List of Major League Baseball replacement players

1994–95 Major League Baseball strike

The following Major League Baseball (MLB) players appeared as strikebreakers during spring training in 1995, crossing picket lines during the 1994–95 MLB strike. Some had not yet been placed on a 40-man roster, and as such were not eligible to join the MLB Players Association (MLBPA) at the time of the strike, while others were former MLB players who had retired before the strike. The list does not include replacement players who never appeared in a regular season MLB game.

Several players who were part of World Series-winning teams were not permitted to have their names or likenesses on commemorative merchandise because they participated in 1995 spring training: Shane Spencer of the 1998–2000 New York Yankees, Damian Miller of the 2001 Arizona Diamondbacks, Brendan Donnelly of the 2002 Anaheim Angels, and Brian Daubach and Kevin Millar of the 2004 Boston Red Sox.

Because they are not permitted to join the MLBPA, replacement players' names or likenesses are also generally not included in merchandise that derives its license from the MLBPA, such as video and tabletop games. Many games include these players' statistics and characteristics, with blank or fictional names and different appearances. This practice is similar to how Jon Dowd replaced Barry Bonds in MVP Baseball 2005 after Bonds left the MLBPA in 2003.

One player, Billy McMillon, was allowed to join the MLBPA after playing in a replacement game. The union determined that the Florida Marlins fraudulently told McMillon that a game he would play in was not a replacement game when, in fact, it was.

Replacement players

No MLB experience before strike

• Joel Adamson
• Benny Agbayani
• Rudy Árias
• Tony Barron
• Steve Bourgeois
• Doug Brady
• Mike Busch
• Edgar Caceres
• Bubba Carpenter
• Joel Chimelis
• Alan Cockrell
• Joe Crawford
• Brian Daubach
• Brendan Donnelly
• Angel Echevarria
• Webster Garrison
• Charles Gipson
• Brian Givens
• Scarborough Green
• Dave Hajek
• Jason Hardtke
• Pep Harris
• Matt Herges
• Matt Howard
• Chris Latham
• Cory Lidle
• Kerry Ligtenberg
• Rich Loiselle
• Eric Ludwick
• Ron Mahay
• Tom Martin
• Dan Masteller
• Jamie McAndrew
• Walt McKeel
• Frank Menechino
• Lou Merloni
• Kevin Millar
• Damian Miller
• Eddie Oropesa
• Keith Osik
• Bronswell Patrick
• Dale Polley
• Alex Ramírez
• Ron Rightnowar
• Dan Rohrmeier
• Mandy Romero
• Pete Rose Jr.
• Chuck Smith
• Shane Spencer
• Joe Strong
• Pedro Swann
• Jeff Tam
• Chris Truby
• Jamie Walker Chimelis was briefly called up by the San Francisco Giants in June 1995, but never appeared in an MLB game, making him a phantom ballplayer.

Had MLB experience before strike

• Shawn Abner
• Jay Aldrich
• Jose Alvarez
• Scott Anderson
• Bob Ayrault
• Mark Bailey
• Billy Bates
• Blaine Beatty
• Kevin Belcher
• Mike Bell
• Terry Blocker
• Danny Boone
• Pedro Borbón
• Oil Can Boyd
• Marty Bystrom
• Nick Capra
• Darrin Chapin
• Mike Christopher
• Marty Clary
• Stu Cole
• Doug Corbett
• Henry Cotto
• Todd Cruz
• Luis DeLeón
• Tom Dunbar
• Gary Eave
• Frank Eufemia
• Steve Fireovid
• Curt Ford
• Alan Fowlkes
• Mike Fuentes
• Jay Gainer
• Jeff Grotewold
• Bert Heffernan
• Willie Hernández
• Kevin Hickey
• Keith Hughes
• James Hurst
• Mark Huismann
• Stan Jefferson
• Shawn Jeter
• Ed Jurak
• Steve Kiefer
• Garland Kiser
• Brent Knackert
• Brad Komminsk
• Randy Kramer
• Randy Kutcher
• Rick Lancellotti
• Ced Landrum
• Terry Lee
• Bill Lindsey
• Mitch Lyden
• Rick Lysander
• Lonnie Maclin
• Ever Magallanes
• Rob Mallicoat
• Paul Marak
• Greg Mathews
• Randy McCament
• Craig McMurtry
• José Mota
• Rob Nelson
• Ken Oberkfell
• Junior Ortiz
• Jim Paciorek
• Dave Pavlas
• Pat Perry
• Marty Pevey
• Gus Polidor
• Lenny Randle
• Rick Reed
• Nikco Riesgo
• Pat Rice
• George Riley
• Dave Rohde
• Wayne Rosenthal
• Rich Sauveur
• Jeff Schulz
• Nelson Simmons
• Doug Sisk
• Joe Slusarski
• Daryl Smith
• Greg Smith
• Ray Soff
• Matt Stark
• Bob Stoddard
• Phil Stephenson
• Glenn Sutko
• Lou Thornton
• Shane Turner
• Héctor Villanueva
• Dave Von Ohlen
• Dana Williams
• Mike Warren
• Robbie Wine
• Herm Winningham
• Matt Winters
• Eric Yelding

