Pescetarianism

Definition and etymology

"Pescetarian" is a neologism formed as a portmanteau of the Italian word "pesce" ("fish") and the English word "vegetarian". The term was coined in the United Kingdom in the late 1980s. "Pesco-vegetarian" is a synonymous term that is seldom used outside of academic research, but it has sometimes appeared in other American publications and literature since at least 1980.

History

Early history

The first vegetarians in written western history may have been the Pythagoreans, a title derived from the Greek philosopher Pythagoras. Though Pythagoras loaned his name to the meatless diet, some biographers suspect he may have eaten fish as well at some points, which would have made him not a vegetarian but a pescetarian by today's standards. Many of Pythagoras's philosophies inspired Plato, who advocated for the moral and nutritional superiority of vegetarian-oriented diets. In Plato's ideal republic, a healthy diet would consist of cereals, seeds, beans, fruit, milk, honey and fish.

In 675, the consumption of livestock and wild animals was banned in Japan by Emperor Tenmu, due to the influence of Buddhism and the lack of arable land. However, Tenmu did not ban the consumption of deer or wild boar. Subsequently, in the year 737 of the Nara period, the Emperor Shōmu approved the eating of fish and shellfish. During the 1200 years from the Nara period to the Meiji Restoration in the latter half of the 19th century, Japanese people ate vegetarian-style meals, and on special occasions, seafood was served. Exceptions were wild fowl served amongst the Heian nobility, and when Europeans arrived in Japan in the 15th century, the Japanese diet included boar meat.

Several orders of monks in medieval Europe restricted or banned the consumption of meat for ascetic reasons, but none of them abstained from the consumption of fish; these monks were not vegetarians, but some were pescetarians.

Marcion of Sinope and his followers ate fish but no fowl or red meat. Fish was seen by the Marcionites as a holier kind of food. They consumed bread, fish, honey, milk, and vegetables.

The "Hearers" of the ecclesiastical hierarchy of Manichaeism lived on a diet of fish, grain, and vegetables. Consumption of land animals was forbidden, based on the Manichaean belief that "fish, being born in and of the waters, and without any sexual connexion on the part of other fishes, are free from the taint which pollutes all animals".

The Rule of Saint Benedict insisted upon total abstinence of meat from four-footed animals, except in cases of the sick. Benedictine monks thus followed a diet based on vegetables, eggs, milk, butter, cheese, and fish. Paul the Deacon specified that cheese, eggs, and fish were part of a monk's ordinary diet. Benedictine monk Walafrid Strabo commented, "Some salt, bread, leeks, fish and wine; that is our menu."

The Carthusians followed a strict diet that consisted of fish, cheese, eggs, and vegetables, with only bread and water on Fridays.

In the 13th century, Cistercian monks consumed fish and eggs. Ponds were created for fish farming. From the early 14th century, Benedictine and Cistercian monks no longer abstained from consuming meat of four-footed animals. In 1336, Pope Benedict XII permitted monks to eat meat four days a week outside of the fast season if it was not served in the refectory.

The anchorites of England ate a pescetarian diet of fish seasoned with apples and herbs, bean or pea soup and milk, butter and oil.

19th century to present

Francis William Newman, who was President of the Vegetarian Society from 1873 to 1883, made an associate membership possible for people who were not completely vegetarian like pescetarians. Eventually, in the 1890s, Newman himself switched from following an ovo-lacto-vegetarian diet to a pescetarian diet, with the rationale that fish do not waste land space, are plentiful due to high reproduction rates, do not care for their young and have no parental feelings to violate, and can be captured and slaughtered in ways that inflict minimal pain.

Interest in pescetarian diets continued to grow into the 21st century, alongside broader trends in plant based eating. Surveys in the 2010s and beyond have found that a small but noticeable segment of populations in Western countries identify with pescetarian or related diets, often citing environmental motivations for reducing consumption of red and processed meats in favor of seafood and plant foods.

A 2016 book Seagan Eating promoted a seafood diet, which is distinguished from ordinary pescetarian diets because it discourages consumption of dairy and eggs.

