My Name Is Earl

Synopsis

Earl Hickey is a small-time thief, living in the fictional rural town of Camden, who loses his winning $100,000 lottery ticket after being hit by a car while he celebrates his good fortune. Lying in a hospital bed, he learns about karma during an episode of the talk show Last Call with Carson Daly. Convinced he has to turn his life around to be happy, Earl gives himself over to the power of karma. He makes a list of every bad thing that he has ever done and every person that he has ever wronged, and makes efforts to fix them all. After doing a first good deed, he finds the $100,000 lottery ticket that he had lost. Seeing this as a sign of karma rewarding him for his commitment, Earl uses his new-found wealth to do more good deeds according to his list.

Earl's wife, Joy, throws him out, keeping her two children — Dodge, whom she conceived before getting together with Earl, and Earl Jr., who was fathered during their marriage, but not by Earl. Earl moves into a motel and lives with his brother Randy, and they meet Catalina, the motel's beautiful maid who illegally migrated from somewhere in Latin America. Earl works on the list which mostly involves strangers and old acquaintances he has wronged, but also contains items involving his family. Initially, Joy plots to kill or blackmail Earl for his lottery winnings, but later gives up. Joy marries Darnell Turner, a mutual friend who works at a local restaurant called the Crab Shack, and with whom she had been having an affair. Until late in Season Four, it is generally accepted that Darnell fathered Earl Jr. In the Season One finale, Earl discovers he had bought the lotto tickets using money he stole from another person, but when he tries to return his winnings to that person, the latter is inflicted with bad karma, so he returns the money to Earl.

The second season has Earl continuing to work on his list. Joy gets in trouble when she steals a delivery truck, and ends up kidnapping and assaulting the member of staff who was inside. Joy is arrested for felonies that would put her in prison for life because it was her third strike. To soften the jury, she decides to have a surrogate baby for her half-sister Liberty Washington and Liberty's husband Ray-Ray. Meanwhile, Catalina has been deported. Earl and Randy visit her home village in Latin America, and Randy marries Catalina in a green card marriage so she can return to the United States. In the season finale, Earl sacrifices himself at Joy's trial by confessing to all of her crimes and is sentenced to two years in a state penitentiary.

In the third season, Earl is still imprisoned, but continues to do good deeds despite not having his list on him. He meets Frank, from whom he had rented the trailer in which Joy and her husband Darnell now live, while Randy gets a job as a prison guard to be closer to Earl. Meanwhile, Joy gives birth to Liberty and Ray-Ray's baby. Earl's good deeds attract the attention of the state warden, Jerry, who offers Earl a reduction in prison time for helping him resolve his issues. When Earl is about to leave, Jerry revokes Earl's reductions as he would lose such a productive helper, but Earl eventually gains the upper hand and forces Jerry to honor his early release. After leaving prison, Earl loses his confidence in the list; he has spent years and the last of his lottery winnings doing good things, but he has nothing to show for it and is insistent that karma should have given him some kind of lasting reward by now. He reverts to his old, malicious ways, doing cruel and illegal things. Frank's ex-girlfriend Billie Cunningham hits Earl with her car and puts him into a coma, then is subsequently struck by a car as well. Randy is able to revive Earl by working on the list. Earl finds Billie and marries her, thinking she is karma's reward for his years of effort. When Earl and Billie argue over the list, and Earl chooses the list over her, Billie goes into a rampage that undoes his good deeds. However, when Billie hides in the Amish-like "Camdenite" settlement, she has a change of heart. She divorces Earl and gives him the rest of her insurance settlement money, which helps him continue the list.

The fourth season goes back to focusing on Earl doing good deeds to cross off his list. A major story arc during this season was that Darnell, who is actually a former assassin from a secret government agency, blows his witness protection cover. He, Joy, and his family are forced to change identities and relocate until Darnell's father, who is also from the agency, goes on a mission with Darnell which clears Darnell's family of needing protection. In the season finale, Earl and the gang learn, from DNA test results, that Earl is actually Dodge's biological father. Earl still has not finished his list as of the season's conclusion, and there is a cliffhanger: It is proven that Darnell is not Earl Jr.'s father, revealing that Joy had another affair.

