The Criterion Collection

History

The company was founded in 1984 by Robert Stein, Aleen Stein and Joe Medjuck, who later were joined by Roger Smith. In 1985, the Steins, William Becker and Jonathan B. Turell founded the Voyager Company to publish educational multimedia CD-ROMs (1989–2000), and the Criterion Collection became a subordinate division of the Voyager Company, with Janus Films holding a minority stake in the company, and decided to expand its product on videocassettes and videodiscs. In March 1994, Verlagsgruppe Georg von Holtzbrinck GmbH bought 20% of Voyager for US$6.7 million; the four founders each retained a 20% owner's share.

In 1997, the Voyager Company was dissolved (Aleen Stein founded the Organa LLC CD-ROM publishing company), and Holtzbrinck Publishers sold the Voyager brand name, 42 CD-ROM titles, the Voyager web site and associated assets to Learn Technologies Interactive, LLC (LTI). Stein sold 42 Voyager titles to LTI from his Voyager/Criterion company share. The remaining three partners, Aleen Stein, Becker and Turell owned the Criterion Collection company, which has a business partnership with Janus Films and had one with Home Vision Entertainment (HVE) until 2005, when Image Entertainment bought HVE. On November 4, 2013, it was announced that Sony Pictures Home Entertainment would handle distribution. In May 2024, Janus Films and Criterion were acquired by Steven Rales.

Home Vision Entertainment

In 1986, Charles Benton founded Home Vision Entertainment (HVE), the home-video division of Public Media Inc. (PMI), which he had previously founded in 1968. The HVE company sold, advertised, marketed and distributed Criterion Collection DVDs, and also sold its own HVE brand of DVDs (co-produced with Criterion), including The Merchant Ivory Collection and the Classic Collection, a joint venture between Home Vision Entertainment and Janus Films. The latter enterprise published HVE imprint films, for which Janus Films owned the video rights, but which were unavailable from the Criterion Collection; however, Criterion published the Classic Collection films. In 2005, Image Entertainment bought HVE making it the exclusive distributor of Criterion Collection products until 2013.

Online ventures and marketing

The Criterion Collection began to provide video-on-demand (VOD) in partnership with Mubi (formerly The Auteurs) in 2008. In February 2011, Criterion began switching its VOD offerings exclusively to Hulu Plus. In November 2016, FilmStruck, a film streaming service from Turner Classic Movies, succeeded Hulu as the exclusive streaming service for the Criterion Collection. Some Criterion films were streamed by Kanopy. On October 26, 2018, Warner Bros. Digital Networks and Turner announced that FilmStruck would shut down on November 29. Criterion stated in a blog post that it was "trying to find ways we can bring our library and original content back to the digital space as soon as possible".

On November 16, 2018, Criterion announced the launch of the Criterion Channel as a standalone service, wholly owned and operated by the Criterion Collection, in the United States and Canada. Some of the VOD service's offerings are also available on the HBO Max streaming platform.

British film magazine Sight & Sound revealed in its April 2016 issue that Criterion would be expanding its releases to the United Kingdom. The first six titles were released on April 18, 2016.

The Criterion Closet is a film closet containing every title distributed by Criterion. Criterion regularly uploads videos of prominent film directors and actors (such as Martin Scorsese and Pamela Anderson) selecting films from the closet on their official YouTube channel.

In July 2025, Criterion agreed to pay US$4.5 million to settle a class action lawsuit alleging it unlawfully shared subscriber information with third parties including Meta and Twilio.

Contributions and influence

Letterboxing

With its eighth LaserDisc release, Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1956), Criterion introduced the letterbox format, which added black bars to the top and bottom of the 4:3 standard television set in order to preserve the original aspect ratio of the film. Thereafter, Criterion made letterboxing the standard presentation for all its releases of films shot in widescreen aspect ratios.

Commentary soundtracks

The Criterion Collection's second LaserDisc title, King Kong (1933), was the debut of the scene-specific audio commentary contained in a separate analog channel of the LaserDisc, in which American film historian Ronald Haver spoke about the production, cast, screenplay, production design and special effects. He also provides commentary on the LaserDisc editions of Casablanca (1942), Here Comes Mr. Jordan (1941), Singin' in the Rain (1952) and The Wizard of Oz (1939). Typically, the chapter-indexed commentaries are exclusive to the Criterion releases and their initial DVD reissues; they became collector's items when the original studios reissued titles previously licensed to Criterion, regardless of whether new commentary tracks were produced.

