Columbus Circle

History

The traffic circle, located at Eighth Avenue/Central Park West, Broadway, and 59th Street/Central Park South, was designed as part of Frederick Law Olmsted's 1857 vision for Central Park, which included a rotary on the southwest corner of the park. It abuts the Merchant's Gate, one of the park's eighteen major gates. Similar plazas were planned at the southeast corner of the park (now Grand Army Plaza), the northeast corner (Duke Ellington Circle), and the northwest corner (Frederick Douglass Circle). Clearing of the land area for the circle started in 1868. The actual circle was approved two years later. The Columbus Monument was placed at the center of the circle in 1892.

Columbus Circle was originally known generically as "The Circle". An 1871 account of the park referred to the roundabout as a "grand circle". After the 1892 installation of the Columbus Column in the circle's center, it became known as "Columbus Circle", although its other names were also used through the 1900s.

By 1901, construction on the first subway line of the Interborough Rapid Transit Company (now the IRT Broadway–Seventh Avenue Line, used by the ) required the excavation of the circle, and the column and streetcar tracks through the area were put on temporary wooden stilts. As part of the subway line's construction, the 59th Street–Columbus Circle station was built underneath the circle. During construction, traffic in the circle was so dangerous that the Municipal Art Society proposed redesigning the roundabout. By February 1904, the station underneath was largely complete, and service on the subway line began on October 27, 1904. The station only served local trains; express trains bypassed the station. The platforms of the IRT subway station were lengthened in 1957–1959, requiring further excavations around Columbus Circle. An additional subway line—the Independent Subway System (IND)'s Eighth Avenue Line, serving the present-day —was built starting in 1925. At Columbus Circle, workers had to be careful to not disrupt the existing IRT Broadway–Seventh Avenue Line or Columbus Circle overhead. The Columbus monument was shored up during construction, and obstructions to traffic were minimized. The line, which opened in 1932, contains a 4-track, 3-platform express station at 59th Street–Columbus Circle, underneath the original IRT station. The IND station were designed as a single transit hub under Columbus Circle.

Conversion to traffic circle

In November 1904, due to the high speeds of cars passing through the circle, the New York City Police Department added tightly spaced electric lights on the inner side of the circle, surrounding the column. The circle was altered in 1905 by William Phelps Eno, a businessman who pioneered many early innovations in road safety and traffic control. In a 1920 book, Eno writes that prior to the implementation of his plan, traffic went around the circle in both directions, causing accidents almost daily. The 1905 plan, which he regarded as temporary, created a counterclockwise traffic pattern with a "safety zone" in the center of the circle for cars stopping; however, the circle was too narrow for the normal flow of traffic. Eno also wrote of a permanent plan, with the safety zones on the outside as well as clearly delineated pedestrian crossings. The redesign marked the first true one-way traffic circle to be constructed anywhere, implementing the ideas of Eugène Hénard. In this second scheme, the public space within the circle, around the monument, was almost as small as the monument's base.

The rotary traffic plan was not successful. A New York Times article in June 1929 stated that the "Christopher Columbus [monument] is safe and serene, but he's the only thing in the Circle that is." At the time, there were eight entrance and exit points to Columbus Circle: two each from 59th Street/Central Park South, to the west and east; Broadway, to the northwest and southeast; Eighth Avenue/Central Park West, to the south and north; and within Central Park to the northeast. Moreover, streetcars on the former three streets did not go counterclockwise around the rotary, but rather, both tracks of all three streetcar routes went around one side of the monument, creating frequent conflicts between streetcars and automobiles using the rotary in opposite directions. The police officers patrolling the circle had to manage the 58,000 cars that entered Columbus Circle every 12 hours.

As part of a plan to reorganize traffic in the "Columbus-Central Park Zone", Eno's circular-traffic plan was abolished in November 1929, and traffic was allowed to go around the circle in both directions. Central Park West, a one-way street that formerly carried southbound traffic into the circle, was now one-way northbound. The bidirectional entrance roads into Central Park, which fed into northbound and eastbound West Drive, were both changed to one-way streets because West Drive had been changed from bidirectional to one-way southbound and eastbound. Traffic going straight through Columbus Circle was forced to go around the left side of the monument, while any traffic making turns from the circle had to go counterclockwise around the rotary using the right side.

