Stereotypes of Arabs and Muslims in the United States

"Billionaires, bombers, and belly dancers"

A report titled 100 Years of Anti-Arab and Anti-Muslim Stereotyping by Mazin B. Qumsiyeh, director of media relations for the American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee, describes what some in the Arab American community refer to as the "three B syndrome": Arabs in American media are typically portrayed as either bombers, belly dancers, or billionaires. This refers to a recurring depiction of Arab men as terrorists or wealthy oil magnates, and Arab women as exoticized sexual objects.

The report also highlights the harmful nature of these stereotypes, especially in cartoons, which often insult Arabs and Muslims. According to Qumsiyeh, such portrayals not only cause psychological harm but also contribute to dehumanization, which can lead to acts of physical violence. He writes:

Thomas Edison made a short film in 1897 for his patented Kinetoscope in which "Arab" women wearing enticing clothes dance to seduce a male audience. The short clip was called Fatima Dances. The trend shifted over the years and was dominated by the "billionaires" stereotype for a short while, especially during the oil crises of the 1970s. However, in the last 30 years, the predominant stereotype by far has been "Arab bombers".

In a piece published in the Los Angeles Times 28 July 1997, Laila Lalami offers a satirical "12-step guide" to making a successful Arab-bashing movie. Her list includes tropes such as: "the villains must all have beards", "they must all wear keffiehs", "they must have names like Ali, Abdul, or Mustapha", and "they must threaten to blow something up".

Following the September 11 attacks, Arab-American actors were increasingly typecast in roles depicting terrorists in film and television.

Jack Shaheen, professor emeritus of mass communications at Southern Illinois University, critically examined the portrayal of Arabs in American media in his book, The TV Arab (). He identified more than 21 major films released over a ten-year span in which the U.S. military is depicted killing Arabs—frequently presenting them as terrorists or adversaries of the United States. Notable examples include:

• Iron Eagle (1986)
• Navy SEALs (1990)
• Patriot Games (1992)
• True Lies (1994)
• Executive Decision (1996)

In his book Reel Bad Arabs (), Shaheen argues that "television's image of the Arab is omnipresent [and] is becoming a part of American folklore." He also observes that Arabs have "consistently appeared in American popular culture as billionaires, bombers, and belly dancers."

Shaheen further summarizes recurring negative stereotypes in American media portrayals, stating:

Arab Muslims are fanatics who believe in a different god, who don't value human life as much as we do. They are intent on destroying us (the West) with their oil or with their terrorism. The men seek to abduct and brutally seduce our women; they are without family, reside in a primitive place (the desert), and behave like primitive beings. The women are subservient—resembling black crows—or are portrayed as mute, somewhat exotic harem maidens.

Shaheen identified the following five films as among the worst offenders in terms of negative portrayals of Arabs in modern cinema:

• Rules of Engagement (2000), which he describes as a film that "justifies U.S. Marines killing Arab women and children."
• The Delta Force (1986)
• Death Before Dishonor (1987)
• True Lies (1994), in which, according to Shaheen, "Arnold S. INC. shoots dead Palestinians like clay pigeons."
• Wanted: Dead or Alive (1987), which, he writes, features "Arab thugs... plan[ning] to ignite Los Angeles... killing millions."

These stereotypes are also central to the semi-autobiographical film Driving to Zigzigland, in which actor and taxi driver Bashar Daas repeatedly finds himself typecast as an Arab Muslim extremist during film auditions in the United States.{{cite web |access-date=2012-10-02 |archive-url=https://web.archive.org/web/20121002123456/https://www.reuters.com/article/us-terror-actor-idUSL1472937920061214 |archive-date=2012-10-02 |url-status=dead

Another widely discussed example of stereotyping is the character Achmed the Dead Terrorist, created by ventriloquist Jeff Dunham. The puppet, which portrays a skeletal suicide bomber with a mock Middle Eastern accent, has drawn criticism for reinforcing anti-Muslim and anti-Arab stereotypes.

Airport racial profiling after 9/11

Main article: Airport racial profiling in the United States

In the aftermath of the September 11 attacks, in which 15 of the 19 hijackers were of Saudi Arabian origin and all were Muslim, Arabs and Muslims complained of increased scrutiny and racial profiling at airports. In a poll conducted by the Boston Globe, 71 percent of blacks and 57 percent of whites believed that "Arabs and Arab-Americans should undergo special, more intensive security checks before boarding airplanes." Some Muslims and Arabs complained of being held without explanation and subjected to hours of questioning and arrest without cause. Such cases have led to lawsuits by the American Civil Liberties Union. Fox News radio host Mike Gallagher suggested that airports have a "Muslims Only" line in the wake of the 9/11 attacks stating "It's time to have a Muslims check-point line in America's airports and have Muslims be scrutinized. You better believe it, it's time." In Queens, New York, Muslims and Arabs complained that the NYPD unfairly targets Muslim communities in raids tied to the alleged Zazi terror plot.

