United States v. Scheinberg

Background

Growth of poker

Main article: Poker boom

In 2003, ESPN expanded its coverage of the World Series of Poker. Between 2003 and 2006, the number of contestants in the $10,000 No Limit Texas hold'em Main Event grew from 839 to 8773.

Changes in gambling laws

On October 13, 2006, the United States Congress passed Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act of 2006 (UIGEA), which makes it a federal offense, punishable by up to five years in prison, for a gambling business to "knowingly accept" payments "in connection with the participation of another person in unlawful Internet gambling." However, according to syndicated columnist Jacob Sullum, the law did not define or alter the definition of unlawful gambling, which under Federal law only applies to sports betting via the Wire Act.

Nevertheless, Party Poker, at the time the largest provider for U.S. demand, decided to withdraw from servicing the United States poker market. The United States Department of Justice later indicted them for services provided prior to 2006 in violation of the Wire Act, a case they settled out of court in the hopes of being allowed to serve the U.S. market at a later date.

Several other sites continued to facilitate the demand for online poker in the U.S., which had been growing about 20% per year.

A 2006 law passed in Washington state that made it a felony to play online poker was upheld as constitutional by the Washington Supreme Court in September 2010. PokerStars immediately withdrew from Washington's market, and Full Tilt soon followed suit, but both sites continued to provide services to players in the other 49 U.S. states.

This case was preceded by a 2009 seizure of $34 million worth of winnings in transit U.S. poker players (q.v. Southern District of New York action against online poker players).

Basis for the case

Since Federal law says nothing specifically about online poker, or any gambling other than sports betting, Preet Bharara, the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York, bases his case on a New York law that makes it a Class A misdemeanor, punishable by up to a year in prison, to run a game of chance where bets are placed within the state.

Additionally, in April 2010, the former head of Intabill, a defunct payment processor in Australia, Daniel Tzvetkoff, was arrested in Las Vegas by the FBI. He was charged with money laundering, bank fraud, and wire fraud. PokerStars and Full Tilt had previously claimed that Tzvetkoff cheated them out of at least $100 million. However, he was quietly let go a few months later in August 2010. He reportedly turned state's evidence after being threatened with a 75-year prison sentence for alleged UIGEA violations.

The indictment also alleged that the executive officers of the sites had sought investment in SunFirst Bank in Utah, which they were using to obtain and pay out player funds by allegedly mis-coding transactions. This case marks only the second time that the Department of Justice has alleged violations of the UIGEA, after the indictment of Daniel Tzvetkoff.

A grand jury handed down a sealed indictment on March 10, 2011.

Domain name seizure

On April 15, 2011,  the United States Attorney in New York seized and shut down defendants' domains which included Pokerstars.com, Fulltiltpoker.com, Absolutepoker.com, Ultimatebet.com and UB.com.

On April 20, 2011, the office of the U.S. Attorney reinstated the control of the domain name Pokerstars.com back to the company. This action was taken to enable the withdrawal of funds held in accounts by U.S. players with the companies.

In July 2012, the government reached settlements with PokerStars and Full Tilt and dismissed civil complaints "with prejudice" against the two companies. Both companies admitted no wrongdoing. The U.S. Government recognized that both companies are eligible to apply for licenses to conduct online gaming in the U.S., contingent upon the provision of a legal structure for such licensing.

Accounts seized

About 76 bank accounts in 14 countries were then frozen, preventing players from accessing balances held by the companies, according to the FBI's New York office. That Full Tilt and Pokerstars accepted a total of $500 million in total player deposits is a conservative estimate.

Persons indicted

The indictment named eleven individuals who were each charged with four crimes, including Raymond Bitar, CEO of TiltWare - software company for Full Tilt Poker, Isai Scheinberg, founder of PokerStars, Scott Tom, part owner of Absolute Poker, John Campos, Vice chairman of the board and part-owner of SunFirst Bank and others.

