Matthias Nicoll

Early life

Nicoll was born in 1627 and was the son of a minister. He lived in Islip, Northamptonshire, and practiced law there.

Life in America

In 1664, he came to the North America with Richard Nicolls. It is not known if the two were related, although some sources say he was Richard's nephew. Matthias was Richard's secretary and was present to the first surrender of the Dutch New Amsterdam to the English. He was clerk of the court in the new English colony and served various judge roles. He was a member of the Convention at Hempstead, New York, in 1664–1665 that established the laws for the new colony.

In 1670, he bought land in present Plandome Manor, New York/Plandome, New York, and he is said to have named it for the Latin 'planus domus' meaning 'plain' or 'peaceful' home.

Political career

In 1672 he was appointed New York City mayor, and served for one year, until he was succeeded by John Lawrence.

In 1674, following the English reconquest of New York from the Dutch, Nicoll was sworn in for a second term. Contemporaneous records of Nicoll's second mayoralty were lost until the 1980s, and his status as the eighth mayor was thus historically absent from city documentation, meaning that the subsequent numbering of the city's mayors was off by one until being corrected at the beginning of 2026.

He was speaker of the General Assembly under Thomas Dongan in 1684 which guaranteed religious freedom to Christians.

Personal life

He and his wife were buried in front of the manor home, although the exact spot is not now known because it was vandalized. A plaque on Plandome Road marks the general area.

One of his children, William Nicoll, would sell the Plandome Manor in 1718, then over 1000 acres, and move to his own estate of 100 sqmi on the Great South Bay in present-day Islip, New York. The Suffolk estate Islip was named after their ancestral home in England.

The manor house itself was torn down in 1998 by its new owner.

References

References

1. [https://books.google.com/books?id=sTwDAAAAYAAJ&dq=Matthias+Nicoll&pg=PA72 John Watts de Peyster, Volume 1 By Frank Allaben - Frank Allaben Genealogical Company - 1906]
2. "Incorporated Village of Plandome Manor". Plandomemanor.com.
3. Christoph, Peter. (July 1989). "Matthias Nicolls, Sixth and Eighth Mayor of New York". New York Genealogical and Biographical Record.
4. Kim, Elizabeth. (December 1, 2025). "Zohran Mamdani will be sworn in as NYC's 111th mayor. But what if that number's wrong?". [[Gothamist]].
5. Lorenzini, Michael. (December 11, 2025). "On Mayors and the Counting Thereof".
6. (December 17, 2025). "Correcting the record: Zohran Mamdani believes he is 112th NYC mayor".
7. Newman, Andy. (December 27, 2025). "Is Mamdani Mayor No. 111 or 112? We Need a Recount.". [[The New York Times]].
8. Honan, Katie. (January 1, 2026). "Mamdani Takes the Helm as City's New Mayor".
9. [https://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9C06E0DE1038F931A25755C0A9639C8B63&sec=&spon=&pagewanted=2 Endangered: Historic Preservation - New York Times - June 12, 2005]