Trends and demographics

, pescetarianism has been described as a plant-based diet. Regular fish consumption and decreased red meat consumption are recognized as dietary practices that may promote health. Pescetarianism has been shown to be more popular among women than men in all regions where the data on sex ratio is available.

Global

In 2018, Ipsos MORI reported 73% of people worldwide followed a diet where both meat and non-animal products were regularly consumed, with 14% considered as flexitarians, 5% vegetarians, 3% vegans, and 3% pescetarians. These are similar to the results collected by GlobalData just a year earlier; where 23% of the sample had below average meat consumption, 5% had vegetarian diets, 2% had vegan diets and 3% had pescetarian diets. Globally, pescetarian diets seem to have increased in popularity in the mid-to-late 2010s; only 40% of pescetarians surveyed had been adhering to the diet for more than a couple years and another 18% reported adhering to diet for about a year.

United Kingdom

A 2018 poll of 2,000 United Kingdom adults found that ≈12% of adults adhered to a meat-free diet; with 2% vegan, 6–7% ovo-lacto-vegetarian, and 4% pescetarian. Different studies and survey have found a more modest number of meat-abstainers; a 2021 survey found 10% of Brits were meat abstainers with 3% of the population being pescetarians.

In Great Britain as of January 2019, women between 18 and 24 years of age were the most likely demographic group to follow a pescetarian diet. In general, men were less interested in pescetarianism, and men 35 years and above were the least likely to adhere to a pescetarian diet pattern.

Other regions

In 2018, one survey found that people in Africa and the Middle East had a high incidence of pescetarian diets (5%) when compared to other areas of the world. In Europe, the incidence of pescetarianism varied by country, according to a 2020 survey documenting the dietary practices of residents in seven European nations: on average, pescetarianism was about 3% of the EU population, with slightly higher incidence in Germany and Belgium.

Motivations and rationale

Animal welfare concerns

Pescetarianism may be perceived as a more ethical choice because fish and shellfish may not experience fear, pain, and suffering as more complex animals like mammals and other tetrapods do. As a counterargument, from a scientific viewpoint, there are functional areas in the brains of fish that can make them feel pain. Furthermore, fish have pain receptors similar to humans, and evidence shows that pain signals are sent from these receptors to the brain, enabling fish to feel pain.{{Cite news|url=https://www.euronews.com/green/2023/06/25/fish-have-feelings-too-why-animal-sentience-means-we-should-rethink-food|title= Fish have feelings too: Why animal sentience means we should rethink food However, this is an ongoing debate.

Some pescetarians may regard their diet as a transition to vegetarianism, while others may consider it an ethical compromise, often as a practical necessity to obtain nutrients that are absent, not easily found, or not readily bioavailable in plants.

Sustainability and environmental concerns

It is common for all kinds of meat-abstainers to participate in the "green movement" and be conscientious about global food sustainability and environmentalism; switching to a pescetarian dietary pattern can potentially positively affect both. People may adopt a pescetarian diet out of desire to lower their dietary carbon footprint. A 2014 lifecycle analysis of greenhouse gas emissions estimated that a pescetarian diet would provide a 45% reduction in emissions compared to an omnivorous diet. Research on the diets of over 55,000 UK residents found that meat-eaters had dietary greenhouse gas emissions that were about 50% higher than pescetarians. Compared to an omnivorous diet, pescetarian diets also had 64% less environmental impact overall when the amount of greenhouse gas emissions, land use and cumulative energy demand were assessed together.

A Japanese study in 2018 found that various diet changes could successfully reduce the Japanese food-nitrogen footprint, particularly by adopting a pescetarian diet which may reduce the impact on nitrogen. Switching from an omnivorous diet to a pescetarian diet also carries high potential in reducing American food loss because fish and shellfish contribute markedly less to food waste at the primary, retail and consumer levels than both red meat and poultry. Additionally, water conservation may be a motivator; a multinational study found that switching a conventional diet for a balanced pescetarian diet could reduce dietary water footprint by 33% to 55%.

Health research

A common reason for adoption of pescetarianism may be health-related, such as fish and plant food consumption as part of the Mediterranean diet, which is associated with lowered risk of cardiovascular diseases. Pescetarian diets are under preliminary research for their potential to affect diabetes, long-term weight gain, and all-cause mortality.

