United Progressive Alliance

History

2004–2008

UPA was formed soon after the 2004 Indian general election when no party had won a majority. The then ruling Bharatiya Janata Party-led National Democratic Alliance (NDA) won 181 seats of 544, as opposed to the UPA's tally of 218 seats.

The Left Front with 59 MPs (excluding the speaker of the Lok Sabha), the Samajwadi Party with 39 MPs and the Bahujan Samaj Party with 19 MPs were other significant blocks that supported UPA at various times. UPA did not achieve a majority, rather it relied on external support, similar to the formula adopted by the previous minority governments of the United Front, the NDA, the Congress government of P. V. Narasimha Rao, and earlier governments of V. P. Singh and Chandra Shekhar.

An informal alliance had existed prior to the elections as several of the constituent parties had developed seat-sharing agreements in many states. After the election the results of negotiations between parties were announced. The UPA government's policies were initially guided by a common minimum programme that the alliance hammered out with consultations with Jyoti Basu and Harkishan Singh Surjeet of the 59-member Left Front. Hence, government policies were generally perceived as centre-left, reflecting the centrist policies of the INC.

During the tenure of Jharkhand Chief Minister Madhu Koda, the constituents of the UPA were, by mutual consent, supporting his government.

On 22 July 2008, the UPA survived a vote of confidence in the parliament brought on by the Left Front withdrawing their support in protest at the India–United States Civil Nuclear Agreement. The Congress party and its leaders along with then Samajwadi Party leader Amar Singh were accused of a "cash for vote" scam as part of the cash-for-votes scandal, in which they were accused of buying votes in Lok Sabha to save the government. During UPA I, the economy saw steady economic growth and many people (100 million+) escaped poverty.

2009–2014

In the 2009 Lok Sabha election, the UPA won 262 seats, of which the INC accounted for 206. During UPA II, the alliance won election in Maharashtra, Haryana and Arunachal Pradesh. However, there were several allegations of scams during its tenure that impacted UPA's image nationwide and the approval rating for the government fell. In addition, many members left for YSRCP. This started a domino effect with members leaving to form their own parties and parties such as DMK leaving the alliance altogether. During this time UPA struggled with state election and leadership stability. The alliance suffered a defeat in 2014 Indian general election as it won only 60 seats. In addition, UPA won only one state election and got wiped out from Andhra Pradesh where they previously had 150+ MLAs.

2015–2019

From 2014 to 2017, UPA won only 3 state elections. This was blamed on the alliance's failed leadership and weakness compared to the NDA. In addition the party lost power in states where they had once won state elections as in Bihar. In 2017 the alliance lost again. In 2018 UPA had a phenomenal comeback in the state elections as the party won important in Karnataka, Rajasthan and others. More parties joined the alliance and it was stronger than ever.

In the 2019 Indian general election the UPA won only 91 seats in the general election and INC won 52 seats, thus failing to secure 10% seats required for the leader of opposition post. The alliance lost another state to the BJP with the party winning by-polls and pushing the UPA into the minority.

Towards the end of 2019, the alliance made huge gains in Haryana, won in Jharkhand and formed a state-level alliance called Maha Vikas Aghadi (MVA) to form the government in Maharashtra with Uddhav Thackeray of Shiv Sena leading the ministry. Shiv Sena had been a member of NDA for twenty five years. It left NDA and joined MVA in 2019.

2020–2023

Since 2020, more parties joined the alliance. The alliance lost the Bihar election that it was expected to win but in 2022, ruling party JD(U) left National Democratic Alliance and rejoined Mahagathbandhan to form the government in Bihar.

In addition UPA only won 1 out of the 5 state elections in 2021. However the alliance made significant gains in a number of MLA races. MVA lost control of Maharashtra due to crisis and split in Shiv Sena. Moreover, UPA lost in Gujarat assembly elections however, it won the state election in Himachal Pradesh.

In 2023, UPA again failed in winning elections in the North-East but won the assembly in the very important state of Karnataka.

The alliance was rebranded as the Indian National Developmental Inclusive Alliance on 18 July 2023, with many parties joining the newly-formed alliance. The alliance contested the 2024 Indian general election, serving as the primary opposition to the ruling National Democratic Alliance.

Former Members

Current Members at the time of dissolution.

Members left before dissolution.

Poll performances

List of presidents

Note that it refers to nomination by alliance, as the offices of President and Vice President are apolitical.

Presidents

List of Vice presidents

List of prime ministers

Candidates in elections

Lok Sabha general elections

• 2009 Indian general election
• 2014 Indian general election
• 2019 Indian general election

Electoral performance

Controversies

The winter session of parliament in October 2008 came under intense criticism from the Left parties and the BJP to demand a full-fledged winter session instead of what was seen as the UPA to having "scuttled the voice of Parliament" by bringing down the sittings to a record low of 30 days in the year. The tensions between the UPA and the opposition parties became evident at an all-party meeting convened by Lok Sabha speaker Somnath Chatterjee when the leader of opposition, L. K. Advani questioned the status, timing and schedule of the current session of parliament.

