Muslim Sicily

History

Early Muslim conquest of Sicily

In 535, Emperor Justinian I reconquered Sicily for the Roman Empire, which by then was ruled from Constantinople. As the power of what is now known as the Byzantine Empire waned in the West, a new and expansionist power was emerging in the Middle East: the Rashidun Caliphate, the first major Muslim state to emerge following the death of the Islamic prophet Muhammad in 632. Over a period of twenty five years, the caliphate succeeded in annexing much of the Persian Sasanian Empire and former Roman territories in the Levant and North Africa. In 652, under Caliph Uthman, an invasion captured most of the island, but Muslims occupation was short-lived, as they left following his death.

By the end of the seventh century, with the Umayyad conquest of North Africa, the Muslims had captured the nearby port city of Carthage, allowing them to build shipyards and a permanent base from which to launch more sustained attacks.

Around 700, the island of Pantelleria was captured by Umayyads, and it was only discord among the Muslims that prevented an attempted invasion of Sicily at that time. Instead, trading agreements were arranged with the Byzantines, and Muslim merchants were allowed to trade goods at Sicilian ports.

The first true attempt at conquest was launched in 740; in that year the Muslim prince Habib, who had participated in the 728 attack, successfully captured Syracuse. Ready to conquer the whole island, they were however forced to return to Tunisia by a Berber revolt. A second attack in 752 aimed only to sack the same city.

Muslim conquest

Main article: Muslim conquest of Sicily, History of Islam in southern Italy

In 826, Euphemius, the commander of the Byzantine fleet of Sicily, forced a nun to marry him. Emperor Michael II caught wind of the matter and ordered that General Constantine end the marriage and cut off Euphemius' nose. Euphemius rose up, killed Constantine and then occupied Syracuse; he in turn was defeated and driven out to North Africa. He offered rule of Sicily over to Ziyadat Allah, the Aghlabid emir of Ifriqiya (around present-day Tunisia), in return for a place as a general and safety; the Emir agreed, offering to give Euphemius the island in exchange for a yearly tribute. The conquest was entrusted to the 70-year-old qadi Asad ibn al-Furat, who led a force 10,000 infantry, 700 cavalry and 100 ships. Reinforced by the Muslims, Euphemius' ships landed at Mazara del Vallo, where the first battle against loyalist Byzantine troops occurred on July 15, 827, resulting in an Aghlabid victory.

Asad subsequently conquered the southern shore of the island and laid siege to Syracuse. After year-long siege, and an attempted mutiny, his troops were able to defeat a large army sent from Palermo, backed by a Venetian fleet led by Doge Giustiniano Participazio. A sudden outbreak of plague killed many of the Muslim troops, as well as Asad himself, forcing the Muslims to retreat to the castle Mineo. They later renewed their offensive, but failed to conquer Castrogiovanni (modern Enna) where Euphemius was killed, forcing them to retreat back to their stronghold at Mazara.

In 830, the remaining Muslims of Sicily received a strong reinforcement of 30,000 Ifriqiyan and Andalusi troops. The Iberian Muslims defeated the Byzantine commander Teodotus between July and August of that year, but again a plague forced them to return to Mazara and later Ifriqiya. However, Ifriqiyan units sent to besiege the Sicilian capital of Palermo managed to capture it after a year-long siege in September 831. Palermo was made the Muslim capital of Sicily, renamed al-Madinah ("The City"), and it became the base for further conquests on the island.

The conquest was an incremental, see-saw affair. With considerable resistance and many internal struggles, it took over a century for Byzantine Sicily to be fully conquered. Messina was besieged and captured in 842 or 843, possibly with the support of some Neapolitans, and became a base for subsequent campaigns into the Italian mainland. Syracuse was captured in 878. The conquest of the island was not fully completed until 902, when Taormina was conquered. Even after this, however, some patches of local Byzantine/Christian resistance continued until 967, after the end of the Aghlabid period.

Muslim rule

In succession, Sicily was ruled by the Sunni Aghlabid dynasty in Ifriqiya until 909, when they were overthrown and replaced by the Shiite Fatimids. The first years of Fatimid rule after 909 were difficult, as the Sicilian Muslims had already begun to acquire a distinct identity and they resisted attempts by new outsiders to assert themselves. The first Fatimid governor was expelled in 912 and the second one, Ibn Qurhub, rebelled until 916. Fatimid authority was only established more securely with the defeat of rebels and the surrender of Palermo in 917. Salim ibn Abi Rashid served as Fatimid governor from 917 to 936. He was related by marriage to the Kalbids, a high-ranking family loyal to the Fatimids. Another major revolt for independence shook the island in 937 and was only suppressed in 941.

