Vale S.A.

Current operations

Although the company's primary operations are in Brazil, Vale has operations in 30 countries, which are detailed below and on the company's website.

Ownership structure

The company is listed on the stock exchanges of São Paulo, New York City, Jakarta, Paris and Madrid.

Mining business

Iron ore: Vale is the world's largest iron ore producer. Sales of iron ore fines and pellets represented 65% of total company revenues in 2014. In 2014, Vale sold 256 million metric tonnes of iron ore fines and 44 million metric tonnes of iron ore pellets. Vale's Mariana Hub was the 9th largest iron ore mining center in the world in 2014, with an output of 39 million metric tonnes. Vale's Serra Sul / S11D is the largest mining reserve in the world. The company's iron ore mines are primarily in Brazil.

Nickel: Vale is the world's largest nickel producer.

Fertilizer products, primarily phosphates and nitrogen: Sales of fertilizer products represented 6% of total company revenues in 2014. In 2014, Vale sold 9 million metric tonnes of fertilizer products.

Copper: Sales of copper concentrate represented 4% of total company revenues in 2014. In 2014, Vale sold 353,000 metric tonnes of copper. The company owns copper mines in Brazil, Canada, Chile and Zambia.

Manganese and alloys: Sales of manganese and alloys represented 1% of total company revenues in 2014. In 2014, Vale sold 2 million metric tonnes of manganese and alloys.

Coal: Sales of coal represented 2% of total company revenues in 2014. In 2014, Vale sold 7.5 million metric tonnes of coal. The company owns coal mines in Australia and Mozambique.

Logistics

Railroads

From 2000 to 2006, Vale invested more than $1.3 billion on the acquisition of over 361 locomotives and around 14,090 freight cars, those locomotives were primarily for iron ore transportation, but some were for regular cargo.

After those investments, Vale became the owner of over 800 locomotives and more than 35,000 freight cars.

Vale owns the concession of three Brazilian railways: Vitória-Minas Railway (EFVM), Ferrovia Centro-Atlântica (FCA) and Carajás railroad (EFC). [[File:FCA e Vitória a Minas railroads.jpg|thumb|right |Ferrovia Centro-Atlântica and Vitória a Minas railroads]]

• Vitória a Minas railroad — Vale operates under a 30-year contract this 905 km, railroad, which is used to transport iron from the Iron Quadrangle in Minas Gerais to the Port of Tubarão in the state of Espírito Santo. The concession expires in 2027. This railroad also carried 1.1 million passengers in 2006.
• Carajás railroad — The concession of this 892 km, gauge railroad also expires in 2027, it links Carajás iron ore mines in the state of Pará to Ponta da Madeira port terminal in the state of Maranhão. Vale operates a train of 3.2 km and 340 cars on this railroad.
• Ferrovia Centro-Atlântica — Vale controls this railroad through the subsidiary FCA. As it is shown on the Vale's operations map above, this 7,000 km, railroad extends through 6 Brazilian states, this railroad originally belonged to the RFFSA. Vale's concession of this railroad expires in 2026.
• Vale also has a stake in railway operators in Mozambique and Malawi via the Nacala Logistics Corridor.

Ports and container terminals

Brazil

On February 5, 2019, the state court of the Province of Minas Gerais ordered Vale to halt use of eight of its tailings dams, including the Laranjeiras dam at Brucutu.

• Port of Tubarão — Vale owns and operates this port located in Vitória, Brazil in the state of Espírito Santo. It's the largest iron ore embarking port in the world. Around 80 million metric tonnes of iron ore (30% of the company's annual production) are shipped through this port.
• Ponta da Madeira — Located in the state of Maranhão, it ships around 70 million metric tonnes mostly of iron ore, but also of manganese and copper for the company; it is being upgraded for the S11D project
• Port of Sepetiba — Vale operates two maritime terminals in the Port of Sepetiba area located in the state of Rio de Janeiro, together they ship around 60 million metric tonnes of iron ore.
• Feijão mine — site of the Brumadinho dam disaster on 25 January 2019.

Vale also operates port terminals in the state of Sergipe and two others in the state of Espírito Santo.

Malaysia

• Teluk Rubiah Maritime Terminal (TRMT), a state of the art maritime terminal in Manjung District, Perak, operates as a distribution centre for iron ore in the Asia Pacific region. The terminal was constructed in 2011 and completed in 2014 at a cost of US$1.4 billion. 60% of its workforce are Manjung District locals.