Stereotypes in film and their effects

The 1999 film The 13th Warrior, starring Antonio Banderas as the Arab diplomat Ahmad ibn Fadlan, is credited with introducing a rare Muslim protagonist in a major Hollywood production. The film has since gained a devoted cult following, particularly among Muslim audiences.

Other films featuring Muslim protagonists include the biographical drama Ali (2001), starring Will Smith as Muhammad Ali, and Disney's live-action adaptation Aladdin (2019), with Mena Massoud portraying the titular character. These productions have been noted for offering more positive and nuanced depictions of Arab and Muslim characters in mainstream cinema.

The 1975 film The Wind and the Lion, starring Sean Connery as Moroccan leader Mulai Ahmed er Raisuni, has also been praised in some reviews for presenting a more dignified portrayal of a Muslim character.

Stereotypes that the west has of the Middle East have made their way into the film industry, including that Muslims are terrorists, that all Muslims and Arabs look alike, and that the women are oppressed and abused, are only housewives and don't work. The TV series Homeland has been criticized for depicting Islam as "inherently violent and backward", with "[e]very single adult male Muslim character" being connected to terrorism. Films such as American Sniper and Argo have also been criticized for depicting Muslims as violent and deceitful.

When impressionable children in the US who may not have much experience with Muslims or Arabs see negative depictions of Arabs they come to believe that this is reality. Children who had had some exposure to Muslims or were familiar with Islam viewed Arab Muslims more positively than less knowledgeable children.

References

References

1. (2022-09-17). "Omar Sharif: The Egyptian who conquered Hollywood".
2. Diab, Khaled. "Omar Sharif: Actor without borders".
3. (2008). "American Educational History Journal Volume 35, Number 1 And 2 2008". Information Age Pub.
4. (2003-07-01). "Interpreting Islam in American Schools". The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science.
5. (15 April 2017). "The SAGE Encyclopedia of Psychology and Gender". SAGE Publications.
6. (2023). "Same view, different lens: How intersectional identities reduce Americans' stereotypes of threat regarding Arab and Black men". Group Processes & Intergroup Relations.
7. Qumsiyeh, Mazin B.. "100 Years of anti-Arab and anti-Muslim stereotyping".
8. Lalami, Laila. "Why Hollywood Owes Me Money".
9. Lalami, Laila. (1997-07-28). "Arab-Bashing for Fun and Profit". Los Angeles Times.
10. Khalil, Ashraf. (2007-10-04). "But can you play a terrorist?". Los Angeles Times.
11. "The Portrayal of Arabs in American Media".
12. Kessler, Jim. "Patrick Harrington interviews Jack Shaheen, author of ''Reel Bad Arabs''". Thirdway.org.
13. "Driving to Zigzigland – Official Site".
14. "Driving to Zigzigland (2006)".
15. (2018-05-08). "How Jeff Dunham's offensive puppets became the voice of Trump's America".
16. (6 February 2002). "Official: 15 of 19 Sept. 11 hijackers were Saudi". [[USA Today]].
17. MacFarquhar, Neil. (2006-06-01). "Terror Fears Hamper U.S. Muslims' Travel". The New York Times.
18. (16 August 2006). "Fox News Airs Suggestion for 'Muslim-Only' Airport Line". [[The Huffington Post]].
19. Henrick Karoliszyn, Samuel Goldsmith. (10 October 2009). "Muslim advocates charge NYPD is racial profiling". [[Daily News (New York)]].
20. (27 August 2024). "The 13th Warrior: The Hollywood blockbuster that pioneered a Muslim hero".
21. (27 August 2024). "The 13th Warrior: The Hollywood blockbuster that pioneered a Muslim hero".
22. (2023-10-05). "How Hollywood sees Arabs - Egyptian Gazette".
23. Airey, Jacob. (2017-01-20). "Classic Film Review – The Wind and The Lion".
24. Change, Teaching for. (2017-04-08). "Countering Arab Stereotypes".
25. Laura Durkay. (29 October 2014). "Islamophobia TV".
26. Gandhi, Insiya. "Reel to Real: Harmful Stereotypes of Arabs and Muslims in American Film and Television".
27. Brown, Christie Spears. (26 December 2017). "U.S. Children's Stereotypes and Prejudicial Attitudes toward Arab Muslims". Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy.