Overacting

Uses

Some roles require overly exaggerated character acting, particularly those in comedy films. For example, the breakthrough roles of Jim Carrey in Ace Ventura: Pet Detective and The Mask (both 1994) saw him portray the lead characters in a very flamboyant fashion, as the script required. He has since played relatively straight roles.

Overacting may be used to portray an outlandish character, or to stress the evil characteristics of a villain. Actor Gary Oldman was almost typecast as an anti-social personality early in his screen career: the necessity to express villainous characters in an overtly physical manner led to the cultivation of a "big" acting style that incorporated projection skills acquired during his stage training. He noted that he has given "over-the-top" performances, and: "If it's coming from a sincere place, then I think the screen can hold the epic, and it can hold the very, very small."

Robert Duvall feels it is often appropriate for an actor to "go big" onscreen. He said, "If you do that within the confines of your temperament, then you can go broad. And sometimes when people really are within the confines of their temperament in a broad way, people say they're overacting – and they're not... A broad moment can be just as valid as a quiet moment."

Actor Al Pacino, when challenged with the notion that he overacts, answered: "Well, all actors do, in a way. You know what they say: in the theater you have to reach the balcony." Pacino suggested that directors serve to rein in screen performances that are too large.

Reactions

In an article on overacting, Independent critic Leigh Singer wrote: "Unlike theatre's declamatory projecting to the back row, a 'stagey' performance onscreen isn't a compliment... ultimately, it really is a matter of personal taste." Jeff Labrecque of Entertainment Weekly argued that "there's a thin line between overacting (bad) and acting that you're overacting (bizarrely genius)"; the publication at one time gave year-end awards for "best" and "worst" overacting in film, with the aforementioned Oldman and Pacino winning the former for their performances in Léon: The Professional (1994) and The Devil's Advocate (1997), respectively. Guardian journalist Chris Michael, a proponent of overacting, wrote: "From Hugo Weaving's Agent Smith to Heath Ledger's Joker to the entire oeuvre of William Shatner, mannered or stylised acting is an underrated skill."

References

References

1. [http://www.worldwidewords.org/qa/qa-che2.htm Chew the scenery] ''worldwidewords.org''
2. Gilliver, David. 1998. "[http://gilliver.net/writing/truman.html Film Review: The Truman Show]". Accessed 29 July 2006.
3. Roberts, Chris. (August 1999). "Gary Oldman: A sheep in wolf's clothing". [[IPC Media]].
4. Sexton, Timothy. [https://web.archive.org/web/20120111121252/http://movies.yahoo.com/news/gary-oldman-avoided-typecasting-weirdo-villain-225700644.html How Gary Oldman Avoided Typecasting as a Weirdo, Villain]. ''[[Yahoo! Movies]]''. [[Wayback Machine]]. 6 December 2011. Retrieved 11 August 2014.
5. ''[[Peter Travers. Popcorn With Peter Travers]]''. Season 5. Episode 15. 9 December 2011. "People who know you ... we remember the ''big'' Gary Oldman."
6. (12 Jan 2018). "Conversations... with Gary Oldman". [[SAG-AFTRA Foundation]].
7. Capretto, Lisa. (January 8, 2016). "Robert Duvall Has A Polarizing Opinion About Today's Actors".
8. [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9DGrDN14fRk&t=30s "Extra: Al Pacino, "Scarface" & Overacting"]. [[CBS]]. April 18, 2010. Retrieved March 6, 2024.
9. (23 October 2011). "The overactors - Mad, bad, and dangerous to the scenery".
10. "Nicolas Cage in 'Bad Lieutenant': Overacting or acting that he's overacting?".
11. (December 30, 1994). "Our Take on This Year's Movies".
12. (December 26, 1997). "Best & Worst / Movie Campaigns".
13. (11 October 2013). "Why I love … movie overacting".