Ships

Vale has also entered the shipping business by ordering 35 Very Large Ore Carriers (VLOC) to transport iron ore between South America and Asia. These 362 m, 400,000 DWT ships are the longest and largest dry bulk carriers in the world. The first ship, Vale Brasil, was delivered in March 2011.

Energy

Vale's energy business is focused on power production to fulfill the needs of its mining operations, as well as supplying the general Brazilian power grid. In 2005, it consumed 16.9 TWh of electrical power, accounting for 4.4% of Brazil's total consumption in that year.

Vale has participation in 8 hydroelectric plants, with 7 of these located in the state of Minas Gerais. Vale's investment in hydroelectric power plants totals $880 million. The company also plans to build a 600 MW thermoelectric power plant in the state of Pará.

In 2011, Vale S.A. bought 70% of Biopalma for US$ 173.5 million for the production of B20 fuel (20% biodiesel, 80% diesel) for Petrobras. The company was sold in 2020 for Brasil BioFuels after a liability of R$ 965 million.

Vale also operates hydroelectric plants in Canada and Indonesia.

Rebranding

In November 2007, the company retired the name CVRD in favour of simplified company name of Vale, and rebranded.

History

Companhia Vale do Rio Doce (widely known as CVRD prior to 2007) (in English, "Doce River Valley Company") was founded in Itabira, Minas Gerais, by the Brazilian Federal Government on 1 June 1942.

One year later the Vitória a Minas railroad was inaugurated.

The 1950s marked Companhia Vale do Rio Doce's entry into the global iron ore market, after the company's mine-railroad-port complex was modernized and iron ore prices doubled. At first, sales were mostly to the United States, but exports to Europe increased over the course of the decade.

In 1966, the company inaugurated in Espírito Santo the Port of Tubarão, which was to become the most important port for CVRD and is still used to export iron ore mined from the Iron Quadrangle in Minas Gerais.

The company acquired a majority interest in the Carajás Mine, with over 1.5 billion tonnes of iron ore in reserves, in 1970.

In 1974, Vale became the world's biggest exporter of iron ore, a title which it still holds today.

In 1982, Vale began to diversify after it started to produce aluminium in Rio de Janeiro.

In the early-to-mid-1980s, profits increased considerably under the leadership of Eliezer Batista, father of Eike Batista.

In 1985, Vale started to explore the Carajás Mine in the state of Pará just after the gauge Carajás railroad was opened.

In 1986, Ponta Madeira port terminal, which is still used to export iron ore mined at the Carajás Mine, was inaugurated in the state of Maranhão.

In March 2017, Vale SA chose a commodities industry veteran, Fabio Schvartsman, as chief executive officer. Schvartsman was CEO of Klabin SA, Brazil's largest paper and cardboard producer, for the previous six years.

Privatization in 1997

In May 1997, despite protests by Vale employees and some politicians, the Brazilian Government auctioned a 41.73% interest in the company, which was sold for R$3.34 billion (US$3.13 billion). The largest interest purchased was a 16.3% stake purchased by Brazilian steel company Companhia Siderúrgica Nacional.

Sale of wood pulp businesses

In 2001, Vale sold its Cenibra wood pulp business to Aracruz and Votorantim Celulose e Papel jointly for US$670.5 million to focus on mining and logistics.

In 2002, Vale sold 100,000 acres of land and the eucalyptus forests thereon related to its wood pulp business for R$137 million.

Sale of steel businesses

In 2000, the company sold its stake in Açominas to Gerdau in exchange for preferred shares in Gerdau.

In 2001, Vale sold its stake in Companhia Siderúrgica Nacional for R$520 million.

In 2004, Vale sold its stake in CST to Arcelor for US$415.1 million.

In 2006, Vale sold its interest in Siderar to Ternium for US$107.5 million.

In 2006, the company sold 5,362,928 shares in Usiminas for or R$378.6 million. In 2007, the company sold the majority of its stake in Usiminas. In 2009, the company sold its remaining stake in Usiminas.

Sale of coal businesses

In 2014, Vale announced the sale of coal assets in Mozambique to Mitsui in a $950 million transaction.

In 2015, Vale's Integra coal mine located in Australia's Hunter Valley in New South Wales was sold to Glencore and Bloomfield in a complex multi-party deal.

Acquisitions of Brazilian iron ore companies

In May 2000, the company acquired Sociomex, owner of the Gongo Sôco Mine, with proven reserves of approximately 75 million tonnes.

In May 2000, the company also acquired a controlling interest in Samitri, one of the biggest pelletizing companies of Brazil.

