Ufology

Etymology

Ufology is a neologism derived from UFO (a term coined by Edward J. Ruppelt), and is derived from appending the acronym UFO with the suffix -logy (from the Ancient Greek -λογία (-logia)). Early uses of ufology include an article in Fantastic Universe (1957) and a 1958 presentation for the UFO "research organization" The Planetary Center.

Historical background

The roots of ufology include the "mystery airships" of the late 1890s, the "foo fighters" reported by Allied airmen during World War II, the "ghost fliers" of Europe and North America during the 1930s, the "ghost rockets" of Scandinavia (mainly Sweden) in 1946, and the Kenneth Arnold "flying saucer" sighting of 1947. Media attention to the Arnold sighting helped publicize the concept of flying saucers. Publicity of UFOs increased after World War II, coinciding with the escalation of the Cold War and strategic concerns related to the development and detection (for example, the Ground Observer Corps) of advanced Soviet aircraft.

Official, government-sponsored activities in the United States related to ufology ended in the late 1960s following the Condon Committee report and the termination of Project Blue Book. Government-sponsored, UFO-related activities in other countries, including the United Kingdom, Canada, Denmark, Italy, and Sweden also ended. An exception to this trend is France, which maintains the GEIPAN program, formerly known as GEPAN (1977–1988) and SEPRA (1988–2004), operated by the French Space Agency CNES. On 14 September 2023, NASA reported the appointment, for the first time, of a Director of U.A.P. (known earlier as U.F.O.), identified as Mark McInerney, to scientifically and transparently study such occurrences.

As a field

Status as a pseudoscience

Main article: Identification studies of UFOs

Despite investigations sponsored by governments and private entities, ufology is not embraced by academia as a scientific field of study, and is instead generally considered a pseudoscience by skeptics and science educators, being often included on lists of topics characterized as pseudoscience as either a partial or total pseudoscience. Pseudoscience is a term that classifies arguments that are claimed to exemplify the methods and principles of science, but do not adhere to an appropriate scientific method, lack supporting evidence, plausibility, falsifiability, or otherwise lack scientific status.

Some writers have identified social factors that contribute to the status of ufology as a pseudoscience, with one study suggesting that "any science doubt surrounding unidentified flying objects and aliens was not primarily due to the ignorance of ufologists about science, but rather a product of the respective research practices of and relations between ufology, the sciences, and government investigative bodies". One study suggests that "the rudimentary standard of science communication attending to the extraterrestrial intelligence (ETI) hypothesis for UFOs inhibits public understanding of science, dissuades academic inquiry within the physical and social sciences, and undermines progressive space policy initiatives".

Current interest

In 2021, astronomer Avi Loeb launched The Galileo Project, which intends to collect and report scientific evidence of extraterrestrials or extraterrestrial technology on or near Earth via telescopic observations. In Germany, the University of Würzburg is developing intelligent sensors that can help detect and analyze aerial objects in hopes of applying such technology to UAP. A 2021 Gallup poll found that belief among Americans in some UFOs being extraterrestrial spacecraft grew between 2019 and 2021 from 33% to 41%. Gallup cited increased coverage in mainstream news and scrutiny from government authorities as a factor in changing attitudes towards UFOs.

In 2022, NASA announced a nine-month study starting in the fall to help establish a road map for investigating UAP—or for reconnaissance of the publicly available data it might use for such research. In 2023, the RAND Corporation published a study reviewing 101,151 public reports of UAP sightings in the United States from 1998 to 2022. The models used to conduct the analysis showed that reports of UAP sightings were less likely within 30 km of weather stations, 60 km of civilian airports, and in more–densely populated areas, while rural areas tended to have a higher rate of UAP reports. The most consistent and statistically significant finding was that reports of UAP sightings were more likely to occur within 30 km of military operations areas, where routine military training occurs.

Methodological issues

Although some ufologists like Peter A. Sturrock have proposed explicit methodological activities for the investigation of UFOs, scientific UFO research is challenged by the facts that the phenomena are spatially and temporally unpredictable, are not reproducible, and lack tangible physicality. That most UFO sightings have mundane explanations limits interpretive power of "interesting," extraordinary UFO-related events, with the astronomer Carl Sagan writing: "The reliable cases are uninteresting and the interesting cases are unreliable. Unfortunately there are no cases that are both reliable and interesting." The ufologists J. Allen Hynek and Jacques Vallée have each developed descriptive systems for characterizing UFO sightings and, by extension, for organizing ufology investigations.

