Religious views on masturbation

Abrahamic religions

Biblical scholarship

Most scholars have held that there are no explicit proscriptions in the Bible about masturbation.For example:

• . "The Bible presents no clear theological ethic on masturbation, leaving many young unmarried Christians with confusion and guilt around their sexuality."
• , The word masturbation is never specifically mentioned in the Bible, nor are there any clear unchallenged references to masturbation. Various passages have been held to implicitly condemn or approve of masturbation, but others disagree; there is not "a clear condemnation of masturbation".

The biblical story of Onan (Genesis 38) is traditionally linked to referring to masturbation and condemnation thereof. A number of scholars have pointed out that the sexual act described by this story is coitus interruptus, not masturbation. Some go further and argue that Onan's death was solely due to his refusal to fulfill the obligation of levirate marriage, rather than any sexual sin. Others argue that Onan's punishment was both for his refusal to fulfill his obligations and because of his perverse sexual act. For example, James Nelson argues that Onan's act was condemned due to the firm "procreative" accent of the Hebrew interpretation regarding sexuality, where survival of the tribe depends on abundant procreation. The story was written by a "prescientific mind" that considered the child to be contained in the sperm the same way a plant is contained in its seed. Onan's offense was therefore the deliberate destruction of human life.

Leviticus 15:16–17 says that a man who has an emission of semen should wash and be ceremonially unclean until evening. Verse 18 goes on to say that if a man and woman have intercourse, the same cleanliness rules apply. Ilona N. Rashkow states that Leviticus 15:16 "refers to the emission rather than its circumstances." According to James R. Johnson, by bringing up intercourse separately, the passage implies that the emission of semen in verses 16 and 17 occurred for the man individually. The passage may be referring to a nocturnal emission, or wet dream, rather than masturbation, but the passage is not specific. In contrast, Deuteronomy 23:9–11 explicitly specifies nocturnal emission. Johnson thus views this passage as suggesting that masturbation is a purely ceremonial cleanliness issue, and not as a matter of morality. Johnson also notes that the passage puts no more disapproval on the solitary experience than it does on intercourse.

Matthew 5:29–30, Matt. 18:6–9, and Mark 9:42–48 state that, if they cause one to sin, one should tear out one's eye and cut off one's hand or foot. Will Deming states "The sinning by eye, hand, and foot may come from a tradition of formulaic warnings against lustful gazing (by the eye), masturbation (by hand), and adultery (by 'foot', the Hebrew euphemism for genitalia)," referencing the Niddah, specifically m. Nid. 2.1 and b. Nid. 13b. In addition to the eye, Deming argues that "the hand plays a major role in lust as well through masturbation". William Loader links this to the story of Origen, where perhaps Origen read "foot" and "hand" as euphemisms for penis and castrated himself. Loader views attaching special meanings to the body parts in these passages as over-interpretation, as these passages are mainly hyperbole.

1 Thessalonians 4:3–4 reads: “What God wants is for you all to be holy. He wants you to keep away from fornication [porneia], and each of you to know how to use the body that belongs to him in a way that is holy and honorable, not giving way to selfish lust like the pagans who do not know God.” The Greek word porneia (πορνεία) is used in other New Testament passages such as Galatians 5:19–23 and has a general meaning of sexual immorality or unchastity. More generally, Paul refers to purity and contamination in 2 Corinthians 7:1. Some commentators view the word porneia as including masturbation, and see these passages as implicitly confirming the immorality of masturbation. Others disagree, holding that this passage simply condemns the pagans' then-common sexual licentiousness and promiscuity, and has no relevance to masturbation.

Romans 1:24 and 1 Corinthians 6:10 are sometimes held to refer to masturbation, but Dedek argues that they refer to sodomy and pederasty respectively.

1 Corinthians 7:3–5 has been held by some to allow masturbation in the context of marriage. Masturbation should not necessarily be a normal circumstance, but if for example sexual tension becomes unmanageable due to extended separation, Johnson states "masturbation would not counteract the divine purpose" with the consent of one's spouse.