In 948, the Fatimid caliph al-Mansur appointed the Kalbid commander al-Hasan ibn Ali al-Kalbi as governor of the island. He became the first emir of the Kalbid dynasty, which effectively ruled the island for the next century on behalf of the Fatimids. Al-Hasan returned to Ifriqiya upon the death of al-Mansur, leaving his son Ahmad as governor of the island, though he returned later to assist in campaigns against the Byzantines. Under Ahmad's tenure, Taormina was conquered again in 962 and Rometta was conquered soon after. The Fatimids subsequently conquered and moved to Egypt in 972–973, leaving the Zirids as their viceroys in Ifriqiya. It was only after this move to Egypt that the Fatimid caliphs implicitly recognized the Kalbids as hereditary rulers, who thenceforth governed the island as amirs on their behalf.

Throughout this period, Sunni Muslims formed the majority of the Muslim community in Sicily, with most (if not all) of the people of Palermo being Sunni, leading to their hostility to the Shia Kalbids. The Sunni population of the island was replenished following sectarian rebellions across north Africa from 943–947 against the Fatimids' harsh religious policies, leading to several waves of refugees fleeing to Sicily in an attempt to escape Fatimid retaliation. The Byzantines took advantage of temporary discord to occupy the eastern end of the island for several years.

Raids into Southern Italy continued under the Kalbids into the 11th century, and in 982 a joint Christian army under the Emperor Otto II and the brothers Landulf and Pandulf was defeated at Stilo near Crotone in Calabria. But Emir Abu'l-Qasim was killed in battle and with Emir Yusuf al-Kalbi (986–998) a period of steady decline began. Under al-Akhal (1017–1037) the dynastic conflict intensified, with factions within the ruling family allying themselves variously with the Byzantine Empire and the Zirids. After this period, Al-Mu'izz ibn Badis attempted to annex the island for the Zirids, while intervening in the affairs of the feuding Muslims; however, the attempt ultimately failed.

Decline and "Taifa" period

By the 11th century, mainland southern Italian powers were hiring Norman mercenaries, who were Christian descendants of the Vikings; it was the Normans under Roger de Hauteville, who became Roger I of Sicily, that captured Sicily from the Muslims. In 1038, a Byzantine army under George Maniaces crossed the strait of Messina, and included a corps of Normans. After another decisive victory in the summer of 1040, Maniaces halted his march to lay siege to Syracuse. Despite his conquest of the latter, Maniaces was removed from his position, and the subsequent Muslim counter-offensive reconquered all the cities captured by the Byzantines. The Norman Robert Guiscard, son of Tancred, then conquered Sicily in 1060 after taking Apulia and Calabria, while his brother Roger de Hauteville occupied Messina with an army of 700 knights.

The Emirate of Sicily began to fragment amid intra-dynastic quarrels. In 1044, under emir Hasan al-Samsam, the island devolved into four qadits, or small fiefdoms: Trapani, Marsala, Mazara and Sciacca led by Abdallah ibn Mankut; that of Girgenti, Castrogiovanni and Castronuovo under Ibn al-Hawwàs; Catania held by Ibn al-Maklatí; and that of Syracuse under Ibn Thumna, while al-Samsam retained control of Palermo longer, before it adopted self-rule under a council of sheikhs. There followed a period of squabbles among the qadits that likely represented kin-groups jockeying for power. Ibn Thumna killed Ibn al-Maklatí, took Catania and married the dead qadi's widow who was the sister of Ibn al-Hawwàs. He also took ibn Mankut's qadit, but when his wife was prevented from returning from a visit to her brother, the Fatimid-allied Ibn Thumna attacked Ibn al-Hawwàs only to be defeated. When he left Sicily to recruit more troops, this briefly left Ibn al-Hawwàs in control of most of the island. In waging his war on his rivals, Ibn Thumna had collaborated closely with the Normans, each using the other to further their goal of ruling the entire island, and though Ibn Thumna's death in a 1062 ambush led the Normans to draw back and consolidate, Ibn Thumna's former allies appear to have continued the alliance, such that Muslim troops constituted the majority of the Hauteville "Norman" army in Sicily.