Other considerations

Concerns have been raised about consuming some fish varieties containing toxins such as mercury and polychlorinated biphenyls (PCB), although it is possible to select fish that contain little or no mercury or moderate the consumption of mercury-containing fish. According to a 2018 global consumer survey, the majority of pescetarians, vegetarians and vegans (87% prevalence) reported that their food product choices are influenced by ideological factors, like ethical concerns, environmental impact or social responsibility. Pescetarians may be motivated by ethical concerns that are not related to animal protection or environmental protection, such as humanitarian or religious reasons. Viable sources of protein that can be consumed by food-insecure humans are not wasted on filter feeders or wild-caught fish.

In religions

Christianity

Main article: Christian vegetarianism

In both the Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox tradition, pescetarianism is referred to as a form of abstinence. During fast periods, Eastern Orthodox Christians often abstain from meat, dairy, eggs, and fish, but on holidays that occur on fast days (for example, 15 August on a Wednesday or Friday), fish is allowed, while meat and dairy remain forbidden. Anthonian fasting has been considered a pescetarian-like variant of Orthodox fasting as poultry and red meat are restricted throughout the year but fish, eggs, oils, dairy and wine are allowed most days.

Pescetarianism is relatively popular among Seventh-day Adventists when compared to the general population; in the 2000s 10% of North American Seventh-day Adventists who were surveyed reported adhering to a pescetarian diet. The higher popularity is likely due to the church promoting a "health message" to its followers and considering meat-consumption to be unfavorable. Adventists who eat seafood do not eat shellfish because the church expects all followers to only eat kosher foods deemed permissible by Leviticus 11.

Judaism

Pescetarianism, provided that the fish is kosher, conforms to Jewish dietary laws. Fish and all other seafood animals must have both fins and scales in order to be considered kosher. Thus, aquatic mammals such as dolphins and whales are not kosher, nor are cartilaginous fish such as sharks and rays, since they all have dermal denticles and not true bony-fish scales. The lack of fins and scales also deems crustaceans (e.g., shrimp, crab, lobster) and molluscs (e.g., oyster, clam, conch, octopus, squid) to be non-kosher. Roe, such as caviar, must come from a kosher fish to be permitted. Pescetarian diets simplify adherence to the Judaic separation of meat and dairy products, as kosher fish is considered pareve ("neutral")—neither "milk" nor "meat", which must be separated from one another.

In 2015, members of the Liberal Judaism synagogue in Manchester, England, founded The Pescetarian Society, citing pescetarianism as originally a Jewish diet, and pescetarianism as a form of vegetarianism. The society has several advocacy interests: public health, promoting healthy eating, praising pescetarianism as "the natural human diet", supporting better animal welfare, bringing awareness to the climate-change crisis, and demanding seafood be sustainable and responsibly-caught.

Hinduism

Some Hindus, by choice, follow a strict lacto-vegetarian diet and in India up to 44% of Hindus self-identify as some type of vegetarian. However, there are Hindus who consume fish, mainly from coastal southwestern India. This community regards seafood in general as "vegetables from the sea", and refrains from eating land-based animals. Other Hindus who consume seafood are those from Bengal, Odisha, and other coastal areas. In Bengal, Hindus consume fish and are known to cook it daily.

Rastafari

The expression of Ital eating can vary from Rasta to Rasta, but a general principle is that food should be natural or pure, and from the earth. Though the Rastafari are generally associated with avid vegetarianism and veganism, a large minority of adherents do deem certain kinds of fish to be an acceptable exception in the Ital diet. Rastafari who permit fish will avoid eating all kinds of shellfish as they are considered to be "unclean" scavengers, a belief that stems from biblical teachings.