1912 Detroit Tigers strike

Main article: Detroit Tigers replacement players (May 18, 1912)

On May 15, 1912, Detroit Tigers star Ty Cobb went into the stands and assaulted a fan who had been heckling him. American League president Ban Johnson suspended Cobb, but other Tigers refused to play unless Cobb was reinstated. Johnson threatened Tigers owner Frank Navin with a stiff fine if he did not field a team. Thus, manager Hughie Jennings quickly recruited a pickup team of sandlot, semi-pro, and college baseball players.

This replacement team played one game, on May 18, after which the Tigers players relented and returned to play future games (under threat of lifetime banishment).

The following players appeared in the May 18 game, which the Tigers lost to the Philadelphia Athletics, 24–2.

• Ed Irwin
• Hughie Jennings
• Bill Leinhauser
• Billy Maharg
• Vincent Maney
• Jim McGarr
• Dan McGarvey
• Deacon McGuire
• Jack Smith
• Joe Sugden
• Allan Travers
• Hap Ward

Sugden and McGuire were Tigers coaches who had had long baseball careers. This game was their last major league appearance. Jennings was the Tigers manager; he also had had a long career and was later elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame. He appeared as pinch hitter in the ninth inning.

None of the other players ever appeared in another major league game before or after, except Maharg, who appeared in one other game as a courtesy in the last game of the 1916 season. He was later deeply involved in the Black Sox Scandal. Smith played two innings in the field but had no plate appearances and consequently no batting average. Irwin was the only recruit to have a hit; the Tigers coaches also each had one hit. Irwin had two triples, and so retired with a batting average of .667 and slugging percentage of 2.000. Travers's 24 runs allowed is still the American League record for a complete game.

Arthur "Bugs" Baer, who later went on to become a journalist and humorist, was a member of the Tigers, recruited as a backup bench player. He did not appear in the game.

