Liquid Swords

Background and recording

Following the success of two earlier Wu-Tang Clan solo albums – Method Man's Tical and Ol' Dirty Bastard's Return to the 36 Chambers: The Dirty Version, Wu-Tang member Raekwon began recording his acclaimed debut Only Built 4 Cuban Linx... in early 1995. While he and producer RZA were putting the final touches on that album, RZA and GZA began writing and recording what would eventually become Liquid Swords. In regards to their decision to begin the album at the time they did, GZA later commented, "We (Wu-Tang) were on a roll, and it was the perfect time to get in the studio and just do it."

"I'm on a different level, trying to be cinematic," he remarked. "Like that shit in 'Killah Hill' where the kid gets his leg cut to hide the dope – that shit really happened, but I'm trying to make it more visual. Liquid Swords is a concept of being lyrically sharp, flowing like liquid metal – mercury, y'know? It comes from this flick, Legend of the Liquid Sword, where people would get their head cut off but it would still be on their shoulders. No one else would notice, because the sword was so sharp. Wu-Tang is a sword style, and this here is the sharpest. I'd rather slip on the pavement than slip on my tongue."

Similar to other early solo Wu-Tang albums, Liquid Swords was recorded in RZA's basement studio in Staten Island, with some beats playing for over two days straight while recording. When asked in a later interview about his opinion of the album's beats, GZA remarked "I loved them. A lot of them had a grimy, rock-like feel to them. I just remember absolutely loving them." In the same interview, GZA described the writing process as "real slow." He further commented "I don’t say slow in the sense that it necessarily took me a long time to finish what I’m writing. I mean, Raekwon and Ghostface can step in and record a song in about forty-five minutes. I on the other hand, would often go back and finish rhymes that I started. I would say I pieced things together more slowly then. Songs generally take me two to three days to write. Sometimes I take different sentences and put them together."

Regarding the overall sensation of writing Liquid Swords, GZA stated "It's hard to say something is gonna be classic or not. But I can say that I felt the magic with this one. I actually saw it grow and come together, and felt that it was special as we were doing it." He later noted in an interview with The Seattle Times: "It has great songs, it's not an ignorant album, it doesn't sound dated. If you listen to it and compare it to what's out now, it's timeless. Lyrically, it's not my best work. Not at all. But the chemistry? Production? Overall, I mean, c'mon! RZA's atmospheric production? Yes. It's my best album."

Promotion

The album's cover was designed by Milestone Media Founder/Creative Director and chief artist Denys Cowan, according to the album's liner notes. GZA's personal manager Geoffrey L. Garfield, commissioned Cowan. Garfield, an avid comic book fan, said the cover art was supervised under the auspices of GZA GrafX, a subsidiary company of GZA Entertainment owned by GZA and Garfield. The concept of the chessboard with its sword-wielding warriors was conceived by GZA, an avid chess player. The GZA version of the Wu-Tang Clan logo, the "G" using the logo iconography, was rendered by Wu-Tang Clan DJ Mathematics who was also an accomplished graphic artist.

GZA also enjoyed a successful side career as a music video director, and with Garfield as writer and producer, created all four videos for the Liquid Swords album ("Liquid Swords", "Cold World", "Shadowboxin'/4th Chamber", and "I Gotcha Back"), and also did videos for Sunz of Man, Ghostface Killah's song ("Motherless Child") on the Sunset Park film soundtrack, Shabazz the Disciple (Penalty Records) and Case (Def Jam). The Source recognized their video "Shadowboxin'/4th Chamber" as one of the Top Five Videos of 1995.

Liquid Swords was performed in its entirety on July 13, 2007, at the Pitchfork Music Festival and again in England, on December 9 at All Tomorrow's Parties and on December 10 at KOKO in London, as part of the ATP-curated Don't Look Back series. After the cancellation of an appearance in Brooklyn, New York, the performance was rescheduled for December 13 and 14 at the Knitting Factory in New York.

Singles

Four total singles were released for Liquid Swords. The first of which was "I Gotcha' Back", released August 22, 1994. Similar to Raekwon's single "Heaven & Hell," the song first appeared on the soundtrack for the movie Fresh, and was the first song written for the album, with its version being re-recorded in 1995. Describing the song's background and theme, GZA later stated "This was a short rhyme I wrote for one of my nephews. When I said, 'My lifestyle so far from well, could've wrote a book called Age Twelve and Going Through Hell.' It's for my nephew who was twelve at the time, and whose father, my brother, had been locked up since '88. So he wasn't around for my nephew when times were rough, so I wanted to up my nephew a bit with this track. I had two nephews in the video, they were both real young at the time. And in video, they both had met up and shots rang out from some young gangsters. It's a shame because both those kids in the video, both nephews of mine, ended up getting in trouble for ringing out shots and are both doing time right now. It's kind of ironic. One of my nephews ended up getting eights years for that shit. So the whole song is a sad irony to me now."

