Haavara Agreement

Background

Although the Nazi Party won the greatest share of the popular vote in the two Reichstag general elections of 1932, they did not have a majority, so Hitler led a short-lived coalition government formed by the Nazis and the German National People's Party. Under pressure from politicians, industrialists and others, President Paul von Hindenburg appointed Hitler as Chancellor of Germany on 30 January 1933. This event is known as the Machtergreifung (seizure of power). In the following months, the Nazis used a process termed Gleichschaltung (roughly 'bringing into line') to consolidate power. By June 1933, virtually the only organisations not under the control of the Nazi party were the army and the churches.

Within the Nazi movement, a variety of increasingly radical "solutions" to the "Jewish Question" were proposed both before and while the Nazi party was in government, including expulsion and the encouragement of voluntary emigration. Widespread civil persecution of German Jews began as soon as the Nazis were in power. For example, on 1 April, the Nazis organized a nationwide boycott of Jewish-owned businesses in Germany; under the Law for the Restoration of the Professional Civil Service, which was implemented on 7 April, Jews were excluded from the civil service; on 25 April, quotas were imposed on the number of Jews in schools and universities. Jews outside Germany responded to these persecutions with a boycott of German goods, which appeared to some Nazis to threaten the Reich.

Meanwhile, in Mandatory Palestine, a growing Jewish population (174,610 in 1931, rising to 384,078 in 1936 and 600,000 in 1948) was acquiring land and developing the structures of a future Jewish state despite conflicting sentiments within the population of Mandatory Palestine.

Hanotea company

Hanotea (הַנּוֹטֵעַ 'the Planter') was a citrus planting company based in Netanya and established in 1929 by long-established Jewish settlers in Palestine involved in the Benei Binyamin movement. In an arrangement with the Reich Economics Ministry, the blocked German bank accounts of prospective immigrants would be unblocked and funds from them used by Hanotea to buy agricultural German goods; these goods, along with the immigrants, would then go to Palestine, and the immigrants would be granted a house or citrus plantation by the company of the same value. Hanotea's director, Sam Cohen, represented the company in direct negotiation with the Reich Economics Ministry beginning in March 1933. In May 1933 Hanotea applied for permission to transfer capital from Germany to Palestine. This pilot arrangement appeared to be operating successfully, and so paved the way for the later Haavara Agreement.

The transfer agreement

The Trust and Transfer Office "Haavara" Ltd. places at the disposal of the Banks in Palestine amounts in Reichmarks which have been put at its disposal by the Jewish immigrants from Germany. The Banks avail themselves of these amounts in Reichmarks in order to make payments on behalf of Palestinian merchants for goods imported by them from Germany. The merchants pay in the value of the goods to the Banks and the "Haavara" Ltd. pays the countervalue to the Jewish immigrants from Germany. To the same extent that local merchants will make use of this arrangement, the import of German goods will serve to withdraw Jewish capital from Germany.

The Trust and Transfer Office,

HAAVARA, LTD.|Example of the certificate issued by Haavara to Jews emigrating to Palestine}}

The Haavara (Transfer) Agreement, negotiated by Eliezer Hoofein, director of the Anglo-Palestine Bank, was agreed to by the Reich Economics Ministry in 1933, and continued, with declining German government support, until it was wound up in 1939. The agreement provided a substantial export market for German factories to British-ruled Palestine. Between November 1933, and 31 December 1937, 77,800,000 Reichsmarks, or $22,500,000, (values in 1938 currency) worth of goods were exported to Jewish businesses in Palestine under the program. By the time the program ended with the start of World War II, the total had risen to 105,000,000 marks (about $35,000,000, 1939 values).

Emigrants with capital of £1,000, (about $5,000 in 1930s currency value) could move to Palestine in spite of severe British restrictions on Jewish immigration under an immigrant investor program similar to the modern United States EB-5 visa. Under the Transfer Agreement, about 39% of an emigrant's funds were given to Jewish communal economic development projects, leaving individuals with about 43% of the funds.

The Haavara Agreement was thought by some German circles to be a possible way to solve the "Jewish problem." The head of the Middle Eastern division of the foreign ministry, the anti-Nazi politician Werner Otto von Hentig, supported the policy of settling Jews in Palestine. Hentig believed that if the Jewish population was concentrated in a single foreign entity, then foreign diplomatic policy and containment of the Jews would become easier. Hitler's own support of the Haavara Agreement was unclear and varied throughout the 1930s. Initially, Hitler seemed indifferent to the economic details of the plan, but he supported it in the period from September 1937 to 1939.

After the German invasion of Poland in September 1939 the program was ended.

Responses

The agreement was controversial both within the Nazi party and in the Zionist movement. As historian Edwin Black put it, "The Transfer Agreement tore the Jewish world apart, turning leader against leader, threatening rebellion and even assassination." Opposition came from the mainstream US leadership of the World Zionist Congress, in particular Abba Hillel Silver and American Jewish Congress president Rabbi Stephen Wise. Wise and other leaders of the Anti-Nazi boycott of 1933 argued against the agreement, narrowly failing to persuade the Nineteenth Zionist Congress in August 1935 to vote against it.

