Majestic 12

History

On May 31, 1987, it was widely reported that British ufologist Timothy Good claimed to be in possession of 1950s-era UFO documents. The documents purported to reveal a secret committee of 12, supposedly formed in 1947 by an executive order by U.S. President Harry S. Truman, and explain how the crash of an alien spacecraft at Roswell in July 1947 had been concealed, how the recovered alien technology could be exploited, and how the U.S. should engage with extraterrestrial life in the future.

According to ufologist William L. Moore, his friend, Los Angeles television writer-producer Jamie Shandera, received documents that appeared to be briefing papers describing "Operation Majestic-12" in mid-December 1984. The documents were found on an undeveloped roll of 35 mm film in a brown paper package that had been dropped through Shandera's mail slot. The package bore no additional information other than a New Mexico postmark.

When developed, the roll of film revealed the Truman-Forestall memo, a "Top Secret" memorandum from President Truman to Defense Secretary Forrestal, dated September 24, 1947, authorizing him and Dr. [Vannevar] Bush to proceed with Operation Majestic-12 and the Eisenhower Briefing Document, a seven page "Top Secret/Eyes Only" Majestic-12 document used to brief President-Elect Eisenhower, dated November 18, 1952.

The concept of "Majestic 12" emerged during a period in the 1980s when ufologists believed there had been a cover-up of the Roswell incident and speculated some secretive upper tier of the U.S. government was responsible. Shandera and his ufologist colleagues Stanton T. Friedman and Bill Moore say they later received a series of anonymous messages that led them to find what has been called the "Cutler/Twining memo" in 1985 while searching declassified files in the National Archives. Purporting to be written by President Eisenhower's assistant Robert Cutler to General Nathan F. Twining and containing a reference to Majestic 12, the memo is widely held to be a forgery, likely planted as part of a hoax. Historian Robert Goldberg wrote that the ufologists came to believe the story despite the documents being "obviously planted to bolster the legitimacy of the briefing papers".

Claiming to be connected to the United States Air Force Office of Special Investigations, a man named Richard Doty told filmmaker Linda Moulton Howe that the MJ-12 story was true, and showed Howe unspecified documents purporting to prove the existence of small, gray humanoid aliens originating from the Zeta Reticuli star system. Doty reportedly promised to supply Howe with film footage of UFOs and an interview with an alien being, although no footage ever materialized.

Soon, distrust and suspicion led to disagreements within the ufology community over the authenticity of the MJ-12 documents, and Moore was accused of taking part in an elaborate hoax, while other ufologists and debunkers such as Philip J. Klass were accused of being "disinformation agents".

On June 24, 1987, Friedman appeared the ABC network news program Nightline opposite Klass, where he discussed the MJ-12 with anchor Ted Koppel. On October 14, 1988, the syndicated television broadcast UFO Coverup? Live introduced many Americans to the Majestic 12 hoax. It featured the first public mention of Nevada's Area 51 as a site associated with aliens.

Analysis

Klass's investigation of the MJ-12 documents found that Robert Cutler was actually out of the country on the date he supposedly wrote the "Cutler/Twining memo", and that the Truman signature was "a pasted-on photocopy of a genuine signature—including accidental scratch marks—from a memo that Truman wrote to Vannevar Bush on October 1, 1947". Klass dismissed theories that the documents were part of a disinformation campaign as "ridiculous", saying they contained numerous flaws that could never fool Soviet or Chinese intelligence. Other discrepancies noted by Klass included the use of a distinctive date format that matched one used in Moore's personal letters, and a conversation reported by Brad Sparks in which Moore confided that he was contemplating creating and releasing some hoax Top Secret documents in hopes that such bogus documents would encourage former military and intelligence officials who knew about the government's (alleged) UFO coverup to break their oaths of secrecy.

As early as the summer of 1987, spokesmen from the White House and National Security Council denied the existence of any organization called Majestic 12, MJ-12 or Majic-12.

On September 15, 1988, a special agent at the United States Air Force Office of Special Investigations (OSI) contacted the Dallas branch of the FBI after receiving the Majestic 12 document from an individual at an unnamed school who claimed to have received it in the mail. The FBI then began its own investigation of the supposed "secret" document and quickly formed doubts as to its authenticity. After receiving information from the OSI on November 30 of that year that no such committee had ever been authorized or formed, the FBI declared that the document was "completely bogus". The Director of the FBI subsequently instructed the Dallas office to close their investigation.

MuckRock contributor Emma Best has suggested that the papers were "government sponsored, or at least tolerated, disinformation" because the declassified FBI file on Majestic 12 does not mention any further investigation to find or prosecute the forger responsible for it.

In addition to the Roswell incident, the "Eisenhower Briefing Document" also mentioned a second crash in 1950. This second alleged crash was in Mexico, near the towns of El Indio and Guerrero along the Mexico–US border. Tom Deuley investigated the Guerrero claim for MUFON, but found no evidence for a reported UFO crash.{{multiref | |

Later in 1996, a document called the MJ-12 "Special Operations Manual" circulated among ufologists. It is also widely considered to be a fake and "a continuation of the MJ-12 myth".

