Chitpavan Brahmins

Etymology and origin

The Chitpavans are also known as Kokanastha Brahmins.

The etymology of their name is given in a legendary myth of the chapter citpāvanabrāhmaṇotpattiḥ i.e. “Origin of the Citpāvan brahmins” in the Hindu Sanskrit scripture Sahyadrikhanda of the Skanda Purana. According to this chapter, Parashurama, the sixth incarnation of God Vishnu, who could not find any Brahmins in Konkan to perform rituals for him, found sixty fishermen who had gathered near a funeral pyre near the ocean shore. These sixty fisherman families were purified and Sanskritized to Brahminhood. Since the funeral pyre is called Chita and pure as pavana, the community was henceforth known by the name *Chitapavan * or "purified at the location of a funeral pyre". However, 'Chita' also means 'mind' in Sanskrit and the Chitapavans prefer "pure of mind" instead of "pure from the pyre". One scholar suggests that the author of the current version was a Deshastha Brahmin and there were earlier suggestions of similarity with the Sadbodhacintāmaṇi published by the community of goldsmiths from Bombay. Madhav Deshpande(2010) rejects these suggestions because it is inconceivable that a Deshastha brahmin would write a "pro-Saraswat" text as there was dislike of the Gaud Saraswats of the west coast of India by the Deshasthas as well as the fact that the Deshastha, Chitpavans and Karhade Brahmin unanimously rejected the Brahmin status claim of the Gaud Saraswat Brahmins (Shenvi) of the western coast of Maharashtra. The Kulavruttanta of the Khare (Chitpavan) family prefers a modified version of the scripture. They state that fourteen dead-bodies were purified by Parshurama. Since "Chiplun pleased Paraśurāma's heart", the Brahmins of that place received the name cittapāvana.

The Chitpavan story of shipwrecked people is similar to the legendary arrival of Bene Israel Jews in the Raigad district. According to the historian Roshen Dalal, similarities between the legends may be due to a connection between the Chitpavans and the Bene Israel communities. The Bene Israel, who also settled in Konkan, claim that the Chitpavans are also of Jewish origin. According to their version, these Jews later adopted Hinduism and later were called Chitpavans by the people in the area. A member of the community, B.J Israel, noted that there might be truth in his community's claim that they and Chitpavans belong to the same stock but there is also a possibility that the Puranic legend of Chitpavan origin had been appropriated by his community to account for their presence on the coast. Yulia Egorova notes that the attempts of Bene-Israel, whose lifestyle was closer to Agriss, but "showed an interest in being associated with" Chitpavan Brahmins who were high locally is similar to the concept of Sanskritisation in which low caste Hindus try to elevate their status. Oroon.K.Ghosh believes that the Chitpavans themselves were Sanskritized into Brahminhood under the rule of the Satavahana dynasty.

Historian Jadunath Sarkar opines that the Chitpavans had a non-Indian origin and bases his views on traditions and inscriptions. Indologist Johannes Bronkhorst writes that there is a belief that Chitpavans are sometimes considered to be people of non-Indian origin who later became Brahmins. Historian O'Hanlon states that there are allegations that Chitpavan are progeny of Arab sailors, and their historic practice of taking bride price was at odds with the standard practice of Kanyadana, or giving a daughter away. Maureen L. P. Patterson writes that the Konkan region witnessed the immigration of groups, such as the Bene Israel, Parsis, Kudaldeshkar Gaud Brahmins, Gaud Saraswat Brahmins, and Chitpavan Brahmins. Each of these arrived at different time, they settled in different parts of the region and there was little mingling between them. The Chitpavans were apparently the last major community to arrive there and consequently the area in which they settled, around Ratnagiri, was the least fertile and had few good ports for trading.

In ancient times, the Chitpavans were employed as messengers and spies. Later, with the rise of the Chitpavan Peshwa in the 18th century they began migrating to Pune and found employment as military men, diplomats and clerks in the Peshwa administration. A 1763–64 document shows that at least 67% of the clerks at the time were Chitpavans.

History

Rise during the Maratha rule

Main article: Maratha Empire, Peshwa

Very little is known of the Chitpavans before 1707 CE Balaji Vishwanth Bhat, a Chitpavan arrived from Ratnagiri to the Pune-Satara area. He was brought there on the basis of his reputation of being an efficient administrator. He quickly gained the attention of Chhatrapati Shahu. Balaji's work so pleased the Chhatrapati that he was appointed the Peshwa or Prime Minister in 1713. He ran a well-organised administration and, by the time of his death in 1720, he had laid the groundwork for the expansion of the Maratha Empire. Since this time until the fall of the Maratha Empire, the seat of the Peshwa would be held by the members of the Bhat family.

