Captive bolt pistol

Variations

Captive bolt pistols are of three types: penetrating, non-penetrating, and free bolt. The use of penetrating captive bolts has largely been discontinued in commercial situations in order to minimize the risk of transmission of disease.

In the penetrating variation, the bolt penetrates the skull of the animal and catastrophically damages the cerebrum and part of the cerebellum. Concussion causes destruction of vital centers of the brain and an increase in intracranial pressure, causing the animal to lose consciousness. This method is considered the most effective type of stunning. It ensures a high probability of a successful stun by physically destroying brain matter but does not damage the brain stem; as a result, the heart continues to pump after the animal is incapacitated, which aids in the exsanguination process. One disadvantage of this method is that brain matter is allowed to enter the blood stream, possibly contaminating other tissue with bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE, colloquially known as mad cow disease).

The action of a non-penetrating stunner is similar, but the bolt is blunt with a mushroom-shaped tip. The bolt strikes the forehead with great force and immediately retracts. The subsequent concussion is responsible for the unconsciousness of the animal. This type of stunner is less reliable at causing immediate unconsciousness than penetrating types; however, it has undergone a resurgence of popularity because of concerns about mad cow disease. In the European Union, this captive bolt design is required for slaughter of animals that will be used for pharmaceutical manufacture.

The free bolt stunner is used for emergency, in-the-field euthanasia of large animals that cannot be restrained. It differs from a true captive bolt gun in that the projectile is not retractable; it is similar in operation to a powder-actuated nail gun or a conventional firearm. Capable of firing only when pressed firmly against a surface (typically the animal's forehead), the device fires a small projectile through the animal's skull. The veterinarian can then either leave the animal to die from the projectile wound or administer lethal drugs.

Use

With cattle, goats, sheep, rabbits, and horses, failure to adequately stun using a penetrating stunner can largely be attributed to incorrect positioning. In commercial operations, rates of failure can be significant and multiple shots are often used. One study looking at cattle found that 12% were shot multiple times, and 12.5% were inadequately stunned. Other research has recorded higher error rates, such as a study looking at young kangaroos which found that 38% of attempts failed to adequately stun the animal.

Captive bolts allow for meat trimmings from the head to be salvaged. In some veal operations, a non-penetrating concussive stunner is used in order to preserve the brain of the animal for further processing. Captive bolt stunners are safer to use for operators in most red meat slaughter processes. There is no danger of ricochet or overpenetration as there is with regular firearms.

The cartridges typically use 2 to of smokeless powder but can use up to 7 gr in the case of large animals, such as bulls. The velocity of the bolt is usually 55 m/s in the case of small animals and 75 m/s in the case of large animals.

Use for homicide

There have been a number of cases where a captive bolt pistol has been used for homicide, including:

• In 1966, in murder of 17-year-old Anna Neumayer, for which Josef Fritzl is among the suspects.
• In 1991, a 46-year-old German man with a history of alcohol abuse and aggressive behaviour killed his wife.
• In 2009, a 40-year-old English slaughterhouse worker killed a woman with two shots to the chest.

Suicide

In medical literature, at least one case report of suicide by captive bolt pistol has been published. The report states this method of suicide is not uncommon in central European countries with less strict laws surrounding the possession and use of such tools.

References

References

1. (2000). "Animal revolution : changing attitudes toward speciesism". New York.
2. (January 1992). "[Observations during captive bolt stunning of rabbits]". Berliner und Munchener tierarztliche Wochenschrift.
3. (May 2001). "Jugular venous emboli of brain tissue induced in sheep by the use of captive bolt guns". Veterinary Record.
4. "Note for guidance on minimising the risk of transmitting animal spongiform encephalopathy agents via human and veterinary medicinal products".
5. Beam, Christopher. (2009-02-25). "They Shoot Horses, Don't They?". Slate.com.
6. (November 2013). "Assessment of stun quality at commercial slaughter in cattle shot with captive bolt". Animal Welfare.
7. (2015-03-20). "Evaluation of a spring-powered captive bolt gun for killing kangaroo pouch young". Wildlife Research.
8. (19 March 2009). "Josef Fritzl to be questioned over string of unsolved murders". The Telegraph.
9. Betz, Peter. (1993). "Homicide with a Captive Bolt Pistol". Raven Press.
10. (8 November 2011). "Bolt-gun murder 'not predictable'". BBC News.
11. (2011-10-14). "Head trauma by captive bolt gun". Case Reports.