The Zirids of North Africa sent an army to Sicily led by Ali and Ayyub ibn Tamin, and these troops progressively brought the qadits under their control, killing al-Hawwàs and effectively making Ayyub emir of Muslim Sicily. However, they lost two decisive battles against the Normans. The Sicilians and North Africans were defeated in 1063 by a small Norman force at the Battle of Cerami, cementing Norman control over the north-east of the island. The sizeable Christian population rose up against the ruling Muslims. Then in 1068, Roger and his men defeated Ayyub at the Battle of Misilmeri, and the Zirids returned to North Africa, leaving Sicily in disarray. Catania fell to the Normans in 1071. Palermo, ruled since the Zirid withdrawal by Ibn al-Ba'ba, a man apparently of Spanish Jewish descent from the city's merchant class who led the city with the support of its sheikhs, would in turn fall on 10 January 1072 after a five-month siege. Trapani capitulated the same year.

The loss of the main port cities dealt a severe blow to Muslim power on the island. The last pocket of active resistance was Syracuse governed by Ibn Abbad (known as Benavert in western chronicles). He defeated Jordan, son of Roger of Sicily in 1075, occupied Catania again in 1081, and raided Calabria shortly after. However, Roger besieged Syracuse in 1086, and Ibn Abbad tried to break the siege with a naval battle, in which he died accidentally. Syracuse surrendered after this defeat. His wife and son fled to Noto and Butera. Meanwhile, the city of Qas'r Ianni (Castrogiovanni, modern Enna) was ruled by a Hammud, who surrendered and converted to Christianity only in 1087. After his conversion, Hammud subsequently became part of the Christian nobility and retired with his family to an estate in Calabria provided by Roger I. In 1091, Butera and Noto in the southern tip of Sicily and the island of Malta, the last Arab strongholds, fell to the Christians with ease. After the conquest of Sicily, the Normans removed the local emir, Yusuf Ibn Abdallah from power, while respecting the customs of the resident Arabs.

Society

The new Arab rulers initiated land reforms, which in turn increased productivity and encouraged the growth of smallholdings, a dent to the dominance of the landed estates. The Arabs further improved irrigation systems through Qanats and introduced new and lucrative crops, including oranges, lemons, pistachio and sugarcane. A description of Palermo was given by Ibn Hawqal, a Baghdad merchant who visited Sicily in 950. A walled suburb called the Kasr (the palace) is the center of Palermo until today, with the great Friday Mosque on the site of the later Roman cathedral. The suburb of Al-Khalisa (Kalsa) contained the Sultan's palace, baths, a mosque, government offices, and a private prison. Ibn Hawqual reckoned 7,000 individual butchers trading in 150 shops. The population of the city during this period is uncertain, as figures given by Arab writers during the era were unreliable. Paul Bairoch estimated Palermo's population at 350,000 in the 11th century, while other historians like Stephan R. Epstein estimated it to be closer to 60,000. Based on al-Maqdisi's statement that Palermo was larger than Old Cairo, Kenneth Meyer Setton put the figure above 100,000 but below 250,000. Around 1330, Palermo's population stood at 51,000.

Arab traveler, geographer, and poet Ibn Jubair visited the area in the end of the 12th century and described Al-Kasr and Al-Khalisa (Kalsa):

Throughout this reign, revolts by Byzantine Sicilians occurred, especially in the east, and part of the lands were even re-occupied before being quashed.{{cite book | url-access =registration

The local population conquered by the Muslims were Greek-speaking and Latin-speaking Byzantine Christians, but there were also a significant number of Jews. The Orthodox and Catholic populations were members of one Church until the events of 1054 began to separate them, the sack of 1204 being the last straw as far as the Byzantine "Orthodox" were concerned.

Christians and Jews were tolerated under Muslim rule as dhimmis but were subject to some restrictions; they were also required to pay the jizya, or head tax, and the kharaj or land tax, but were exempt from the tax that Muslims had to pay (Zakaat). Under Arab rule there were different categories of Jizya payers, but their common denominator was the payment of the Jizya as a mark of subjection to Muslim rule in exchange for protection against foreign and internal aggression. The conquered population could avoid this subservient status by converting to Islam. About half the population was Muslim at the time of the Norman Conquest. The co-existence with the conquered population fell apart after the reconquest of Sicily starting in the 1160s and particularly following the death of King William II of Sicily in 1189. The policy of oppression visited upon Christians was applied to Muslims.

