Holding Out for a Hero

Background

Paramount Pictures asked Bonnie Tyler to record a song for the soundtrack to the 1984 film Footloose. She agreed on the condition that Jim Steinman, who was her producer at the time through CBS/Columbia, could work with her on the project. Steinman wrote the song with Dean Pitchford, who co-wrote every song on the soundtrack album. Tyler was invited to the Paramount film studios in Los Angeles to watch the film rushes to see how "Holding Out for a Hero" would fit into the plot.

"Holding Out for a Hero" shares numerous musical elements with "Stark Raving Love", a track from Steinman's solo album Bad for Good (1981), including the piano riff and vocal harmonies.

Critical reception

In a retrospective review, The A.V. Clubs William Hughes stated that the song "displays some of the worst of its decade's (and composer's) typical excesses: The lyrics are laughable, and the heavy-handed synths and piano riffs come dangerously close to cheese", but adds, "The sum of those parts transcends their limitations, hooking directly into pure emotional need like only the greatest of torch songs can."

Paul Stenning of Metal Hammer described the song as "the ultimate pop anthem", stating "Only Jim Steinman can get away with such bombastic overtones, in this case the perfect coupling with Tyler's inimitable voice." Carl Nevillie in his book, No More Heroes?: Steroids, Cocaine, Finance and Film in the 70s, called it a "typically overblown (and fabulous) piece of Wagnerian Hi-NRG," while Ryan Britt of Fatherly felt it exemplified "pure, gushy ’80s over-the-top power pop."

Music video

The accompanying music video for "Holding Out for a Hero" was produced by Jeffrey Abelson for Parallax Productions, directed by Doug Dowdle, with the concept by Keith Williams. It was filmed at the Grand Canyon, Arizona, and at Veluzat Ranch, California. It was the second video released to promote Footloose while featuring no movie footage in the video.

The video sees Tyler escaping from a burning house; the video is set primarily in the vicinity of the burning house and on the edge of the Grand Canyon – interspersed with shots of angelic background singers in white dresses. Evil cowboys dressed in black, carrying neon whips appear before Tyler, threatening her; a cowboy hero dressed in white, brandishing a revolver, appears on horseback and the evil cowboys flee on horseback, with the hero in pursuit. As the song fades out, the hero cowboy appears in front of Tyler.

Tyler was later featured in a parody of the video by David Copperfield.

Live performances

Two recorded performances of "Holding Out for a Hero" have been released on Tyler's concert DVDs Bonnie on Tour (2006) and Live in Germany 1993 (2011), and their respective CD editions.

Re-recordings and media usage

"Holding Out for a Hero" has featured in numerous commercials, film and television soundtracks, and the song has been covered by various artists. In 1984, E. G. Daily's version was used as the theme for the television series Cover Up. In 1986 Chrysler used the song in a Le Baron GTS commercial. The song was also used in various movies during the 1980s including Footloose, Short Circuit 2, and Who's Harry Crumb?. In 2004, Jennifer Saunders recorded a version of the song for Shrek 2 which she performs in character as the Fairy Godmother. Frou Frou also recorded a version for the credits sequence. Saunders' version would later be used in the opening ceremony for the 2010 Summer Youth Olympics. Ella Mae Bowen recorded a cover of the song for the 2011 Footloose remake. Doro Pesch recorded a cover version for the soundtrack of the 2019 German film The Last Cop. This song was also used in the films Bandits, Nacho Libre, The Angry Birds Movie 2, The Super Mario Bros. Movie, and LEGO Marvel Avengers: Mission Demolition, as well as in the trailers for Detective Pikachu.

In 2021, the song was noted for its appearances in a trailer for Masters of the Universe: Revelation, a trailer for the Guardians of the Galaxy video game, and in the Loki episode "The Variant", all of which premiered in the same week. This led to a significant increase in downloads and streams, and a placement atop Billboard’s Top TV Songs chart. In February 2022, the song again received media coverage for its use in "The Trials and Tribulations of Trying to Pee While Depressed", the seventh episode of the American TV series Euphoria.

In 2001, Tandi Iman Dupree and Dee St. James performed a dance routine to "Holding Out for a Hero" at the Miss Gay Black America pageant. Footage of the event went viral after it was uploaded to YouTube in 2009.

A bardcore version was recorded by Hildegard von Blingen.

Tyler has released re-recordings of the song in 2004 and 2011. In 2013, she recorded a new version of the song for use in a Children in Need fundraising campaign.

Track listings and formats

• 1984 7" single

1. "Holding Out for a Hero" – 4:22
2. "Faster Than the Speed of Night" – 4:40

• 1984 12" single

1. "Holding Out for a Hero" (Extended Remix) – 6:19
2. "Holding Out for a Hero" (Instrumental) – 5:15
3. "Faster Than the Speed of Night" – 4:40

• 1991 12"/CD single

1. "Holding Out for a Hero" – 4:41
2. "Faster Than the Speed of Night" – 4:40
3. "Total Eclipse of the Heart" – 6:49

