Life of the Virgin (Maximus)

Authenticity

It is doubted that this work is by Maximus the Confessor. :"In a series of recent articles Stephen Shoemaker (esp. Shoemaker 2012), following Michel van Esbroeck, has argued in favour of Maximus' authorship of the Greek model for a Georgian 'Life of the Virgin'. This is improbable for various reasons both historical and theological. In short: first, the argument depends on the notion that Maximus spent some time in Constantinople in the period c.620-26, which lacks direct attestation; second, none of Maximus' characteristic preoccupations appear in the 'Life', and in turn none of the 'Life's central themes appear in the fleeting Marian reflections contained within his genuine corpus; third, there is no extant Greek manuscript which witnesses the text, in whole or in part; fourth, both admirers of Maximus (e.g. Sophronius, John of Damascus) and those who describe his works (e.g. Photius, Anastasius Bibliothecarius) show no knowledge of the 'Life'; and fifth, there is no witness to the existence of the entire 'Life' before the second half of the tenth century. For the arguments in more detail see Booth (forthcoming)." A recent theory suggests that the Life of the Virgin was actually composed by the monk Euthymius the Athonite, who in turn made a paraphrased translation of an earlier Life written by John Geometres.

Editions

• Maximus the Confessor, The Life of the Virgin: Translated, with an Introduction and Notes, Stephen J. Shoemaker, trans. (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2012) ()
• Vie de la Vierge by Michel von Esbroeck. This edition is based on the oldest surviving manuscript, Tbilissi A-40.

Notes

References

References

1. Stephen J. Shoemaker, “Early Christian Apocryphal Literature.” In ''The Oxford handbook of early Christian studies'' by Susan Ashbrook Harvey, David G. Hunter 2008 {{ISBN. 978-0-19-927156-6 page 527
2. Stephen J. Shoemaker, “Between Scripture and Tradition: The Marian Apocrypha of Early Christianity.” In ''The reception and interpretation of the Bible in late antiquity'' by Lorenzo DiTommaso, Lucian Turcescu 2008 {{ISBN. 90-04-16715-3 page 507
3. Stephen J. Shoemaker, “The Virgin Mary in the Ministry of Jesus and the Early Church according to the Earliest Life of the Virgin.” ''Harvard Theological Review'' 98 (2005): 441-67; [http://commonwealmagazine.org/maximus%E2%80%99s-mary Maximus's Mary], by Sally Cuneen, ''Commonweal Magazine'', December 04, 2009
4. (2015). "The Oxford Handbook of Maximus the Confessor". Oxford University Press.
5. (April 2016). "The (Pseudo?-)Maximus ''Life of the Virgin'' and the Byzantine Marian Tradition". The Journal of Theological Studies.
6. Simelidis, Christos. (2020). "Two Lives of the Virgin: John Geometres, Euthymios the Athonite, and Maximos the Confessor". Dumbarton Oaks Papers.