The second single released for the album, was the title track "Liquid Swords", released over one year later on October 10, 1995. GZA later commented "Usually I take a beat home and write to it for a few days, but it wasn’t like that with this track. I think RZA played the beat for me and I just spit to it right there. The hook was actually a routine from around ‘84 that me RZA and Ol' Dirty would do: 'When the emcees came, to live out the name.' Just like that."

November 28, 1995 saw the release of the album's third single "Cold World". In regards to his writing approach to the song, GZA stated "Normally, when I hear a beat, I already know where to go with it. I can picture the track and just vibe off it. As soon as I heard the beat to “Cold World,” I knew it would be another inner-city story."

The fourth and final single released for the album was "Shadowboxin'", released early 1996, with "4th Chamber" as its B-Side. In an interview with Wax Poetics, GZA praised Method Man's rapping on "Shadowboxin'", saying that the song "seemed more like Meth's track". GZA stated "Making '4th Chamber' was crazy because I didn’t have a rhyme ready for that one. That’s why I went last on it. Plus, Ghost killed it with his verse so I knew I had to come correct. It’s not even a GZA song to me—it’s a Wu-Tang song. And Ghost’s verse is just incredible to me. He delivered so well. I don’t know if you saw the video, I directed that too. This song, the guest verses, the video, the crowd response, all turned out perfect for this one."

Critical reception

Upon its release, Liquid Swords received critical acclaim. Selwyn Seyfu Hinds from The Source called GZA "a highly focused master-graftsman" and felt that "throughout Liquid Swords he maintains a clear, precise flow, one that reflects deadly-sharp purpose and skilled execution." Hinds also praised RZA's production on the album, noting his "increasingly sophisticated style: shuffling kicks, neck snapping snares, haunting melodies via strings or vibe-like textures and penetrating bass tones." In his review for Entertainment Weekly, Dimitri Ehrlich said that, "With its tight beat, Liquid Swords emphasizes the finesse with which GZA weaves his vocals over straightforward rhythms." Los Angeles Times critic Cheo H. Coker described GZA as "a hip-hop M. C. Escher" whose lyrics "reveal layer after layer of thought with repeated listening", concluding that the album cements the Wu-Tang Clan as "the kings of New York rap."

NME hailed Liquid Swords as "the best hip-hop album" in years, citing RZA's "spooked, creaky, incredibly dense" production and GZA's complex and "quite brilliant" lyrics. Mojo magazine characterized the album as "creepily beautiful" and "East Coast hip hop with a far more warped and disturbing slant on inner-city sickness than the in-your-face Californian equivalent". In Select, Matt Hall wrote that RZA "provides a series of austere rhythms, sparsely dotting violin stabs and plucked harps to provide the perfect backdrop to Genius' downbeat tales of New York's mean streets… Liquid Swords sneaks under the tape to qualify as Rap Album Of The Year." Tom Doyle of Q wrote that GZA can seem "perhaps unreasonably hardcore in some of his approaches...[but] when his rhyming is enhanced by the dislocated soul chorus of 'Cold World', the result is dramatic and hypnotic."

Robert Christgau was somewhat less enthusiastic, giving the album a two-star honorable mention, which indicated a "likable effort that consumers attuned to its overriding aesthetic or individual vision may well enjoy". In his column for The Village Voice, Christgau cited "Shadowboxin'" and "Killah Hills 10304" as highlights and called the record "gangsta [rap] as mystery, religious and literary".

Retrospect

Liquid Swords continues to be held in high regard as one of the best releases in the Wu-Tang Clan's catalog and among the greatest hip hop albums of all time. According to AllMusic critic Steve Huey, it is "often acclaimed as the best Wu-Tang solo project of all" and "cemented the Genius/GZA's reputation as the best pure lyricist in the group—and one of the best of the '90s". Huey likewise viewed it as a significant progression for RZA as a producer, noting his experiments "with stranger sounds and more layered tracks", while evaluating Liquid Swords as "one of the group's undisputed classics", along with Enter the Wu-Tang (36 Chambers) (1993) and Raekwon's Only Built 4 Cuban Linx... (1995). Reviewing Liquid Swords for RapReviews "Back to the Lab" series, writer Steve Juon called it "an album of 100% Wu-Tang sonic mastery", adding that among Wu-Tang Clan solo albums, "it may the best—if not one of the top two or three." Nick Catucci, writing in The New Rolling Stone Album Guide (2004), said that, on the album, GZA "went goth, painting the Wu's street grime black." Record Collectors Paul Bowler stated that Liquid Swords represented an artistic peak for the Wu-Tang Clan as a whole, noting what he found to be their subsequent creative decline from Wu-Tang Forever (1997) onward. Chris Smith from Stylus Magazine wrote that the group "never yet managed to make anything this memorable, otherworldly, and strangely beautiful again."