Ufologists Linda Moulton Howe and Stanton T. Friedman believed the MJ-12 documents to be authentic. Friedman examined the documents and argued that the United States government has conspired to cover up knowledge of a crashed extraterrestrial spacecraft.

The name "Majestic 12" had been prefigured in the UFO community when Bill Moore asked National Enquirer reporter Bob Pratt in 1982 to collaborate on a novel initially called MAJIK-12 and eventually changed by Moore to The Aquarius Project. Because of this, Pratt was suspicious of the authenticity of the Majestic 12 documents.

Scientific skeptic author Brian Dunning investigated the history of the subject, and reported his findings in the 2016 Skeptoid podcast episode "The Secret History of Majestic 12". He cited ufologist Bill Moore's suspicion that, rather than a hoax perpetrated by the UFO community, the papers were actually part of a disinformation campaign of the US government meant to deflect attention from secret Air Force projects.

Alleged members

The following individuals were described in the Majestic 12 documents as "designated members" of Majestic 12.

• Lloyd Berkner
• Detlev Bronk
• Vannevar Bush
• James Forrestal
• Gordon Gray
• Roscoe H. Hillenkoetter
• Jerome Clarke Hunsaker
• Donald H. Menzel
• Robert M. Montague
• Sidney Souers
• Nathan F. Twining
• Hoyt Vandenberg

References

Notes

Not to be confused with the Twining memo of 1947 establishing Project Sign

References

1. Donovan, Barna William. (2011-07-20). "Conspiracy Films: A Tour of Dark Places in the American Conscious". McFarland.
2. (2016-01-20). "Everything 'X Files' Fans Need to Know about MJ-12, the Most Significant UFO Conspiracy Theory".
3. D'Estefano, Diana. (2022-03-11). "How Deus Ex: Mankind Divided's Majestic 12 Conspires to Control the World".
4. (1987-05-31). "UFO memo: Aliens crashed". The Bismarck Tribune.
5. Klass, Phillip J.. (Winter 1987–1988). "The MJ-12 Crashed-Saucer Documents". [[Skeptical Inquirer]].
6. Wood, Stacy Elizabeth. (2017). "Making Secret(s): The Infrastructure of Classified Information". University of California, Los Angeles.
7. Goldberg. (2008). "Enemies Within: The Culture of Conspiracy in Modern America". Yale University Press.
8. Frazier. (2010). "The Hundredth Monkey: And Other Paradigms of the Paranormal". Prometheus Books, Publishers.
9. Knight. (2003). "Conspiracy Theories in American History: An Encyclopedia". ABC-CLIO.
10. Friedman, Stanton. (2008). "FLYING SAUCERS AND SCIENCE: A SCIENTIST INVESTIGATES THE MYSTERIES OF UFOS: INTERSTELLAR TRAVEL, CRASHES, AND GOVERNMENT COVER-UPS". New Page Books.
11. (11 August 2023). "Stanton Friedman vs Philip Klass (1987)".
12. Gulyas, Aaron. (2015-06-11). "The Paranormal and the Paranoid: Conspiratorial Science Fiction Television". Rowman & Littlefield.
13. Peebles, Curtis. (1995-12-12). "Watch the Skies!: A Chronicle of the Flying Saucer Myth". Berkley Books.
14. Clary, David A.. (2001-01-22). "Before and After Roswell: The Flying Saucer in America, 1947-1999". Xlibris Corporation.
15. (May 2000). "The New Bogus Majestic-12 Documents".
16. Humes, Edward. (August 24, 1987). "UFO hunter is a serious sleuth, not a space case". [[Santa Ana Orange County Register]].
17. "FBI – Majestic 12 Part 1 of 1". An FBI archive containing details of "Majestic 12".
18. North-Best, Emma. (2017-06-05). "Conspiracy Weary: FBI's real-life "X-Files" document one of the Bureau's laziest investigations".
19. Goldberg, Robert Alan. (2001). "Enemies Within: the Culture of Conspiracy in Modern America". Yale University Press.
20. Blum, Howard. (1990). "Out There: The Government's Secret Quest for Extraterrestrials". Simon and Schuster.
21. Klass, Philip J.. (September 2000). "Significant Discrepancy Between EBD And '1st Annual Report'". Skeptics UFO Newsletter.
22. Denzler. (2001). "The Lure of the Edge: Scientific Passions, Religious Beliefs, and the Pursuit of UFOs". University of California Press.
23. (August 10–12, 2007). "The Secret Pratt Tapes and the Origins of MJ-12". Mutual UFO Network.
24. (July 19, 2016). "The Secret History of Majestic 12".
25. Blum. (1991). "Out there: the government's secret quest for extraterrestrials". Simon and Schuster.