Pro Cluentio, VI.15)
• :"Lust conquered shame; audacity, fear; madness, reason."
• Histories make men wise; poets, witty; the mathematics, subtle; natural philosophy, deep; moral, grave; logic and rhetoric, able to contend. (Francis Bacon)

Mesozeugma

A mesozeugma is a zeugma whose governing word occurs in the middle of the sentence and governs clauses on either side. A mesozeugma whose common term is a verb is called "conjunction" (coniunctio) in the Roman Rhetorica ad Herennium.

• "What a shame is this, that neither hope of reward, nor feare of reproch could any thing move him, neither the persuasion of his friends, nor the love of his country. " (Henry Peacham)

References

References

1. Bernard Marie Dupriez. (1991). "A Dictionary of Literary Devices: Gradus, A-Z". University of Toronto Press.
2. Liddell, H. G. & al. ''A Greek-English Lexicon''
3. ''[[Random House Dictionary]]''. [http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/syllepsis?s=t "Syllepsis"]. 2013. Retrieved 24 January 2013.
4. [https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/zeugma Zeugma]: Merriam-Webster Online
5. [https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/syllepsis Syllepsis]: Merriam-Webster Online
6. (2020-05-21). "What is a Zeugma? {{!}}{{!}} Oregon State Guide to Literary Terms".
7. (16 September 2013). "Zeugma". Literary Devices.
8. ''Random House Dictionary''. [http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/zeugma?s=t "Zeugma"]. 2013. Retrieved 24 January 2013.
9. ''Oxford Dictionaries Online''. [https://web.archive.org/web/20130917121425/http://oxforddictionaries.com/definition/english/zeugma?q=zeugma "Zeugma"]. [[Oxford University Press]]. Retrieved 24 January 2013.
10. WordNet. [http://wordnetweb.princeton.edu/perl/webwn?s=zeugma "Zeugma"]. Princeton University Press. Retrieved 23 January 2013.
11. Knapp, James F. ''The Norton Anthology of Poetry''. [http://www.wwnorton.com/college/english/nap/Glossary_Versification.htm "Glossary of Literary Terms"] {{Webarchive. link. (29 January 2013 . [[W.W. Norton). W. W. Norton & Co.]], 2005. Retrieved 24 January 2013.
12. Baldwick, Chris. 2008. ''Oxford Dictionary of Literary Terms''. "Syllepsis" Oxford University Press. New York. p. 325.
13. Corbett, Edward P.J. and Conners, Robert J. 1999. ''Style and Statement''. Oxford University Press. New York. Oxford. pp. 63-64.
14. Burton, Neel. (2019). "Hypersanity: Thinking Beyond Thinking". Acheron.
15. Delany, Samuel R.. (August 1998). "Racism and Science Fiction". [[New York Review of Science Fiction]].
16. Feltgen. (11 December 2002). "Histoire de la lutte contre les maladies vénériennes à Rouen".
17. Frith, John. (November 2012). "Syphilis: Its Early History and Treatment Until Penicillin, and the Debate on its Origins". Journal of Military and Veterans' Health.
18. Shen, Yeshayahu. (March 1998). "Zeugma: Prototypes, Categories, And Metaphors". Metaphor and Symbol.
19. Baldick, Chris. ''The Concise Oxford Dictionary of Literary Terms''. "Zeugma". 2004.
20. Bacon, Francis. (1601). "Of Studies".
21. (2013-09-16). "Zeugma - Examples and Definition of Zeugma".
22. "diazeugma". Silva Rhetoricae.
23. "hypozeugma". Silva Rhetoricae.
24. {{lang. la. [[Rhetorica ad Herennium]]
    
25. Riccio, Ottone M.. (1980). "The intimate art of writing poetry". [[Prentice-Hall]].
26. "prozeugma". Silva Rhetoricae.
27. "mesozeugma". Silva Rhetoricae.
28. {{lang. la. [[Rhetorica ad Herennium]]. [https://archive.org/stream/adcherenniumdera00capluoft#page/322/mode/2up/ IV. xxvii.] Retrieved 24 January 2013. via [[Internet Archive]]