Special editions

The Criterion Collection began in 1984 with the releases of Citizen Kane (1941) and King Kong (1933) on LaserDisc, the latter's source negatives courtesy of the Library of Congress. The company later became known for pioneering the "special edition" DVD concept containing bonus materials such as trailers, commentaries, documentaries, alternate endings and deleted scenes. The success of these releases established the special-edition version in the DVD business. In 2006, taking advantage of advanced film-transfer and film-restoration technologies, Criterion published higher-quality versions, with bonus materials, of early catalog titles such as Amarcord (1973), Brazil (1985) and Seven Samurai (1954).

Film restoration

Originally, Criterion released art, genre and mainstream movies on LaserDisc such as Halloween (1978), Ghostbusters (1984), Bram Stoker's Dracula (1992), Armageddon (1998) and The Rock (1996). Increasingly, the Criterion Collection has also focused on releasing world cinema, mainstream cinema classics and critically successful obscure films. Using the best available source materials, the company produced technologically improved and cleaner versions, such as those for The Passion of Joan of Arc (1928), M (1931), Children of Paradise (1945), The Third Man (1949), Seven Samurai (1954) and Amarcord (1973). Almost every title contains film-cleaning and film-restoration essays in the booklets, while some even have featurettes comparing the restored and unrestored images.

Licenses

Some previously licensed Criterion Collection titles, such as The Harder They Come (1972), are now commercially unavailable as new product, and are only available in resale (used) form. Titles such as RoboCop (1987), Hard Boiled (1992), The Killer (1989) and Ran (1985) became unavailable when their publishing licenses expired or when Criterion published improved versions, such as those for Beauty and the Beast (1946), M (1931), The Wages of Fear (1953) and Seven Samurai (1954). over 200 of the 384 titles from the List of Criterion Collection Laserdisc releases have been re-released.

Another example is the film Charade (1963), which had become a public-domain property for lacking the legally-required copyright notice. Criterion produced a restored edition under license from Universal Pictures for the initial edition and for the later anamorphic widescreen re-release edition of the film.

Periodically, Criterion releases material on DVD and Blu-ray disc licensed from the studios with whom the company had previously dealt (such as Universal's and Terry Gilliam's 1985 film Brazil); these new releases are generally undertaken on a case-by-case basis.

Criterion released its first Walt Disney Pictures title, Andrew Stanton's WALL-E, in 2008. This was not the result of an ongoing deal between Disney (who has maintained a relationship with the distributor for titles from Touchstone Pictures and, since 2019, 20th Century Studios) and Criterion, but rather licensed as a one-off, with Stanton approaching Criterion and "wanting to be part of the club".

Formats

All Criterion titles are numbered, which is shown on the bottom of the spine of the packaging. Though the bulk of Criterion's catalog is of live-action films, they have also released animated films (such as Akira, Fantastic Planet, Fantastic Mr. Fox and WALL-E), television series (such as Tanner '88, Fishing with John and select episodes of I Love Lucy and The Addams Family) and music videos (Beastie Boys Video Anthology).

LaserDisc and VHS/Betamax

The Criterion Collection began publishing LaserDiscs on December 1, 1984, with its release of Citizen Kane, until March 16, 1999, with Michael Bay's Armageddon (#384). Three of the company's early titles (The 39 Steps, The Lady Vanishes and The Third Man) were also issued on VHS and Betamax. These were Criterion's only releases on those formats—other Janus/Criterion titles were often released to VHS through Home Vision Entertainment.

DVD and Blu-ray

Criterion entered the DVD market in 1998 with a reset numbering system, beginning with Seven Samurai, spine #2 (Grand Illusion, #1, was delayed for a year while restoration was underway on a then-newly-found camera negative). As with its laserdiscs, Criterion's early DVD editions of widescreen films were presented in the letterbox format, but Criterion did not anamorphically enhance its discs for 16:9 monitors until mid-1999 with its release of Insomnia (#47).

Criterion was slow to expand into high-definition releases, partly because of the HD format war between Blu-ray and HD DVD. Once Blu-ray emerged as the industry-standard high-definition home-video format, Criterion began to release Blu-ray editions of select films from its collection, beginning with the Blu-ray release of Wong Kar-wai's Chungking Express (#453) on December 16, 2008.