On October 8, 2015, the Recording Industry Association of America announced that Liquid Swords had earned a platinum certification for having sold more than 1 million copies. It became the first Wu-Tang-related album to get certified since 2004, when Method Man and Ghostface Killah both earned plaques.

Track listing

Track listing information is taken from the official liner notes and AllMusic. All tracks produced by RZA, except track 13 produced by 4th Disciple.

Notes

• "Duel of the Iron Mic" erroneously lists Dreddy Kruger as featured artist.
• "Hell's Wind Staff" erroneously lists Dreddy Kruger, Killah Priest, and Masta Killa as featured artists.
• "Swordsman" erroneously lists Killah Priest as featured artist.

Sample credits

• "Liquid Swords" contains samples from "Groovin'" and "Mercy, Mercy, Mercy" by Willie Mitchell, and "Legend of Lone Wolf" by W. Michael Lewis & Mark Lewis from the movie Shogun Assassin.
• "Duel of the Iron Mic" contains a sample from "I'm Afraid the Masquerade Is Over" by David Porter, and dialogue excerpts from the films Shogun Assassin and Dragon on Fire.
• "Living in the World Today" contains samples from "I'm His Wife, You're Just a Friend" by Ann Sexton and "In The Hole" by The Bar-Kays.
• "Gold" contains a sample from "The Aries" by Cannonball Adderley.
• "Cold World" contains samples from "In The Rain" by The Dramatics and "Plastic People" by The Mothers of Invention, interpolations from "Rocket Love" by Stevie Wonder and "Love Me In A Special Way" by DeBarge, and dialogue excerpts from the film Shogun Assassin.
• "Labels" contains a sample from "Don't Leave Me This Way" by Thelma Houston.
• "4th Chamber" contains a dialogue excerpt from the film Shogun Assassin, and samples from "Assassin With Son" by W. Michael Lewis & Mark Lewis from the movie Shogun Assassin, "Groovin'" by Willie Mitchell and "Dharmatma Theme Music (Sad)" by Kalyanji Anandji.
• "Shadowboxin'" contains a dialogue excerpt from the film Shaolin vs Lama, and a sample from "Trouble, Heartaches & Sadness" by Ann Peebles.
• "Hell's Wind Staff" contains an interpolation of "Lost in Love" by New Edition and "Killah Hills 10304" contains a sample from "Soul Vibrations" by Dorothy Ashby.
• "Investigative Reports" contains a sample from "I'd Be So Happy" by Three Dog Night.
• "I Gotcha Back" contains a dialogue excerpt from the film Shogun Assassin and samples from "As Long as I've Got You" by The Charmels and "Is It Him or Me" by Jackie Jackson.
• "B.I.B.L.E. (Basic Instructions Before Leaving Earth)" contains a sample from "Our Love Has Died" by the Ohio Players.

Personnel

• GZA – performer
• RZA – producer, performer
• Killah Priest – performer
• Inspectah Deck – performer
• Ghostface Killah – performer
• Method Man – performer
• Masta Killa – performer
• Raekwon – performer
• U-God – performer
• Ol' Dirty Bastard – performer
• Dreddy Kruger – vocals
• Life – vocals
• 4th Disciple – producer
• Tom Coyne – mastering
• Wendy Goldstein – A&R
• Geoffrey L. Garfield – personal management
• Cyril Gittens – art direction
• Mathematics – art concepts
• Mark A. Humphrey – photography
• Denys Cowan – cover art