In April 2001, the company acquired Ferteco, then the third largest Brazilian producer of iron ore, with a production capacity of 15 million tonnes per year.

In 2006, the company acquired Rio Verde Mineração for $47 million.

Acquisition of [[Caemi]] and acquisition and partial disposition of MBR

On 1 April 2000, Vale offered to pay Mitsui US$277 million for 50% of the common shares and US$150 million for 40% of the preferred stock in Caemi. Caemi owned MBR, Brazil's second largest iron ore producer, mining over 60 million tonnes per year.

The acquisition was approved by European regulators subject to conditions.

In September 2003, Vale purchased an additional stake in Caemi from Mitsui for US$426.4 million.

On 23 January 2006, the company announced a stock swap merger to acquire the interest Caemi that it did not already own.

In 2007, increased its ownership in MBR by purchasing additional interests from Mitsui for US$114.5 million.

Also in 2007, Vale announced that it will lease the shares of MBR that it did not already own from their 7 Japanese shareholders for a 30-year period. The agreement required the company to pay a total of US$60.5 million in 2007 and US$48.1 million annually for a 30-year period and gave it total control of MBR.

In 2015, Vale announced the sale of a 36.4% interest in MBR for R$4 billion.

Diversification into [[non-ferrous metals]], [[coal]] and [[phosphate]]

In 2001, Vale increased its copper mining operations by purchasing the Sossego mine in Carajas, in northern Brazil, for $48.5 million.

In 2005, Vale acquired Canico Resource, owner of a nickel mine in Brazil, after increasing its offer to $865 million.

In October 2006, Vale acquired Canadian-based nickel producer Inco for $18.9 billion, including $17.7 billion in cash and the assumption of $1.2 billion in debt. To gain approval from Canadian authorities, Vale promised to continue investments in Canada and not lay off people for 3 years after closing.

In 2007, Vale made a major entry into coal mining by acquiring AMCI Holdings Australia for AU$835 million.

In 2010, Vale launched a public offer to acquire fertilizer and copper producer Paranapanema.

In 2010, Vale acquired a controlling interest in Fosfertil via a series of transactions.

In June 2011, Jason Chenier and Jordan Fram were killed at the 3,000 foot level of the Frood Mine near Sudbury, Ontario.

In 2011, the company sold its aluminum business to Norsk Hydro in a US$5.27 billion transaction. Norsk Hydro thus became a truly integrated aluminium company. This gave Hydro the world's largest alumina refinery and aimed to "secure raw materials for more than a hundred years of aluminum production". Hydro gained a large bauxite supply, including control of the Paragominas mine, one of the largest bauxite mines in the world. It also gained large alumina refining and aluminum production capacity, including a 51 percent stake in the Albras aluminum plant and 91 percent ownership of Alunorte, then the world's largest alumina refinery and now the largest outside China.

In July 2012, Vale sold its ferro-manganese plants in Europe to Glencore for $160 million.

In 2014, Vale sold its interest in Fosbrasil S.A., a manufacturer of phosphate-based products to Israel Chemicals Ltd for $52 million.

In 2015, the company announced that it would sell a 25% interest in gold produced from its Salobo mine, located in Brazil, to Silver Wheaton for US$900 million.

In 2015, the company entered into a letter of intent to sell bauxite assets to Norsk Hydro.

On 26 November 2015, Vale announced that it planned to reduce its budget for capital expenditures from US$8 billion in 2015 to US$6.2 billion in 2016, with further reductions to US$4–5 billion by 2018.

In May 2023 it was announced by Eduardo Bartolomeo that Mark Cutifani would be appointed as Chair of the new Vale Base Metals (VBM) subsidiary in a spin-off event. Vale was looking to divest from its tar baby, as early as December 2022. At the time VBM was a supplier to Tesla and General Motors. Reports were afoot that GM, Mitsui, and the Saudi Public Investment Fund were interested buyers of a 10% stake. Former Tesla executive Jerome Guillen would join the "energy transition board" of VBM along with Cutifani.

Vale spun out its metals business as a separate ringfenced entity headquartered in Toronto, with an independent board chaired by Cutifani. That process completed in July 2023. The unit was then one of the world’s largest producers of nickel, copper, and cobalt, and has operations across the globe. The parent company's chief executive stated that Cutifani could help the division explore a future “liquidity event”. In early 2023, the parent company earned 80% of its profits in its South American iron mines, and the balance from its Base Metals group.