Government

Seated in what is now the Royal Palace in Palermo, the emir held authority over most affairs of state, including the army, administration, justice, and the treasury. He appointed the governors of major cities, high ranking judges (qāḍī), and arbitrators for minor disputes between individuals (hakam). An assembly of notables called giamà'a played a consultative role, albeit sometimes making important decisions in lieu of the emir. It is also very likely that the authorities operated a tiraz, an official workshop that produced valuable fabrics such as silk, which were granted as a sign of appreciation to their subject or as a gift to foreign dignitaries.

Muslim sovereignty was never absolute across the island, and the creation of three subdivisions served to distinguish different approaches to government. Under the Arab rule the island was divided in three administrative regions, or "vals", roughly corresponding to the three "points" of Sicily: Val di Mazara in the west; Val Demone in the northeast; and Val di Noto in the southeast. Western Sicily was more Islamized and heavily populated by Arabs, allowing for full and direct administration; by contrast, the northeast region of Val Demone remained majority Christian and often resistant to Muslim rule, prompting a focus on tax collection and maintaining public order, as a result, revolts by Byzantine Sicilians continuously occurred in the east where Greek-speaking Christians predominated. Parts of the island were re-occupied before revolts were quashed.By the 11th century, the Emirate of Sicily began to fragment as intra-dynastic quarreling fractured the Muslim government.

The fighters or junud in conquering the lands obtained four-fifths as booty (fai) and one fifth was reserved for the state or the local governor (the khums), following the rules of Islamic law. However, this rule was not always respected and in many areas such as that of Agrigento the new owners would not have had the right. But it must be said that this distribution of the lands brought about the end of the large estates and the possibility of better exploitation of the lands. New crops were thus introduced where only wheat had been grown for centuries. Sugarcane, vegetables, citrus fruits, dates and mulberry trees appeared and mining exploitation began.

Coinage

The coin introduced by the Arabs was the dinar, in gold and weighing 4.25 grams. The dirhem was silver and weighed 2.97 grams. The Aghlabites introduced the solidus in gold and the follis in copper. While following the conquest of Palermo in 886 the kharruba was coined which was worth 1/6 of a dirhem.

Aftermath

The Norman Kingdom of Sicily under Roger II has been characterized as "multi-ethnic in nature and religiously tolerant". Normans, Jews, Muslim Arabs, Byzantine Greeks, Lombards and native Sicilians lived in relative harmony. Arabic remained a language of government and administration for at least a century into Norman rule, and traces remain in the language of Sicily and evidently more in the language of Malta today. Muslims also maintained their domination of industry, retailing, and production, while Muslim craftsmanship, masonry, and expertise in government and administration were highly sought after.

However, the island's Muslims were faced with the choice of voluntary departure or subjection to Christian rule. Many Muslims chose to leave, provided they had the means to do so. "The transformation of Sicily into a Christian island", remarks Abulafia, "was also, paradoxically, the work of those whose culture was under threat". Also, Muslims gradually converted to Christianity, the Normans replaced Orthodox clergy with Latin clerics. Despite the presence of an Arab-speaking Christian population, Greek churchmen attracted Muslim peasants to receive a baptism and even adopted Greek Christian names; in several instances, Christian serfs with Greek names listed in the Monreale registers had living Muslim parents. The Norman rulers followed a policy of steady Latinization by bringing in thousands of Italian settlers from the northwest and south of Italy, and some others from southeast France. To this day, there are communities in central Sicily which speak the Gallo-Italic dialect. Some Muslims chose to feign conversion, but such a remedy could only provide individual protection and could not sustain a community.[[File:Arabo-NormanArchitecture.JPG|thumb|[[Arab-Norman culture|Arab-Norman]] art and architecture combined European and [[Classical architecture|Classical]] features with [[Islamic architecture|Islamic architectural]] features such as [[muqarnas]]]]