Credits and personnel

• Bonnie Tyler – lead vocals
• Jim Steinman – producer
• John Jansen – associate producer
• Greg Edward, Arthur Payson, Neil Dorfsman – recording, mixing
• Greg Calbi – mastering
• Sterling Smith – piano, synthesizer, Linn drums
• Hiram Bullock – guitar
• John Philip Shenale – programming, synthesizer
• Art Wood – Simmons and Linn drums
• Tom "Bones" Malone – trombone, horn arrangements
• Michael Brecker – tenor saxophone
• Alan Rubin – trumpet
• Lew Soloff – trumpet
• Jim Pugh – trombone
• Dave Taylor – bass trombone
• Rory Dodd, Eric Troyer, Holly Sherwood – background vocalists, vocal arrangement
• Ellen Foley – additional vocal arrangement

Charts

Weekly charts

Year-end charts

Monthly charts

Certifications

Japanese version

Main article: w:ja:ヒーロー HOLDING OUT FOR A HERO

Hero: Holding Out for a Hero (Japanese: ヒーロー HOLDING OUT FOR A HERO) is a cover version with Japanese lyrics written by Masao Urino. It was first released as a single by in 1984. It was then released as a single by on 5 July 1984 and reached number 50 on the Oricon Singles Chart. It was then released as a single by on 5 November 1984. This single reached number 19 on the Oricon Singles Chart and number 20 on the Music Labo singles chart. It sold 181,000 copies according to Oricon and 200,000 copies according to Mamoru Murakami.

References

References

1. "Bonnie Tyler - Holding Out for a Hero".
2. Tyler, Bonnie. (June 1986). "Bonnie's Secret Dreams". Freetracks Publications Ltd.
3. Everley, Dave. (21 April 2021). "The mad genius of Jim Steinman in seven glorious songs".
4. Hughes, William. (21 July 2015). "Bonnie Tyler's "Holding Out For A Hero" forces its way to greatness".
5. Stenning, Paul. (August 2005). ""Golden Gods 2005 Issue"". Metal Hammer.
6. Neville, Carl. (March 27, 2015). "No More Heroes?: Steroids, Cocaine, Finance and Film in the 70s". John Hunt Publishing.
7. (December 15, 2021). "Let's Talk About That 'Loki' Bonnie Tyler Needle Drop".
8. Zuckerman, Faye. (21 April 1984). "Australian Firm Looks to Music". Lynne Segall.
9. Copperfield, David. (1984-04-06). "The Magic of David Copperfield VI: Floating Over the Grand Canyon". The Cates Brothers Company.
10. Cutchin, Rusty. (22 December 1984). "Company News".
11. "- YouTube".
12. Matthew Ryan. (2022-09-27). "Short Circuit 2 - Holding Out For A Hero".
13. Brodsky, Rachel. (19 May 2021). "How Shrek Blew My Band Up".
14. O'Connell, Sean. (10 August 2011). "Footloose Soundtrack Mixes New Material With Songs From Original Film".
15. Ridgeley, Charlie. (16 June 2021). ""Holding Out for a Hero" Trends After Being Used in Loki, Guardians of the Galaxy, and Masters of the Universe".
16. Rutherford, Kevin. (23 July 2021). "'Loki' Makes a Splash on Top TV Songs Chart".
17. Zorrilla, Mónica Marie. (20 February 2022). "'Euphoria' Stars Maude Apatow and Austin Abrams Explain That Epic Dance Number". [[Variety (magazine).
18. (2021-01-16). "The Story of the Legendary Drag Queen Tandi Iman Dupree and Her Epic "Holding Out for a Hero" Performance".
19. Owen, Cathy. (15 October 2013). "Bonnie Tyler revisits a classic for Children in Need".
20. Kent, David. (1993). "Australian Chart Book 1970–1992". Australian Chart Book.
21. (26 May 1984). "Hits of the World". Lynne Segall.
22. (5 October 1985). "Europarade – 5 October 1985".
23. Pennanen, Timo. (2021). "Sisältää hitin - 2. laitos Levyt ja esittäjät Suomen musiikkilistoilla 1.1.1960–30.6.2021". Kustannusosakeyhtiö Otava.
24. "Bonnie Tyler's Top 1 Selling Singles".
25. "South African Rock Lists Website SA Charts 1965 – 1989 Acts T".
26. "Cash Box Top 100 – Week ending April 21, 1984".
27. "Rock On The Net".
28. "Music & Media Singles Hot 100".
29. "Music & Media Airplay Top 50".
30. (18 January 1986). "Top 100 Singles: January 5–December 28, 1985".
31. "Loki Makes a Splash on Top TV Songs Chart".
32. [https://www.zakzak.co.jp/article/20241017-OAEWG45O4JI6HOOQHEB6EHOOXY/ 作詞家・売野雅勇さん、夕刊フジ「ぴいぷる」に登場　麻倉未稀さん代表曲、原曲では「I」が「You」なのはなぜ？長年の疑問が氷解]. ZAKZAK from the Sankei Shimbun. 17 October 2024.
33. Catalogue number RHS-151
34. [https://www.oricon.co.jp/prof/198281/rank/single/ シングル売上TOP3作品]. Oricon News.
35. [https://www.oricon.co.jp/prof/250929/rank/single/ シングル売上TOP6作品]
36. Billboard. 2 February 1985, [https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=ziQEAAAAMBAJ&pg=PT95#v=onepage&q&f=false p 80]. 26 January 1985, [https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=7CQEAAAAMBAJ&pg=PT148#v=onepage&q&f=false p 75].
37. 1968-1997 Oricon Chart Book. 1st Edition: 11 December 1997. p 12.
38. Billboard. 11 May 1985. [https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=1CQEAAAAMBAJ&pg=PT72#v=onepage&q&f=false p J-9].