Alterations

The bidirectional traffic pattern through Columbus Circle failed to eliminate congestion. In 1941, engineers with the New York City Parks Department and the Manhattan Borough President's office formed a tentative agreement to redesign Columbus Circle yet again. "Local" and "express" lanes would segregate north–south traffic passing within the circle. Local north–south traffic and all east–west traffic would go around the circle's perimeter in a counterclockwise direction, along a 45 ft roadway. Through north–south traffic on Broadway, Eighth Avenue, and Central Park West would use two 71 ft divided roadways with 5 ft landscaped medians, running in chords on either side of the Columbus monument. Traffic from southbound Broadway and northbound Eighth Avenue would use the western chord, and northbound Broadway and southbound Central Park West would use the eastern chord. The center of the circle would be refurbished with a tree-lined plaza, and pedestrian traffic from the north and south would be able to pass through the center of the circle. The exit into Columbus Circle from West Drive would be eliminated, and the entrance to West Drive would be relocated. In a related development, the 59th Street trolley route's tracks would be removed. This was crucial to the reorganization of the circle, as the trolley had already been discontinued.

The proposed reorganization of Columbus Circle was widely praised by civic groups and city officials. On the other hand, William Phelps Eno advocated for a return to his original 1905 proposal. However, the plan still had some issues, the largest of which was that traffic traveling on Broadway in either direction would be routed onto Eighth Avenue or Central Park West, and vice versa. The reconfiguration of the circle was deferred due to World War II. The trolley routes that ran through Columbus Circle were discontinued in 1946, but the bus routes that replaced the trolley lines took the same convoluted paths through the circle. In June 1949, it was announced that the reconstruction of Columbus Circle would finally begin. Work on removing the abandoned trolley tracks commenced in August. In conjunction with Columbus Circle's rehabilitation, the New York City Department of Transportation designed a variable traffic light system for the circle. The project was originally set to be complete by November 1949 at a cost of $100,000. However, delays arose due to the need to maintain traffic flows through the circle during construction. The project was ultimately completed that December.

The entirety of Eighth Avenue south of Columbus Circle was converted to northbound-only traffic in 1950. In 1956, in preparation for the opening of the New York Coliseum on Columbus Circle's west side, traffic on Central Park West and Broadway was rearranged. Central Park West was made northbound-only for a short segment north of the circle, and two blocks of Broadway south of the circle were converted to southbound-only. A new northbound roadway was cut through the southern tip of the center traffic island that contained the statue, from Eighth Avenue to the eastern chord. At the same time, the eastern chord was converted to northbound-only.

1990s and 2000s renovation

By the late 20th century, it was regarded as one of the most inhospitable of the city's major intersections, as the interior circle was being used for motorcycle parking, and the circle as a whole was hard for pedestrians to cross. In 1979, noted architecture critic Paul Goldberger said that the intersection was "a chaotic jumble of streets that can be crossed in about 50 different ways—all of them wrong." In 1987, the city awarded a $20 million contract to Olin Partnership and Vollmer Associates to create a new design for the circle.

The circle was refurbished in 1991–1992 as part of the 500th-anniversary celebration of Columbus's arrival in the Americas. In 1998, as a result of the study, the circular-traffic plan was reinstated, with all traffic going around the circle in a counterclockwise direction. The center of the circle was planned for further renovations, with a proposed park 200 ft across. The design for a full renovation of the circle was finalized in 2001. The project started in 2003, and was completed in 2005. It included a new water fountain by Water Entertainment Technologies, who also designed the Fountains of Bellagio; benches made of ipe wood; and plantings encircling the monument. The fountain, the main part of the reconstructed circle, contains 99 jets that periodically change in force and speed, with effects ranging between "swollen river, a rushing brook, a driving rain or a gentle shower". The inner circle is about 36000 sqft, while the outer circle is around 148000 sqft. The redesign was the recipient of the 2006 American Society of Landscape Architects' General Design Award Of Honor. In 2007 Columbus Circle was awarded the Rudy Bruner Award for Urban Excellence silver medal.

Monument

Main article: Columbus Monument (New York City)

The Columbus Monument, a 76 ft column installed at the center of Columbus Circle, consists of a 14 ft marble statue of Columbus atop a 27.5 ft granite rostral column on a four-stepped granite pedestal. Created by Italian sculptor Gaetano Russo, the monument was installed at the center of the circle in 1892. It is listed on the National Register of Historic Places.

Neighborhood

The five streets radiating from the circle separate the immediate surrounding area into five distinct portions.

In the early 20th century, much of the development around Columbus Circle was spurred by magazine publisher William Randolph Hearst, who acquired several plots before he ultimately erected the Hearst Magazine Building at Eighth Avenue and 57th Street in 1928. Hearst had envisioned the creation of a large Midtown headquarters for his company near Columbus Circle, in the belief that the area would become the city's next large entertainment district. By the late 1920s, Hearst was acquiring large amounts of land in the area in an effort to create a "Hearst Plaza" near Columbus Circle. The Hearst Magazine Building, later expanded into the Hearst Tower, is the only remnant of this scheme, the other parts of the proposal having collapsed in the Great Depression.

West

To the west of the circle is a superblock spanning two streets, bounded by Broadway, 60th Street, Ninth Avenue, 58th Street, and Eighth Avenue. The superblock was formerly two separate blocks. In 1901 the first theatre built in the Columbus Circle area, the Circle Theatre, was built. From 1902 to 1954, the Majestic Theatre occupied the more southerly of the two blocks.

