Cornflake Girl

Inspiration and meaning

Amos' inspiration for "Cornflake Girl" came from the book Possessing the Secret of Joy by Alice Walker, which is about female genital mutilation in Africa, specifically how a close female family member would betray the victim by performing the procedure. Amos has said that growing up, the name they gave to girls who would hurt you despite close friendship was "cornflake girls".

Release

Two separate "Cornflake Girl" CD singles were released in the UK. The first, released on January 10, 1994, contains three original B-sides: "Sister Janet", "All the Girls Hate Her" and "Over It"; the latter two being part of a Piano Suite. The second, released on January 17, 1994, was a limited edition picture CD housed in a digipak, containing cover versions of the songs "A Case of You" by Joni Mitchell, "If 6 Was 9" by Jimi Hendrix and "Strange Fruit" by Billie Holiday. The first CD single was replicated for the German and Australasian release, and its B-sides were re-used for the US "God" and "Cornflake Girl" releases. Other than "A Case of You" appearing on a US promotional CD compilation and a limited two-CD Australian tour edition of "Under the Pink", the three cover versions on the limited UK "Cornflake Girl" CD single have not been released on any other title to date, and are not available to purchase through digital retailers. As such, this CD remains a collectible item.

Reception

Ned Raggett from AllMusic described the song as "a waltz-paced number with an unnerving whistle and stuttering vocal hook." Larry Flick from Billboard magazine noted it as a "bouncy, piano-driven single". He added, "As always, Amos weaves lyrics that push you to think as well as hum" and "this could be the big hit Amos has been waiting for." Troy J. Augusto from Cash Box wrote, "More painful confessional from Amos, a gifted singer-songwriter with a knack for making childhood pain perfect top-40 fodder. Reminiscent of early Kate Bush, this track will look to alternative and college radio for acceptance first, with rock outlets hopefully responding as well. Thematically, a bit depressing for hits stations, but an affecting, important release nonetheless." Peter Paphides from Melody Maker said, "'Cornflake Girl' is a seductive mordant piano and guitar duel that resolves itself only when everything stops and Tori does this really scary Kate Bush-like squeal on the chorus." Another Melody Maker editor, Chris Roberts, remarked the "sedulous swing" of the song.

A reviewer from Music & Media stated, "Amos is no musical Tory; she's as progressive and challenging as can be. But then again, this cornflake girl wouldn't have been what she is without having eaten from Kate Bush's cereal." John Kilgo from The Network Forty called it "trademark Tori Amos from the lyrics to the grassroots cadence." Mark Frith from Smash Hits gave it a score of two out of five, describing it as a "melancholy tune that doesn't go anywhere." Keeley Bolger commented in the 2010 book, 1001 Songs You Must Hear Before You Die, that it "could sound depressing in the wrong hands, but Amos's charm conjures up a song that is as otherworldly as its subject. The piano cascades, soft percussion, and ghostly chorus set it apart from the plod of Britpop and post-grunge dominating transatlantic charts at the time." In 2014, Stereogum ranked the song number one on their list of the 10 greatest Tori Amos songs, and in 2023, The Guardian ranked the song number seven on their list of the 20 greatest Tori Amos songs.

The song reached number four on the UK Singles Chart and was Amos' most successful international hit at the time. The single peaked within the top 10 in Ireland and ranked in Blender magazine's The 500 Greatest Songs Since You Were Born at number 433.

Music video

There were produced two different music videos for "Cornflake Girl". The UK version was directed by Big TV!, two directors from the UK. Amos said that is based on The Wizard of Oz, except that Dorothy goes to Hell instead. Amos stated that she wanted there to be "two different visual expressions" of the song. The US video, directed by Amos and Nancy Bennett, features Amos driving a truck full of women around a typical American desert.

Track listings

• US CD single

1. "Cornflake Girl" (edit) – 3:53
2. "Sister Janet" – 4:01
3. "Daisy Dead Petals" – 3:02
4. "Honey" – 3:47

• US cassette single

1. "Cornflake Girl" (edit) – 3:53
2. "Honey" – 3:47

• Canadian and Australian CD single, UK CD1

1. "Cornflake Girl" – 5:05
2. "Sister Janet" – 4:02
3. Piano Suite :# "All the Girls Hate Her" – 2:23 :# "Over It" – 2:11

• UK CD2

1. "Cornflake Girl" – 5:05
2. "A Case of You" – 4:38
3. "If 6 Was 9" – 3:59
4. "Strange Fruit" – 4:00

• UK 7-inch and cassette single

1. "Cornflake Girl" – 5:05
2. "Sister Janet" – 4:01

Credits and personnel

Credits are adapted from the Under the Pink album booklet.

Studios

• Recorded at The Fishhouse (New Mexico, US)
• Mixed at Olympic Studios (London, England)
• Mastered at Gateway Mastering (Portland, Maine, US)

Personnel

• Tori Amos – writing, vocals, piano, production
• Merry Clayton – guest vocals
• Steve Clayton – guitar, mandolin
• George Porter Jr. – bass
• Carlo Nuccio – drums
• Paulinho da Costa – percussion
• Eric Rosse – production, recording (guitars, other instruments), programming
• John Beverly Jones – recording (vocals, piano, percussion)
• Paul McKenna – recording (bass, drums)
• Kevin Killen – mixing
• Bob Ludwig – mastering

Charts

Weekly charts

Year-end charts

Release history

Cover versions and other uses

The song was covered by post-hardcore band Jawbox as a hidden track on their self-titled 1996 album, as well as by the band Tapping the Vein on the Tori Amos tribute album, Songs of a Goddess. In 2007, after Amos had to pull out of an appearance on the Australian comedy program The Sideshow, musical comedy trio Tripod performed the song in her place.