Phenomena linked to ufology

In addition to UFO sightings, certain supposedly related phenomena are of interest to some ufologists, including crop circles, cattle mutilations, anomalous materials, alien abductions and implants. Some ufologists have also promoted UFO conspiracy theories, including the Roswell Incident of 1947, the Majestic 12 documents, and UFO disclosure advocates. Skeptic Robert Sheaffer has accused ufology of having a "credulity explosion", writing that "the kind of stories generating excitement and attention in any given year would have been rejected by mainstream ufologists a few years earlier for being too outlandish." The physicist James E. McDonald also identified "cultism" and "extreme...subgroups" as negatively impacting ufology.

In Posadism

During the Cold War, ufology was synthesized with the ideas of a Trotskyist movement in South America known as Posadism. Posadism's main theorist, J. Posadas, believed the human race must "appeal to the beings on other planets ... to intervene and collaborate with Earth's inhabitants in suppressing poverty". Posadas wished to collaborate with extraterrestrials to create a socialist system on Earth. The adoption of this belief among Posadists, who had previously been a significant political force in South America, has been noted as a contributing factor in their decline.

Governmental and private ufology studies

Starting in the 1940s, governmental agencies and private groups sponsored investigations, studies, and conferences related to ufology. Typically motivated by visual UFO sightings, the goals of these studies included critical evaluation of the observational evidence, attempts to resolve and identify the observed events, and the development of policy recommendations. These studies include Project Sign, Project Magnet, Project Blue Book, the Robertson Panel, and the Condon Committee in the United States, the Flying Saucer Working Party and Project Condign in Britain, GEIPAN in France, and Project Hessdalen in Norway. Private studies of UFO phenomena include those produced by the RAND Corporation in 1968, Harvey Rutledge of the University of Missouri from 1973 to 1980, and the National Press Club's Disclosure Project in 2001. Additionally, the United Nations from 1977 to 1979 sponsored meetings and hearings concerning UFO sightings. In August 2020, the United States Department of Defense established the Unidentified Aerial Phenomena Task Force to detect, analyze and catalog unidentified aerial phenomena that could potentially pose a threat to U.S. national security.

UFO organizations and events

Main article: List of UFO organizations

A large number of private organizations dedicated to the study, discussion, and publicity of ufology and other UFO-related topics exist worldwide, including in the United States, the United Kingdom, Australia, and Switzerland. Along with such "pro-UFO" groups are skeptic organizations that emphasize the pseudoscientific nature of ufology. During the annual World UFO Day (2 July), ufologists and associated organizations raise public awareness of ufology to "tell the truth about earthly visits from outer space aliens." The day's events include group gatherings to search for and observe UFOs.