Business trends

The key trends for Vale are (as of the financial year ending 31 December):

Disasters and incidents

Bento Rodrigues dam collapse

Main article: Mariana dam disaster

On 5 November 2015, the Mariana dam disaster caused 19 deaths and massive environmental contamination when a tailings dam collapsed at the Samarco mining site, co-owned by Vale and BHP. Heavy metal contamination of the Doce River caused water emergencies in many downstream cities which depend on the river for drinking water. Activities at the mine were suspended, and the companies agreed to pay compensation of R$4.4 billion (US$1.55 billion).

An investigation into the disaster commissioned by BHP, Vale and Samarco found the collapse was due to a variety of construction and design flaws. In June 2018, Samarco, Vale and BHP signed an agreement to drop a US$7 billion lawsuit and allow two years for the companies to address the greater US$55 billion suit seeking social, environmental and economic compensation.

Brumadinho dam disaster

Main article: Brumadinho dam disaster

On 25 January 2019, the Brumadinho dam disaster occurred at the Córrego do Feijão mine in the Brazilian state of Minas Gerais, releasing 3 billion gallons of mine waste, in a wave of red iron ore which destroyed the mine's cafeteria, where many workers were present and died, and which flooded the town of Brumadinho. 270 were killed. In 2020, prosecutors found that Vale had falsified safety reports for at least ten of its dams. They later charged sixteen officials of Vale including its CEO, with manslaughter.

In 2021, Vale agreed to pay victims $7 billion. Though substantially deadlier, the environmental devastation was not as severe as with Bento Rodrigues.

Following the Córrego do Feijão disaster, a Brazilian court ordered Vale to stop disposing of tailings at eight dams.

Tax dispute

In 2013, Vale S.A. agreed to pay the equivalent of $9.5 billion to settle a tax dispute with the Brazilian authorities regarding its overseas profits from 2003 to 2012.

Totten Mine

On September 28, 2021, thirty-nine miners were trapped underground for 24 hours at the Totten Mine in Ontario after the entrance shaft became obstructed.

Criticism

In January 2012, Vale received the "people's choice" Public Eye Award as the corporation with the most "contempt for the environment and human rights" in the world. Vale received 25,000 votes, with the Belo Monte Dam cited as a reason.

During the interim between the two dam disasters of 2015 and 2019; Vale had denied owning an upstream tailings waste structure such as collapsed, causing the Brumadinho dam to burst.

Following the 2019 disaster, BBC News reported that "Correspondents say the alarm system the company had installed to warn residents of any risk did not go off."

In February 2021, an agreement was signed that required Vale to pay over $7 billion in compensation to the families of the victims. $55 million was the settlement cost to the company for its role in making false certifications in regards to the 2019 disaster which the company reached with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission in late March 2023.

References

Bibliography

• Michel Braudeau, « Mourir dans l'or à Serra Pelada », in Le rêve amazonien, éditions Gallimard, 2004 ().