Robert Moses closed and eliminated that block of 59th Street during the New York Coliseum's construction from 1954 to 1956. The construction project, in turn, was the culmination of an effort to remove San Juan Hill, the slum that had been located at the site. Until the Jacob K. Javits Convention Center was built in Hell's Kitchen in the 1980s, the Coliseum was the primary event venue for New York City. By 1985, there were plans to replace the Coliseum, and after a series of delays, the Coliseum was demolished in 2000.

Since 2003, the site has been occupied by Deutsche Bank Center (originally Time Warner Center). The center consists of a pair of 750 ft towers 53 stories high. The complex also hosts the Shops at Columbus Circle mall, Jazz at Lincoln Center, the New York City studio headquarters of CNN, and the Mandarin Oriental, New York hotel. The mall inside the complex includes prestigious restaurants in the center such as Bad Roman, Per Se, and Masa.

North

The north side of Columbus Circle is bounded by Broadway, Central Park West, and 61st Street. In 1911, Hearst bought this city block. The plot was developed with a three-story building by 1914, designed by Charles E. Birge. Its superstructure was designed to support the weight of a 30-story tower that was never built.

The 44-story Gulf and Western Building (later the Trump International Hotel and Tower) was completed on the site in 1969 or 1970. It served in this capacity until the conglomerate filed for bankruptcy in 1991. In 1994, Donald Trump announced his plans to convert the building into a mixed-purpose hotel and condominium tower. Renovations started in 1995, and were completed by 1997. The building was stripped to its steel skeleton and reclad in a new facade, becoming the Trump International Hotel and Tower. The steel globe outside the building was installed in this renovation.

Northeast

On the northeast lies the Merchant's Gate to Central Park, dominated by the USS Maine National Monument. The USS Maine monument was designed by Harold Van Buren Magonigle and sculpted by Attilio Piccirilli, who did the colossal group and figures, and Charles Keck, who was responsible for the "In Memoriam" plaque. An imposing Beaux-Arts edifice of marble and gilded bronze, it was dedicated in 1913 and was funded by Hearst. The statue is a memorial to sailors killed aboard the battleship USS Maine, whose mysterious 1898 explosion in Havana harbor precipitated the Spanish–American War.

South

Actors' Equity was founded in 1913 in the old Pabst Grand Circle Hotel, on the southern side of the circle.

The original structure at 2 Columbus Circle was torn down in 1960. It was replaced by 2 Columbus Circle, an International Modernist tower designed by architect Edward Durrell Stone to house the Huntington Hartford Gallery of Modern Art. Vacated when the city's Department of Cultural Affairs departed in 1998, 2 Columbus Circle was listed as one of the World Monuments Fund's "100 most endangered sites" in 2006. After a renovation by architect Brad Cloepfil, the building became the new home of the Museum of Arts and Design in 2008. Its radical transformation was controversial for the failure of the city's Landmarks Preservation Commission to hold hearings on its worthiness for designation.

Southeast

Several buildings are on the block bordering the circle's southeast section. 240 Central Park South, a balconied moderne apartment building across Broadway from the museum, is directly on the southeast corner of the circle. Built between 1939 and 1940 to designs by Albert Mayer and Julian Whittlesey, it is a city-designated landmark and a National Registered Historic Place. 240 Central Park South has 28 stories across two apartment blocks, and is variously quoted as having either 325, 326, or 327 apartments. The building contains several roof gardens, and from the outset, was marketed toward people who wanted suburban lifestyles.

On Central Park South, just east of 240 Central Park South, is the Gainsborough Studios. Designed by Charles W. Buckham, it was built between 1907 and 1908 as artists' cooperative housing, and rises 16 stories with 34 studio units, some of them double-story units. The facade has a bust of the English painter Thomas Gainsborough, a bas-relief by Isidore Konti, and tile murals by Henry Chapman Mercer. It is a New York City designated landmark.

To the east of 240 Central Park South and the Gainsborough Studios is 220 Central Park South, a 70-story residential skyscraper designed by Robert A.M. Stern Architects and SLCE Architects, and completed in 2019. The building contains some of the most expensive residences ever sold in New York City.

On 58th Street, east of 220 Central Park South, are two New York City designated landmarks: the Helen Miller Gould Stable and the firehouse of Engine Company 23. The four-story horse stable, at 213 West 58th Street, was designed by York and Sawyer in the French Renaissance style for wealthy philanthropist Helen Miller Gould. Completed in 1902–1903 on the site of an existing stable, the stable became Allan Murray's shoe shop in the 1950s, and has served as the Unity Center of Practical Christianity since 1982. It has a limestone base with a large entrance arch; a limestone-and-brick facade on the second and third stories; a bracketed cornice over the third story; and a hip roof on the fourth story, with a dormer window. The stable was one of several on that block of West 58th Street in the early 20th century, and is the only remaining former stable on the block.