The prosecutors were seeking jail sentences for the indicted executives and $3 billion from the poker companies. When the U.S. Department of Justice pursued Party Poker in 2006, it led to a $300 million plea agreement by PartyGaming co-founder Anurag Dikshit and a $105 million settlement with the company itself in 2009. In the criminal case, "The maximum penalty for violation of the UIGEA and operating a gambling business is 5 years in prison and a fine of $250,000 or twice the gross gain or loss for each charge, for conspiracy to commit wire fraud is 30 years in prison and a fine of $1 million or twice the gross gain or loss, and for money laundering conspiracy is 20 years in prison and a fine of $500,000 or twice the amount laundered."

Government position

Preet Bharara, the United States Attorney for the Southern District of New York, expressed his view when the indictment was unsealed:

As charged, these defendants concocted an elaborate criminal fraud scheme, alternately tricking some U.S. banks and effectively bribing others to assure the continued flow of billions in illegal gambling profits. Moreover, as we allege, in their zeal to circumvent the gambling laws, the defendants also engaged in massive money laundering and bank fraud. Foreign firms that choose to operate in the United States are not free to flout the laws they don't like simply because they can't bear to be parted from their profits.

FBI Assistant Director-in-Charge Janice K. Fedarcyk added:

These defendants, knowing full well that their business with U.S. customers and U.S. banks was illegal, tried to stack the deck. They lied to banks about the true nature of their business. Then, some of the defendants found banks willing to flout the law for a fee. The defendants bet the house that they could continue their scheme, and they lost.

In the amended complaint the government alleged that "Full Tilt Poker did not maintain funds sufficient to repay all players, and in addition, the company used player funds to pay board members and other owners more than $440 million since April 2007." Furthermore, the amended complaint uses the term ponzi scheme prominently, including in its title.

A lawyer for Ferguson has denied the allegations, suggesting that the issues may have been the result of mismanagement not malice. A lawyer for some of the defendants issued a press release stating that the phrase ponzi scheme was inaccurate, unfair and disingenuous and that its use was counterproductive.

The parties reached a settlement on July 31, 2012, ending all litigation between the government and the PokerStars/Full Tilt companies.

Player response

"Along with everyone else in the poker world, I'm shocked," said Brandon Adams, a poker professional who has appeared in televised tournaments on NBC and ESPN. "The expectation was that there would be warning signs. These sites went from multibillion-dollar enterprises to on the ropes overnight." He added: "Some players have literally millions of dollars in their online poker accounts."

The Poker Players Alliance called upon poker players affected by the shutdown to contact their congressional representatives.

Poker player and then-current U.S. Congressman Barney Frank, in an interview with The Hill, lamented that the Justice Department is more focused on prosecuting online poker sites than those responsible for the subprime mortgage crisis and the 2008 financial crisis.

In an editorial in the Washington Post, poker player and a former three-term U.S. Senator from New York Alfonse D'Amato, a long-time favorite of industry lobbyists, wrote: "This is an attack on Internet poker and American poker players like me. Through these strong-arm tactics, prosecutors think they can ban Internet poker. Instead, they are making millions of Americans victims in an attempt to make online poker illegal without the support of legislators or the public." He called on President Barack Obama to rein in the prosecuting attorneys in the Southern District of New York.

International response

Antigua and Barbuda said US violated global trade laws and considered filing action in WTO. They had successfully won a similar case against US with WTO in response to US prosecution of owners of offshore gambling sites. At the time, online poker was the second largest industry in Antigua's economy.

Various sources report that this opened the way for Jack Binion to buy Full Tilt and ensure all Full Tilt Poker players get refunded in the process. On June 30, European investors agreed to provide capital to repay Full Tilt Players in exchange for a majority stake in the company. On July 26, the hearing revealed that Full Tilt owed () in overdue licensing fees to the AGCC, which Full Tilt paid within seven days as promised clearing the way for approval of a refinancing deal. The hearing was suspended until no later than September 15 as a result of the revelation. The delay until September 15 offers Full Tilt a chance to complete its negotiated settlement. On September 29, the AGCC stripped Full Tilt of its license. The AGCC's statement said that Full Tilt had misrepresented its financial situation, while Full Tilt said the action would jeopardize its ability to repay its customers.

