Syndicated procurement

Real-world examples

Auto industry

Competing German automobile manufacturers often procure steel in combined orders to reduce price.

Government

In early 2010 New Zealand’s Ministry of Social Development considered using syndicated procurement to purchase computers collectively with other New Zealand government agencies. In the United Kingdom, Crown Commercial Service (CCS) periodically arranges aggregation opportunities so that several public bodies can achieve savings through their consolidated buying power. Generally these opportunities operate as national further competitions (NFCs) using an existing government framework agreement to which all of the public bodies involved have access. CCS notes that the time involved in assembling a group of customers and collating their needs may mean the procurement process takes longer than it would if customers acted separately.

Construction

Australian building firms and contractors have begun to use syndicated procurement to purchase building materials. Procurement rounds have yielded price reductions of between 30% and 45%.

Legal considerations

In many jurisdictions syndicated procurement must be executed through a professional manager. Otherwise, competing firms placing orders together can be legally deemed to be price fixing, or artificially controlling market prices. However, syndicated procurement through a professional manager is the legal equivalent of purchasing through a wholesaler, and is therefore legally permissible.

Professional syndicate managers also provide a forum for syndication to competing firms that otherwise might be uncomfortable working together (this benefit is much more relevant to the private sector than to government agencies and non-profits).

Efficiency

Syndicated procurement is potentially more efficient than traditional procurement, because the syndicate manager identifies the precise volume, time, and locus of demand before the order is placed.

1. Traditional procurement chains typically include distributors and wholesalers, who make bulk orders without precise knowledge of the volume of customer demand for a given product, which means that orders can be too large (leftover stock) or to small (unsatisfied customer demand).
2. Distributors and wholesalers do not know when demand will appear, and so risk having to stock items for undetermined periods of time, and incur associated costs (or, conversely, risk not procuring items for which demand exists, and then missing a sale).
3. Finally, distributors and wholesalers do not know precisely where demand will appear, and as a result unwittingly deliver merchandise to points of sale with low demand, while leaving locations with high demand undersupplied. The result is missed sales, or incurring the expense and time lag of transporting the article.

Syndicate managers eliminate these three inefficiencies by knowing in advance exactly where, when, and how much of a given product will be needed.

Leadership and innovation

Facilitated by evolving telecommunications technologies and global logistics services, syndicated procurement is a fairly recent concept. A few pioneers are developing and establishing its methods and conventions:

Public sector

The New Zealand government has been a leader in introducing syndicated procurement among different government agencies. The New Zealand Ministry of Social Development has been particularly active in encouraging syndicated procurement.

References

References

1. (2010-02-15). "ComputerWorld article 15 February 2010". Fairfax Media Business Group.
2. {{OGL-attribution. Crown Commercial Services, [https://www.crowncommercial.gov.uk/buy-and-supply/aggregation/ Aggregation], accessed 26 February 2023
3. [http://www.med.govt.nz/upload/51233/terms-of-reference.pdf Ministry of Economic Development publication on syndicated procurement] {{webarchive. link. (May 23, 2010)
4. [http://plone.e.govt.nz/archive/services/procurement/coc/listing_archives New Zealand e-government page on syndicated procurement]