Christianity

Main article: Christian views on masturbation

Christian denominations have different views on masturbation. Today, Roman Catholic (including Eastern Catholic), Eastern Orthodox, Oriental Orthodox and some Protestant Christians consider masturbation to be a sin. Many Protestant churches in Northern and Western Europe and some Protestant churches in Northern America and in Australia/New Zealand see masturbation as not a sin.

According to Björn Krondorfer, "Auto-erotic sex became conceivable as a distinct entity among sexual sins only when the autonomous self emerged." He goes on to cite Laqueur, "Only after the Freudian revolution...did a cultural shift occur. Masturbation was now valued as an adult, non-pathological, pleasurable activity. 'Beginning in the 1950s, picking up energy with the feminism of the 1960s and early 1970s, with the subsequent sex wars, and with the worldwide gay movement of the last quarter of the century, it would become an arena of sexual politics and for art across a wide spectrum of society...Due to this cultural change across the spectrum, even theological reassessments of masturbation as a positive sexual practice were possible – though, admittedly, rare."

Islam

Main article: Sexuality in Islam#Masturbation

In Islam, masturbation () is forbidden or makruh (discouraged) according to the majority of scholars' opinions. However, a minority viewpoint within some Islamic schools of thought permits masturbation as an alternative to zina (fornication), or if one is unable to marry. Bathing (ghusl) is compulsory after any kind of seminal discharge whether through sexual intercourse, masturbation, or nocturnal emissions.

Judaism

Main article: Judaism and masturbation

Maimonides stated that the Tanakh does not explicitly prohibit masturbation. By virtue of Onan, traditional Judaism condemns [male] masturbation.

states that any male who emits semen is considered ritually impure - whether the emission came through masturbation, nocturnal emission, or sex between married heterosexual partners. The traditional rabbinical interpretation of Leviticus 15 was that it applies to all sperm flows, including sperm flows due to masturbation. Other than this ritual impurity, no consequences or punishments are specified.

Even among Jewish scholars and among rabbis, it is widely disputed whether the prohibition of masturbation is a biblical prohibition or a rabbinical prohibition, since it is never explicitly mentioned in the Torah. Many Ultra-Orthodox rabbis are afraid to publicly discuss their disagreement with the traditional interpretation about it being prohibited by the Bible.

Indian and Iranian religions

Hinduism

Seeking bodily pleasure is only considered condemned for those who dedicate themselves to chastity. There are no references in Hindu religious texts to suggest that masturbation itself desecrates sexual purity. For those who are dedicated to chastity, this sin is absolutely minor, and can be absolved either by taking a bath, or by worshipping the Sun, or by saying three prayers.

Buddhism

The most used formulation of Buddhist ethics are the Five Precepts. These precepts take the form of voluntary personal undertakings, However, different schools of Buddhism have differing interpretations of what constitutes sexual misconduct.

Buddhism was advanced by Gautama Buddha as a method by which human beings could end dukkha (suffering) and escape samsara (cyclic existence). Normally this entails practicing meditation and following the Four Noble Truths and the Noble Eightfold Path as a way to subdue the passions which, along with the skandhas, cause suffering and rebirth. Masturbation (Pali: sukkavissaṭṭhi) is accordingly seen as problematic for a person who wishes to attain liberation. According to a lecture by Lama Thubten Zopa Rinpoche, it is important to abstain from "sexual intercourse, including masturbation, any action that brings an orgasm and so forth, because this results in a rebirth." He clarifies: "Generally, the action that is the opposite of the precept brings the opposite negative result, takes us further from enlightenment, and keeps us longer in samsara."

Shravasti Dhammika, a Theravadin monk, cites the Vinaya Pitaka in his online "Guide to Buddhism A to Z", and states the following:

His opinions regarding non-Buddhists notwithstanding, the Buddha did encourage his serious disciples to limit their sexual behaviour or to embrace celibacy. Indeed, emphasis on chastity in Buddhism is strong for bhikkhus and bhikkhunis (renunciates), who vow to follow the rules of the Vinaya. Not only are monastics celibate, but they also take more and stricter vows in order to conquer their desires. In the Theravadin tradition, masturbation is also stressed as being harmful for upāsakas and upāsikās (lay devotees) who practice the Eight Precepts on Uposatha days, leading a more ascetic lifestyle that does not allow for masturbation. Indeed, public masturbation is explicitly characterised as sexual misconduct in the mahāyāna Upāsakaśīla sūtra:

Nevertheless, some contemporary writers on Buddhism suggest that masturbation is essentially harmless for a layperson.