Economic impact

Prior to the indictments, the United States accounted for 25 to 40% of the poker business for these companies. For PokerStars, the International business share was 70 to 75% and for Full Tilt it was 50 to 60%, according to one source.

The companies combined for an estimated US$200 million in advertising and marketing in the United States and their withdrawal from the U.S. market left network shows such as Poker After Dark and The Big Game without advertising sponsors. On Game Show Network, prepaid episodes of High Stakes Poker continued to air for several months after the event, but the show was in danger of not returning.

The companies accounted for a large proportion of World Series of Poker qualifiers via online satellites.

Wynn Resorts allied with PokerStars on March 25 to seek the legalization of Internet gambling in the U.S., but terminated the accord on April 15.

U.S. citizens who play online poker for a living effectively lost their livelihoods due to the DOJ action. Pokernews pointed out a thread on the Two Plus Two forums where the PPA asked players to share their stories. Among the poker networks seen as potential destinations for U.S. Poker players looking for a new online home are Carbon Poker and DoylesRoom.

According to Brandon Adams, live poker gambling at casinos might be a short-term beneficiary of the crackdown, but often online and live poker are not competitive but complementary, with players honing their skills in cheap, fast games online before gaining the nerve to play for higher stakes at a casino.

According to Time, the opposition to legalized domestic online gambling is depriving the United States economy from a huge potential source of tax revenues. One political action committee that received approximately $300,000 from PokerStars returned the money.

On April 26, PokerStars began processing cashouts. On May 4, Blanca Gaming of Antigua, the parent company to UB and Absolute Poker who had already laid off 95% of its employees, decided that it would have to pursue bankruptcy. On May 6, Pokerstars augmented their cashout policies to allow players to cashout frequent player points and pro-rata portions of partially earned VIP rewards bonuses.

On May 27, the Department of Justice unfroze an Irish account containing more than one-third of the more than $100 million that was owed to players. The account belonged to Full Tilt and its co-founder, Raymond Bitar. This was one of nine frozen Irish accounts. Full Tilt Poker had failed to uphold its promise to return U.S. Poker players by May 15, following the April 15 events. As a result, Full Tilt Pro Phil Ivey announced he would not be playing the 2011 World Series of Poker and suing Full Tilt. Ivey voluntarily withdrew the suit on June 30.

Arrests

John Campos and Chad Elie were arrested on Black Friday. Campos is part-owner and vice chairman of the board of directors for SunFirst Bank. On Monday, April 18, Campos, of St. George, Utah, appeared in a Utah court, but did not enter a plea. He was released on $25,000 bond, ordered to surrender his passport and to appear in a New York court for his next appearance. Chad Elie, of Las Vegas, made his first court appearance in Manhattan on Tuesday April 19. He was released on $250,000 bail.

Bradley Franzen made a court appearance in Manhattan on Monday April 18, entering a plea of 'not guilty' to the nine counts listed on his indictment, including bank fraud and money laundering charges. Franzen's bail was set at $200,000, for which his parents' house was used as collateral. Franzen pleaded guilty in a New York court on May 23, 2011. It is not known when he will be sentenced; however, it appears that Franzen struck a plea agreement with prosecutors, in which he agreed to cooperate in the probe, in return for which prosecutors would recommend leniency. Most of the other named defendants were out of the country.

Ray Bitar surrendered to authorities on July 2, 2012.

Isai Scheinberg surrendered to authorities upon landing in New York on January 17, 2020. Scheinberg surrendered his passports, posted a $1 million bond, and was released with orders to remain in the New York area. He was the last of the 11 original defendants to face his charges in the US. In September 2020, Scheinberg was sentenced to pay a fine of $30,000 with no jail time.