The adjoining firehouse of Engine Company 23, at 215 West 58th Street, was designed by Alexander H. Stevens (the New York City Fire Department's superintendent of buildings) in the Beaux-Arts style. It was constructed between 1905 and 1906 to replace a former firehouse at 233 West 58th Street, now taken up by the 240 Central Park South apartment building. The design contains an arched fire truck entrance at ground level; a limestone-and-brick facade on the second and third stories, with two small windows flanking a large window on each story; a bracket above the second story; and a parapet atop the third story. The building remains an active firehouse of the FDNY.

3, 4, 5, and 6 Columbus Circle

3, 4, 5, and 6 Columbus Circle are the numbers given to four buildings on the south side of 58th Street. From east to west, the buildings are numbered 5, 3, 4, and 6 Columbus Circle.

5 Columbus Circle (also known by its address, 1790 Broadway), is a 286 ft, 20-story tower on the southeast corner of Broadway and 58th Street. It was originally built as the headquarters of the United States Rubber Company (U.S. Rubber) in 1912. It was part of Broadway's "Automobile Row" during the early 20th century. The lobby contains part of a flagship store for Nordstrom, which extends into the Central Park Tower and 1776 Broadway.

Between Eighth Avenue and Broadway on the south side of 58th Street is 3 Columbus Circle (also 1775 Broadway), a 310 ft, 26-story tower. It is occupied by Young & Rubicam, Bank of America, Chase Bank, and Gilder Gagnon Howe & Co. The tower sits atop a 3-story structure called the Colonnade Building. The first three stories were built in 1923 and the top 23 stories were added in 1927–1928. During the expansion, the original building's three-story Ionic supports were kept. The new expansion, designed by Shreve & Lamb, hosted General Motors' headquarters from 1927 to 1968. In 1969, Midtown Realty purchased the building's lease, and in 1980, acquired the land. Half of the building was leased by Bankers Trust until the late 1980s, and Newsweek leased a third of the building from 1994 until 2006. When the Moinian Group purchased the building in 2000, the building assumed its current name; a subsequent renovation refurbished the exterior and removed all remnants of the Colonnade Building. A neon sign for CNN was located on the roof of the building from the mid-2000s to 2015. A Nordstrom annex is at the base of 3 Columbus Circle.

4 Columbus Circle, an eight-story low-rise located at 989 Eighth Avenue at the southwest corner of the intersection with 58th Street, was built in the late 1980s. Swanke Hayden Connell Architects designed the building, which houses the furniture company Steelcase on the upper floors and a Duane Reade and a Starbucks on the ground floor. Cerberus Capital Management bought the building in 2006 for $82.9 million. In 2011, it was sold to German real estate firm GLL Real Estate Partners for $96.5 million.

Directly to the west is 6 Columbus Circle, an 88-room, 12-floor boutique hotel called 6 Columbus. Acquired by the Pomeranc Group in 2007, the hotel was put on sale in December 2015. A 700 ft tower is planned for the site.

Transportation

The buses all serve the circle, with the M5, M7, M20 and M104 providing through service and the southbound M10 terminating near the circle. Under the circle is the New York City Subway's 59th Street–Columbus Circle station, served by the .

Cultural significance

Geographic center

Columbus Circle is the traditional municipal zero-mile point from which all official city distances are measured, although Google Maps uses New York City Hall for this purpose. For decades, Hagstrom sold maps that showed the areas within 25 mi or 75 mi from Columbus Circle.

The travel area for recipients of a C-2 visa, which is issued for the purpose of immediate and continuous transit to or from the headquarters of the United Nations, is limited to a 25-mile radius of Columbus Circle. The same circle coincidentally defines the city's "film zone" that local unions operate in, a counterpart to Los Angeles' studio zone. The New York City government employee handbook considers a trip beyond a 75-mile radius from Columbus Circle as long-distance travel.

As a center for soapbox orators

The circle became known as a center for soapbox orators in the early-mid 20th century, comparable to Speakers Corner in London. It became a home particularly for non-leftists in contrast to Union Square, and for a time in the late 1930s it became a home to a number of far right speakers. The area sometimes had a poor reputation for cranks and street preachers, the "lunatic fringe whose tub-thumping make a nightmare of Columbus Circle" condemned by a New York Court of Appeals ruling in a case related to elsewhere in the city, that prompted mid-20th century configurations, but was also sometimes showcased by the national government as a rambunctious symbol of American freedom of speech.