However, many Buddhist practitioners disagree on whether masturbation constitutes sexual misconduct or not, where Gampopa (1079-1153) believed that anal or oral sexes with any genders as improper sexual behavior, and Longchenpa (1308–1363) included masturbation along with it as sexual misconduct. Je Tsongkhapa (1357–1419) however, accepts masturbation. On the other hand, Dalai Lama Tenzin Gyatso reportedly believes that masturbation does constitute sexual misconduct.

Zoroastrianism

The act of masturbation is known as Shoeythra Gunaah, or Shoithra-gunah, which can also be used to refer to onanism.

The Zoroastrian holy book Avesta, with its stress on physical cleanliness, lists voluntary masturbation among the unpardonable sins that one can commit. This view was supported by James R. Russell. The Verses 26-28 of Fargard VIII, Section V of the Vendidad state

Ahura Mazda answered: 'Eight hundred stripes with the Aspahê-astra, eight hundred stripes with the Sraoshô-karana.'

O Maker of the material world, thou Holy One! If a man voluntarily emits his seed, what is the penalty for it? What is the atonement for it? What is the cleansing from it?

Ahura Mazda answered: 'For that deed there is nothing that can pay, nothing that can atone, nothing that can cleanse from it; it is a trespass for which there is no atonement, for ever and ever.'

When is it so?

'It is so, if the sinner be a professor of the law of Mazda, or one who has been taught in it. But if he be not a professor of the law of Mazda, nor one who has been taught in it, then this law of Mazda takes his sin from him, if he confesses it and resolves never to commit again such forbidden deeds.}}

The scholar Sorabji Edalji Dubash has also written:

Masturbation is also considered a Drujih-i-Buji (evil associated with menstrual flow) which is caused by the menstrual discharge of a woman if proper precautions are not followed. Drujih (evil) is more smarter and stronger than human intelligence. Thus also enumerated in the Expiatory prayer of Dasturan Dastur Adarbad Mahrespand fall under Drujih-i-Buji. A right knowledge of Drujih-i-Buji and of the ill-effects is said to save young boys of the age of puberty from the fangs of masturbation.

In the story of Jamshid and Taxmoruw (Tahmuras) preserved in a Parsi rivayat, Ahriman is shown to be a masturbator.

Zoroastrian hell is also said to have sinners forced to defecate and masturbate continually.

East Asian religions

Taoism

Some teachers and practitioners of Traditional Chinese medicine, Taoist meditative and martial arts say that masturbation can cause a lowered energy level in men. They say that ejaculation in this way reduces "origin qi" from dantian, the energy center located in the lower abdomen. Some maintain that sex with a partner does not do this because the partners replenish each other's qi. Some practitioners therefore say that males should not practice martial arts for at least 48 hours after masturbation while others prescribe up to six months, because the loss of Origin Qi does not allow new qi to be created for this kind of time.

Some Taoists strongly discouraged female masturbation. Women were encouraged to practice massaging techniques upon themselves, but were also instructed to avoid thinking sexual thoughts if experiencing a feeling of pleasure. Otherwise, the woman's "labia will open wide and the sexual secretions will flow." If this happened, the woman would lose part of her life force, and this could bring illness and shortened life.

Confucianism

Since the Song dynasty, the framing of sexual asceticism as a moral imperative began to spread among intellectual elites due to the emergence of neo-Confucianism. The elite masculinity of junzi (the cultured man) emphasised intellectuals’ capability to assist the emperor to govern the country. Strict self-cultivation (xiushen) through obedience to the patriarchal family institution was then seen as a necessary means for budding intellectuals to transform themselves into eligible political elites. Excessive or deviant sexual desire, viewed as men's overindulgence in private affairs and disobedience to their masculine family/public obligations, was thus disparaged by dynastic rulers. This norm was also imposed on the emperors themselves. Masturbation raises an ethical crisis because it means that men waste their bodily essence for pleasure, harm their spirit and productivity, and thus disobey their obligation to carry on the family lineage and fail to practice filial piety.