The judge presiding over the case acknowledged the wrongdoings but also recognized the positive actions taken by PokerStars under Scheinberg's leadership. Notably, PokerStars had stepped in to cover the debts of its rivals, Full Tilt and Ultimate Bet/Absolute Poker, ensuring that players received their frozen balances. The light sentence reflected these remedial actions and the broader context of Scheinberg's contributions to the online poker industry.

Convictions

On December 20, 2011, Absolute Poker co-founder Brent Buckley pleaded guilty to misleading banks. The plea deal calls for him to receive a sentence between a year and a year and a half in prison. Sentencing was set for April 19, 2012. Buckley was sentenced to 14 months.

On January 17, 2012, Ira Rubin entered a plea agreement in a Manhattan federal court in front of US Magistrate Judge Gabriel Gorenstein. Rubin agreed to plead guilty to three of the nine counts of conspiracy to commit bank fraud he faced and was expected to be sentenced to 18–24 months of prison. He received a three-year sentence. Judge Kaplan said, "You are an unreformed con man and fraudster," and calling his actions a "brazen" defiance of US law. "A significant sentence is necessary to protect the community."

John Campos pleaded guilty in March 2012 to a single misdemeanor bank gambling charge. He was sentenced in June to three months in prison. During his plea, Campos said his processing of the gambling proceeds for PokerStars and Full Tilt Poker was not in return for a $10 million investment in the bank.

