He Loves U Not

Content

Upon Dream's signing to Puff Daddy's Bad Boy Entertainment, the quartet recorded "He Loves U Not" as their breakthrough single, setting aside previously recorded songs "Do U Wanna Dance," "Baby," and "Miss You" that they had done while signed to Clockwork Entertainment with Judith Fontaine as their manager.

Lead vocals are performed by Holly Arnstein with speaking breaks by Melissa Schuman. Diana Ortiz can be heard saying a few Spanish phrases, such as Él me quiere ("He loves me") and No te quiere ("He doesn't love you"). An early version of the song opened with a young girl's voice saying "He loves me, he loves you not," though this opening was removed on the album and single versions, although the phrase "he loves you not" is heard at the end of the album version.

The song is sung from the point of view of a girl confronting another girl who is trying to steal her boyfriend, to whom she claims, "He loves me, he loves you not."

Critical reception

"He Loves U Not" received a mixed reception from music critics who praised the production and lyrics but felt that it was derivative compared to other songs of its ilk. Billboard praised the song for having a street edge in its production, the group's performance and compared the lyrics positively to Brandy and Monica's duet "The Boy Is Mine", concluding that "With Bad Boy's genius and solid talent here, "He Loves U Not" has a good shot at becoming a dream come true." AllMusic's Stephen Thomas Erlewine highlighted the song as a "Track Pick", giving credit to P. Diddy's team of producers and songwriters. Arion Berger of Rolling Stone praised the song for exuding bright attitude, saying that it has a "whipping elasticity and sass to spare." David Browne of Entertainment Weekly called the song "an utterly derivative piece of song-and-dance pop-R&B," but did highlight the rhythm and guitar sounds as "intriguing" and the lyrical catfight for having "enough hiss in it to be interesting." A writer for People, reviewing the album, was less positive towards the song's adult content and preferred the tracks "Mr. Telephone Man" and "How Long" for how "the girls sound their age."

The song gave them a Soul Train Lady of Soul Award nomination for Best R&B/Soul or Rap New Artist, Group, Band or Duo but lost to 3LW's "No More (Baby I'ma Do Right)". In 2017, Billboard placed "He Loves U Not" at number 36 on their list of the 100 Greatest Girl Group Songs of All Time.

Commercial performance

"He Loves U Not" debuted at number 99 on the US Billboard Hot 100 for the week of September 30, 2000. Six weeks later, it entered the top 40 at number 32 for the week of November 11. It entered the top 10 at number eight for the week of December 16. The song eventually peaked at number two for two weeks in December 2000 and January 2001. It also reached number 15 on the Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Singles & Tracks chart the week of January 6, 2001. It was certified gold by the RIAA on January 2, selling over 500,000 copies in the United States.

In Australia, where the song was released on February 26, 2001, "He Loves U Not" entered the ARIA Singles Chart on March 11, and stayed there for three weeks, peaking at number 30. The song was also released in the United Kingdom, peaking at number 17 on the UK Singles Chart on March 17, and staying on the chart for seven weeks.

Music video

The music video for "He Loves U Not" was shot June 28–30, 2000, and directed by Marcus Raboy. It featured three settings: in the first, the girls, clad in pink outfits, danced in a white room with the Dream logo flashing behind them; in the second, the girls danced on stage in a California desert; in the third, the girls moved around a rotating white room; the same one used previously in the videos for *NSYNC's "Bye Bye Bye" and Sugar Ray's "Fly". The video inspired the title sequence from the Peacock musical comedy series Girls5eva, according to ''Slate'''s Heather Schwedel.

Live performances

Dream first performed the song live on November 26, 2000, by touring with fellow pop group *NSYNC on the second leg of their No Strings Attached Tour in the Staples Center in Los Angeles. The song was also performed when they opened alongside Baha Men and Debelah Morgan for 98 Degrees on their Revelation Tour (2001) and on MTV's Total Request Live Tour (2001).

They made their television debut performing it live on TRL on December 11, 2000, to promote the premiere of the song's music video. On January 24, 2001, they performed it on two talk shows to promote the release of their debut album a day before: Live with Regis in Las Vegas and The Tonight Show with Jay Leno. On February 12, it was performed on The Rosie O'Donnell Show. On June 10, they performed this and "This Is Me" at the 2001 Walt Disney World Summer Jam Concert, aboard the Disney Wonder cruise ship in the Bahamas. A week later, they performed it at Wango Tango, an annual all-day concert organized by KIIS-FM, in California. Troy J. Augusto of Variety put their performance alongside Eden's Crush and Vertical Horizon's, saying that they were "easy to forget." Eight days later, they appeared on The Early Show on June 25, 2001, to perform this and "This Is Me". On August 28, 2001, they performed both album and remix versions of the song at the 7th Annual Soul Train Lady of Soul Awards.