"Lombard" pogroms against Muslims started in the 1160s. Muslim and Christian communities in Sicily became increasingly geographically separated. Though likely still a majority, the island's Muslim communities were mainly isolated beyond an internal frontier that divided the south and western half of the island from the Christian north and eastern half; in particular, the northeast region of Val Demone had remained predominantly Byzantine Greek and Christian, even during Islamic rule. As a subject people, Sicilian Muslims became dependent on the mercy of their Christian masters and, ultimately, on royal protection. After King William the Good died in 1189, royal protection was lifted, and the door was opened for widespread attacks against the island's Muslims. This destroyed any lingering hope of coexistence, however unequal the respective populations might have been. The death of Henry VI and his wife Constance a year later plunged Sicily into political turmoil. With the loss of royal protection and with Frederick II still an infant in papal custody, Sicily became a battleground for rival German and papal forces. The island's Muslim rebels sided with German warlords like Markward von Anweiler. In response, Pope Innocent III declared a crusade against Markward, alleging that he had made an unholy alliance with the Saracens of Sicily. Nevertheless, in 1206 Innocent III had attempted to convince Muslim leaders to remain loyal. By this time, the Muslim rebellion was in full swing. They were in control of Jato, Entella, Platani, Celso, Calatrasi, Corleone (taken in 1208), Guastanella and Cinisi. Muslim revolt extended throughout a whole stretch of western Sicily. The rebels were led by Muhammad Ibn Abbād. He called himself the "prince of believers", struck his own coins, and attempted to find Muslim support from other parts of the Muslim world.

However, Frederick II, no longer a child, responded by launching a series of campaigns against the Muslim rebels in 1221. The Hohenstaufen forces rooted out the defenders of Jato, Entella, and the other fortresses. Rather than exterminate the Muslims. who numbered about 60,000, in 1223, Frederick II began deporting them to Lucera in Apulia. A year later, expeditions were sent against Malta and Djerba, to establish royal control and prevent their Muslim populations from helping the rebels. Paradoxically, Saracen archers remained a common component of these "Christian" armies and the presence of Muslim contingents in the imperial army remained a reality even under Manfred and Conradin.

The House of Hohenstaufen and their successors (Capetian House of Anjou and Aragonese House of Barcelona) gradually "Latinized" Sicily over the course of two centuries, and this social process laid the groundwork for the introduction of Latin (as opposed to Byzantine) Catholicism. The process of Latinization was fostered largely by the Roman Church and its liturgy. The removal of Islam in Sicily was completed by the late 1240s, when the final deportations to Lucera took place. The remaining population of Sicilian Muslims converted to Catholicism due to the incentives put in place by Fredrich II. By the time of the Sicilian Vespers in 1282, there were no Muslims in Sicily, and the society was completely Latinized.

During the reigns of Frederick II as well as his son, Manfred, a large amount of Muslims were brought, as slaves, to farm lands and perform domestic labor. Enslaved persons in Sicily were not afforded the same privileges as the Muslims in mainland Italy. The trend of importing a considerable amount of slaves from the Muslim world did not stop with the Hohenstaufen but was amplified under the Aragonese and Spanish crowns, and was in fact continued until as late as 1838.

List of rulers

Aghlabid governors

• Muhammad ibn al-Fadl (882–885, 892)

Kalbids

• al-Hasan al-Kalbi (948–953)
• Ahmad ibn al-Hasan al-Kalbi (954–969)
• Ya'ish (969–970), usurper
• Abu'l-Qasim Ali ibn al-Hasan al-Kalbi (970–982)
• Jabir al-Kalbi (982–983)
• Ja'far al-Kalbi (983–985)
• Abdallah al-Kalbi (985–990)
• Yusuf al-Kalbi (990–998)
• Ja'far al-Kalbi (998–1019)
• al-Akhal (1019–1037)
• Abdallah ibn Al-Mu'izz (1037–1040), Zirid usurper
• Hasan as-Samsam (1040–1053)

Taifa period

• Abdallah ibn Mankut – Trapani and Mazara (1053–?)
• Ibn al-Maklatí – Catania (1053–?)
• Muhammed ibn Ibrahim (Ibn Thumna) – Syracuse (1053–1062) and in later years Catania and Trapani/Mazara
• Alí ibn Nima (Ibn al-Hawwās) – Agrigento and Castrogiovanni (1053–about 1065), all Taifas from 1062
• Ayyub ibn Tamim (Zirid) (about 1065–1068)
• Ibn al-Ba'ba, Palermo (1068–1072)
• Hammad – Agrigento and Castrogiovanni (1068–1087)
• Ibn Abbad (Benavert) – Syracuse and Catania (1071–1086)