Charts

Weekly charts

Year-end charts

Certifications

Accolades

• (*) signifies unordered lists

References

Bibliography

References

1. link. (2015-10-17 . riaa.org. Retrieved 2010-07-31.)
2. link. (October 21, 2012 ": ''[[Chicago Tribune]]'': 4. June 20, 1999.)
3. link. (July 13, 2011 . ''[[XXL (magazine)). XXL]]''. Retrieved 2010-07-31.
4. Ma, David. [http://www.waxpoetics.com/2008/11/the-making-of-liquid-swords/ The Making Of Liquid Swords (page 1)]. ''[[Wax Poetics]]''. Retrieved 2010-07-31. {{webarchive. link. (April 28, 2010)
5. ''[[Select (magazine). Select]]'', January 1996
6. Matson, Andrew. (August 22, 2008). "Rapper GZA Riffs on the Thinking Man's Rap Masterpiece". [[The Seattle Times]].
7. Juon, Steve 'Flash'. (March 19, 2002). "Genius/GZA Liquid Swords".
8. Ling, Tony. (August 4, 2008). "Treble : Album Review : Genius/GZA – Liquid Swords".
9. Cowan's black and white line art was inked by Inker Prentis Rollins. Milestone's Color Editor, Jason Scott Jones created the cover color art digitally at a time when digital coloring was emerging in comic art eventually becoming the standard.Milestone Media Color Editor Jason Scott Jones
10. RZA, The, 2005. P:63
11. Ma, David. [http://www.waxpoetics.com/2008/11/the-making-of-liquid-swords/2/ The Making Of Liquid Swords (page 2)]. ''[[Wax Poetics]]''. Retrieved 2010-07-31. {{webarchive. link. (April 30, 2010)
12. (2016-05-20). "Wu-Tang Clan's GZA runs down every track off Liquid Swords - Wax Poetics".
13. "Liquid Swords [The Chess Box] by Genius / GZA Reviews and Tracks".
14. Huey, Steve. "''Liquid Swords'' – GZA".
15. Ehrlich, Dimitri. (November 24, 1995). "''Liquid Swords''".
16. Wazir, Burhan. (November 24, 1995). "GZA/Genius: ''Liquid Swords'' (Geffen)". [[The Guardian]].
17. Coker, Cheo H.. (December 2, 1995). "The Genius, 'The Genius,' Geffen.". [[Los Angeles Times]].
18. (November 11, 1995). "GZA: ''Liquid Swords''".
19. Cohen, Ian. (July 27, 2012). "GZA: ''Liquid Swords'': Chess Box Deluxe Edition". [[Pitchfork (website).
20. Doyle, Tom. (February 1996). "GZA: ''Liquid Swords''".
21. Bowler, Paul. (September 2012). "Genius/GZA – ''Liquid Swords: The Chess Box''".
22. Fernando, S. H. Jr.. (November 30, 1995). "GZA/Genius: ''Liquid Swords''".
23. Hinds, Selwyn Seyfu. (December 1995). "Genius: ''Liquid Swords''".
24. (January 1996). "GZA: ''Liquid Swords''".
25. Christgau, Robert. (2000). "Christgau's Consumer Guide: Albums of the '90s". [[St. Martin's Griffin]].
26. Christgau, Robert. (January 23, 1996). "Consumer Guide". [[The Village Voice]].
27. Ekpo, Ime. (July 23, 2018). "GZA Explores 'Liquid Science' in New Netflix Show". [[The Source (magazine).
28. Catucci, Nick. (2004). "The New Rolling Stone Album Guide". [[Simon & Schuster]].
29. Smith, Chris. (September 1, 2003). "GZA – ''Liquid Swords'' – On Second Thought".
30. "GZA Gives Wu-Tang Clan First Platinum Album In More Than A Decade (Oct 8, 2015, Forbes Magazine)".
31. (1995). "Liquid Swords". Geffen Records.
32. "Liquid Swords - GZA".
33. "GZA, TLP".
34. "GZA, BLP".
35. "Top Billboard 200 Albums – Year-End 1996".
36. "Top R&B/Hip-Hop Albums – Year-End 1996".
37. Adaso, Henry. [http://rap.about.com/od/toppicks/ss/Top100RapAlbums_4.htm About.com's 100 Greatest Hip-Hop Albums] {{Webarchive. link. (April 5, 2015 . [[About.com]]. Retrieved 2010-05-04.)
38. Adaso, Henry. [http://rap.about.com/od/top10albums/ss/90sBestRapMusic_6.htm About.com's Best Rap Albums of 1995] {{Webarchive. link. (July 12, 2014 . About.com. Retrieved 2010-05-04.)
39. (1999). "Ego Trip's Book of Rap Lists". [[St. Martin's Press]].
40. (November 21, 2007). "1000 Albums to Hear Before You Die".
41. . (March 2006). "Top Albums 1995–2005".
42. . (December 23–30, 1995). "Albums of the Year". *[[IPC Media]]*.
43. . (December 23–30, 1995). ["Smashing Bumpkin! NME Writers' Top 50 LPs"](https://www.nme.com/features/1995-2-1045368). *[[IPC Media]]*.
44. Paste Staff. (June 3, 2024). "The 300 Greatest Albums of All Time".
45. (November 17, 2003). "Top 100 Albums of the 1990s".
46. (23 March 2010). "1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die: Revised and Updated Edition". Universe.
47. (December 15, 2005). "The Chris Rock 25".
48. (September 22, 2020). "The 500 Greatest Albums of All Time – Rolling Stone".
49. . (January 1996). "1995: Top 50 Albums of the Year".
50. . (January 1998). "100 Best Albums: The Top Hip-Hop LP's of All Time".
51. (March 22, 2004). "Top 101-200 Favourite Albums Ever".
52. (1995). "Liquid Swords". Geffen.