With the ascension of Balaji Baji Rao and his family to the supreme authority of the Maratha Empire, Chitpavan immigrants began arriving en masse from the Konkan to Pune where the Peshwa offered all important offices to his fellow caste members. The Chitpavan kin were rewarded with tax relief and grants of land. In 1762-63, Azad Bilgrami wrote:

On the other hand, Mahars were subjected to degradation during the rule of the Peshwas, who treated them as untouchables. Historians cite nepotism and corruption as causes of the fall of the Maratha Empire in 1818. Richard Maxwell Eaton states that this rise of the Chitpavans is a classic example of social rank rising with political fortune.

British Era

After the fall of the Maratha Empire in 1818, the Chitpavans lost their political dominance to the British. The British would not subsidise the Chitpavans on the same scale that their caste-fellow, the Peshwas, had done in the past. Pay and power was now significantly reduced. Poorer Chitpavan students adapted and started learning English because of better opportunities in the British administration. As per the 1901 census, about 5% of the Pune population was Brahmin and about 27% of them were Chitpavans.

Some of the prominent figures in the Hindu reform movements of the 19th and 20th centuries came from the Chitpavan Brahmin community. These included Dhondo Keshav Karve, Justice Mahadev Govind Ranade, Vinayak Damodar Savarkar, Gopal Ganesh Agarkar, Vinoba Bhave.

Some of the strongest resistance to change came from the very same community. The vanguard and the old guard clashed many times. D. K. Karve was ostracised. Even Tilak offered penance for breaking caste or religious rules. One was for taking tea at Poona Christian mission in 1892 and the second was going to England in 1919.

When the social reformer Jyotirao Phule was trying to get the backward castes educated, historian Umesh Chattopadhyaya says that "Pune's Chitpavans would not allow any Dalit and backward to join schools". This opposition from them resulted in Phule establishing schools in and around Pune.

The Chitpavan community includes two major politicians in the Gandhian tradition: Gopal Krishna Gokhale, whom Mahatma Gandhi acknowledged as a preceptor, and Vinoba Bhave, one of his outstanding disciples. Gandhi describes Bhave as the "jewel of his disciples", and recognised Gokhale as his political guru. However, strong opposition to Gandhi came from the Chitpavan community. Vinayak Damodar Savarkar, the founder of the Hindu nationalist political ideology Hindutva, was a Chitpavan Brahmin and several other Chitpavans were among the first to embrace it because they thought it was a logical extension of the legacy of the Peshwas and caste-fellow Tilak. These Chitpavans felt out of place with the Indian social reform movement of Phule and the mass politics of Gandhi. Large numbers of the community looked to Savarkar, the Hindu Mahasabha and finally the RSS, drew their inspiration from fringe groups.

Anti-Brahmin violence in the 20th century

Main article: Marathi_Brahmin#Anti-Brahmin_violence

After Mahatma Gandhi's assassination by Nathuram Godse, a Chitpavan, Brahmins in Maharashtra, became targets of violence, mostly by the Maratha caste members. V. M. Sirsikar, a political scientist at the University of Pune, noted that The violence after the assassination affected Chitpavan Patwardhan family ruled princely states such as Sangli, where the Marathas were joined by the Jains and the Lingayats in the attacks against the Brahmins. Here, specifically, the loss was about Rs.16 million. This event led to the hasty integration of the Patwardhan states into the Bombay Province by March 1948 – a move that was opposed by other Brahmins as they feared the Maratha predominance in the integrated province.

Military

The Chitpavans have considered themselves to be both warriors and priests. Their involvement in military affairs began with the rise of the Peshwas and their willingness to enter military and other services earned them high status and power in the Deccan.

Culture

In their original home of Konkan, their primary occupation was farming, while some earned money by performing rituals among their own caste members.

Anthropologist Donald Kurtz writes that the late 20th century opinions about the culture of the Chitpavans was that they were frugal to the point of appearing cheap, impassive, not trustworthy and also conspiratorial. According to Tilak, a Chitpavan himself, his community was known for cleanliness and being industrious but he suggested they should learn virtues such as benevolence and generosity from the Deshasthas. During the heyday of the Maratha Empire, the city of Pune became the financial metropolis of the empire with 150 big and petty moneylenders. Most of these were Chitpavan or Deshastha Brahmins.