References

Sources

References

1. (7 October 2007). "Brief history of Sicily". Archaeology.Stanford.edu.
2. [https://www.ft.com/content/dc14c6b6-b7d4-440a-8ca3-56fcbb1e4fb2 William Dalrymple on Sicily's Islamic past.] ''Financial Times'' (Jan. 9, 2021). "The prosperity this generated led to Sicily, and especially Palermo, becoming a rich hub in the trading networks of the Mediterranean, the meeting place for merchants from the Middle East, north Africa and the young Italian trading republics."
3. Of Italy, Touring Club (2005). ''Authentic Sicily''. Touring Editore. {{ISBN. 978-88-365-3403-6.
4. Mattozzi, Savin. "‘Sicilians have affinity for the Islamic world in their DNA’".
5. Davis-Secord, Sarah. (2017-12-31). "Where Three Worlds Met". Cornell University Press.
6. Mack Smith, Denis. (1968). "''A History of Sicily: Medieval Sicily 800—1713''". Chatto & Windus, London.
7. [[Charles William Previté-Orton. Previte-Orton]] (1971), vol. 1, pg. 370
8. link. (2011-07-14 , by Alwi Alatas)
9. Davis-Secord, Sarah. (2017). "Where Three Worlds Met: Sicily in the Early Medieval Mediterranean". Cornell University Press.
10. Bondioli, Lorenzo M.. (2018). "The Aghlabids and Their Neighbors: Art and Material Culture in Ninth-Century North Africa". Brill.
11. Kreutz, Barbara M.. (1991). "Before the Normans: Southern Italy in the Ninth and Tenth Centuries". University of Pennsylvania Press.
12. Kleinhenz, Christopher. (2017). "Routledge Revivals: Medieval Italy (2004): An Encyclopedia – Volume II". Routledge.
13. Mazot, Sibylle. (2011). "Islam: Art and Architecture". h.f.ullmann.
14. Davis-Secord, Sarah. (2017). "Where Three Worlds Met: Sicily in the Early Medieval Mediterranean". Cornell University Press.
15. Halm, Heinz. (1996). "The Empire of the Mahdi: The Rise of the Fatimids". E.J. Brill.
16. Metcalfe, Alex. (2021). "Encyclopaedia of Islam, Three". Brill.
17. Nef, Annliese. (2021). "A Companion to Byzantine Italy". Brill.
18. Brett, Michael. (2017). "The Fatimid Empire". Edinburgh University Press.
19. {{Encyclopaedia of Islam, Second Edition. U.. Rizzitano
20. Brett, Michael. (2017). "The Fatimid Empire". Edinburgh University Press.
21. Bosworth, Clifford Edmund. (1996). "The New Islamic Dynasties: A Chronological and Genealogical Manual". Edinburgh University Press.
22. Brett, Michael. (2017). "The Fatimid Empire". Edinburgh University Press.
23. (26 Aug 2014). "Infidel Kings and Unholy Warriors: Faith, Power, and Violence in the Age of Crusade and Jihad". Macmillan.
24. (1995). "Italia judaica, Volume 5". Ufficio centrale per i beni archivistici, Divisione studi e pubblicazioni.
25. (2007). "Arts of the City Victorious: Islamic Art and Architecture in Fatimid North Africa and Egypt". Yale University Press.
26. (1 Jan 1955). "Africa in Europe: Antiquity into the Age of Global Exploration". Lexington Books.
27. (2004). "The New Cambridge Medieval History". Cambridge University Press.
28. Alex Metcalf, ''The Muslims of Medieval Italy'', Edinburgh:Edinburgh University Press, 2009, pp. 84-85
29. Metcalf, ''The Muslims of Medieval Italy'', pp. 94-95
30. Metcalf, ''The Muslims of Medieval Italy'', pp. 97-98
31. (1997). "Latin Siege Warfare in the Twelfth Century". Oxford University Press.
32. (7 October 2007). "Chronological - Historical Table Of Sicily". In Italy Magazine.
33. Marshall W. Baldwin. (2016). "A History of the Crusades, Volume 1 The First Hundred Years". University of Pennsylvania Press.
34. E. Buringh. (2011). "Medieval Manuscript Production in the Latin West: Explorations with a Global Database". Brill.
35. J. Bradford De Long and Andrei Shleifer. (October 1993). "Princes and Merchants: European City Growth before the Industrial Revolution". [[University of Chicago Press]].