Despite the emergence of Blu-ray as the industry-standard high-definition format, Janus/Criterion continues to support the DVD format. Most of their new Blu-ray releases accompanied by a standard-definition DVD version and/or a 4K version (see below). Previous releases are regularly revised and upgraded for the newer formats. "Dual format" packages that contained both DVD and Blu-ray discs were briefly experimented with between November 2013 with their release of the Zatoichi boxset (#679), up through September 2014 with All That Jazz (#724), in response to negative customer feedback.

Aside from the core catalog, the company has also released films through its Essential Art House, Eclipse, Merchant Ivory and Janus Contemporaries lines, as well as a few releases outside of any product line. Many of these releases have also been collected and sold in various box sets.

In early 2016 for the first time in its history, Criterion announced it would begin releasing its catalogue outside of the US and Canada (earlier international Criterion titles such as the Japanese LaserDisc of Blade Runner were licensed to other companies). In partnership with Sony Pictures Home Entertainment, releases began to be distributed with the launch of six titles in the U.K. during the month.[[Image:Criterion Collection Blu-ray.png|thumb|right|112px|A Criterion Collection logotype: Blu-ray Criterion label, dates from the first movies released on December 16, 2008.]] Criterion's DVD releases are a mixture of NTSC-standard Region 0 (region-free) and Region 1 DVDs. Blu-ray discs are Region A-locked in North America or Region B-locked in the United Kingdom (though there are exceptions). However, when SPHE moved to Elevation Sales in the UK, the distribution moved to Spirit Entertainment.

Ultra HD Blu-ray

On August 11, 2021, Criterion announced that it would begin publishing titles on the Ultra HD Blu-ray format in November 2021. All Criterion Ultra HD Blu-ray releases will include both an Ultra HD Blu-ray copy and a regular Blu-ray copy of a film (with all the special features on the regular Blu-ray), with select releases including Dolby Vision HDR and Dolby Atmos. The first such releases were announced on August 16 for a November 21 release: Citizen Kane (#1104, returning to the collection for the first time since 1992), Mulholland Drive and Menace II Society. The company also released The Red Shoes, A Hard Day's Night and The Piano on Ultra HD Blu-ray disc. The 2019 film Uncut Gems (#1101), which was previously planned for a remastered Blu-ray release in October 2021, was delayed until November in order to also give the film an Ultra HD Blu-ray release.

Streaming as The Criterion Channel

After forays in providing titles from the Collection as streaming video-on-demand (VOD) in partnership with other companies – Mubi (formerly The Auteurs, 2008), Hulu (2011–2016) and TCM's FilmStruck (2016–2018) – Criterion titles found themselves without an online home when FilmStruck announced it would be shutting down on November 29, 2018. The company stated in a blog post that it was "trying to find ways we can bring our library and original content back to the digital space as soon as possible".

A month later, Criterion announced their own standalone subscription service, The Criterion Channel, available to subscribers in the United States and Canada. The service began on April 8, 2019. The Channel's offerings include rotating playlists, temporarily licensed films (and some television offerings) from a variety of studios and rights holders alongside streaming editions of Criterion Collection releases replete with special features. The Channel also hosts some original content, including academic overviews and curated introductions as well as featuring some Janus-owned titles that have yet to be released on physical media. Criterion maintains a close relationship with Warner Bros. Discovery's streaming platform HBO Max, which frequently also houses Criterion-released titles.