Main cast

Main article: List of My Name Is Earl characters

• Jason Lee as Earl Hickey, a small-time thief who turns his life around after winning money on a lottery scratcher, compiling a list of wrongs that he plans to make amends for.
• Ethan Suplee as Randy Hickey, Earl's dim-witted & lazy younger brother.
• Jaime Pressly as Joy Turner, Earl's ex-wife who lives in a trailer park.
• Nadine Velazquez as Catalina Aruca, the maid at the motel where Earl and Randy reside.
• Eddie Steeples as Darnell Turner, a worker at the local restaurant that Earl and the gang frequent. He marries Joy in season 1.

Production

Conception

Creator and head writer Greg Garcia wrote the pilot while working on another sitcom, Yes, Dear. He initially pitched the series to Fox, which passed on it. He then approached NBC, which optioned the pilot on a cast-contingent basis, meaning they would order the pilot provided a suitable cast could be assembled. Jason Lee was approached for the lead role, but was uninterested in working in television and passed on the series twice before finally agreeing to read the pilot script. Though he liked the pilot, he was hesitant to commit to his first TV starring role until meeting with Garcia, after which he signed on to play Earl Hickey.

Locations

My Name Is Earl is set in fictional Camden County. Creator Greg Garcia says:

In the episode "BB", Earl's driver's license address is at "Pimmit Hills Trailer Park, Space C-13, Camden County", but the state is not listed. Creator Greg Garcia said that Camden County is loosely modeled on Pimmit Hills, Virginia, the neighborhood where he grew up. The filming location in Los Angeles was not a trailer park, but was built up to look like one.

Many of the locations were filmed in San Fernando Valley in California. In the season 1 episode "The Professor", Earl receives a postcard from Alex with the address "Earl Hickey, The Palms Hotel RM 231, 9005 Lincoln Blvd, Camden USA" with Earl's hand covering up most of the postmark. The Palms Motel structure is actually a motel in North Hills, California, now named the Palm Tree Inn Motel. It was also used to film other shows and films such as Gilmore Girls, The Mentalist, and Heroes. Exterior shots of the Crab Shack and Club Chubby were also taken from locations in Van Nuys and North Hills. Houses and shops for the various characters come from locations in Van Nuys, Santa Clarita, Northridge, Moorpark, Los Angeles, and other Southern California cities. In the episode "Didn't Pay Taxes", Earl and Randy climb the landmark Artesia Water Tower, although they do not refer to it by name.

Other episodes have listed states that were unlikely to have Camden County. In the episode "Our Other Cops is On", officer Stuart Daniels states that his surveillance equipment was "supposed to go to Camden, New Jersey, but came here instead". In "Earl and Joy's Anniversary", when killer bees have invaded Camden and then left, Iqball says that the bees are heading for Texas. The flashback episodes "Inside Probe" describe Camden County as trying to stay independent during the American Civil War and forming its own country called Central, which lasted less than a day. In episode "Y2K", Joy states that she "may move to Florida", while in episode "BB" Randy suggests they go to Arizona.

In season 1 episode 7, "Stole Beer from a Golfer", Hagerstown and Cumberland are mentioned and assumed to be relatively nearby as Earl and Randy are on busses traveling opposite directions. The state of Maryland isn't mentioned in the episode, but in real life these towns are both in Maryland about 70 miles apart off Interstate 68.

Cancellation, future and potential reboot

The series was cancelled abruptly on May 19, 2009, after running for four seasons. Season four had ended with the caption 'To Be Continued'. The series' producer, 20th Century Fox Television, approached the Fox, TBS and TNT networks to continue the series, but they were unable to come to terms without "seriously undermining the artistic integrity of the series." In a May 2009 interview, Ethan Suplee said "Ultimately there are just a couple more episodes that I'd like to see done. It doesn't have to be the show that runs infinitely, but there are a few episodes that (creator Greg Garcia) wanted to make, that I was excited about making", meaning that writing already had started for a fifth season.

In October 2011, Jason Lee told E! Online he has been in talks with Greg Garcia to finish the list via a movie, possibly to be released online.

On October 1, 2013, creator Greg Garcia participated in an "Ask Me Anything" (AMA) on Reddit. One person asked "Who was Earl Jr's. real father and did Earl ever finish the list?"