M. Karunanidhi had said he felt "let down" by the "lukewarm" response of the centre and had demanded amendments in the resolution on Sri Lanka -

• One of the amendments was to "declare that genocide and war crimes had been committed and inflicted on the Sri Lankan Tamils by the Sri Lanka Army and the administrators".
• The second one was "establishment of a credible and independent international commission of investigation in a time-bound manner into the allegations of war crimes, crimes against humanity, violations of international International human rights law, violations of international humanitarian law and crime of genocide against the Tamils". Karunanidhi said Parliament should adopt the resolution incorporating these two amendments.

Between 2005 to 2008 and 2010 to 2013, the UPA faced sustained criticism, due to the failure to prevent several terrorist attacks nationwide. The UPA Government repealed the Prevention of Terrorism Act, 2002 in 2004, which was criticized by then Gujarat Chief Minister and Future Prime Minister Narendra Modi, as it weakened India’s counterterrorism framework and reduced the powers available to law-enforcement agencies. Subsequently, several terror attacks took place in 2008 across cities like Jaipur, Bangalore, Ahmedabad and Delhi, led by the Indian Mujahideen under support from Pakistan-based ISI, as well as the 2005 Delhi bombings, 2006 Mumbai train bombings and 2006 Varanasi bombings; allies of UPA such as Samajwadi Party were also criticized for labeling the Batla House encounter as fake and supporting the accused arrested by Delhi Police, which occurred less than a week after the Delhi bombings in September 2008.

During the November 2008 terror attacks in Mumbai, when 10 Pakistani terrorists from the banned terror outfit Lashkar-e-Taiba under support from Pakistan Army and ISI, came from the sea route and targeted the city from 26 to 29 November 2008, the UPA Government faced widespread outrage from citizens and leaders of opposition for intelligence failures as well as delay in deploying NSG commandos, who neutralized 8 of the 10 terrorists at the Taj Mahal Palace Hotel, the Oberoi Trident hotel, and the Chabad House. Furthermore, Congress leader Digvijaya Singh, faced heavy criticism for launching a book which mentioned that the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh was somehow linked to the attack, despite credible evidence and confessions from Ajmal Kasab, the only gunman who was captured by Mumbai Police; Singh, along with several other UPA leaders, was also publicly criticized for coining the terms Hindu Terror and Saffron Terror. The 2008 attacks in Mumbai subsequently led to resignation of several leaders like Vilasrao Deshmukh, R. R. Patil and Shivraj Patil, on the grounds of moral responsibility as well as for making insensitive statements in the aftermath. Additionally, the UPA faced condemnation from opposition leaders and commentators for ruling out military action against Pakistan, with critics describing the response as insufficiently strong.{{cite news |author=Press Trust of India |title=No military action against Pakistan: India |work=Times of India |location=India |date=2 December 2008 |url= http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/No_military_action_against_Pakistan_India/articleshow/3783853.cms |access-date=9 December 2008}}

Following the 2011 Mumbai bombings, which claimed 26 lives and injured 130+, UPA leader and INC General Secretary Rahul Gandhi remarked that it was impossible to stop every terror attack, adding that "We work towards defeating it, but it is very difficult to stop all the attacks. Even the United States, they are being attacked in Afghanistan.". His comments were slammed from some quarters of the Indian political spectrum, who criticised him for equating the Mumbai attacks with those in Afghanistan and called it an insult to those killed in the blasts. The ineptness towards national security, the insensitive statements made by Congress leadership following the terror attack, and the inaction against Pakistan sponsored terrorist groups was one of the few factors that led to the UPA suffering a major defeat in the 2014 General elections.

The UPA was criticised for its alleged involvement scams such as the Commonwealth Games Scam of 2010, the 2G spectrum case, the Indian coal allocation scam, and the AgustaWestland VVIP chopper deal. Apart from the above-mentioned scams, the UPA has been under intense fire for the alleged doles handed out to the son-in-law of the Gandhi family, Robert Vadra, by UPA-run state governments. The UPA was also rebuked for shielding and not prosecuting RJD leader and Railway Minister during UPA 1 Lalu Prasad Yadav, for his involvement in several corruption cases, including the fodder scam case as well as creating Jungle Raj in Bihar between 1990 and 2005, which affected economic and social standing of the state. Additionally, the UPA faced serious criticism on mishandling the national carrier Air India, which led to its financial crisis in 2006–07, before being sold to the Tata group in 2022.