References

References

1. "The Criterion Collection Inc.". [[Hoover's]].
2. (April 16, 2014). "How Hulu Found a Subscriber Lure in Obscure Films". [[Bloomberg News.
3. Hunt, Joshua. (February 29, 2024). "Sure, It Won an Oscar. But Is It Criterion? - How the Criterion Collection became the film world's arbiter of taste". [[The New York Times]].
4. Kay, Jeremy. (2024-05-20). "Indian Paintbrush founder Steven Rales buys Criterion, Janus Films (exclusive)".
5. "Criterion Mission Statement".
6. (February 26, 2015). "How Criterion Collection Brings Movies Back From the Dead – Gizmodo on YouTube".
7. "The Criterion Collection".
8. Kozak, Oktay Ege. (December 5, 2017). "The Best Boutique Blu-ray Distributors (Who Aren't Criterion)".
9. Jarvis, Henry. (August 12, 2022). "10 Best Boutique Blu-Ray Brands".
10. (January 28, 2023). "Alliance Entertainment's Distribution Solutions Announces Partnership Extension with the Criterion Collection".
11. Virshup, Amy. (July 1996). "The Teachings of Bob Stein".
12. Brockman, John. "Bob Stein: The Radical". [[Edge.org.
13. (1985-10-23). "Janus And Voyager Team on Homevid". [[Variety (magazine).
14. "Aleen Stein". Organa Online.
15. "History". Home Vision Entertainment.
16. "Sony Inks Distribution, Admin Deal With Criterion".
17. Hasan, Mark Richard. (September 2004). "DVD Review". Music From the Movies.
18. (August 2, 2005). "Image Entertainment Acquires Home Vision Entertainment and Enters into Exclusive Multi-Year Home Video Distribution Agreement with The Criterion Collection".
19. Lawler, Ryan. (February 15, 2011). "As Netflix Goes After TV Fans, Hulu Chases Movie Buffs". [[The New York Times]].
20. Kleeman, Sophie. (April 26, 2016). "21 Classic Movies Getting Yanked From Hulu Soon". [[Gizmodo]].
21. Spangler, Todd. (October 26, 2018). "WarnerMedia to Shut Down FilmStruck Subscription-Streaming Service".
22. "News About FilmStruck".
23. "New, Independent Criterion Channel to Launch Spring 2019".
24. (March 4, 2016). "Criterion to Begin Releasing on Blu-ray in the UK". Blu-ray.com.
25. (March 4, 2016). "The Criterion Collection is expanding to the UK on April 18". CriterionCast LLC.
26. Article, Vittoria Benzine ShareShare This. (2024-09-17). "The Criterion Collection Is Taking Its Beloved Video Closet on the Road".
27. (3 July 2025). "$4.5M The Criterion Collection subscription class action settlement". Top Class Actions.
28. The Criterion Collection. "Invasion of the Body Snatchers".
29. The Criterion Collection. "FAQ".
30. (October 15, 2018). "From the Archives: The KING KONG commentary on Vimeo".
31. "The First Audio Commentary".
32. Barlow, Aaron. (2005). "The DVD Revolution: Movies, Culture, and Technology". Greenwood Publishing Group.
33. (January 11, 2009). "Entertainment Tonight: Criterion LaserDiscs – 1985".
34. Ulaby, Neda. (June 2004). "Criterion DVD Collection".
35. [https://web.archive.org/web/20070527103302/http://www.criterion.com/asp/laserdisc_browse.asp Criterion Collection on Laserdisc]
36. (June 27, 2010). "To Martin Scorsese, the Criterion Collection and Anyone Else Who'll Listen: More Public Domain Classics Worth Saving{{!}}HuffPost".
37. "Charade (Universal 100th Anniversary): DVD Talk Review of the DVD Video".
38. (April 27, 2015). "25 Essential DVD/Blu-ray Releases from The Criterion Collection « Taste of Cinema".
39. Zilko, Christian. (November 5, 2022). "Andrew Stanton Reached Out to Criterion About 'WALL-E' Because He 'Wanted to Be in the Club'". [[IndieWire]].
40. Ebiri, Bilge. (November 23, 2022). "Andrew Stanton Remembers When 'Nobody Wanted to Make' Wall-E". [[New York (magazine).
41. "Criterion Collection Laserdiscs".
42. "FAQS". The Criterion Collection.
43. Griffin, Al. (September 2008). "Criterion Remastered". [[Sound & Vision (magazine).
44. (November 22, 2008). "Chungking Express Blu-ray".
45. "Chungking Express (1994)".
46. "Why Dual-Format?{{!}}The Current{{!}}The Criterion Collection".
47. "Re:Format{{!}}The Current{{!}}The Criterion Collection".
48. "New UK Releases for April 2016". criterion.com.
49. "FAQ".
50. (August 11, 2021). "Citizen Kane to Lead Criterion's First 4K Slate".
51. (2021-08-16). "Criterion Announces November 2021 Titles".
52. (September 2021). "Criterion Sets 'Uncut Gems' 4K Edition for Nov. 23 – Media Play News".
53. "The Criterion Channel Announces Launch Lineup".