D.L.Sheth, the former director of the Center for the Study of Developing Societies in India (CSDS), lists Indian communities that were traditionally "urban and professional" (following professions like doctors, lawyers, teachers, engineers, etc.) immediately after Independence in 1947. This list included Chitpavans and CKPs(Chandraseniya Kayastha Prabhus) from Maharashtra; the South Indian Brahmins; the Nagar Brahmins from Gujarat; the Punjabi Khatris, Kashmiri Pandits and Kayasthas from northern India; the Probasi and the Bhadralok Bengalis; the Parsis and the upper crusts of Muslim and Christian communities. According to P.K.Verma, "Education was a common thread that bound together this pan Indian elite" and almost all male members of these communities could read and write English and were educated beyond school.

Language

Chitpavan Brahmins in Maharashtra speak Marathi as their language. The Marathi spoken by Chitpavans in Pune is the standard form of language used all over Maharashtra today. This form has many words derived from Sanskrit and retains the Sanskrit pronunciation of many, misconstrued by non-standard speakers as "nasalised pronunciation".

Social status

Earlier, the Deshastha Brahmins openly disparaged the Chitpavans as parvenus (a relative newcomer to a socio-economic class), and in Kumar's words "barely fit to associate on terms of equality with the noblest of the Dvijas". The Deshastha Brahmins were also joined by the Karhade Brahmins who also showed disdain for the Chitpawans and both these castes even declined to eat food together with them. Thus, they did not treat them as social equals. Even the Peshwas themselves were not given access to the ghats reserved for Deshastha priests at Nashik on the Godavari river.

After the appointment of Balaji Vishwanath Bhat as Peshwa, Kokanastha Brahmin migrants began arriving en masse from the Konkan to Pune, where the Peshwa offered some important offices to the Kokanastha Brahmin caste. The Kokanastha Brahmin kin were rewarded with tax relief and grants of land. Historians point out nepotism and corruption during this time.

The rise in prominence of the Chitpavans compared to the Deshastha Brahmins resulted in intense rivalry between the two communities. 19th century records also mention Gramanyas or village-level debates between the Chandraseniya Kayastha Prabhus and the Chitpavans, Saraswat Brahmins and the Chitpavans, Pathare Prabhus and the Chitpavans and Shukla Yajurvedi Deshastha Brahmins and the Chitpavans. These disputes pertaining to the so-called violation of "Brahmanical ritual code of behavior" were quite common in Maharashtra during that period.

Bal Gangadhar Tilak believed that the Deshasthas, Chitpavans and Karhades should get united. As early as 1881, he encouraged this by writing comprehensive discussions on the urgent need for these three Maharashtrian Brahmin sub-castes to give up caste exclusiveness by intermarrying and dining together.

Starting in the 20th century, the relations between the Deshastha Brahmins and the Chitpavan Brahmins have improved by the large-scale mixing of both communities on social, financial and educational fields, as well as with intermarriages.

Diet

Traditionally, Chitpavan Brahmins are vegetarian. Rice is their staple food.

''Bodan''

A.J. Agarkar describes Bodan as follows and adds that some kind of dancing is also involved: Vandana Bhave has published the only dedicated book on Bodan Vidhi (Bodan method) named Merutantrokta Bodan Vidhi.

Bodan finds mention in the Akshi Shilalekh (Pillar Inscription), dated to 1012 CE (sake 934) by Dr. S. G. Tulpule, and by Dikshit to 1209-1210 CE (Sake 1132). V. V. Mirashi agrees with Sake 1132 as the right date. Tulpule reads the content as donation of 9 kuvalis of grain towards Goddess Mahalakshmi for Bodan, whereas Dikshit interprets it as digging a well to honor Mahalaskhmi.

Genealogy

The community has published several family history and genealogy almanacs called Kulavruttantas. These books usually document various aspects of a clan's history, name etymology, ancestral land holdings, migration maps, religious traditions, genealogical charts, biographies, and records of births, deaths and marriages within the clan.