Wicca

Wicca, like other religions, has adherents with a spectrum of views ranging from conservative to liberal. Wicca is generally undogmatic, and nothing in Wiccan philosophy prohibits masturbation. On the contrary, Wiccan ethics, summed up in the Wiccan Rede "An it harm none, do as thou wilt", are interpreted by many as endorsing responsible sexual activity of all varieties. This is reinforced in the Charge of the Goddess, a key piece of Wiccan literature, in which the Goddess says, "all acts of love and pleasure are my rituals".

References

Bibliography

References

1. Ley, David J.. (8 June 2016). "Porn vs. Religion".
2. Jech, Carl L.. (9 November 2016). "Religion as Art Form: Reclaiming Spirituality Without Supernatural Beliefs". Resource Publications, Wipf and Stock Publishers.
3. (Fall 2005). "Historical development of new masturbation attitudes in Mormon culture: secular conformity, counterrevolution, and emerging reform". Sexuality & Culture.
4. (2011). "What the Bible Really Tells Us: The Essential Guide to Biblical Literacy". Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
5. (2014). "God and the Gay Christian: The Biblical Case in Support of Same-Sex Relationships". Doubleday Religious Publishing Group.
6. Coogan, Michael. (October 2010). "God and Sex. What the Bible Really Says". Twelve. Hachette Book Group.
7. "Birth Control | Catholic Answers".
8. (2006). "Sex in the Bible: a new consideration". Praeger Publishers.
9. Confirmed by The Web Bible Encyclopedia at http://www.christiananswers.net/dictionary/onan.html {{Webarchive. link. (2012-01-31 quote: "Some have mistakenly assumed that Onan's sin was masturbation. However, it seems clear that this is not the case. Onan was prematurely withdrawing from sexual intercourse with his new wife, Tamar. This is a form of birth control still practiced today (''coitus interruptus'').")
10. (1992). "Contraception and abortion from the ancient world to the Renaissance". Harvard University Press.
11. (2018). "The new Oxford annotated Bible : New Revised Standard version with the Apocrypha". Oxford University Press.
12. (1998). "Catholic sexual ethics : a summary, explanation & defense". Huntington, Ind. : Our Sunday Visitor.
13. (2003). "Religion and American Cultures: An Encyclopedia of Traditions, Diversity, and Popular Expressions". ABC-Clio.
14. (2000). "Taboo Or Not Taboo: Sexuality and Family in the Hebrew Bible". Fortress Press.
15. (1971). "Contemporary sexual morality". New York, Sheed and Ward.
16. (2014). "How and When to Tell Your Kids About Sex: A Lifelong Approach to Shaping Your Child's Sexual Character". NavPress, Tyndale House.
17. (January 1990). "Mark 9. 42–10. 12, Matthew 5. 27–32, and B. Nid . 13b: A First Century Discussion of Male Sexuality". New Testament Studies.
18. (2014). "The Oxford Encyclopedia of the Bible and Gender Studies". Oxford University Press.
19. (2010). "Matthew: Exegetical Commentary on the New Testament". Zondervan.
20. (2014). "The Oxford Handbook of Theology, Sexuality, and Gender". OUP Oxford.
21. "G4202 – porneia – Strong's Greek Lexicon (kjv)".
22. (2007). "Homosexuality & the Catholic Church : clear answers to difficult questions". West Chester, Penn. : Ascension Press.
23. Harvey, John F.. (May 1, 1993). "The Pastoral Problem of Masturbation". The Linacre Quarterly.
24. (June 1982). "Toward a Biblical Approach to Masturbation". Journal of Psychology and Theology.
25. Krondorfer, Björn. (2009). "Men and Masculinities in Christianity and Judaism: A Critical Reader". Hymns Ancient and Modern Ltd.