In popular culture

Columbus Circle was featured in the 1954 romantic comedy film It Should Happen to You, in which Judy Holliday's character, Gladys Glover, began her quest for fame by renting a large billboard overlooking Columbus Circle. The USS Maine Memorial, was featured in the 1976 movie Taxi Driver, where Robert De Niro's character was thwarted in an attempt to assassinate a presidential nominee. Columbus Circle was featured in the 1984 movie Ghostbusters as the place where the Stay Puft Marshmallow Man manifests and then walks up Central Park West. The shooting of Joseph Colombo in Columbus Circle by Jerome A. Johnson in 1971 was featured in the 2019 film The Irishman. Starting in seasons 6 of the TV show The Venture Bros., the Venture family relocates to a skyscraper located on Columbus Circle.

Gallery

File:Museum of Arts and Design (MAD) - NYC (51395616531).jpg|The Museum of Arts & Design at 2 Columbus Circle File:USS Maine National Monument.jpg|The USS Maine National Monument at the Merchant's Gate entrance to Central Park File:4118-NYC-Columbus Circle.JPG|The Trump International Hotel and Tower File:Time Warner Center May 2010.JPG|The Deutsche Bank Center, which replaced the New York Coliseum, while it was still known as the Time Warner Center File:Looking south along 8th Avenue from Columbus Circle.jpg|220 Central Park South (2018) rises above 240 Central Park South (1939)