References

1. "Vale: Leadership".
2. "Vale's Performance in 2015".
3. (2019-01-30). "Vale: The pride of Brazil becomes its most hated company".
4. "Vale".
5. "Vale ordered to halt operations at Brucutu".
6. (2019-02-05). "Vale Loses License at Dam That Caused Iron Ore Force Majeure". Bloomberg.com.
7. (February 10, 2019). "Vale Denied Having 'Upstream' Dams Ahead of Deadly Accident". [[The Wall Street Journal]].
8. "Vale: Across the World".
9. Cecilia Jamasmie. (25 February 2016). "Vale posts record loss, to sell core assets". Mining.com.
10. "ANNUAL REPORT PURSUANT TO SECTION 13 OR 15(d) OF THE SECURITIES EXCHANGE ACT OF 1934".
11. Vladimir Basov. (17 September 2015). "True giants of mining: World's top 10 iron ore mines". Mining.com.
12. Araujo, Gabriel. (2022-05-06). "Brazil's Vale signs long-term deal to supply Tesla with nickel". Reuters.
13. (2006). "CVRD-controlled Carajas Railway received 12 new SD70M locomotives from Electro-Motive Diesel in December to handle growing traffic". [[International Railway Journal]].
14. (2008-05-15). "EMD: JT2CWR".
15. "Ferrovia Centro Atlântica".
16. "Railway Gazette: Mining drives African rail plans".
17. "Porto e Negócios".
18. (2008-09-27). "New port for Espirito Santo, Brazil".
19. (28 December 2021). "Vale committed to sustainable and viable presence in Malaysia". The Malaysian Reserve.
20. "Mining Weekly - Brazilian mining group's giant ore carrier soon to enter service".
21. (December 8, 2022). "CORRECTED-UPDATE 4-Brazil's Vale forecasts flat iron ore output, shares dive 4.4%". Reuters.
22. (December 7, 2022). "Brazil's Vale forecasts flat iron ore output, shares dive 4.4%". financialpost.com.
23. "SEC Info - Vale S.A., et al. - '20-F' for 12/31/05".
24. "A CVRD Anuncia a Construção de uma Térmica a Carvão - Adriano Pires: O Globo Online".
25. Nery, Carmen. (15 September 2011). "Laboratórios focam o biocombustível de segunda geração". [[Valor Econômico]].
26. (21 October 2020). "Aquisição da Biopalma pela BBF é aprovada sem restrições pelo Tribunal do Cade".
27. "Vale S.A., et al. – '20-F' for 12/31/05". Gaming Law Review and Economics.
28. (30 November 2007). "As CVRD changes name to Vale, iron ore pre-talks begin". Mineweb.
29. "Vale History Book: Chapter 1".
30. "Vale History Book: Chapter 3".
31. "Vale History Book 5".
32. Alan Riding. (19 May 1985). "Mining for Profits in the Jungles of Brazil". [[New York Times]].
33. (2017-03-28). "Vale taps veteran executive Schvartsman as new CEO". Reuters.
34. (7 May 1997). "Brazil Awards Big Mining Stake To Group Bidding $3.13 Billion". [[New York Times]].
35. (June 6, 2001). "World Business Briefing {{!}} Americas: Brazil: Paper Stake". NY Times.
36. (December 18, 2011). "Cenibra may kill $2.5 bln Brazil pulp project-paper". reuters.com.
37. (10 June 2002). "CVRD Sells its Last Pulp and Paper Assets". [[PRNewswire]].
38. (7 December 2000). "CVRD Divests AÇOMINAS".
39. (15 March 2001). "Cross Shareholding Unwinding: CVRD Sells Its CSN Stake". [[PRNewswire]].
40. (28 June 2004). "CVRD Divests Its Stake in CST". [[PRNewswire]].
41. (28 December 2006). "Ternium Purchases CVRD's Ownership Stake in Siderar". [[Business Wire]].
42. (6 November 2006). "CVRD Restructures Its Investment in Usiminas". [[PRNewswire]].
43. (17 April 2007). "Brazilian mining giant Vale do Rio Doce share offer seen yielding R$1.93 billion".
44. (17 April 2009). "Vale sells its stake in Usiminas". Steel Orbis.
45. (9 December 2014). "Vale of Brazil Sells Coal Stake to Mitsui & Co. for About $950 Million". [[New York Times]].
46. (26 August 2015). "Glencore, Bloomfield split Vale's Integra coal mine".
47. (15 May 2000). "CVRD Acquired SOCOIMEX".
48. (30 May 2000). "Acquisition of SAMITRI".
49. (12 April 2001). "CVRD Negotiates the Acquisition of FERTECO".
50. (26 January 2007). "CVRD to Invest US$ 6.3 Billion in 2007". [[PRNewswire]].
51. Matthew Flynn. (15 April 2003). ["CVRD's Caemi purchase might face conditions"](http://www.bnamericas.com/en/news/mining/CVRD%27s_Caemi_purchase_might_face_conditions}}{{Dead link). BN Americas.
52. (30 October 2001). "Commission clears merger between Brazilian iron ore producers subject to undertakings". [[European Commission]].
53. (5 September 2003). "CVRD in $426m iron-ore acquisition". [[Mining Weekly]].
54. (23 January 2006). "CVRD Announces Stock Merger With Caemi". [[PRNewswire]].
55. (2 May 2007). "Mitsui to Sell Shares in EBM to CVRD". [[Mitsui]].
