Now All Roads Lead to France

Contents

The book is biographical in nature and details the life of Edward Thomas before poetry, turning to poetry, the times of war, and his final days, including a reflection of the impact of his work.

Hollis gives a detailed picture of Thomas' life and the poet's inner struggles. Thomas, Hollis writes, suffered through chronic depression, with Thomas stating that he felt "plagued with work, burning my candle at 3 ends" with frequent thoughts of suicide and vicious verbal sparring with his wife Helen. Walking through the English countrysides offered Thomas some relief. Still, it took Thomas' meeting with Robert Frost, an immigrant from the U.S. seeking to break into English literary circles, in 1913 to change his life's path.

Frost's relationship to Thomas, as Hollis discusses, essentially saved Thomas' life. Their friendship serves as the heart of the book. Hollis details how the two poets spent hours "talks-walking", in Frost's words, around the bucolic areas of Gloucestershire to think. Thomas wrote in September 1914, "I am slowly growing into a conscious Englishman."

In a short space of about two years, Thomas published as much as other poets took a lifetime to write. His work, Hollis recounts, conveyed his deep sense of wandering insecurity and lack of connection, particularly using his emotional reflections based on nature. Hollis describes how the advent of World War I, the horrors of which Thomas knew well, brought out a profound purpose in Thomas' mind. Commissioned as a second lieutenant in the British army, Thomas sought out action in 1917, and he died from the shock-wave of a passing shell just about ten weeks after arriving on the Western Front.

Reception

Supportive reviews ran in a variety of publications. Travel writer Robert Macfarlane summed up the book for The Guardian by writing, "An impressive new view of Edward Thomas helps us to understand how much more there is to the poet than willow-herb and meadowsweet". He also commented that Hollis' "narrative is calm and discreet, his tone witty and scholarly", and "he is unsentimentally candid about his subject's troubles and solipsism." The Independent published praise from writer Sean O'Brian; O'Brian remarked, "In this extremely readable critical-biographical study, place and landscape have an importance equal to poetry."

Author and journalist Allan Massie wrote a positive review in The Wall Street Journal. He stated about Thomas that once he "took to poetry at age 36, it was as if the ice on a winter river had melted and the water could flow freely." Massie concluded about the book,

The book won the 2011 Costa Book Award for 'Best Biography'. The judges commented: "Dramatic and engrossing. A brilliant biography that moved us all." It also won the 2011 H. W. Fisher Best First Biography Prize.

The 2011 Costa awards were subject to some attention from bookmakers. They offered odds of 2/1 for favourite Now All Roads Lead To France to win as overall 'Book of the Year' and odds of 3/1 for novelist Andrew Miller's Pure. Pure narrowly won out, the judging panel having been locked in a "fierce debate and quite bitter dissent" and eventually using a vote to decide on the winner.

References

References

1. Macfarlane, Robert. (2011-08-05). "Now All Roads Lead to France by Matthew Hollis – review". [[The Guardian]].
2. O'Brien, Sean. (2011-07-29). "Now All Roads Lead to France: The Last Years of Edward Thomas". [[The Independent]].
3. Massie, Allan. (2012-10-26). "Book Review: Now All Roads Lead to France". [[The Wall Street Journal]].
4. Macfarlane, Robert. (2011-08-05). "Now All Roads Lead to France by Matthew Hollis – review". The Guardian.
5. (2012-01-04). "Costa book awards winners 2011 – in pictures". [[The Guardian]].
6. "Previous Winners - Best First Biography Award".
7. Parker, Sam. (20 January 2012). "Why Costa Awards Have Bookies In A Flutter: The Rise Of Culture Betting". [[Huffington Post]].
8. Clark, Nick. (25 January 2012). "Literary feud lies behind novel choice for Costa book of the year". [[The Independent]].
9. (25 January 2012). "Andrew Miller wins Costa award for novel 'Pure'". [[The Irish Times]].