References

References

1. "Ufology".
2. Blake, Joseph A.. (2015-05-27). "Ufology: The Intellectual Development and Social Context of the Study of Unidentified Flying Objects". The Sociological Review.
3. Restivo, Sal P.. (2005). "Science, technology, and society: an encyclopedia". Oxford University Press US.
4. Ruppelt, Edward. (2007). "The Report On Unidentified Flying Objects". BiblioBazaar.
5. Sanderson, Ivan T. "An Introduction to Ufology." ''Fantastic Universe''. Feb. 1957: 27–34. Print.
6. Adam. "Challenge of UFOs – Part II Chapter VII".
7. Brake, Mark. (June 2006). "On the plurality of inhabited worlds; a brief history of extraterrestrialism". International Journal of Astrobiology.
8. Denzler, Brenda. (2003). "The lure of the edge: scientific passions, religious beliefs, and the pursuit of UFOs". University of California Press.
9. Denzler (2003), p. 9
10. Schulgen, George. (October 28, 1947). "Schulgen Memo".
11. "The Air Force Intelligence Report".
12. Haines, Gerald K.. (April 14, 2007). "CIA's Role in the Study of UFOs, 1947–90".
13. "UFOs". nationalarchives.gov.uk.
14. (February 28, 2010). "UFO reports to be destroyed in future by MoD". Telegraph.
15. "Archived – Canada's UFOs: The Search for the Unknown – Library and Archives Canada – Archive 蒃 – Le phénomène des ovnis au Canada – Bibliothèque et Archives Canada". collectionscanada.gc.ca.
16. (January 29, 2009). "Secret UFO archives opened". The Copenhagen Post.
17. [http://www.aeronautica.difesa.it/Organizzazione/SMA/EntiDipendenti/Pagine/RGS_Ufo.aspx Italian Air Force UFO site] (in Italian)
18. (May 6, 2009). "För insyn: 18 000 svenska UFO-rapporter". Expressen.
19. GEIPAN stands for ''Groupe d'Études et d'Informations sur les Phénomènes Aérospatiaux Non-identifiés'' ("unidentified aerospace phenomenon research and information group").
20. Chang, Kenneth. (14 September 2023). "NASA Introduces New U.F.O. Research Director – The role was created in response to the recommendations of a report that found the agency could do more to collect and interpret data on unidentified anomalous phenomena.". [[The New York Times]].
21. Moldwin, Mark. (November 2004). "Why SETI IS Science and UFOlogy Is Not: A Space Science Perspective on Boundaries". [[Skeptical Inquirer]].
22. Tuomela, Raimo. (1985). "Science, action, and reality". Springer.
23. Feist, Gregory J.. (2006). "The psychology of science and the origins of the scientific mind". Yale University Press.
24. Restivo, Sal P.. (2005). "Science, technology, and society: an encyclopedia". Oxford University Press US.
25. Shermer, Michael. (2002). "The Skeptic Encyclopedia of Pseudoscience". ABC–CLIO, Inc.
26. {{Scientific American Frontiers. 8. 2. "Beyond Science"
27. Fraknoi, Andrew. (October 2009). "The 'Great Moon Hoax': Did Astronauts Land on the Moon?". [[Astronomical Society of the Pacific]].
28. (July 1986). "Statement of the position of the Iowa Academy of Science on Pseudoscience". [[Iowa Academy of Science]].
29. National Science Foundation. (2002). "Science and Engineering Indicators". National Science Foundation.
30. Hansson, Sven Ove. (September 3, 2008). "Science and Pseudo-Science".
31. Feist (2006), pp. 219–20
32. Eghigian, Greg. (2015-12-06). "Making UFOs make sense: Ufology, science, and the history of their mutual mistrust". Public Understanding of Science.
33. Cooper, Rachel. (2009). "Psychiatry as Cognitive Neuroscience: Philosophical Perspectives". [[Oxford University Press]].
34. Dodd, Adam. (27 April 2018). "Strategic Ignorance and the Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence: Critiquing the Discursive Segregation of UFOs from Scientific Inquiry". Astropolitics.
35. Loeb, Avi. (19 September 2021). "Astronomers Should be Willing to Look Closer at Weird Objects in the Sky – The Galileo Project seeks to train telescopes on unidentified aerial phenomena". [[Scientific American]].
36. (27 July 2021). "Galileo Project: scientists to search for signs of extraterrestrial technology". The Guardian.
37. (24 January 2022). "Can we find UFOs from above?". The Hill.
38. Mann, Adam. "Avi Loeb's Galileo Project Will Search for Evidence of Alien Visitation". Scientific American.
39. "Public Announcement".
40. (3 September 2021). "Deutschlandweit einmalig – Ufo-Forschung an der Uni Würzburg". BR24.
41. "UAP & SETI – Chair of Computer Science VIII – Aerospace Information Technology".
42. "Where Science and UAP Meet".
43. (2022). "Extraterrestrial Intelligence: Academic and Societal Implications". Cambridge Scholars Publishing.