References

References

1. (2011-04-20). "Online Poker Companies Reach Accord With U.S. on Players' Access to Money". [[Bloomberg News]].
2. (2011-06-01). "Civil complaint". Scribd.com.
3. Silver, Nate. (2011-04-20). "After 'Black Friday,' American Poker Faces Cloudy Future". [[The New York Times]] (blog).
4. Berzon, Alexandra. (2011-09-21). "U.S. Alleges Poker Site Stacked Deck". [[The Wall Street Journal]].
5. Richtel, Matt. (2011-09-21). "Poker Web Site Cheated Users, U.S. Suit Says". [[The New York Times]].
6. Richtel, Matt. (15 April 2011). "U.S. Cracks Down on Online Gambling". The New York Times.
7. (2012-07-31). "ESPN: PokerStars settles, acquires FTP". Espn.go.com.
8. Vaughn, Jake. "Legal Status of Online Poker in the United States". OCBB.
9. "WSOP {{!}} Tournament Schedule".
10. Cypra, Dan. (2011-04-25). "iMEGA: Signs Were There for Online Poker Seizures".
11. PULKKINEN, LEVI. (2010-09-23). "High Court upholds state ban on Internet poker, online gambling". Seattle P-I.
12. Mahoney, Kevin J.. (2011-04-21). "U.S. Attorney's Office on Tilt". Mahoney Criminal Defense Group.
13. "18 USC § 1955 - Prohibition of illegal gambling businesses". Law.cornell.edu.
14. (2011-04-22). "Witness protection likely for Tzvetkoff". Sydney Morning Herald.
15. Sullum, Jacob. (2010-04-21). "Getting Away With Poker: How is helping people play a card game like murder?". Reason.
16. Bennett, Meet The Boy Genius Who Just Took Down The Online Poker Industry Dashiell. (2011-04-15). "Meet The Boy Genius Who Just Took Down The Online Poker Industry". [[Business Insider]].
17. Toohey, Paul. (2011-04-16). "Web king behind FBI raids". The Courier-Mail.
18. McKenna, Michael. (2011-04-16). "Arrests follow internet high-flyer's release". [[The Australian]].
19. Johnson, Mike. (2011-04-18). "PokerCast Episode 168 – Black Friday Special; Aftermath of the Online Poker Indictments". [[Two Plus Two Publishing.
20. Sullum, Jacob. (2011-04-20). "Poker Bars: Why Should Anyone Go to Prison for Helping People Play Cards?". [[KRLA]].
21. Richtel, Matt. (2011-04-15). "U.S. Cracks Down on Online Gambling". [[The New York Times]].
22. "UNITED STATES ENTERS DOMAIN-NAME USE AGREEMENTS WITH TWO ONLINE POKER COMPANIES".
23. Rubenfeld, Samuel. "PokerStars, Full Tilt Poker Settle with Justice Department". WSJ.
24. (2011-04-18). "Online Poker Player Accounts Frozen as U.S. Indicts Operators". [[Bloomberg News]].
25. (2011-04-15). "Three largest online poker sites indicted and shut down by FBI". [[Los Angeles Times]].
26. Newell, Jennifer. (2009-04-07). "PartyGaming Settles With U.S. Dept. of Justice for $105 Million". [[Bluff Magazine]].
27. Bharara, Preet. (2011-04-22). "Manhattan U.S. Attorney Charges Principals of Three Largest Internet Poker Companies With Bank Fraud, Illegal Gambling Offenses and Laundering Billions in Illegal Gambling Proceeds". United States Attorney Southern District of New York.
28. (2011-09-20). "Manhattan U.S. Attorney Moves To Amend Civil Complaint Alleging That Full Tilt Poker and Its Board of Directors Operated Company As A Massive Ponzi Scheme Against Its Own Players". [[United States Department of Justice]].
29. United States of America. (September 20, 2011). "VERIFIED FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT 11 Civ. 2564". UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK.
30. Greg Howard. (September 22, 2011). "Full Tilt Poker Denies it's a Ponzi Scheme". The Slatest.
31. Berzon, Alexandra. (September 22, 2011). "Poker Site Fires Back at U.S.". The [[Wall Street Journal]].
32. Richtel, Matt. (2011-09-21). "Poker Site Fires Back Over 'Ponzi Scheme' Charge". [[The New York Times]].
33. Berzon, Alexandra. (2012-08-02). "PokerStars and Full Tilt Poker Reach Settlement With Justice Department - WSJ.com". Online.wsj.com.
34. (2012-07-31). "Full Tilt Poker Issues Media Release Following Civil Settlement". Diamond Flush Poker.
35. "FBI — Manhattan U.S. Attorney Announces $731 Million Settlement of Money Laundering and Forfeiture Complaint with PokerStars and Full Tilt Poker". Fbi.gov.
36. Nagesh, Gautham. (2010-04-18). "Rep. Frank: Administration 'wasting time' with online poker crackdown". [[The Hill (newspaper).