References

References

1. Luna, Taryn. (1 July 2015). "Legal Sea Foods launches 'Pescatarianism' ad campaign". The Boston Globe.
2. "Pescetarianism | Description, Seafood, Vegetarianism, & Benefits | Britannica".
3. (August 2018). "An exploration into diets around the world".
4. "Definition of Pescatarian by Merriam-Webster".
5. (31 May 2022). "Pescaterian". Merriam-Webster Dictionary.
6. (1980). "Journal of Nursing Care". Health Science Division of Technomic Publishing Company, Incorporated.
7. Hanson, Liz. (February 1982). "How to give a Vegetarian Cooking Class". Vegetarian Times.
8. (23 May 2019). "Pythagoras".
9. Avey, Tori. (28 January 2014). "From Pythagorean to Pescatarian – The Evolution of Vegetarianism".
10. "The Republic Of Plato: An Ideal Commonwealth by Jowett, Benjamin (Translator): Very Good Hardcover (1901) {{!}} Back Lane Books".
11. (July 2001). "Dietetics in ancient Greek philosophy: Plato's concepts of healthy diet". European Journal of Clinical Nutrition.
12. Hisao Nagayama. 「たべもの江戸史」 新人物往来社, 1976. {{ISBN. 4309473105 p. 66. 『、「牛馬犬猿鶏の宍(肉)を食うことなかれ」の殺生禁断の令は有名拍車をかけたのが仏教の影響である。』
13. Ishige, Naomici. (2014-06-17). "History Of Japanese Food". Routledge.
14. Mitsuru Kakimoto. International Vegetarian Union, http://www.ivu.org/news/3-98/japan1.html {{Webarchive. link. (11 March 2016)
15. Ishige, The History and Culture of Japanese Food, pg 73-74
16. Shimizu. Akira, Meat Eating in the Kojimachi District of Edo, 2010. in Japanese Foodways, Past and Present, University of Illiois Press, Assman, Stepanie and Rath, Eric C eds. 2010
17. Lutterbach, Hubertus: ''Der Fleischverzicht im Christentum'', in: ''Saeculum'' 50/II (1999) p. 202.
18. May, Gerhard; Greschat, Katharina. (2013). ''Marcion und seine kirchengeschichtliche Wirkung / Marcion and His Impact on Church History''. De Gruyter. pp. 213–216. {{ISBN. 978-3-11-017599-8
19. Fontaine, Petrus Franciscus Maria. (1994). ''Gnostic Dualism in Asia Minor During the First Centuries, A.D. II''. Brill Academic Publishing. p. 84. {{ISBN. 978-90-5063-346-8
20. Tyson, Joseph B. (2006). ''Marcion and Luke-Acts: A Defining Struggle''. University of South Carolina Press. p. 35. {{ISBN. 978-1-57003-650-7
21. Spencer, Colin. (2002). ''Vegetarianism: A History''. Four Walls Eight Windows. pp. 135–136. {{ISBN. 1-56858-238-2
22. {{Cite EB1911. Conybeare. Frederick Cornwallis
23. Keevill, Graham; Aston, Mick; Hall, Teresa. (2017). ''Monastic Archaeology''. Oxbow Books. p. 54. {{ISBN. 978-1-78570-567-0
24. Butler, Edward Cuthbert. (1919). [https://archive.org/details/benedictinemonac00butluoft/page/44 ''Benedictine Monachism: Studies in Benedictine Life and Rule'']. London: Longmans, Green. p. 44
25. Riché, Pierre. (1978). ''Daily Life in the World of Charlemagne''. University of Pennsylvania Press. p. 171. {{ISBN. 0-8122-1096-4
26. Barber, Bruno. (2004). ''The Cistercian Abbey of St Mary Stratford Langthorne, Essex''. Museum of London Archaeology Service. p. 158. {{ISBN. 978-1-901992-38-0
27. Kerr, Julie. (2006). ''Life in the Medieval Cloister''. Continuum. pp. 48–50. {{ISBN. 978-1-84725-161-9
28. Clay, Rotha Mary. (1914). [https://archive.org/details/hermitsanchorite00clayuoft/page/104/mode/2up ''The Hermits and Anchorites of England'']. London: Methuen. p. 104
29. Anson, Peter F. (1932). [https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.75798/page/n251/mode/2up ''The Quest of Solitude'']. London: J. M. Dent. p. 232. "The food of an anchorite or an anchoress was mainly vegetarian. They could have soups or “pottages” made of herbs, peas, or beans; or “furmity,” sweetened with milk, butter, or oil, and fish seasoned with apples or herbs."