Notable people

Main article: List of Chitpavan Brahmins

Notes

References

References

1. Guy Delury. "India, the Rebel Continent".
2. (1989). "Language and society: steps towards an integrated theory". E.J. Brill.
3. Conlon, Frank F.. (1999). "State Intervention and Popular Response: Western India in the Nineteenth Century". Popular Prakashan.
4. Kurtz, Donald V.. (1993). "Contradictions and Conflict: A Dialectical Political Anthropology of a University in Western India". BRILL.
5. Nairne, Alexander Kyd. History of the Konkan. Vol. 1. Asian Educational Services, 1988.[https://books.google.com/books?id=nzPCcILP-XwC&pg=PR15]
6. Deshpande, M.M.. (2010). "Pañca Gauḍa and Pañca Drāviḍa: Contested borders of a traditional classification". Studia Orientalia.
7. Stanley Wolpert. (8 January 2021). "Tilak and Gokhale: Revolution and Reform in the Making of Modern India". Univ of California Press.
8. Joan G. Roland. (16 January 2018). "Jewish Communities of India: Identity in a Colonial Era". Routledge.
9. Yulia Egorova. (22 February 2008). "Jews and India: Perceptions and Image". Routledge.
10. Raphael Patai. (26 March 2015). "Encyclopedia of Jewish Folklore and Traditions". Routledge.
11. Ken Blady. (1 March 2000). "Jewish Communities in Exotic Places". Jason Aronson, Incorporated.
12. Roshen Dalal. (18 April 2014). "The Religions of India: A Concise Guide to Nine Major Faiths". Penguin Books Limited.
13. K.K.Gangadharan. (1970). "Sociology of Revivalism: A Study of Indianization, Sanskritization, and Golwalkarism". Kalamkar Prakashan.
14. Egorova, Yulia. (2006). "Jews and India: Perceptions and Image". Taylor & Francis.
15. Strizower, Schifra. (1971). "The Bene Israel of Bombay: A Study of a Jewish Community". Knopf Doubleday Publishing.
16. Yulia Egorova. (22 February 2008). "Jews and India: Perceptions and Image". Routledge.
17. Ghosh, Oroon K. (1976). "The Changing Indian Civilization: A Perspective on India, Volume 1".
18. Sarkar. (1993). "India Through the Ages". Orient Blackswan.
19. Bronkhorst, Johannes. (2016). "How the Brahmins won : from Alexander to the Guptas". Brill.
20. (2013). "Performance in a World of Paper: Puranic Histories and Social Communication in Early Modern India*". Oxford Academic.
21. (2007). "Structure and Change in Indian Society". AldineTransaction (Transaction Publishers).
22. Gordon Johnson. (1970). "elites in south asia". Cambridge University Press.
23. Percival Griffiths. (23 April 2019). "The British Impact on India". Taylor & Francis.
24. [[Balkrishna Govind Gokhale]]. (1988). "Poona in the Eighteenth Century: An Urban History". Oxford University Press.
25. Stewart Gordon. (16 September 1993). "The Marathas 1600–1818". Cambridge University Press.
26. Gokhale, B.G., 1985. The religious complex in eighteenth-century Poona. ''Journal of the American Oriental Society'', 105(4), pp.719-724.
27. Sandhya Gokhale. (2008). "The Chitpavans: social ascendancy of a creative minority in Maharashtra, 1818–1918". Shubhi Publications.
28. Edmund Leach, S. N. Mukherjee. (1970). "Elites in South Asia". Cambridge University Press.
29. J.S. Grewal. (2005). "The State and Society in Medieval India". Oxford University Press.
30. Christophe Jaffrelot. (2006). "Dr Ambedkar and Untouchability: Analysing and Fighting Caste". Permanent Black.
31. Tryambaka Śaṅkara Śejavalakara. (1946). "Panipat: 1761".
32. Anil Seal. (2 September 1971). "The Emergence of Indian Nationalism: Competition and Collaboration in the Later Nineteenth Century (Political change in modern South Asia)". CUP Archive.
33. Shejwalkar, T.S. (1947) [https://books.google.com/books?id=5sM8AAAAMAAJ&q=nepotism ''The Surat Episode of 1759''] Bulletin of the Deccan College Research Institute, Vol. 8; page 182.
34. Govind Sakharam Sardesai. (1986). "New history of the Marathas: Sunset over Maharashtra (1772–1848)". Phoenix Publications.
35. J. R. Śinde. (1985). "Dynamics of cultural revolution: 19th century Maharashtra".
36. (3 May 2007). "Dalits in Modern India: Vision and Values". SAGE Publishing India.
37. Richard Maxwell Eaton. "A social history of the Deccan, 1300–1761: eight Indian lives, Volume 1".
38. Cashman, Richard I. (1975). "The myth of the Lokamanya: Tilak and mass politics in Maharashtra". University of California.