The UPA Government has been severely condemned for mishandling the aftermath of the 2012 Delhi gang rape case. As per several media houses, the Government had failed to act positively or give credible assurances to the protesters and instead used police force and lathi-charging against protesters, while pushing the media out of the scene, and shutting down metro rail stations. In the aftermath of the incident, while the Government passed an amendment of the laws against rape and sexual assault, which ensured stricter punishments for rape convicts, the amendment was criticized and labeled as an eyewash, as the changes in the laws failed to serve as a deterrent to rising incidents of rape. Furthermore, several key suggestions were ignored, including the criminalisation of marital rape and trying military personnel accused of sexual offences under criminal law, which was severely condemned by several women's safety activists. The UPA was also slammed for inaction against political leaders such as Digvijaya Singh and Mulayam Singh Yadav for their comments which promoted misogyny and anti-women views, with Yadav and his party leadership being labeled in 2014 as supporters and defenders of rape and rapists; Yadav was previously condemned for opposing the Women's Reservation Bill in March 2010 and warning to withdraw from the alliance, making a sexist comment that "if the bill is passed it will fill Parliament with the kind of women who invite catcalls and whistles".

During its tenure between 2004 and 2014, as well as before, the UPA faced widespread condemnation for indulging in appeasement politics for vote-bank of the Muslim community across India. Following the introduction of Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Marriage) Act, 2019, which criminalized triple talaq or instant divorce and replaced the Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act 1986, several leaders from the UPA opposed the law. In addition, the UPA faced immense criticism for the formation of the WAQF Board to appease the Muslim community, which has been responsible for land grabbing and forcible acquisition of properties nationwide, while evicting the original owners who possessed legal documents of ownership.

The UPA, in its opposition, faced immense criticism by the NDA Government for banking frauds, mostly by giving unsecured loans to fugitive businessmen Vijay Mallya, Nirav Modi and Mehul Choksi during the tenure of then Prime Minister Manmohan Singh. Mallya owes money to a consortium of 17 banks, from whom he took loan to fund his now closed Kingfisher Airlines, and Modi owes money to the Punjab National Bank. While Mallya and Modi have been apprehended in the Great Britain and awaiting extradition, Choksi acquired citizenship of Antigua and Barbuda, with a warrant against him to extradite to India for the bank fraud.