References

Explanatory notes

Citations

Bibliography

References

1. "NYC Planning {{!}} Community Profiles". New York City Department of City Planning.
2. "NYC Planning {{!}} Community Profiles". New York City Department of City Planning.
3. Heckscher, M.H.. (2008). "Creating Central Park". Metropolitan Museum of Art.
4. (October 13, 1892). "The Voyager in Marble; Unveiling of the Great Columbus Monument". The New York Times.
5. (October 13, 1892). "Columbus is Unveiled by a Little Girl". New York Herald.
6. {{harvnb. Jackson. 2010
7. (1869). "Minutes of Proceedings of the Board of Commissioners of the Central Park for the Year Ending April 30 ...". Wm. C. Bryant & Company, printers.
8. (1871). "The Metropolis Explained and Illustrated in Familiar Form ...". Devlin & Company.
9. {{Cite naming
10. (1902). "Improving Columbus Circle.". The New York Times.
11. (May 26, 1901). "Scenes Along the Route of the Tunnel; How Work Is Carried on Under the Columbus Column". The New York Times.
12. {{harvnb. Jackson. 2010
13. (April 16, 1903). "Eighth Avenue Circle". The New York Times.
14. (February 1, 1904). "By Handcar Through the Subway—End of the Great Engineering Feat Now in Sight". The Globe and Commercial Advertiser.
15. (1918). "Fifty Years of Rapid Transit — 1864 to 1917". Law Printing.
16. (October 27, 1904). "Subway Opening to-day With Simple Ceremony; Exercises at One o'Clock; Public to be Admitted at Seven". The New York Times.
17. Katz, Ralph. (May 10, 1958). "IRT to Complete Repairs in a Year; Broadway Express Will Be Modified and Stations Revamped by June".
18. Warner, Arthur. (November 22, 1931). "The City's New Underground Province; The Eighth Avenue Subway Will Be Not Only a Transit Line but a Centre for the Shopper".
19. Collins, F.a.. (October 10, 1926). "New Subway Burrows Under New York; Old Open Trench Methods No Longer Employed".
20. (September 9, 1932). "City to Open Subway in 8th Av. Tonight; Crowds Visit Tube".
21. (April 24, 1927). "Plan Huge Centre of Subway Traffic; Transit Lines Will Build Dual Station at Columbus Circle Four Blocks in Length".
22. (November 15, 1904). "Lane of Electric Lights; Police Plan Measure for Vehicles in the Columbus Circle.". The New York Times.
23. Henebery, Ann. [https://www.enotrans.org/article/the-rules-of-the-road-then-versus-now/ "The Rules of the Road: Then Versus Now"] {{Webarchive. link. (October 10, 2017, [[Eno Center for Transportation]], October 6, 2015. Accessed October 9, 2017. "William P. Eno is internationally recognized as an original pioneer of traffic regulation and safety.... He was dubbed the 'Father of Traffic Safety' and many of the traffic-flow innovations that we now take for granted were a result of Eno's hard work. He is credited with designing Columbus Circle in New York City and the traffic circle surrounding the Arc de Triomphe in Paris.")
24. Eno, William P.. (1920). "The Science of Highway Traffic Regulation: 1899–1920". Brentano's.
25. Petroski, Henry. (2016). "The Road Taken: The History and Future of America's Infrastructure". Bloomsbury Publishing USA.
26. (1917). "Municipal Engineering". Municipal Engineering Company.
27. Dunlap, David W.. (August 4, 2005). "An Island of Sanctuary in the Traffic Stream". The New York Times.
28. (June 30, 1929). "Columbus Circle a Traffic Maze; Intersecting Streets and Car Tracks Make Orderly Movement Impossible".
29. (November 26, 1929). "Whalen Sets Traffic Plans". Yonkers Statesman.
30. (November 30, 1929). "Whalen Installs New Traffic Rules; He Takes Up Post in Columbus Circle to See Effect of Ending 'Rotary' Travel".
31. (May 9, 1941). "Board to Act on Traffic Jam". New York Sun.
32. (May 9, 1941). "Columbus Circle Gets Traffic Plan to End Bottleneck".
33. (May 10, 1941). "Many Back Plan to Beautify Circle; City Officials and Civic Units Praise Idea as Benefit to Realty and Traffic".
34. (June 8, 1941). "Traffic Expert Advocates Change in Proposal at Columbus Circle".
35. Ingraham, Joseph C.. (November 6, 1949). "Columbus Circle Traffic Puzzle is Redrawn".
36. (June 16, 1949). "Columbus Circle to Be Rearranged With 5 Roadways and 5 'Islands'; 45-Foot Wide Perimeter Strip and Four Cross Lanes are Planned to Expedite Traffich".
37. (August 15, 1949). "Columbus Circle's Traffic Puzzle To Be Simplified by New Design".
38. (December 6, 1949). "Traffic Is Faster, Smoother in Test Of Columbus Circle's Rotary Plan".
39. Ingraham, Joseph C.. (December 30, 1950). "More One-Way Avenues Set As City Speeds Defense Plan".
40. Ingraham, Joseph C.. (February 20, 1956). "Columbus Circle Traffic Will Shift; Changes Will Include New Road to Ease Jam at Coliseum". The New York Times.
41. Lombino, David. (June 28, 2005). "Two Years and $20M Later, Traffic-Plagued Columbus Circle Near Completion".
42. Newman, Andy. (August 11, 1998). "Traffic on Columbus Circle Finally Comes, Well, Full Circle". The New York Times.
43. (2006). "ASLA 2006 Professional Awards". American Society of Landscape Architects.
44. (2008). "Silver Medal Winner – Columbus Circle – New York, New York". Bruner Foundation.
45. (September 5, 1892). "Italy's Gift Is Here". The Press.
46. (June 13, 1892). "Columbus Memorials.; Three of Them Soon to Be Presented to This City.". The New York Times.
47. "New York – Columbus Monument".
48. (November 23, 2018). "Weekly List 20181123". [[U.S. National Park Service]].