The right-wing Revisionist Zionists and their leader Vladimir Jabotinsky were even more vocal in their opposition. The Revisionist newspaper in Palestine, Hazit Haam published a sharp denunciation of those involved in the agreement as "betrayers", and shortly afterwards one of the negotiators, Haim Arlosoroff was assassinated.

In the post-war period, the agreement has sometimes been cited by anti-Zionists, antisemites, and critics of Israel (Ken Livingstone, Lyndon LaRouche, Louis Farrakhan, Mark Weber, Joseph Massad, Mahmoud Abbas) as evidence of Nazi support for Zionism or Zionist collaboration with the Nazis. Keith Kahn-Harris responds to this interpretation that "making an agreement with Zionists did not make Hitler a supporter of Zionism any more than the Nazi–Soviet pact made him a supporter of communism."

References

References

1. "Haavara".
2. Krüger, C. G.. (2009). "Review of Zionism and Anti-Semitism in Nazi Germany". The English Historical Review.
3. [http://www.historyandtheheadlines.abc-clio.com/ContentPages/ContentPage.aspx?entryId=1281494&currentSection=1271019&productid=16 Arab-Israeli Wars: 60 Years of Conflict, Ha Avara], [[ABC-CLIO]], ''accessed 7 May 2013''.
4. Yf’aat Weiss, [http://www.yadvashem.org/odot_pdf/Microsoft%20Word%20-%203231.pdf The Transfer Agreement and the Boycott Movement: A Jewish Dilemma on the Eve of the Holocaust], [[Yad Vashem]] Shoah Resource Center, ''accessed 28 April 2016''.
5. [[Francis R. Nicosia]] [https://books.google.com/books?id=8bjbj5CZbgMC ''The Third Reich & the Palestine question''], pp. 41-49.
6. Evans, Richard J.. (2005). "The Third Reich in Power". Penguin.
7. Shirer, William L.. (1960). "[[The Rise and Fall of the Third Reich]]". Simon & Schuster.
8. McNab, Chris. (2009). "The Third Reich". Amber Books.
9. Evans, Richard J.. (2005). "The Third Reich in Power". Penguin.
10. Harran, Marilyn J.. (2000). "The Holocaust Chronicles: A History in Words and Pictures". Publications International.
11. Weiss, Yf'aat. "The Transfer Agreement and the Boycott Movement: A Jewish Dilemma on the Eve of the Holocaust". Yad Va'shem Shoa Journal.
12. "Jewish & Non-Jewish Population of Israel/Palestine (1517-Present)".
13. Jewish Responses to Persecution: 1933-1938, [[Jürgen Matthäus]], [[Mark Roseman]], Rowman & Littlefield, 2010
14. Nahum Karlinsky ''California Dreaming: Ideology, Society, and Technology in the Citrus Industry of Palestine, 1890-1939'' SUNY Press, pp. 76-8, 118, 218
15. Rafael N. Rosenzweig ''The Economic Consequences of Zionism'', New York: BRILL, 1989, pp.82-83
16. Francis R. Nicosia: [https://books.google.com/books?id=8bjbj5CZbgMC ''The third Reich & the Palestine question''], p. 39 ff.
17. Leni Yahil, ''The Holocaust: The Fate of European Jewry, 1932-1945'', Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1991, p.101
18. (8 March 1938). "Haavara Pact Extended for Only 3 Months; Seen Losing Reich's Support". JTA.
19. (8 September 1939). "Haavara Winds Up Reich-palestine Transfer Operations; Handled $35,000,000 in 6 Years". [[Jewish Telegraphic Agency]].
20. (25 May 1936). "Reich Migrants to Palestine Get Back 42% of Funds in Cash". JTA.
21. [https://web.archive.org/web/20020220213423/http://www.pbs.org/wnet/heritage/episode8/documents/documents_11.html Heritage: Civilization and the Jews] (PBS)
22. [[Francis R. Nicosia]] [https://books.google.com/books?id=8bjbj5CZbgMC ''The Third Reich & the Palestine question''], pp. 132–133.
23. Francis R. Nicosia: [https://books.google.com/books?id=8bjbj5CZbgMC ''The Third Reich & the Palestine question''], pp. 140, 142.
24. (2023-08-06). "Ninety years ago a negotiated 'transfer' led more than 50,000 German Jews to Palestine". Le Monde.fr.
25. "StackPath".
26. Aaron Berman ''Nazism, the Jews and American Zionism, 1933-1988'', Detroit: Wayne State University Press, 1992, p.39; Jennifer Ring, ''Political Consequences of Thinking, The: Gender and Judaism in the Work of Hannah Arendt'', New York: SUNY Press, 1 Feb 2012, pp.59-63
27. Francis R. Nicosia ''Zionism and Anti-Semitism in Nazi Germany'' Cambridge University Press, 5 May 2008, p.99
28. Weber, Mark. "Zionism and the Third Reich".
29. Massad, Joseph. "Zionism, anti-Semitism and colonialism".
30. "Yad Vashem Condemns Statements of PA Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas".
31. (2016-05-03). "The truth about Hitler and Zionism".
32. (Winter 1987). "The Transfer Agreement: Zionist Collaboration?". [[Shofar (journal).
33. Kahn-Harris, Keith. (2019). "Strange hate: antisemitism, racism and the limits of diversity". Repeater Books.