Melanin theory

Claims

Melanin theory posits that individuals' responses to social stimuli are determined by the prevalence of the skin pigment melanin. Historian Stephen Ferguson describes melanin theory as a component of "strong" Afrocentrism, which assigns biological causes to social phenomena such as white supremacy. Proponents of melanin theory ("melanists") argue that insecurity among European males leads to efforts to socially dominate and emasculate African males, taking the form of unemployment, incarceration, and political and social marginalization.

Some black supremacists, including professor of black studies Leonard Jeffries and psychologist Frances Cress Welsing, argue without evidence that higher levels of melanin give black people inherently superior qualities to white people, including supernatural abilities such as extrasensory perception. According to Bernard Ortiz de Montellano, "the alleged properties of melanin, mostly unsupported, irrelevant, or distortions of the scientific literature, are [...] used to justify Afrocentric assertions. One of the most common is that humans evolved as blacks in Africa, and that whites are mutants (albinos, or melanin recessives)". Ortiz de Montellano wrote in 1993 that melanin theory as an ideological movement would increase scientific illiteracy and would contribute to "widening the gap between the races".

Welsing states that Africans possess dominant genes in comparison to the recessive genes of Europeans, which, she posits, leads to a struggle by Europeans to maintain their genetic distinctness. Welsing derived her hypothesis partly through a neo-Freudian analysis of cultural symbols rather than scientific evidence, arguing that the motivation for white supremacy is an unconscious response to white genetic and sexual inferiority. Ferguson equates this argument with "white male penis envy" toward black men.

In popular culture

In 2006, the views of adherents and critics of melanin theory were dramatized in Cassandra Medley's play Relativity.

References

References

1. (2005). "Encyclopedia of Black Studies". SAGE.
2. Ferguson, Stephen C.. (2015). "Philosophy of African American Studies: Nothing Left of Blackness". Palgrave Macmillan.
3. Genzlinger, Neil. (May 2, 2006). "Science and Race Issues Clash in Cassandra Medley's 'Relativity'". The New York Times.
4. Morrow, Lance. (24 June 2001). "Controversies: The Provocative Professor".
5. Newkirk, Pamela. (2002). "Within the Veil: Black Journalists, White Media". New York University Press.
6. Ortiz de Montellano, Bernard. (Winter 1992). "Magic Melanin: Spreading Scientific Illiteracy Among Minorities: Part II".
7. Ortiz de Montellano, Bernard R.. (1993). "Melanin, afrocentricity, and pseudoscience". American Journal of Physical Anthropology.