39. (1963). "The New Brahmans: Five Maharashtrian Families". University of California Press.
40. (April 1991). "Tilak and Gokhale: Revolution and Reform in the Making of Modern India". Oxford University Press.
41. "Vinayak Damodar Savarkar: Public Enemy or national Hero?".
42. (2009). "Heidelberg Student papers, Vinayak Damodar Savarkar: Public Enemy or national Hero". Heidelberg University.
43. (April 1991). "Tilak and Gokhale: Revolution and Reform in the Making of Modern India". Oxford University Press.
44. (1999). "State intervention and popular response : western India in the nineteenth century". Popular Prakashan.
45. (April 1991). "Tilak and Gokhale: Revolution and Reform in the Making of Modern India". Oxford University Press.
46. (1975). "The myth of the Lokamanya : Tilak and mass politics in Maharashtra". University of California Press.
47. (19 June 2013). "Approaching Humankind: Towards an Intercultural Humanism". Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht.
48. Swapan Dasgupta, Smruti Koppikar. (3 August 1998). "Godse on Trial". India Today.
49. Arnold P. Goldstein, Marshall H. Segall. (1983). "Aggression in global perspective".
50. Thomas Blom Hansen. (18 November 2001). "Wages of Violence: Naming and Identity in Postcolonial Bombay". Princeton University Press.
51. Ullekh N P. (2018). "The Untold Vajpayee: Politician and Paradox". Random House India.
52. V.M.Sirsikar. (1999). "State Intervention and Popular Response: Western India in the Nineteenth Century". Popular Prakashan.
53. Maureen Patterson. (October 1988). "City, countryside and society in Maharashtra". University of Toronto, Centre for South Asian Studies.
54. Bhatt, Chetan. (2001). "Hindu Nationalism: Origins, Ideologies and Modern Myths". Berg.
55. Sandhya Gokhale. (2008). "The Chitpavans: social ascendancy of a creative minority in Maharashtra, 1818–1918". Shubhi.
56. Hansen, Thomas Blom. (2001). "Wages of Violence: Naming and Identity in Postcolonial Bombay". Princeton University Press.
57. (1992). "Encyclopedia of world cultures: South Asia – Volume 2". Macmillan Reference USA.
58. Donald V. Kurtz. (31 December 1993). "Contradictions and Conflict: A Dialectical Political Anthropology of a University in Western India". BRILL.
59. M. V. Kamath. (1991). "The Makings of a Millionaire: A Tribute to a Living Legend, Raosaheb B.M. Gogte, Industrialist, Philanthropist & Educationist". Jaico Publishing House.
60. H. Damodaran. (25 June 2008). "India's New Capitalists: Caste, Business, and Industry in a Modern Nation". Palgrave Macmillan UK.
61. Pavan K. Varma. (2007). "The Great Indian Middle class". Penguin Books.
62. (2000). "Searching for identity among Dalit middle class in Maharashtra". Indian Social Institute.
63. "D.L. Sheth".
64. (1996). "Handbook of twentieth century literatures of India". Greenwood Press.
65. Ravinder Kumar. (28 October 2013). "Western India in the Nineteenth Century: A study in the social history of Maharashtra". Taylor & Francis.
66. (1985). "Rajarshi Shahu Chhatrapati Papers: 1900–1905 A.D.: Vedokta controversy". Shahu Research Institute.
67. Anil Seal. (1971). "The Emergence of Indian Nationalism: Competition and Collaboration in the Later Nineteenth Century". CUP Archive.
68. Gordon, Stewart. (16 September 1993). "The Marathas 1600–1818". Cambridge University Press.
69. Gokhale, Sandhya. (2008). "The Chitpwans". Shubhi Publications.
70. Sandhya Gokhale. (2008). "The Chitpavans: social ascendancy of a creative minority".
71. A. C. Paranjpe. (1970). "Caste, Prejudice, and the Individual". Lalvani Publishing House.
72. (11 November 2014). "Tamil Brahmans: The Making of a Middle-Class Caste". University of Chicago Press.
73. Gordon Johnson. (1970). "Elites in South Asia". Cambridge University Press.
74. (1998). "India's Communities, Volume 5". Oxford University Press.
75. A. J. Agarkar. (1950). "Folk-dance of Maharashtra". R. Joshi.
76. (12 March 2024). "Bodan Vidhi (बोडण विधी)- Book".
77. Mirashi, Vasudev Vishnu. (1977). "Corpus Inscriptionum Indicarum Vol VI Inscriptions of Silaharas". Archeological Survey of India.
78. "Chitpavan Brahmins, a history". [[Pune University]].
79. (2007). "Structure and change in Indian society". AldineTransaction.