Henry Tang illegal basement controversy

Overview

Wine-cellar rumours

Questions asked by the Ming Pao newspaper the previous October met with Tang's denial that he had a basement wine cellar at this residence. On 13 February 2012, he admitted that there was an unauthorized structure at his luxury residence at No. 5A York Road, in the upscale Kowloon Tong district, which he identified as a canopy above the garage. According to Tang, an underground garage on his family's adjacent property (7 York Road) existed at the time of purchase, and had since been excavated "for storage" but not as a wine cellar.

Alleged floor plan

On 15 February, Chinese-language newspaper Sharp Daily published a set of floor plans purporting to be of the 2,400-square-foot illegal basement at one of Tang's properties comprising a store room, fitness room, changing room, cinema and wine-tasting room dating from 2003.

Tang said the drawing "does not match. [The basement at No. 7 York Road] is basically used for storage." The Buildings Department said that the property was inspected on 22 January 2007, and no unauthorized structures were found. The property was held through a British Virgin Islands company in which he once held shares; Tang had transferred full ownership to his wife in 2010.

A media circus gathered at York Road on 16 February as inspectors made a site visit. Some media organisations hired cranes to get a bird's-eye view of the property while photographers climbed onto the wall to photograph inside the compound. Democrat Leung Kwok-hung led a protest outside Tang's residence and urged him to withdraw from the election.

Tang's response

On 15 February, having acknowledged the existence of the basement, Tang rejected demands by media organisations to inspect it on grounds of privacy, saying "It doesn't matter what the facilities inside are." In a press conference on 16 February, Tang's wife took responsibility for the illegal basement facility. Tang also apologised for mishandling the issue and for not properly addressing the furore generated. Tang refused to withdraw from the election, and said he had "realized that there was an illegal underground basement in my residence." He blamed the mishandling on the marital problems he was facing at the time. He has been criticised as "hiding behind his wife". On his election website, Tang blamed his woes on "unprecedented attacks, which are wolf-like and fierce".

Responses

Media and public opinion

The leader of the South China Morning Post of 17 February was highly critical. It asserted that Tang had no option but to quit. It said: "One oversight is perhaps not fatal. But attempts to cover up one's mistakes are political suicide. The chief executive hopeful has given the impression that he has not been telling the truth as the fiasco continues to unfold ... Instead of giving a straightforward answer, he appeared to have played with words and repeatedly dodged the key question to play down the controversy. But his statements have been unconvincing and his explanations have only raised more questions."

Experts commented that the secret basement, standing larger than the footprint of the house, was no afterthought and engineers commented on the near impossibility of building such a large underground structure after completion of the main house. The building plan filed with the Buildings Department showed over-engineered foundations: piles driven five metres deep, sufficient to permit at least one storey underground.

Pundits said Tang, with his privileged background and his tycoon backers, embodied Hong Kong’s political and economic elite which the general public felt was out of touch with the rest of the population. A poll conducted by the University of Hong Kong showed a sharply declining level of support for Tang to stay in the race over the two days of the breaking scandal. Tang's support level among the public continued to nosedive: 66% believed he should quit the race. Opposition to Tang was 72.2 per cent (23.5 percentage points higher) one week after the initial poll.

Pro-establishment parties

Tang's support from pro-establishment political parties showed signs of softening: the Liberal Party indicated that, although it would not seek the return of its 62 election committee nominations, its members might not vote for him in the election. The Democratic Alliance for the Betterment and Progress of Hong Kong said it would "carefully consider the saga and Tang's personal integrity to determine whether they will nominate and support him in the chief executive election." Despite the scandals, some, such as Peter Woo of Wharf Holdings, continued to support Tang.

Regina Ip, another potential candidate, called on Tang to withdraw from the race, saying that his "integrity and credibility have been tarnished."

Remedial work

The government declined to issue a demolition order on the house, as the owners agreed to remedy the problem.

Legal and political implications

Then Secretary for Development Carrie Lam said that the Buildings Department investigation into Tang's illegal construction would be a drawn-out process. She warned of criminal proceedings against Tang and his wife if there was evidence that drawings submitted to the Buildings Department in 2007 had "knowingly" been misrepresented. Property owners found guilty of knowingly undertaking construction work without government approval may face two years in jail and a fine of up to HK$400,000; owners misrepresenting any drawings submitted to the Buildings Department are liable to a fine of HK$1 million and three years in prison.

Commentators observed that Henry Tang had embarrassed Beijing and made it lose control of the election process. Liberal Party chairman James Tien said his party would not support Tang if 50% or more of the public continued to oppose his candidacy, as he feared Hong Kong could "face a governance crisis". He warned that if Tang succeeded in becoming Chief Executive despite his unpopularity, a hundred thousand people might "take their anger onto the streets."

The illegal basement was filled in during March 2013.Chan, Kahon (28 November 2013). "Henry Tang’s wife fined HK$110,000 for illegal basement". Archived from the original on 20 May 2014.

In July 2013, Lisa Kuo appeared in court, where she pleaded guilty to one charge of "building an illegal basement", and not guilty to a second charge of "knowingly commencing building works without obtaining approval". The second charge was subsequently dropped. Tang was not charged with any offence. In November, the court fined Kuo a total of HK$110,000. Tang complained about the magnitude of the fine, saying that the heaviest such penalty in the past decade was HK$15,000.