37. D'Amato, Alphonse. (2011-04-22). "Make online poker legal? It already is". Washington Post.
38. Sutton, Jane. (2011-04-21). "Antigua says U.S. online poker shutdown was illegal". Reuters.
39. Collson, Brett. (2011-04-23). "U.S. Could Face World Trade Organization Action for Online Poker Shutdown".
40. Holloway, Chad. (2011-06-29). "Breaking News: Full Tilt Poker License Suspended by AGCC (Updated 9:20 a.m. PDT)". [[Poker News]].
41. Ruddock, Steve. (2011-06-29). "Is Jack Binion in talks with Full Tilt Poker?". PokerNewsBoy.com.
42. (2011-06-28). "Binion linked to Tilt stake". eGaming Review Magazine.
43. Berzon, Alexandra. (2011-06-30). "Regulator Closes Full Tilt Poker Website". [[The Wall Street Journal]].
44. Popper, Nathaniel. (2011-06-30). "Full Tilt Poker to be sold to European investors: Deal could allow U.S. players to recover as much as $150 million from the online poker company, which was shut down by U.S. prosecutors in April". [[Los Angeles Times]].
45. Berzon, Alexandra. (2011-07-01). "Full Tilt Owner Finds Buyer". [[The Wall Street Journal]].
46. Victor, Tom. (2011-08-08). "Full Tilt pays overdue Alderney licence fees".
47. (14 September 2011). "Full Tilt Poker". Aldernyey Gambling Control Commission.
48. Arnold, Susan. (2011-08-07). "Full Tilt Poker Pays Overdue Licensing Fees to AGCC". Internet Poker.
49. (2011-09-29). "Full Tilt Poker Site Loses License". [[The New York Times]].
50. (2011-04-17). "After indictments, poker industry looks forward". [[ESPN]].
51. (2011-04-17). "Poker programming takes hit after FBI's crackdown on sites". [[USA Today]].
52. (2011-07-26). "Inside the TV Poker Machine". [[Wall Street Journal]].
53. Peters, Donnie. (2011-04-22). "PokerNews Debate: Are Hysteric Reactions to Black Friday Warranted". Pokernews.
54. (2011-04-22). "Prosecutions turn online poker into a shaky bet".
55. Pappas, John. (2011-04-17). "The PPA Wants to Know How This Impacts You – Post Your Story in This Thread!". [[Two Plus Two Publishing.
56. Karp, Gregory. (2011-04-18). "Online poker industry ponders next move: Bust by Justice Department causes turmoil". Chicago Tribune.
57. Saporito, Bill. (2011-04-19). "Keeping Us Safe from Poker".
58. (2011-04-26). "PokerStars Processing U.S. Player Cashouts". Pokernewsdaily.com.
59. Brunker, Mike. (2011-05-04). "Indicted poker websites bound for bankruptcy: Collapse of Absolute Poker and UB sites means U.S. players may lose deposits". NBC News.
60. Holloway, Chad. (2011-05-04). "UB & Absolute Poker to File Bankruptcy". [[Poker News]].
61. "United States Players: Frequently Asked Questions". [[Pokerstars.com]].
62. (2011-05-27). "EXCLUSIVE: First Full Tilt account unfrozen". egaming.
63. (2011-06-01). "Phil Ivey sits out World Series of Poker". [[ESPN]].
64. [https://www.clarkcountycourts.us/Anonymous/CaseDetail.aspx?CaseID=8941347 Clark County Courts: Register of Actions]
65. (2011-04-19). "Chad Elie and John Campos Released". Pokernews.com.
66. (2002-05-29). "Associated Press: Illinois Man Pleads Guilty in Online Poker Case". Hosted.ap.org.
67. Bray, Chad. (2011-05-23). "Wall Street Journal: Guilty Plea in Online Poker Case". Online.wsj.com.
68. (2011-04-27). "Defendant in Online Poker Indictments Ira Rubin Arrested". Pokernews.com.
69. Vardi, Nathan. "Feds Arrest Full Tilt CEO Ray Bitar And Again Call Full Tilt Poker A Ponzi Scheme". Forbes.com.
70. (2020-01-25). "PokerStars Founder Isai Scheinberg To Face Federal Gambling Charges".
71. Schult, Steve. (2020-09-24). "Poker Site Operator Gets Slap On The Wrist For Charges Stemming From Black Friday".
72. (2020-03-25). "Southern District of New York {{!}} PokerStars Founder Pleads Guilty {{!}} United States Department of Justice".
73. (2020-09-23). "Scheinberg Gets Minimal Sentence for PokerStars' Illegal US Operations".
74. Neumeister, Larry. (2011-12-20}}{{dead link). "Poker company co-founder pleads guilty in NYC". Boston Globe.
75. B., Maggie. (July 29, 2012). "Real Money Online Poker, Black Friday Eleven, & Casino Bonuses". Casino Scam Report.
76. (2012-01-17). "Man Pleads Guilty in US Internet Gambling Crackdown". Wall Street Journal.
77. Neumeister, Larry. (2012-06-27). "Ex-Utah exec gets 3 months in NY poker case". [[Associated Press]].