26. The Lawful And The Prohibited In Islam, Yusuf Al-Qardawi – 1997
27. The New Arab Man: Emergent Masculinities, Technologies, and Islam in the Middle East, p. 168, Marcia C. Inhorn – 2012
28. "Janabah - Oxford Islamic Studies Online".
29. link. (2019-11-20 Jewish law clearly prohibits male masturbation. This law is derived from the story of Onan (Gen. 38:8–10), who practiced coitus interruptus as a means of birth control to avoid fathering a child for his deceased brother. God killed Onan for this sin. Although Onan's act was not truly masturbation, Jewish law takes a very broad view of the acts prohibited by this passage, and forbids any act of ha-sh'cha'tat zerah (destruction of the seed), that is, ejaculation outside of the vagina. In fact, the prohibition is so strict that one passage in the Talmud states, "in the case of a man, the hand that reaches below the navel should be chopped off." (Niddah 13a). The issue is somewhat less clear for women. Obviously, spilling the seed is not going to happen in female masturbation, and there is no explicit Torah prohibition against female masturbation. Nevertheless, Judaism generally frowns upon female masturbation as "impure thoughts.")
30. (2003). "Matters of life and death : a Jewish approach to modern medical ethics". Jewish Publication Society.
31. Gagnon, Robert A.J.. (2005-02-07). "A critique of Jacob Milgrom's views on Leviticus 18:22 and 20:13". Yale University Press.
32. Gold, Michael. (2003). "Encyclopedia of Jewish Medical Ethics: A Compilation of Jewish Medical Law on All Topics of Medical Interest ...". Feldheim Publishers.
33. (2012). "The Cultural Context of Sexual Pleasure and Problems: Psychotherapy with Diverse Clients". Routledge.
34. Bullough, Vern L.. (23 January 2003). "Masturbation". Informa UK Limited.
35. Cornog, Martha. (2003). "The Big Book of Masturbation: From Angst to Zeal". Down There Press.
36. Higgins, Winton. (6 December 2006). "BuddhaNet Magazine Article: Buddhist Sexual Ethics".
37. Lama Thubten Zopa Rinpoche. (3 May 2015). "Kopan Course No. 03 & No. 04 (1972–73): Appendix One: The Eight Mahayana Precepts".
38. "Masturbation". Bhante Dhammika.
39. (1986). "Buddhism and Sex". Bhante Dhammika.
40. "Sutra of the Upasaka Precepts, fascicle 6, 優婆塞戒經".
41. Sūtra of the Upāsaka Precepts, fascicle 6, Chapter 24a
42. (January 8, 2009). "A Sensitive Topic".
43. "Masturbation: Does Your Religion Give It a Thumbs Up or Thumbs Down?".
44. Chaibuntan, Prakob. "Sexual Misconduct: The Poisonous Social". Global Interactive Journal of World Religions and Cultures.
45. Hutokhsh. (2009-12-01). "The Rationale of PATET".
46. James R. Russell. (1987). "Zoroastrianism in Armenia". Harvard University, Department of Near Eastern Languages and Civilizations.
47. Dubash, Sorabji Edalji. (2016). "The Zoroastrian Sanitary Code, with Critical and Explanatory Notes". Sanj Vartaman Printing Press.
48. "A Zarathustri Soul & His Divine Plan".
49. Masani, Phiroze Shapurji. (1917). "Zoroastrianism Ancient and Modern: Comprising a Review of Dr. Dhalla's Book of Zoroastrian Theology". Masani.
50. ''Les types du premier homme et du premier roi dans l'histoire légendaire des Iraniens'' Part I (1917) by Christensen, Arthur pps. 184–189.
51. Rosemary Guiley. (2009). "The Encyclopedia of Demons and Demonology". Infobase Publishing.
52. Liang, Chenglin. (2024-05-03). "Abstinence for the sake of modest success: a Chinese anti-masturbation group's path to individualisation". Inter-Asia Cultural Studies.
53. (2006-08-08). "Alternative Sexuality". Tangled Moon Coven.