36. (2014). "The Peoples of Sicily: A Multicultural Legacy". Trinacria Editions.
37. [https://web.archive.org/web/20100821054137/http://www.cliohres.net/books/3/Dalli.pdf Archived link]: ''From Islam to Christianity: the Case of Sicily'', Charles Dalli, page 153. In ''Religion, ritual and mythology : aspects of identity formation in Europe'' / edited by Joaquim Carvalho, 2006, {{ISBN. 88-8492-404-9.
38. (7 October 2007). "Brief history of Sicily". Archaeology.Stanford.edu.
39. Costantino, Alberto. (2021-04-05). "Gli arabi in Sicilia / Alberto Costantino".
40. [http://concise.britannica.com/ebc/article-9377080/Roger-II Roger II - Encyclopædia Britannica] {{webarchive. link. (2007-05-23)
41. Inturrisi, Louis. (April 26, 1987). "Tracing the Norman Rulers of Sicily". The New York Times.
42. (1996). "Understanding Arabic: Essays in Contemporary Arabic Linguistics in Honor of El-Said Badawi". American Univ in Cairo Press.
43. [https://web.archive.org/web/20100821054137/http://www.cliohres.net/books/3/Dalli.pdf Charles Dalli, From Islam to Christianity: the Case of Sicily, p. 159] (archived link)
44. Abulafia, The end of Muslim Sicily cit., p. 109
45. [https://web.archive.org/web/20100821054137/http://www.cliohres.net/books/3/Dalli.pdf Charles Dalli, ''From Islam to Christianity: the Case of Sicily'', p. 159] (archived link)
46. J. Johns, The Greek church and the conversion of Muslims in Norman Sicily?, "Byzantinische Forschungen", 21, 1995; for Greek Christianity in Sicily see also V. von Falkenhausen, "Il monachesimo greco in Sicilia", in C.D. Fonseca (ed.), ''La Sicilia rupestre nel contesto delle civiltà mediterranee'', vol. 1, Lecce 1986.
47. [https://web.archive.org/web/20100821054137/http://www.cliohres.net/books/3/Dalli.pdf Charles Dalli, From Islam to Christianity: the Case of Sicily, p. 160] (archived link)
48. (2009). "The Muslims of Medieval Italy". Edinburgh University Press.
49. (1854). "Storia dei musulmani di Sicilia". F. Le Monnier.
50. (19 Sep 2014). "Routledge Handbook of Islam in the West". Routledge.
51. (1 Jan 2002). "The Society of Norman Italy". BRILL.
52. (7 Oct 2002). "Arabic Administration in Norman Sicily: The Royal Diwan". Cambridge University Press.
53. Metcalfe (2009), pp. 34–36, 40
54. Loud, G. A.. (2007). "The Latin Church in Norman Italy". Cambridge University Press.
55. [https://web.archive.org/web/20100821054137/http://www.cliohres.net/books/3/Dalli.pdf Charles Dalli, From Islam to Christianity: the Case of Sicily, p. 160-161] (archived link)
56. [https://web.archive.org/web/20100821054137/http://www.cliohres.net/books/3/Dalli.pdf Charles Dalli, From Islam to Christianity: the Case of Sicily, p. 161] (archived link)
57. Aubé, Pierre. (2001). "Roger Ii De Sicile - Un Normand En Méditerranée". Payot.
58. A.Lowe: The Barrier and the bridge, op cit;p.92.
59. (2007-11-28). "Saracen Archers in Southern Italy".
60. Abulafia, David. (1988). "Frederick II: A Medieval Emperor". Allen Lane.
61. Zeldes, Nadia. (2014). "Offering economic and social benefits as incentives for conversion: The case of Sicily and southern Italy (12th-15th centuries)". Materia Giudaica: Rivista dell'associazione Italiana per Lo Studio del Giudaismo.
62. Taylor, Julie Anne. (2007-04-01). "Freedom and Bondage among Muslims in Southern Italy during the Thirteenth Century". Journal of Muslim Minority Affairs.
63. Bonazza, Giulia. (2018-12-13). "Abolitionism and the Persistence of Slavery in Italian States, 1750–1850". Springer.
64. De Lucia, Lori. (2020). "Sicily and the Two Seas: The Cross Currents of Race and Slavery in Early Modern Palermo". UCLA.
65. Goodman, Jack. (June 2017). "Slavery and Manumission in Fourteenth-Century Palermo". Western Michigan University.