References

Notes

References

1. "United Progressive Alliance political organization, India".
2. Lowell Barrington. (2009). "Comparative Politics: Structures and Choices". Cengage Learning.
3. (2012). "Pax Ethnica: Where and How Diversity Succeeds". PublicAffairs.
4. (May 2012). "UPA and secularism".
5. DeSouza, Peter Ronald. (2006). "India's Political Parties Readings in Indian Government and Politics series". [[SAGE Publishing]].
6. (2014). "Globalization and Democracy". [[Rowman & Littlefield]].
7. N. S. Gehlot. (1991). ["The Congress Party in India: Policies, Culture, Performance"]({{Google books). Deep & Deep Publications.
8. (2018). "Religion and Nationalism in Global Perspective". [[Cambridge University Press]].
9. (1989). "Nehru on Social Issues". Concept Publishing.
10. "United Progressive Alliance, UPA, UPA Performance General Election 2009, UPA Tally, UPA in Lok Sabha Elections 2009, India Elections 2009, General Elections, Election Manifesto, India Election News, India Elections Results, Indian Election Schedule, 15th Lok Sabha Elections, General Elections 2009, State Assembly Elections, State Assembly Elections Schedule, State Assembly Election Results". electionaffairs.com.
11. "Opposition meeting: 26 Indian parties form alliance to take on PM Modi". BBC News.
12. (2023-07-18). "NDA vs I.N.D.I.A in 2024 as UPA rebrands itself as Indian National Developmental Inclusive Alliance at Opposition meet".
13. [http://www.hindu.com/2008/07/12/stories/2008071260391200.htm Small parties, independents in great demand] {{Webarchive. link. (19 May 2009)
14. Originally the SP had [http://164.100.47.134/newls/membershomepage.aspx 39 MPs] {{Webarchive. link. (31 August 2009 . [https://www.rediff.com/news/2008/jul/25upavote1.htm 6 MPs defied party whip] and have been expelled from the party.)
15. [http://164.100.47.134/newls/membershomepage.aspx Lok Sabha members] {{webarchive. link. (31 August 2009)
16. (May 2016). "Congress pins hopes on Jyoti Basu }}{{dead link". The Times of India.
17. [http://www.rediff.com/news/2006/sep/14jhar5.htm Madhu Koda to be next Jharkhand CM] {{Webarchive. link. (3 January 2008 . Retrieved 26 March 2007.)
18. (22 July 2008). "Indian government survives vote". BBC News.
19. (5 August 2011). "Cash-for-votes scam: The deadly secrets of sting Singh : Cover Story – India Today". intoday.in.
20. "Cash For Vote Scam – Amar Singh – Supreme Court – Sudheendra Kulkarni – Swamajwadi Party – BJP". oneindia.com.
21. "Cash-for-vote scam 2008: Court orders further probe". indianexpress.com.
22. (23 January 2022). ""Wasted 25 Years in Alliance With BJP...," Says Uddhav Thackeray". NDTV.com.
23. (2023-07-19). "'I.N.D.I.A': Rebranded UPA has a new name and the same contradictions".
24. "List of Presidents of India since India became republic {{!}} My India".
25. Political Bureau. "Left joins BJP to sing chorus against UPA". The Financial Express.
26. "DMK pulls out of UPA govt over Sri Lanka Tamils issue – ''The Times of India''". [[The Times of India]].
27. "[http://www.expressindia.com/latest-news/Modi-accuses-Centre-of-adopting-double-standards-on-terrorism/309910/ Modi accuses Centre of adopting double standards on terrorism] {{Webarchive. link. (17 May 2008 ", [[The Indian Express). Express India]], 15 May 2008.
28. "Bangalore, Ahmedabad blasts uncannily similar".
29. "'SP may pull out if Jamia students are innocent'".
30. Gopalakrishnan, Raju. (1 December 2008). "India directs anger at politicians after Mumbai attacks".
31. Sharma, Aman. (29 November 2008). "Red tape delays NSG by 6 hours".
32. Pandey, Raghav. (13 May 2018). "After Nawaz Sharif's admission of Pakistan role in 26/11, time Congress apologised to RSS, India".
33. (28 December 2010). "RSS & 26/11: Digvijaya flags it off again, this time in Mumbai".
34. [https://web.archive.org/web/20081201183544/http://sify.com/news/politics/fullstory.php?id=14808590 Shivraj Patil resigns]. Sify.com (30 November 2008). Retrieved on 29 December 2011.
35. (December 2008). "Maharashtra deputy cm RR Patil resigned.". The Economic Times.
36. (30 November 2008). "Deshmukh visit Taj with R.G. Varma sparked anger.". Hindustan Times.
37. (14 July 2011). "Difficult to stop terror attacks all the time, says Rahul Gandhi".
38. (14 July 2011). "Sena slams Rahul for equating Mumbai and Afghan attacks".
39. "Opposition slams Rahul's statement on terror".
40. "UPA government's decision not to act against Pakistan after 26/11 amounted to treachery: Eknath Shinde".
41. "CAG raps Haryana govt. for showing undue favours to Robert vadra". The Economic Times.
42. (8 September 2011). "Air India aircraft acquisition was necessary". [[Malayala Manorama]].
43. Choudhury, Santanu. (8 September 2011). "Auditor Slams Air India Plane Orders". [[The Wall Street Journal]].
44. Kaul, Vivek. (24 December 2012). "Shinde-speak shows all that is wrong with government". FirstPost.
45. "To Solve Violence Against Women, We Need More Than Just Criminal Law Reforms".
46. (3 February 2013). "We have accepted 90% of Justice Verma panel's recommendations: Law Minister". NDTV.
47. "Boys Make Mistakes: Mulayam Defends Rape".
48. (27 July 2013). "Digvijaya calls Meenakshi Natarajan 'sau tunch maal', rapped for sexist remark". The Times of India.
49. (9 November 2012). "Mulayam opposes Women Reservation Bill, says 'our poor and rural women are not attractive'". The Times of India.
50. (10 April 2014). "Mulayam's shocker on rape: Boys make mistakes, why hang them?". NDTV.
51. (27 December 2018). "Lok Sabha debates bill 'criminalising' instant triple talaq: Who said what". The Times of India.
52. "Waqf board bill based on Congress appointed panel's suggestions: Union min".
53. (30 January 2017). "Loans to Vijay Mallya granted during UPA rule, Manmohan Singh to blame, alleges BJP".
54. (9 March 2019). "'Nirav Modi cheated banks during UPA era... many brought back, others will follow': BJP reacts after PNB scam accused spotted".
55. (2 May 2018). "PNB scam: CBI to file chargesheet against 19 accused by May 15".
56. (3 March 2016). "SBI seeks Vijay Mallya's arrest in Kingfisher loan default case". The Financial Express.
57. Vijay Tagore. (25 May 2021). "PNB scam: Mehul Choksi goes missing in Antigua, may have fled to Cuba".
58. (14 May 2020). "Vijay Mallya loses final appeal against extradition". moneycontrol.com.
59. Shirbon, Estelle. (2021-02-25). "UK court allows extradition of diamond billionaire Nirav Modi to India". [[Reuters]].