56. (2 May 2007). "CVRD seeking synergies with MBR". BN Americas.
57. (30 June 2015). "Vale announces the sale of a minority stake of MBR".
58. (25 October 2001). "Acquisition of the Sossego Project Confirms CVRD Copper Strategy". [[PRNewswire]].
59. (9 December 2005). "CVRD Successfully Completes Take-Over Bid for Canico". [[PRNewswire]].
60. (12 November 2005). "Canico accepts sweetened CVRD offer". [[Globe & Mail]].
61. (11 August 2006). "CVRD Announces Proposed All-Cash Offer to Acquire Inco". [[PRNewswire]].
62. (18 October 2006). "CVRD obtains Investment Canada Act approval". Vale.
63. Freed, Jamie. (2007-02-28). "Brazilian move into local coal".
64. (29 July 2010). "Vale launches public offer to acquire Paranapanema".
65. Fernanda de Biagio. (29 July 2010). "Vale offers to buy Paranapanema for US$1.14bn". BN Americas.
66. Fernanda de Biagio. (30 September 2010). "VVale concludes acquisition of Mosaic stake in Fosfertil for US$1.03bn". BN Americas.
67. (28 January 2010). "Vale acquires Fosfertil shares".
68. (19 September 2013). "Vale mine death plea disappoints union". [[Canadian Broadcasting Corporation.
69. (28 February 2011). "Hydro-Vale aluminium transaction to be completed today". [[Norsk Hydro]].
70. (2010-05-02). "Hydro secures bauxite supply in $4.9 bln Vale deal". Reuters.
71. "Glencore announces the acquisition of equity stakes in Mineracão Rio do Norte S.A. and Alunorte S.A. from Norsk Hydro ASA".
72. (11 July 2012). "Vale sells ferromanganese units to Glencore for $160 mln". [[Reuters]].
73. (December 26, 2013). "Vale sells Fosbrasil stake to Israel Chemicals for $52 mln". Reuters.
74. (January 28, 2015). "Understanding the completion of stake sale in Fosbrasil". finance yahoo.
75. (2 March 2015). "Silver Wheaton Acquires Additional Gold Stream From Vale's Salobo Mine". [[PRNewswire]].
76. (9 October 2015). "Norsk Hydro: Hydro enters LoI with Vale to raise MRN ownership to 45%". [[Globe Newswire]].
77. "Vale presents strategic planning for 2016 in London".
78. "New Vale base metals boss Cutifani to focus on margins, marketing and potential IPO".
79. (7 December 2022). "Vale to break out base metals business, sell stake in 2023 - BNN Bloomberg".
80. (16 March 2023). "Vale mulls listing base metals unit following minority stake sale".
81. "Vale taps ex-Anglo CEO Cutifani to chair battery metals board".
82. (7 July 2023). "Former Sudbury mining leader is back on board with Vale".
83. "Vale (VALE) - Revenue".
84. "Vale (VALE) - Earnings".
85. "Vale (VALE) - Total assets".
86. "Vale (VALE) - Net Assets".
87. "Vale (VALE) - Market capitalization".
88. (2 March 2016). "BHP Billiton reaches $1.55bn settlement with Brazil over dam collapse". Australian Associated Press.
89. (2016-08-29). "Samarco dam disaster probe reveals construction and design flaws". ABC News.
90. (2018-06-25). "BHP signs deal to suspend $55b Samarco lawsuit for two years". ABC News.
91. [https://www.npr.org/2019/02/04/691502156/court-orders-vale-to-stop-using-tailings-dams-as-death-toll-climbs-above-120 "Court Orders Vale To Stop Using Tailings Dams As Death Toll Climbs Above 120", by Vanessa Roma, February 4, 2019. Retrieved February 10, 2019.]
92. Phillips, Dom. (2019-01-26). "Hundreds feared dead as Brazil dam collapse releases mud tide". The Observer.
93. Timm-Garcia, Jaide. (5 February 2021). "Vale will pay nearly $7 billion over Brazilian dam collapse that killed 270 people". CNN.
94. (2021-02-04). "Vale Mining Company to Pay $7 Billion in Compensation for Brazil Dam Collapse". The New York Times.
95. "Brazilian mining giant to settle long-running tax dispute".
96. (27 September 2021). "Vale miners stranded for 24 hours underground using ladder to exit Totten".
97. Chaudhuri, Saabira. (27 January 2012). "Public Eye award singles out Brazilian mining company, Barclays". [[The Guardian]].
98. [https://www.bbc.com/news/world-latin-america-47096011 "Brazil dam: Startling pictures of Brumadinho collapse"], [[BBC News]], ''British Broadcasting Corporation'', February 1, 2019. Retrieved February 10, 2019.
99. (2021-02-04). "Vale dam disaster: $7bn compensation for 270 killed". BBC News.
100. Eric Beech & Chris Reese. Reuters reporters.(28 March 2023). "UPDATE 1-Brazilian miner Vale to pay $56 mln over US regulator dam safety charges". [https://finance.yahoo.com/news/1-brazilian-miner-vale-pay-233817039.html Yahoo Finance website] Retrieved 30 March 2023.