49. {{Cite NYCS map. neighborhood. Midtown West
50. "Columbus Cir, New York, NY".
51. (February 16, 1988). "Hearst Magazine Building". [[New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission]].
52. (November 29, 1903). "In the Real Estate Field.; Week of Interesting Developments". The New York Times.
53. (May 18, 1921). "Plans Skyscraper in Columbus Circle; W. R. Hearst Finally Completes the Assembly of Plot Containing 70,000 Square Feet". The New York Times.
54. {{Cite New York 1930
55. Swanberg, William Andrew. (1961). "Citizen Hearst: A Biography of William Randolph Hearst". Scribner.
56. {{harvnb. Jackson. 2010
57. (1996). "The Papers of Will Rogers: Wild West and vaudeville : April 1904-September 1908". [[University of Oklahoma Press]].
58. (January 28, 1949). "International Theatre in New York, NY".
59. Gray, Christopher. (April 26, 1987). "The Coliseum; The 'Hybrid Pseudo-Modern' on Columbus Circle". The New York Times.
60. Hudson, Edward. (April 13, 1954). "Coliseum is Begun After 8-year Lag". The New York Times.
61. Blair, William G.. (May 3, 1985). "14 Plans for Coliseum Site Sent to City and M.T.A.". The New York Times.
62. Dunlap, David W.. (February 20, 2000). "Built, but Not Destined, to Last; A Robert Moses Legacy, Coliseum Is Coming Down". The New York Times.
63. Dunlap, David W.. (January 19, 2003). "A Vertical Neighborhood Takes Shape". The New York Times.
64. (May 25, 2021). "Time Warner Center renamed Deutsche Bank Center".
65. Jacobs, Karrie. (April 21, 2009). "The New Time Warner Center".
66. Crow, Kelly. (December 9, 2001). "The Newest Tower: Working 24/7". The New York Times.
67. {{harvnb. Jackson. 2010
68. (February 14, 2023). "Bad Roman, Offering Modern Italian, Opens in Columbus Circle". The New York Times.
69. Ensminger, Kris. (October 9, 2005). "Columbus Circle: A New World". The New York Times.
70. (2017). "Dining". The Shops at Columbus Circle.
71. (June 29, 1911). "Hearst Buys Block in Columbus Circle; Site of Old Durland Riding Academy Taken for a Building for His Newspapers". The New York Times.
72. (October 4, 1914). "W. R. Hearst's Columbus Circle Building". The New York Times.
73. (August 22, 1914). "Renewed Activity at Columbus Circle". The Real Estate Record: Real Estate Record and Builders' Guide.
74. {{harvnb. White. Willensky. Leadon. 2010
75. Rothstein, Mervyn. (January 31, 1993). "Commercial Property: The Gulf ands Western Building; Twisting in the Wind On Columbus Circle". The New York Times.
76. Dunlap, David W.. (July 17, 1994). "For a Troubled Building, a New Twist". The New York Times.
77. Muschamp, Herbert. (June 21, 1995). "Trump Tries to Convert 50s Style Into 90s Gold; Makeover Starts on Columbus Circle Hotel". The New York Times.
78. (January 19, 1997). "New Trump Hotel On Central Park". The New York Times.
79. Pogrebin, Robin. (April 25, 1996). "52-Story Comeback Is So Very Trump;Columbus Circle Tower Proclaims That Modesty Is an Overrated Virtue". The New York Times.
80. Dunlap, David W.. (October 26, 2016). "Trump Wanted His Name Across the Earth. New York City Said No.". The New York Times.
81. (May 25, 1913). "Monument to Maine Heroes Ready for Unveiling; Distinguished Guests and Imposing Ceremonies at the Dedication on Memorial Day". The New York Times.
82. [https://www.nycgovparks.org/parks/central-park/monuments/966 USS Maine National Monument] {{Webarchive. link. (September 20, 2017, [[New York City Department of Parks and Recreation]]. Accessed October 9, 2017.)
83. Harding, Alfred. (May 27, 1934). "After a Stormy Youth Equity Comes of Age; Equity Reaches the Age of Twenty-One". The New York Times.
84. Muschamp, Herbert. (January 8, 2006). "The Secret History of 2 Columbus Circle". The New York Times.
85. (Summer 2005). "100 Most Endangered Sites 2006". World Monuments Fund.
86. {{harvnb. White. Willensky. Leadon. 2010
87. {{harvnb. Jackson. 2010
88. Ouroussoff, Nicolai. (September 25, 2008). "Brad Cloepfil's Museum of Arts and Design Gives a Building a New Face and Restores Its Original Mission". The New York Times.
89. Pogrebin, Robin. (December 1, 2008). "Preservation and Development, Engaged in a Delicate Dance". [[The New York Times]].
90. Wolfe, Tom. (July 4, 2005). "The 2 Columbus Circle Game".
91. Hales, Linda. (June 13, 2004). "Columbus Circle site sets off a controversy". Washington Post.
92. {{harvnb. White. Willensky. Leadon. 2010
93. (April 3, 2009). "Historic Structures Report: 240 Central Park South". [[National Register of Historic Places]], [[National Park Service]].
94. {{Cite nycland
95. Gray, Christopher. (February 9, 1997). "A Model of High-Density Residential Development". The New York Times.
96. (June 25, 2002). "240 Central Park South". [[New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission]].
97. Goldberger, Paul. (October 6, 1977). "The City's Top 10 Apartment Buildings". The New York Times.
98. (January 21, 1940). "House of Wings Rising Opposite Central Park S: Largest Suite Building in Construction in City To Be Completed in June". New York Herald Tribune.
99. "Gainsborough Studios". Art Nerd New York.
100. (February 16, 1988). "Gainsborough Studios". [[New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission]].
101. Stephens, Suzanne. (September 15, 1988). "Currents; The Old Is Made New Again". The New York Times.
