Lower Manhattan Security Initiative

History

When the New York City Police Department launched the initiative in 2008, it aimed to install over 3,000 new security cameras in Lower Manhattan, as well as 100 automatic number plate recognition devices which are intended to scan plates and compare the numbers with information in a database. According to police spokesman Paul J. Browne, the footage from the cameras would be monitored from a center staffed by police officers and private employees. The activities the cameras are programmed to pick up on include the delivery of packages. For privately owned cameras, Scientific American reported in 2011 that the NYPD depends on private CCTV camera operators to manually control their cameras to point at significant elements in their environment, and the NYPD would cut into those dynamic feeds as needed. Other features of the system include mobile roadblocks, which could swivel into the streets and block traffic, and radiation detectors.

Upon its initial proposal in 2007, the estimated cost of the LMSI was around $US 90 million (excluding the cost of radiation detectors), with the Department of Homeland Security paying for 10 million of this, and the city government covering 15 million.

In 2009 an extension to Midtown was announced, supported with $24 million from DHS. As of 2010, the Midtown Manhattan Security Initiative (MMSI) used 689 surveillance cameras between 30th and 60th Streets. As of 2010, the LMSI and MMSI combined used 1,159 cameras.

The program was further extended in cooperation with Microsoft and is fully active as of 2012. It is known as the Domain Awareness System.

As of August 2014, the LMSCC uses feeds from 6,500 cameras owned by NYPD and private stakeholders, and reads approximately 2 million license plates per day. Whereas most cities' cameras aren't networked and require an individual to retrieve the footage, NYPD's cameras are viewed in real time by officers located at the LMSCC.

Criticism

The plan has been compared to the ring of steel around the City of London, the financial district at the center of Greater London. The City of London had 649 city-government-operated cameras in 2011.

In October 2007, the New York Civil Liberties Union served the NYPD with a FOIA request for all documents related to the planned surveillance system. After multiple requests, the NYPD responded with only 91 pages of documents, prompting the NYCLU to sue the NYPD in State Supreme Court in September 2008.

Gothamist reporter Jake Dobkin expressed concern over the IT security of the LMSI in a critical editorial, noting that the Wi-Fi password for the facility was "P@ssword1".

References

References

1. "Counterterrorism - NYPD".
2. Buckley, Cara. (2007-07-09). "New York Plans Surveillance Veil for Downtown". [[The New York Times]].
3. Hogarty, Dave. (2007-09-07). "Downtown Surveillance Network Proceeds". Gothamist LLC.
4. "NYPD - Press Release".
5. (2009-10-04). "Mayor Bloomberg And Police Commissioner Kelly Announce $24 Million In Homeland Security Funding For Expansion Of Lower Manhattan Security Initiative To Midtown".
6. Greenemeier, Larry. (September 11, 2011). "The Apple of Its Eye: Security and Surveillance Pervades Post-9/11 New York City". Scientific American.
7. (16 September 2011}}{{cbignore}}{{Dead Youtube links). "New York City's Hidden Surveillance Network Part 1- by Scientific American". Scientific American.
8. Eisenberg, Carol. (2007-09-07). "New NYC cameras will watch every move in Financial District". Newsday Inc.
9. (2007-01-25). "Mayor Bloomberg Presents $57.1 Billion FY 2008 Preliminary Budget". The City of New York.
10. ""Ring of Steel" coming to Midtown". WNYC News.
11. "NYPD Press Release - Midtown Manhattan Security Initiative".
12. (2014-12-01). "Analytics in Action at the New York City Police Department's Counterterrorism Bureau". Military Operations Research.
13. (February 2012). "The Price of Privacy: How local authorities spent £515m on CCTV in four years". Big Brother Watch.
14. (2008-09-17). "NYCLU v. New York City Police Department (Seeking access to information on Lower Manhattan Security Initiative under FOIL)".
15. "British Clown Makes Appearance At NYPD Security Theatre".