Encounters with the Archdruid

Synopsis

While notionally a profile of Brower, Encounters is broken into three sections. The first chronicles Brower's conflict with Charles Park, a mineral engineer hoping to find and exploit mineral reserves in Glacier Peak Wilderness. Charles Park is portrayed as calculating and pragmatic, unwilling to foreclose real economic value from current generations in order to leave the environment pristine for future generations. This pragmatic view is starkly contrasted with Brower's insistence that "I believe in wilderness for itself alone". McPhee facilitates or observes the dialogue between these two contrasted figures as he does for the other two sections in the book.

The second section introduces Charles Fraser, a real estate developer in Hilton Head Island, South Carolina. Fraser's characterization of environmentalists as modern druids who "worship trees and sacrifice human beings to those trees" provides the charge against Brower that forms the title of the book. Brower came to Georgia in order to stop Fraser's plan to develop Cumberland Island. Like Park, Fraser is depicted as nuanced and pragmatic: his vision of development is controlled and regulated land use. Fraser's development of Hilton Head Island is still considered a model for planned development and McPhee notes that Fraser considers himself a true conservationist. Brower would eventually win this battle, with a groundswell of opposition forcing Fraser to sell his development on Cumberland Island to the National Park Foundation.

The third section presents David Brower's unraveling. Here Brower battles Floyd Dominy, then the commissioner of the United States Bureau of Reclamation. Displaying only some of the reserve and pragmatism of the previous two figures, Dominy relished the damming of rivers, while Brower considered damming the ultimate offense. Brower struggled to save the Glen Canyon from being flooded by the Glen Canyon Dam but failed and as the story progresses, he is increasingly marginalized in the environmental movement for his perceived militancy. Wendy Nelson Espeland, in The Struggle for Water, argues that the Bureau carries much of the blame (or credit) for "radicalizing" Brower.

Reception and influence

McPhee's catalog of these conflicts between the growing needs of society and the shrinking wilderness presaged what would become known as "wise use", or prescriptions for use that balance the existential value of the environment against societal needs. Encounters was positively received in both The New York Times and The Wall Street Journal. Time gave a positive review as well, noting the narrative similarities to a novel. The term "archdruid" stuck with Brower and was used appreciatively in many of his obituaries, including one McPhee wrote for him, when he died in 2000.

Footnotes

References

1. (April 17, 1972). "Spring Cleaning". [[Time (magazine).
2. McPhee, John. (1971). "Encounters with the Archdruid". Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
3. Nelson, Robert H.. (Spring 1997). "Does 'Existence Value' Exist? Environmental Economics Encroaches on Religion". The Independent Institute.
4. Fuller, Edmund. (August 11, 1971). "Of Honest Men Who Disagree". [[The Wall Street Journal]].
5. Jellenick, Roger. (September 12, 1971). "The Last Word: Wild Men". [[The New York Times]].
6. McPhee (1971), pp. 92–95
7. Martin, Douglas. (December 19, 2002). "Charles E. Fraser, 73, Dies; Developer of Hilton Head". [[The New York Times]].
8. McPhee (1971), pp. 149–150
9. Royte, Elizabeth. (February 17, 2008). "Of Crime and the River". [[The New York Times]].
10. Robinson, Nicholas A.. (Summer 2001). "David Ross Brower and Nature's Laws". Pace University.
11. Nelson Espeland, Wendy. (1998). "The Struggle for Water: Politics, Rationality, and Identity in the American Southwest". University of Chicago Press.
12. Bentley, Susanne. (2000). "Western Futures: Perspectives on the Humanities at the Millennium". University of Nevada Press.
13. Reed, Christopher. (November 8, 2000). "David Brower: Environmental champion whose passion founded Friends of the Earth". [[The Guardian]].
14. McPhee, John. (January 2001). "Passages: Farewell to the Archdruid: Earth's best friend, David Brower, 1912-2000". [[Sierra Club]].