References

References

1. Baer, Bill. (2019-08-12). "Players who crossed picket line in 1995".
2. Gutierrez, Paul. (2006-08-12). "The Replacements". [[The Sacramento Bee]].
3. Monagan, Matt. (November 20, 2020). "The video game creator who became Barry Bonds".
4. "Replacement Players".
5. Kurkjian, Tim. (August 29, 2002). "The Replacements".
6. (May 23, 2000). "Five years later, replacements still feel the heat". The Holland Sentinel.
7. (February 19, 1995). "Catchers' Agendas Differ". [[Miami Herald]].
8. Ferrell, Scott. (July 31, 1995). "One Giant puzzle". The Shreveport Times.
9. Blum, Ronald. (December 16, 1995). "Union snubs replacements". Bay City Times.
10. (July 17, 1995). "'Bad Karma' Vetoes Move -- Padres Won't Recall Replacement Player". Seattle Times.
11. Curry, Jack. (2 April 1995). "BASEBALL; Living on a Yankee Tightrope". The New York Times.
12. Etkin, Jack. (1995-04-10). "What happens when big leaguers, replacements cross paths?". Waterloo Courier.
13. (2003-06-22). "Donnelly could be snubbed". The Arizona Republic.
14. Finnigan, Bob. (July 30, 1995). "M's Have Lots Of Company Seeking Starting Pitching". [[Seattle Times]].
15. Dierker, Larry. (1995-09-19). "Fight, flight show 'team' in Astros". The Houston Chronicle.
16. (1998-09-23). "Extra effort". CNNSI.com.
17. Johnson, Chuck. (September 21, 1995). "Replacements resented: Presence angers players, but GMs won't budge". [[USA Today]].
18. Megargee, Steve. (1995-03-29). "Dodgers prove to be best of replacements". Indian River Press Journal.
19. Chass, Murray. (November 17, 1996). "Spoils to the Victors, Grudgingly". [[The New York Times]].
20. Hoynes, Paul. (1995-03-30). "Tigers drop Diaz but adds power hitter and pitcher". Cleveland Plain Dealer.
21. Zolecki, Todd. (2006-08-13). "On baseball: There aren't many strikes against 1995 scabs". [[The Philadelphia Inquirer]].
22. Chass, Murray. (May 25, 1995). "ON BASEBALL; Credibility Test for Players' Union". [[The New York Times]].
23. Gloster, Rob. (April 3, 1995). "Thanks: Marlins pay $25,000; Reds offer $19 for gas". Muncie Evening Press.
24. Bradley, John Ed. (August 11, 1997). "Honor thy father: Pete Rose Jr. has struggled through nine years in the minor leagues, driven partly by a dream of drawing closer to his distant father".
25. (1995-04-02). "Alvarez believes Braves need him". The Macon Telegraph.
26. Zack, Bill. (1995-03-19). "Green pitchers face seasoned hitters". Ledger-Enquirer.
27. (July 31, 1995). "Bagwell Breaks Hand Again, Probably Will Miss 3-4 Weeks". Seattle Times.
28. Shea, John. (June 8, 2003). "Royal contract clause for Sweeney". [[The San Francisco Chronicle]].
29. Haudricourt, Tom. (February 27, 1995). "Brewers Bring back Bates for Spring Training". [[Milwaukee Journal Sentinel]].
30. Stapleton, Arnie. (April 3, 1995). "Owners discard replacements". The Paducah Sun.
31. Horrigan, Jeff. (1995-03-31). "Johnson suddenly likes revamped 'fun little team'". The Cincinnati Post.
32. (March 8, 1995). "Astros 7, Mets 4". [[The News-Press]].
33. Odum, Charles. (April 1, 1995). "Braves fans have mixed feelings". Clarion-Ledger.
34. Larwin, Tom. "Danny Boone".
35. Chass, Murray. (April 18, 1995). "Union Lists Those Who Did Not Back Strike". [[New York Times]].
36. Beaton, Rod. (1995-03-13). "Following the balancing ball". [[USA Today]].
37. "Pedro Borbon: In Memoriam".
38. Rhoden, William C.. (July 8, 1999). "Sports of The Times; Oil Can Boyd at Peace With His Own Team". [[New York Times]].
39. Madden, Bill. (March 6, 1995). "Blame Game, Not Bystrom".
40. Grant, Evan. (1995-03-07). "Decision weighs heavy on Capra". Florida Today.
41. Grant, Evan. (1995-05-03). "Lewis aims to end minors nightmare". USA Today.
42. Hoynes, Paul. (1995-04-02). "No strikes, replacements are out". [[Cleveland Plain Dealer]].
43. Roberts, Jeannie. (July 6, 1995). "Pitcher has paid his dues". The Muskegon Chronicle.
44. (1995-03-31). "National League Team Capsules". [[USA Today]].
45. Sullivan, Paul. (1995-04-02). "Sox outfielder Cotto hoping decision to play pays off".
46. Bonfatti, John F.. (1995-02-28). "Pain fails to deter Todd Cruz". Pottsville Republican.
47. Reaves, Joseph A.. (March 4, 1995). "Cubs Opener: No Pickets, No Protests".
48. Parker, Rob. (March 9, 1995). "Dunbar plays; new dream is to coach". [[Detroit Free Press]].
49. Horst, Craig. (February 26, 1995). "KC replacement liking special treatment". The Salina Journal.
50. Rieper, Max. (2015-02-26). "The Royals replacement players of 1995". [[SB Nation]].