44. Inc, Gallup -->. (2021-08-20). "Larger Minority in U.S. Says Some UFOs Are Alien Spacecraft".
45. Kelvey, Jon. (10 June 2022). "Nasa UFO study to focus on gathering data, not making conclusions". The Independent.
46. "NASA is assembling a team to gather data on unidentifiable events in the sky". CNN.
47. Bock, Michael. (9 June 2022). "NASA to Set Up Independent Study on Unidentified Aerial Phenomena".
48. (2023-07-25). "Not the X-Files: Mapping Public Reports of Unidentified Aerial Phenomena Across America". RAND Corporation.
49. Sturrock (2000) p. 163
50. Denzler (2003), p. 35
51. Hoyt, Diana Palmer. (2000-04-20). "UFOCRITIQUE: UFO's, Social Intelligence and the Condon Committees". [[Virginia Polytechnic Institute]].
52. Markovsky B., "UFOs", in ''The Skeptic's Encyclopedia of Pseudoscience'', edited by [[Michael Shermer]], 2002 Skeptics Society, p. 260
53. Sagan, Carl. (1975). "Other Worlds". Bantam.
54. Hynek, J. Allen. (1974). "The UFO experience: a scientific enquiry". Corgi.
55. Tumminia, Diana G.. (2007). "Alien worlds: social and religious dimensions of extraterrestrial contact". Syracuse University Press.
56. Vallée, Jacques F.. (1998). "Physical Analyses in Ten Cases of Unexplained Aerial Objects with Material Samples". [[Journal of Scientific Exploration]].
57. (2003). "Crop circles: signs of contact". Career Press.
58. (4 August 2011). "Coming soon to a field near you". [[Physics World]].
59. Howe, Linda Moulton. (1989). "Alien Harvest: Further Evidence Linking Animal Mutilations and Human Abductions to Alien Life Forms". Linda Moulton Howe Productions.
60. "Stanford Professor Garry Nolan Is Analyzing Anomalous Materials From UFO Crashes". Vice.
61. (1 January 2022). "Improved instrumental techniques, including isotopic analysis, applicable to the characterization of unusual materials with potential relevance to aerospace forensics". Progress in Aerospace Sciences.
62. Denzler (2003), p. 239
63. Leir, Roger K.. (1998). "The aliens and the scalpel : scientific proof of extraterrestrial implants in humans". Columbus, NC : Granite Pub..
64. Oberhaus, Daniel. (17 November 2017). "Watch This Doc on Alien Gangsters and the 'Biggest Story Never Told'". vice.com.
65. Leir, Roger. "The Smoking Gun".
66. "Aliens in Roswell".
67. (1992). "Crash at Corona: The U.S. Military Retrieval and Cover-up of a UFO". Paragon House.
68. (1991). "UFO Crash at Roswel". Avon Books.
69. Friedman, Stanton T.. (1997). "TOP SECRET/MAJIC". Marlowe & Co..
70. Salla, Michael. (2004). "Exopolitics: Political Implications of Extraterrestrial Presence". Dandelion Books.
71. Greer, Steven M.. (2001). "Disclosure : Military and Government Witnesses Reveal the Greatest Secrets in Modern History". Crossing Point.
72. Sheaffer, Robert. "A Skeptical Perspective on UFO Abductions". In: Pritchard, Andrea & Pritchard, David E. & Mack, John E. & Kasey, Pam & Yapp, Claudia. ''Alien Discussions: Proceedings of the Abduction Study Conference''. Cambridge: North Cambridge Press. pp. 382–388.
73. McDonald (1968)
74. "J. Posadas: Flying saucers ... and the socialist future of mankind (26 June 1968)".
75. Steven, John Sandor (2006). ''Permanent Revolution on the Altiplano: Bolivian Trotskyism''. Ann Arbor, Michigan: ProQuest Information and Learning Company, p. 314.
76. Kocher, George. (November 1968). "UFOs: What to Do?". [[RAND Corporation]].
77. Rutledge, Harley D.. (1981). "Project Identification: the first scientific field study of UFO phenomena". Prentice-Hall.
78. Dickinson, Alexander K.. (February 1982). "Interesting, But UFO's Still Unidentified". [[The Physics Teacher]].
79. Raymer, Katelynn. (May 10, 2001). "Group Calls for Disclosure of UFO Info". ABC News.
80. Watson, Rob. (May 10, 2001). "UFO spotters slam 'US cover-up'". [[BBC News]].
81. Kehnemui, Sharon. (May 10, 2001). "Men in Suits See Aliens as Part of Solution, Not Problem". Fox News.
82. link. (2011-06-22 UNBISnet- United Nations Bibliographic Information System, [[Dag Hammarskjöld Library]] (Retrieved May 4, 2010))
83. link. (2011-06-22 , UNBISnet (Retrieved May 4, 2010))
84. (August 14, 2001). "Establishment of Unidentified Aerial Phenomena Task Force". U.S. Dept. of Defense.
85. (26 June 2012). "July 2: World UFO Day, the Real U.S. Independence Day, I Forgot Day, Violin Lover's Day and Freedom from Fear of Public Speaking Day". Yahoo News.
86. (10 October 2012). "Organisations & Groups supporting / celebrating World UFO day". World UFO Day Website.
87. (2 July 2003). "Can you answer the UFO questions?". BBC News.
88. Schwartz, John. (3 July 2010). "Out of This World, Out of Our Minds". The New York Times.