Garcia replied:

I had always had an ending to Earl and I'm sorry I didn't get the chance to see it happen. You've got a show about a guy with a list so not seeing him finish it is a bummer. But the truth is, he wasn't ever going to finish the list. The basic idea of the ending was that while he was stuck on a really hard list item he was going to start to get frustrated that he was never going to finish it. Then he runs into someone who had a list of their own and Earl was on it. They needed to make up for something bad they had done to Earl. He asks them where they got the idea of making a list and they tell him that someone came to them with a list and that person got the idea from someone else. Earl eventually realizes that his list started a chain reaction of people with lists and that he's finally put more good into the world than bad. So at that point he was going to tear up his list and go live his life. Walk into the sunset a free man. With good karma and finally at peace with what he's accomplished.

In 2023, Ethan Suplee explained during an episode of the Slick & Thick podcast exactly what led to the show being cancelled:

In July 2023, Suplee said that everybody involved with the show has previously said that they would do a reboot or a film of the show, and that Garcia pitched a reboot to a number of studios. Suplee said that he found it unlikely that a reboot would happen.

Reception

Critical response

The show was well-received by critics and audiences alike. One reviewer speculated that Earl's forthrightness to having led a life of idiocy is what endears him to the viewer, and is what suggests there is a depth to his character beyond what is initially seen.

Allegations of Scientology influence

Some critics questioned if the series had been influenced by Scientology, with actors Jason Lee (who left Scientology in 2016) and Ethan Suplee being Scientologists at that time; the show also featured guest appearances from high-profile Scientologist actors including Michael Peña, Juliette Lewis and Giovanni Ribisi. In 2008, Alec Baldwin publicly named Earl creator Greg Garcia as being a Scientologist; Garcia quickly denied any involvement with Scientology, claiming that the Daily Mirror had incorrectly reported him to be a Scientologist.

Ratings

The series premiered on September 20, 2005, drew in 14.9 million viewers in the United States, earning a 6.6 rating. By the airing of the third episode it was apparent that My Name Is Earl was the highest rated of NBC's new fall offerings, and a full season (22 episodes) was ordered. In its first month, it was also the highest rated new sitcom of the season to air on any network and was the highest rated sitcom on any network in the 18–49-year-old demographic. The show was renewed for a second (2006–07), a third (2007–08), and a fourth season (2008–09).

Awards and nominations

The series was nominated twice for Best International Programme at the British Academy Television Awards in 2007 and 2008. The pilot episode won Emmy awards for Outstanding Writing and Directing in a Comedy Series for Greg Garcia and Marc Buckland respectively at the 58th Primetime Emmy Awards. Jaime Pressly won for Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Comedy series at the 59th Primetime Emmy Awards. Other Emmy nominations include Beau Bridges and Giovanni Ribisi for Outstanding Guest Actor in a Comedy Series.

Episodes

Main article: List of My Name Is Earl episodes

Home media

Syndication

20th Century Fox Television has cleared My Name Is Earl in nearly 50% of the U.S., said Bob Cook, the company's president and chief operating officer. 20th had sold the off-net sitcom to the Fox, Tribune, CBS, Hearst-Argyle, and Sinclair station groups for a fall 2009 debut.

My Name Is Earl aired in off-network syndication and on TBS, Ion Television, and MyNetworkTV in the United States. The series premiered in January 2006 on Channel 4 in the UK. The fourth season was shown on E4 in October 2008. In 2013, 5Star gained the repeat rights to the series. The show was repeated on Comedy Central Extra from March 5, 2018.