References

References

1. link. (7 January 2013 . ''The Standard'')
2. [https://web.archive.org/web/20120219133750/http://www.sharpdaily.hk/article/index/4104/20120215/54495/ 最新：面積大過間屋 唐宅僭建地下行宮 [Latest: Floor area greater than house itself; Tang residence has illegally constructed basement]]. ''Sharp Daily''. 15 February 2012 Archived from [http://www.sharpdaily.hk/article/index/4104/20120215/54495 the original] on 20 February 2012.
3. link. (20 May 2014 . ''The Standard'')
4. Lam, Lana (19 February 2012). "Tang revelation triggers calls for transparency". ''South China Morning Post''
5. [https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-17071207 "Row erupts over HK hopeful Henry Tang's basement"]. BBC (17 February 2012).
6. link. (20 May 2014 . ''The Standard'')
7. Staff reporters (17 February 2012). [https://web.archive.org/web/20140521031409/http://www.onenewspage.com/n/Asia-Pacific/74r3tb78r/Tang-declares-basement-off-limits.htm "Tang declares basement off limits"]. ''South China Morning Post''. Archived from [http://www.onenewspage.com/n/Asia-Pacific/74r3tb78r/Tang-declares-basement-off-limits.htm 3rd party site] on 27 February 2012.
8. link. (20 May 2014 . ''The Standard'')
9. Lee, Colleen; Cheung, Gary (24 February 2012). "Leung signs up as Tang lashes out". ''South China Morning Post''
10. Leader (17 February 2012). "Tang has no option but to quit the race". ''South China Morning Post''
11. Lo, Alex (23 February 2012). "Tang's basement sexier than his bedroom". ''South China Morning Post''
12. Cheung, Chi-fai; Wong, Olga (16 February 2012). "Tang's basement no afterthought, experts say". ''South China Morning Post''
13. Drew, Kevin (20 February 2012). {{Webarchive. link. (18 June 2022 . ''The New York Times''. Archived from [https://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/21/world/asia/henry-tang-a-candidate-to-lead-hong-kong-runs-into-trouble.html the original] on 23 February 2012.)
14. Yun, Michelle ;Richardson, Ben (19 February 2012). [https://web.archive.org/web/20120221043035/http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-02-18/hong-kong-holds-building-probe-into-leadership-election-front-runner-tang.html "Henry Tang Should Quit Hong Kong Leadership Election, Newspaper Poll Shows"]. Bloomberg. Archived from [https://www.bloomberg.com/news/2012-02-18/hong-kong-holds-building-probe-into-leadership-election-front-runner-tang.html the original] on 20 February 2012
15. Cheung, Gary (23 February 2012). "66pc of public want Tang to pull out of race". ''South China Morning Post''
16. So, Peter; Lee, Ada (24 February 2012). "Support for Tang falls to record low". ''South China Morning Post''
17. Siu, Phila (23 February 2012).[http://www.thestandard.com.hk/news_detail.asp?pp_cat=30&art_id=120006&sid=35510755&con_type=1&d_str=20120223&isSearch=1&sear_year=2012 "Tang support still growing"]. ''The Standard''.
18. Luk, Eddie; So, Alice (17 February 2012) [http://www.thestandard.com.hk/news_detail.asp?pp_cat=30&art_id=119825&sid=35445894&con_type=1&d_str=20120217&isSearch=1&sear_year=2012 "Ip stands ready to run if Tang quits"]. ''The Standard''
19. Gregory Wong, former president of the [[Hong Kong Institution of Engineers]], described the work as relatively simple and could be completed within two weeks at a cost of about HK$300,000 (US$38,500).Wong, Olga (23 February 2012). "Filling in basement will take 80 cement trucks". ''South China Morning Post''
20. Luk, Eddie (24 February 2012) [http://www.thestandard.com.hk/news_detail.asp?pp_cat=30&art_id=120061&sid=35523251&con_type=1&d_str=20120224&isSearch=1&sear_year=2012 "Moment of truth for Tang"]. ''The Standard''.
21. Pomfret, James; Tang, Sisi (22 February 2012). [https://web.archive.org/web/20120224001853/http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/02/22/us-hongkong-china-election-idUSTRE81L0BZ20120222 "China frets as choice for Hong Kong leader strays off script"], Reuters. Archived from [https://www.reuters.com/article/us-hongkong-china-election-idUSTRE81L0BZ20120222 the original] on 23 February 2012.
22. Chugani, Michael (22 February 2012). 'Public Eye' – "Let's hear it for Henry, he's made the chief executive race racier". ''South China Morning Post''
23. Lee, Colleen; Cheung, Gary (25 February 2012). "Liberals give Tang an ultimatum". ''South China Morning Post''
24. Lee, Simon; Wong, Alan (12 July 2013). [https://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-07-11/henry-tang-s-wife-admits-guilt-over-illegal-basement.html "Henry Tang’s Wife Admits Guilt Over Illegal Basement"]. [https://web.archive.org/web/20140521033639/http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-07-11/henry-tang-s-wife-admits-guilt-over-illegal-basement.html Archived] from the original on 20 May 2014.