30. Spencer, Colin. (1995). ''The Heretic's Feast: A History of Vegetarianism''. University Press of New England. pp. 274–276. {{ISBN. 0-87451-708-7
31. Yeh, Hsin-Yi.. (2013). "Boundaries, Entities, and Modern Vegetarianism: Examining the Emergence of the First Vegetarian Organization". Qualitative Inquiry.
32. [https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:May_Vegetarians_Eat_Fish_1895.png ''May Vegetarians Eat Fish?'']. ''Dundee Evening Telegraph'' (11 September 1895).
33. "Pescetarianism » Eat For Longer - Food Lifestyle Guides".
34. [https://www.theguardian.com/food/shortcuts/2019/nov/07/fishy-business-should-we-all-be-seagans "Fishy business: should we all be seagans?"]. ''The Guardian''. Retrieved 18 January 2022.
35. Erbentraut, Joseph. (2017). [https://archive.today/20220118114942/https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/seagan-diet-vegans-eating-seafood_n_57879151e4b08608d333169c "'Seagan' Diet Suggests It's Not A Crazy Idea For Vegans To Eat Seafood"]. huffingtonpost.co.uk. Retrieved 18 January 2022.
36. [https://www.macmillandictionary.com/buzzword/entries/seaganism.html "Seaganism"]. macmillandictionary.com. Retrieved 18 January 2022.
37. [https://www.heartfoundation.org.nz/wellbeing/healthy-eating/nutrition-facts/plant-based-vegetarian-vegan-diets "Plant-based, vegetarian and vegan diets"] {{Webarchive. link. (6 October 2020. Heart Foundation NZ. Retrieved 30 October 2020.)
38. Summerfield, Liane M.. (8 August 2012). "Nutrition, Exercise, and Behavior: An Integrated Approach to Weight Management". [[Cengage Learning]].
39. [https://www.todaysdietitian.com/newarchives/040715p32.shtml "The Pescetarian Diet By Judith C. Thalheimer, RD, LDN"] {{Webarchive. link. (27 April 2019. Today's Dietitian. Retrieved 30 October 2020.)
40. (12 September 2018). "Flexitarian diet on trend, says GlobalData".
41. Tatum, Megan. (13 April 2018). "12% of Brits follow meat-free diet, The Grocer research shows".
42. (July 2018). "Consumer Focus: the rise of plant-based food products and implications for meat and dairy".
43. Johnson, Georgia-Rose. (30 January 2019). "UK diet trends".
44. (13 May 2022). "What share of people say they are vegetarian, vegan, or flexitarian?".
45. "Adults following pescatarian diet GB 2019".
46. (30 October 2020). "The results of the Veganz nutrition study 2020 are here!".
47. (8 August 2013). "Do fish feel pain? Not as humans do, study suggests".
48. (March 2014). "Can fish really feel pain?". Fish and Fisheries.
49. (March 2015). "Fish do not feel pain and its implications for understanding phenomenal consciousness". Biology and Philosophy.
50. "It's Official: Fish Feel Pain".
51. "Scientists say fish feel pain. It could lead to major changes in the fishing industry.". [[The Washington Post]].
52. Ronald L. Sandler, ''Food Ethics: The Basics'', Routledge, 2014, p. 74.
53. Rohrer, Finlo. (5 November 2009). "The rise of the non-veggie vegetarian". BBC News.
54. (January 2019). "Energy Embedded in Food Loss Management and in the Production of Uneaten Food: Seeking a Sustainable Pathway". Energies.
55. (November 2014). "Global diets link environmental sustainability and human health". Nature.
56. (2018). "Carbon footprint factsheet". Center for Sustainable Systems, University of Michigan.
57. (11 June 2014). "Dietary greenhouse gas emissions of meat-eaters, fish-eaters, vegetarians and vegans in the UK". Springer.
58. (1 January 2020). "A Perspective on the Transition to Plant-Based Diets: a Diet Change May Attenuate Climate Change, but Can It Also Attenuate Obesity and Chronic Disease Risk?". Advances in Nutrition.