Notes

References

References

1. DeWolf Smith, Nancy. (September 16, 2005). "''Arts and Entertainment Review''". Wall Street Journal.
2. (September 19, 2008). ""My Name Is Earl" Season 4 Preview: The Legend Of Dan Coscino – Channel Guide Magazine".
3. My Name is Earl season 1 DVD extra: Making Things Right: Behind the Scenes of My Name is Earl Featurette
4. Seibel, Deborah Starr. (October 9, 2004). "Comedy Means Always Having to Say You're Sorry". [[New York Times]].
5. (January 13, 2006). "The surprise hit of ''My Name is Earl''".
6. Chas Demster. (September 2014). "My Name Is Earl – The Main Locations".
7. Blake, Lindsay. (January 29, 2016). "The Palms Motel from "My Name Is Earl"".
8. Hutchinson, Guy. (November 2, 2007). "My Name Is Earl hotel".
9. Hutchinson, Guy. (February 17, 2012). "Film locations: The "My Name is Earl" motel".
10. Hoffarth, Tony. (January 28, 2010). "My Name is Earl".
11. Chas Demster. (September 2014). "My Name Is Earl – The Houses Of Camden County".
12. Chas Demster. (September 2014). "My Name Is Earl – Businesses, Churches And Schools Of Camden County".
13. "My Name Is Earl – Other Memorable Locations".
14. Official City of Artesia, California. (2015). "Investigating the Water Tower's Structural Integrity".
15. Fernandez, Maria Elena. (May 19, 2009). "'My Name Is Earl' creator is OK with being 'thrown off the Titanic'". Los Angeles Times.
16. Littleton, Cynthia. (June 8, 2009). "TBS may give new 'Earl' segs a whirl". [[Variety (magazine).
17. Flint, Joe. (May 20, 2009). "TBS ready to be lifeboat for 'My Name Is Earl'". Los Angeles Times.
18. Suplee, Ethan. (May 23, 2009). "Thanks for the effort guys…". [[Twitter]].
19. (June 9, 2009). "Could ''My Name Is Earl'' Be Saved?". [[E!]].
20. O'Connor, Mickey. (June 10, 2009). "''My Name Is Earl'' in Talks to Move to TBS". [[TV Guide]].
21. Godwin, Jennifer. (June 11, 2009). "''My Name Is Earl'' Dead, Deal with TBS Won't Work Out". [[E!]].
22. Ausiello, Michael. (June 11, 2009). "This just in: 'My Name is Earl' will NOT live on".
23. https://www.newshub.co.nz/entertainment/ethan-suplee-fuming-over-my-name-is-earl-axing-2009052518
24. (October 21, 2011). "Jason Lee on My Name Is Earl Movie: "It's Time!"". E! Online.
25. (June 26, 2023). "Why My Name is Earl Was Canceled - and How the Finale Was Supposed Wrap up".
26. Dick, Jeremy. (2023-06-28). "Ethan Suplee Hopes My Name Is Earl Gets a Revival to Finish the Story".
27. Donaghy, James. (June 29, 2007). "My name is L Ron Hubbard". The Guardian.
28. ''[[Gawker]]'' article: "[http://gawker.com/#!5046307/alec-baldwin-doesnt-take-any-shit-from-scientologists Alec Baldwin Doesn't Take Any Shit From Scientologists] {{webarchive. link. (March 25, 2011 .")
29. Spiegelman, Ian. (April 17, 2009). "Greg Garcia Responds to Baldwin: 'I'm Not a Scientologist.'". [[Gawker.com]].
30. (May 26, 2006). "Series". [[The Hollywood Reporter]].
31. (May 25, 2007). "2006–07 primetime wrap". [[The Hollywood Reporter]].
32. Justin Van De Kamp. (June 1, 2008). "TV Ratings: 2007–2008 Season Top-200". blogspot.com.
33. (May 19, 2009). "Season Program Rankings from 09/22/08 through 05/17/09". [[American Broadcasting Company.
34. "My Name Is Earl – The Complete 1st Season DVD Information". [[TVShowsOnDVD.com]].
35. "My Name Is Earl – The Complete 2nd Season DVD Information". [[TVShowsOnDVD.com]].
36. "My Name Is Earl – The Complete 3rd Season DVD Information". [[TVShowsOnDVD.com]].
37. (September 30, 2008). "My Name Is Earl – Season Three (2009)".
38. "(UK) : My Name Is Earl: Season 3 (4 Discs) : DVD – Free Delivery". Play.com.
39. "My Name Is Earl – The Complete 4th Season DVD Information". [[TVShowsOnDVD.com]].
40. Paige Albiniak. (January 8, 2009). "Twentieth Clears 'Earl' In Half The Country". Reed Business Information.