102. "220 Central Park South – The Skyscraper Center". skyscrapercenter.com.
103. "220 Central Park South". Emporis.
104. "The Villas at 220 Central Park South". Emporis.
105. Clarke, Katherine. (November 2, 2018). "As Manhattan's Most Secretive Skyscraper Rises, a Super-Elite Clientele Emerges". Wall Street Journal.
106. Gray, Christopher. (December 5, 2008). "Where the Horses Slept and the Cars Idled)". The New York Times.
107. (August 29, 1989). "(Former) Helen Miller Gould Stable". [[New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission]].
108. (August 29, 1989). "Engine Company Number 23". [[New York City Landmarks Preservation Commission]].
109. {{cite FDNY locations
110. "Engine Company 23".
111. Neamt, Ioana. (February 18, 2016). "Nordstrom's Future New York Store is an Eyecatcher".
112. "U.S. Rubber Company Building, New York City".
113. Gray, Christopher. (November 26, 1989). "Streetscapes: U.S. Rubber Company Building; Restoring Luster to a 1912 Lady". The New York Times.
114. Dunlap, David W.. (July 7, 2000). "Street of Automotive Dreams". The New York Times.
115. Wilson, Reid. (February 12, 2016). "Official Renderings Revealed Of Nordstrom Tower's Retail Base Under Construction At 217 West 57th Street". New York YIMBY.
116. Warerkar, Tanay. (February 12, 2016). "Central Park Tower's Nordstrom Flagship Gets Its First Render". Curbed NY.
117. "3 Columbus Circle, New York City".
118. "3 Columbus Circle". The Real Deal New York.
119. Dunlap, David W.. (February 20, 2008). "Switching Brands in the Skyline". The New York Times.
120. (February 27, 1921). "Colonnade Building at Columbus Circle Will Be Important Commercial Improvement". The New York Times.
121. {{harvnb. White. Willensky. Leadon. 2010
122. (February 9, 1926). "Noyes & Co. Close $24,000,000 Deal". Brooklyn Standard Union.
123. Oser, Alan S.. (September 15, 1999). "Commercial Real Estate; Developer Is Stepping Up Its Activity in West Midtown Area". The New York Times.
124. Clarke, Katherine. (July 30, 2015). "Neon CNN sign removed from Columbus Circle perch after 10 years". NY Daily News.
125. Piskora, Beth. (August 26, 1999). "Newsweek Building Sold for $140 Million". New York Post.
126. Cuozzo, Steve. (December 27, 2007). "Broadway Bonanza". New York Post.
127. Strassel, Kimberley A.. (August 25, 1999). "David Werner Is Set to Purchase Manhattan's Newsweek Building". Wall Street Journal.
128. "4 Columbus Circle". The Real Deal New York.
129. Fung, Amanda. (August 3, 2011). "Germans pay $96.5M for 4 Columbus Circle". Crain's New York Business.
130. Conlin, Jennifer. (July 1, 2007). "Anticipation Builds, and Builds Some More, for Latest Chic New York Hotel". The New York Times.
131. Hylton, Ondel. (January 12, 2016). "See How 6 Columbus Circle Could Change the Central Park Skyline".
132. Schram, Lauren Elkies. (December 1, 2015). "6 Columbus Circle Hotel Site Hits the Market, Expected to Fetch $88.9M". Commercial Observer.
133. Baird-Remba, Rebecca. (January 8, 2016). "Vision: A 700-Foot-Tall Tower for 6 Columbus Circle?". New York YIMBY.
134. {{cite NYC bus map. M
135. {{NYCS const. map
136. Garlock, Stephanie. (June 27, 2014). "The Sign Says You've Got 72 Miles to Go Before the End of Your Road Trip. It's Lying.". Bloomberg.
137. (1984). "Hagstrom 25-mile radius from Columbus Circle, New York City". Hagstrom Map Co.
138. Company, Hagstrom Map. (March 1, 2006). "Hagstrom 75-Mile Radius Map: From Columbus Circle, NYC". Hagstrom Map Company, Incorporated.
139. Shribman, David. (June 8, 1982). "Justice Dept. Denies 315 Visas for U.N. Disarmament Session". The New York Times.
140. Prevost, Lisa. (February 16, 2003). "Lights! Camera! Action! Location Fees!". The New York Times.
141. "25 Mile Studio Zone Map".
142. (2005). "Theatrical Agreement".
143. (March 2015). "Economic & Fiscal Impact of the Nassau County Film Industry".
144. (August 21, 2017). "FAQs: Directive #6 – Travel, Meals, Lodging, and Miscellaneous Agency Expenses".
145. (May 2016). "City Vehicle Driver Handbook".
146. Emery, Steuart M.. (October 11, 1925). "Hyde Park Has a Rival in New York; Soap-Box Nights in Columbus Circle". The New York Times.
147. Stevenson, L.L.. (April 20, 1939). "Lights of New York". San Jose Evening News.
148. Carleton, William G.. (1960). "The Passing of Bughouse Square". The Antioch Review.
149. Appeals, New York (State) Court of. (1948). "New York Court of Appeals. Records and Briefs.".
150. Palmer, Alfred T.. (1941). "The four freedoms. Freedom of speech is still the way of the land. Here is Columbus Circle, famous New York promenade' a "soap box" orator is giving forth his theories. A few steps away may be another unsung genius who, likely as not, will proceed to tear down everything his predecessor has said".
151. United States. War Department. (1952). "Armed Forces Talk". War Department.
152. (July 14, 2016). "Judy Holliday in It Should Happen to You".
153. Carr, Nick. (December 6, 2017). "New York, You've Changed: Taxi Driver, Part III". [[Huffington Post]].
154. "otsony".
155. (August 2023). "Martin Scorsese's The Irishman Glosses Over a Key Point".
156. Bruney, Gabrielle. (December 1, 2019). "Here's the True Story of 'Crazy Joe' Gallo From 'The Irishman'".
157. Mattise, Nathan. (January 30, 2016). "The Venture Bros. blew up its universe, moved to NYC—and stayed as fun as ever".