59. (1 November 2014). "Global diets link environmental sustainability and human health". Nature.
60. (1 July 2014). "Dietary greenhouse gas emissions of meat-eaters, fish-eaters, vegetarians and vegans in the UK". Climatic Change.
61. (2020). "Greenhouse gas emissions, energy demand and land use associated with omnivorous, pesco-vegetarian, vegetarian, and vegan diets accounting for farming practices". Sustainable Production and Consumption.
62. (1 April 2018). "Food nitrogen footprint reductions related to a balanced Japanese diet". Ambio.
63. "Beef Research - Food Waste".
64. "Change your diet to save both water and your health". ScienceDaily.
65. (22 September 2020). "A Pesco-Mediterranean diet with intermittent fasting". Journal of the American College of Cardiology.
66. (4 January 2021). "Should we all go pesco-vegetarian?". European Heart Journal.
67. (25 February 2019). "Vegetarian diets and risk of hospitalisation or death with diabetes in British adults: results from the EPIC-Oxford study". Nutrition & Diabetes.
68. (7 March 2019). "Weight change over 14 years in meat-eaters, pescatarians, vegetarians and vegans". Proceedings of the Nutrition Society.
69. (26 April 2017). "Food groups and risk of all-cause mortality: a systematic review and meta-analysis of prospective studies". American Journal of Clinical Nutrition.
70. (2000). "Toxicological Effects of Methylmercury". National Academies Press.
71. "Experts Say Consumers Can Eat Around Toxins In Fish". ScienceDaily.
72. (30 July 2019). "Survey: Most meat eaters are influenced by ethical concerns".
73. "The Fasting Rule of the Orthodox Church".
74. (17 May 2013). "Fasting Rules".
75. (21 August 2020). "Effects of Orthodox fasting on cardiometabolic risk factors: a comparative evaluation between lay fasters and Athonian monks". Endocrine Abstracts.
76. (June 2017). "Health benefits and consequences of the Eastern Orthodox fasting in monks of Mount Athos: a cross-sectional study". European Journal of Clinical Nutrition.
77. "Adventist Health Study-2".
78. (2014). "History of Seventh-day Adventist Work with Soyfoods, Vegetarianism, Meat Alternatives, Wheat Gluten, Dietary Fiber and Peanut Butter (1863-2013): Extensively Annotated Bibliography and Sourcebook". Soyinfo Center.
79. Aryeh Citron, [http://www.chabad.org/library/article_cdo/aid/1182104/jewish/All-About-Kosher-Fish.htm "All About Kosher Fish"] {{Webarchive. link. (16 December 2013)
80. [https://oukosher.org/faqs/verifying-kosher-fish/ Verifying Kosher Fish] {{Webarchive. link. (28 February 2021 ''OU Kosher Certification''. Retrieved 9 August 2019.)
81. Menachem Posner. "May fish be consumed with dairy?". Chabad.org.
82. (2019). "Pescetarian Society Home Page". The Pescetarian Society.
83. (10 June 2022). "Popular Pescetarian Meals – Healthy Living".
84. (8 July 2021). "Eight-in-ten Indians limit meat in their diets, and four-in-ten consider themselves vegetarian".
85. (1998). "Portuguese Orientalism and the making of the village communities of Goa". Ethnohistory.
86. (December 1974). "Regional Preference for Food: Some Aspects of Food Habit Patterns in India". The Canadian Geographer.
87. Sinclair-Brull, Wendy. (1997). ''Female Ascetics: Hierarchy and Purity in an Indian Religious Movement''. Curzon Press. p. 158. {{ISBN. 0-7007-0422-1
88. (12 October 2012). "Ital Is Vital". The New York Times.
89. "Rasta fare {{!}} alimentarium".
90. (2002). "Chant Down Babylon: Freedom of Religion and the Rastafarian Challenge to Majoritarianism". Journal of Law and Religion.
91. (8 June 2021). "The Ital Diet, A Rastafarian Recipe For Eating Right".
92. Snider. (28 June 2020). "Rastafari Culture".