On March 25, 2010, British electronic musician Imogen Heap covered the song live in Australia. The performance was done per request by the winner of an online charity auction who paid about US$4000 to win the item "VIP Experience Meet Imogen Heap + A Song Just For You".

On September 19, 2018, the British band Florence + The Machine released their version of this song, exclusively for Spotify.

A cover version performed by Jeff Russo and Noah Hawley was used for the soundtrack to season 2 of the TV series Legion.

In 2023, the song was featured in the drama television series Yellowjackets (Season 2, Episode 1, "Friends, Romans, Countrymen") and the Netflix dramedy series Beef (Season 1, Episode 2, "The Rapture of Being Alive").

References

References

1. Christensen, Thor. (1998). "MusicHound Rock: The Essential Album Guide". [[Visible Ink Press]].
2. (July 16, 2013). "The Unsung Stories of Merry Clayton & Darlene Love".
3. (October 18, 2011). "Tori Amos' Real-Life Stint as a Cornflake Girl". Mental Floss.
4. Raggett, Ned. "Tori Amos – ''Under the Pink''". [[AllMusic]].
5. Flick, Larry. (June 18, 1994). "Single Reviews".
6. Augusto, Troy J.. (June 18, 1994). "Pop Singles: Reviews".
7. Paphides, Peter. (January 15, 1993). "Singles".
8. Roberts, Chris. (January 29, 1994). "Albums".
9. (January 22, 1994). "New Releases: Singles".
10. Kilgo, John. (June 10, 1994). "Mainstream: Music Meeting".
11. Frith, Mark. (January 5, 1994). "New Singles".
12. (2011). "1001 Songs You Must Hear Before You Die". [[Octopus Publishing Group]].
13. Dick, Jonathan. (June 18, 2014). "The 10 Best Tori Amos Songs".
14. Petridis, Alexis. (August 17, 2023). "Tori Amos's 20 greatest songs – ranked!".
15. (December 26, 2008). "Hottest 100 > 1994". [[Australian Broadcasting Corporation.
16. "Blender Magazine – 500 Greatest Songs From 1980–2005 (Music Database :: Dave Tompkins)".
17. (October 16, 2012). "NME > Tori Amos – The Story Behind 'Cornflake Girl – Classic Song".
18. (April 9, 1994). "Music Video: Production Notes".
19. (1994). "Cornflake Girl". [[Atlantic Records]].
20. (1994). "Cornflake Girl". Atlantic Records.
21. (1994). "Cornflake Girl". [[East West Records.
22. (1994). "Cornflake Girl". EastWest Records.
23. (1994). "Cornflake Girl". EastWest Records.
24. (1994). "Cornflake Girl". EastWest Records, Atlantic Records.
25. (1994). "Cornflake Girl". EastWest Records, Atlantic Records.
26. (1994). "Under the Pink". Atlantic Records.
27. (February 5, 1994). "Eurochart Hot 100 Singles".
28. (March 26, 1994). "Adult Contemporary Europe Top 25".
29. (February 19, 1994). "EHR Top 40".
30. https://musiikkiarkisto.fi/oa/_tiedostot/julkaisut/sisaltaa-hitin.pdf {{Bare URL PDF. (August 2024)
31. (March 24, 1994). "Íslenski Listinn Topp 40 (24.03.1994 – 30.03.1994)". [[Dagblaðið Vísir]].
32. "Classifiche". [[Musica e dischi]].
33. (February 12, 1994). "The Airplay Chart".
34. "The ARIA Australian Top 100 Singles 1994". [[Australian Recording Industry Association.
35. (January 2, 1995). "Árslistinn 1994". Dagblaðið Vísir.
36. (January 7, 1995). "1994 – Singles".
37. (January 8, 1994). "Single Releases".
38. "New Release Summary – Product Available from: 14/2/1994 > Singles (from The ARIA Report Issue No. 209 – Week Ending 13th February 1994)". ARIA.
39. Hajari, Nisid. (July 26, 1996). "Music Capsule Review: Jawbox".
40. "A Tribute To Tori Amos – Songs Of A Goddess".
41. ''The Sideshow'', Episode 15. September 15, 2007.
42. (2010). "Broadcast Yourself".
43. Zuckerman, Esther. (March 24, 2023). "'Yellowjackets' Season 2 Premiere Recap: Best Friends Forever".
44. Tangcay, Jazz. (March 24, 2023). "'Yellowjackets' Music Supervisor on Why Tori Amos' 'Cornflake Girl' Was Perfect for Season 2 Premiere: 'It Deals With Betrayals Between Women'".
45. Bitran, Tara. (April 7, 2023). "Rock Out to the Angsty '90s Songs in the 'BEEF' Soundtrack. Music supervisor Tiffany Anders threw all her rules "out the window" for Lee Sung Jin's new series.".