51. Wyche, Steve. (1995-03-02). "Yankees open with uncertainty, replacements". [[The Miami Herald]].
52. Hertzel, Bob. (March 2, 1995). "Eufemia Playing For Purest Motives". [[The Record (Bergen County)]].
53. Niedzielka, Amy. (1995-02-19). "Reluctant replacement". [[The Miami Herald]].
54. Niedzielka, Amy. (1995-03-24). "Ford's stroke of irony". The Miami Herald.
55. Knobler, Danny. (March 4, 1995). "Baseball's back but barely". [[The Muskegon Chronicle]].
56. Gehring, Chris. (October 28, 2021). "20 years after the strike, replacement player remembers it wasn't just about baseball".
57. Scanlan, Wayne. (1995-09-13). "'Coach' gets one more kick at the can, and makes it a beauty". The Ottawa Citizen.
58. (March 7, 1995). "Hernandez joins Yankees". Argus-Leader.
59. Nightengale, Bob. (1995-03-17). "Baseball : Hernandez Now Most Recognized Replacement".
60. Frey, Jennifer. (1995-02-18). "BASEBALL; Met Camp Attractive To Players In Need". The New York Times.
61. (April 6, 1995). "Meet the 1995 Omaha Royals". Omaha World Herald.
62. Mandelaro, Jim. (August 28, 1995). "Hurst snafu costs Orioles $24,000". Democrat and Chronicle.
63. Kaegel, Dick. (1995-03-26). "Royals pitcher a blast from past". The Kansas City Star.
64. Guest, Larry. (March 26, 1995). "Mauch: replacements part of healing process". [[Orlando Sentinel]].
65. Lang, Evan. (January 13, 2022). "The replacement Rockies that could have been". [[SB Nation]].
66. (1995-03-06). "Yankee replacement bitter at union". The Tennessean.
67. (1995-04-01). "Take me out to the ballgame". [[The Daily Sentinel (Grand Junction, Colorado).
68. Fraley, Gerald. (1995-02-26). "Strange lineups form from replacement players". Corpus Christi Caller-Times.
69. Lee, Victor. (March 12, 1995). "Ex-Marlin Lyden gets a Royal opportunity". [[Palm Beach Post]].
70. Rock, Steve. (2001-03-31). "Who were these guys?". [[Kansas City Star]].
71. Reaves, Joseph A.. (1995-03-26). "Instead Of Solidifying Family Ties, Baseball Pulling Them Apart".
72. Street, Jim. (1995-03-30). "Replacement players' pay may take a hit". The Indianapolis Star.
73. (May 4, 1997). "Walker won't let decision stop him". [[Topeka Capitol-Journal]].
74. (1995-04-02). "The heart of the replacement teams". [[The Akron Beacon Journal]].
75. Newhan, Ross. (February 16, 1995). "Strike Throws Curve Into Start of Spring Training".
76. LaRue, Larry. (1995-03-29). "Replacement players believe the end is near". [[The News Tribune]].
77. LaRue, Larry. (1995-03-30). "Piniella's optimism replaced by confusion". The News Tribune.
78. (1995-04-29). "Former Marlin killed". [[Gainesville Sun]].
79. (2010). "Strike Three! - A Player's Journey Through the Infamous Baseball Strike Of 1994". Strike Three.
80. Morales, Javier. (April 6, 1995). "Toros opening season with seasoned roster". Arizona Daily Star.
81. Kram, Mike. (1998-07-02). "He's (still) available". Philadelphia Daily News.
82. (August 23, 1995). "Slusarksi returns to majors". [[Cleveland Plain Dealer]].
83. Olney, Buster. (August 27, 1995). "2nd former replacement makes exit". [[Baltimore Sun]].
84. Robinson, Tom. (April 5, 1995). "The Tides Have Talent". [[The Virginian-Pilot]].
85. Beaton, Rod. (March 30, 1995). "Big-time agents feel pinch of strike in pocketbooks". [[USA Today]].
86. Rutter, Joe. (March 6, 2005). "Major replacements". [[The Pittsburgh Tribune-Review]].
87. (1995-03-28). "Former coach's mad dash lifts Milwaukee". The Capital Times.
88. (1995-04-02). "Preview of replacement teams". The Daily Oklahoman.
89. (1995-04-02). "Game's cancelled; Marlins replacements figure they're next". News-Press.
90. Harrington, Mike. (June 24, 1995). "Bison have bounced back nicely from rocky start". [[The Buffalo News]].
91. Holtzman, Jerome. (January 24, 1995). "Replacement team in Cobb's day lacked something: quality".
92. Livacari, Gary. "Allan Travers".
93. Godfrey, Andrew. (September 3, 2009). "1912 Tigers Pickup Team Loses 24-2".
94. Forrester, Wade. (May 18, 2014). "May 18, 1912: Replacement Players Take The Field For The Striking Tigers".
95. "Hughie Jennings Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Rookie Status & More".
96. Lamb, Bill. "Billy Maharg".
97. "Detroit Tigers vs Philadelphia Athletics Box Score: May 18, 1912".
98. "Bill Irwin Stats, Height, Weight, Position, Rookie Status & More".
99. "Most Runs Allowed In A Complete Game".
100. "Most runs allowed by starting pitcher in single game".