Track listings

US CD single

1. "He Loves U Not" – 3:46
2. "He Loves U Not" (instrumental) – 3:46

US 12-inch single :A1. "He Loves U Not" (HQ2 club mix) – 8:24 :A2. "He Loves U Not" (HQ2 instrumental) – 8:24 :B1. "He Loves U Not" (HQ2 radio mix) – 3:48 :B2. "He Loves U Not" (Meeker & MC Supplier 2 step garage mix) – 6:24

Australian CD single

1. "He Loves U Not" (radio mix) – 3:48
2. "He Loves U Not" (remix featuring G. Dep) – 3:50
3. "He Loves U Not" (Ingroove club mix) – 6:36
4. "He Loves U Not" (HQ2 club mix) – 8:25
5. "He Loves U Not" (Meeker & MC Supplier 2 step garage mix) – 6:27 UK CD single
6. "He Loves U Not" (radio version) – 3:47
7. "He Loves U Not" (remix featuring G. Dep) – 3:49
8. "He Loves U Not" (radio edit video)

UK 12-inch single :A1. "He Loves U Not" (radio version) – 3:47 :A2. "He Loves U Not" (remix featuring G. Dep) – 3:49 :B1. "He Loves U Not" (remix instrumental) – 3:08

UK cassette single

1. "He Loves U Not" (radio version) – 3:47
2. "He Loves U Not" (remix) – 3:49

European CD single

1. "He Loves U Not" (radio mix) – 3:48
2. "He Loves U Not" (HQ2 remix) – 8:52

Credits and personnel

Credits are adapted from the liner notes of It Was All a Dream.

Recording

• Recorded and mixed at Canyon Reverb, The Sweatbox, and Sony Studios (California, US)

Personnel

• Dave Way – mixer (Pacifique Recording Studios; North Hollywood, Los Angeles)
• Wassim Zreik – assistant engineer
• David Frank – keyboards, drums, songwriting
• Steve Kipner – additional keyboards, songwriting
• Pamela Sheyne – songwriting, additional background vocals

Charts

Weekly charts

Year-end charts

Certifications

Release history

References

References

1. (August 26, 2000). "Reviews & Previews: Singles". [[Nielsen Corporation.
2. Erlewine, Stephen Thomas. "It Was All a Dream - Dream". [[AllMusic]].
3. Berger, Arion. (January 23, 2001). "It Was All A Dream : Dream : Review". [[Jann Wenner.
4. Browne, David. (January 26, 2001). "It Was All a Dream". [[Time Inc.]].
5. (January 22, 2001). "Picks and Pans Review: It Was All a Dream". [[Meredith Corporation]].
6. (July 31, 2001). "Scott, 3LW, Anderson Lead Lady Soul Noms". [[Prometheus Global Media]].
7. (July 10, 2017). "100 Greatest Girl Group Songs of All Time: Critics' Picks".
8. "The Hot 100: September 30, 2000".
9. "The Hot 100: November 11, 2000".
10. "The Hot 100: December 16, 2000".
11. "Hot R&B/Hip-Hop Songs: January 6, 2001".
12. (February 26, 2001). "The ARIA Report: ARIA New Releases Singles – Week Commencing 26th February 2001". [[Australian Recording Industry Association.
13. "Official Singles Chart Top 100: 17 March 2001". [[Official Charts Company]].
14. "Rando / Other pages / Broadcast/Film/Commercial".
15. Schwedel, Heather. (May 20, 2021). "The Girls5eva Easter Eggs You Might Have Missed". [[The Slate Group]].
16. Schumacher-Rasmussen, Eric. (February 22, 2001). "Baha Men, Debelah Morgan Join Dream/98 Degrees Tour". Viacom.
17. Chung, Sandra M.. (August 24, 2001). "Concert Review: MTV's TRL Tour Arrives". [[The Tech (newspaper).
18. "Episode 93".
19. "Episode 27".
20. "Episode 110".
21. (May 25, 2001). "The Summer Kicks Off With the 'Walt Disney World Summer Jam Concert'". [[PR Newswire]].
22. Nichols, Natalie. (June 19, 2001). "Wango Tango Serves Up Pop-Pourri". [[Los Angeles Times]].
23. Augusto, Troy J.. (June 18, 2001). "Review: 'Wango Tango, Day Two'". [[Penske Media Corporation.
24. "Episode 445".
25. van Horn, Teri. (August 29, 2001). "Aaliyah's Absence Felt At Lady Of Soul Awards". [[Viacom (2005–2019).
26. (2000). "He Loves U Not". [[Bad Boy Entertainment]].
27. (2000). "He Loves U Not". Bad Boy Entertainment.
28. (2001). "He Loves U Not". Bad Boy Entertainment, [[Arista Records]], [[Bertelsmann Music Group.
29. (2001). "He Loves U Not". Bad Boy Entertainment, Arista Records, BMG.
30. (2001). "He Loves U Not". Bad Boy Entertainment, Arista Records, BMG.
31. (2001). "He Loves U Not". Bad Boy Entertainment, Arista Records, BMG.
32. (2001). "He Loves U Not". Bad Boy Entertainment, Arista Records, BMG.
33. (2001). "[[It Was All a Dream (Dream album)". [[Bad Boy Entertainment]].
34. "Cross Canada Countdown: February 10, 2001".
35. "Dream Chart History (Canadian Digital Songs)".
36. (March 31, 2001). "Eurochart Hot 100 Singles".
37. "Tipparade-lijst van week 14, 2001". [[Dutch Top 40]].
38. (April 3, 2018). "Brazilian Top 100 Year-End 2001". [[Crowley Broadcast Analysis]].
39. "Canada's Top 200 Singles of 2001". [[Jam!]].
40. "End of Year Charts 2001".
41. (December 29, 2001). "Hot 100 Singles & Tracks".
42. (December 21, 2001). "Most-Played Mainstream Top 40 Songs of 2001".
43. (December 21, 2001). "Most-Played Rhythmic Top 40 Songs of 2001".
44. (August 18, 2000). "CHR/Pop: Going for Adds".
45. (November 24, 2000). "AddVance Notice".
46. "Dream: Discografi".
47. (March 3, 2001). "New Releases – For Week Starting March 5, 2001: Singles".