But Here We Are

Background

As early as mid-2021, Dave Grohl had already been planning for a follow-up album to Medicine at Midnight (2021). Grohl noted that each album the band records is a response to the prior one, and in response to Medicine at Midnight, he was considering writing "an insane prog-rock record". Grohl had not even started writing said material, as the band was still focusing on touring in support of Medicine at Midnight. Despite this, all plans were abruptly cancelled after longtime drummer Taylor Hawkins unexpectedly died in March 2022. The band cancelled everything planned for the rest of the year, largely going quiet and leaving their future uncertain. In December 2022, a statement was released confirming that Foo Fighters would continue, but that they were "going to be a different band going forward".

Rumors of a new album arose in February 2023, when radio DJ Chris Moyles on the UK's Radio X casually mentioned a new album to be released in March. Moyles would later apologize for speaking out of turn on the subject, but refused to clarify his comments. The album was later officially announced on April 19, 2023, alongside its official title, But Here We Are. At the time of the album's announcement, a replacement for Hawkins had still not been publicly disclosed. It was later disclosed that Grohl performed the drums on the album, his first drumming credit on a Foo Fighters studio album since 2005.

Recording and themes

The album is the third collaboration with producer Greg Kurstin, following Medicine at Midnight (2021) and Concrete and Gold (2017). The band described the album's sound as "sonically channeling the naivete of Foo Fighters' 1995 debut album, informed by decades of maturity and depth" while lyrically exploring "a brutally honest and emotionally raw response to everything Foo Fighters have endured recently [...] 10 songs that run the emotional gamut from rage and sorrow to serenity and acceptance, and myriad points in between." The album was also described as "the first chapter of the band's new life". Lyrically, the album explores Grohl coming to terms with not only Hawkins' death, but also that of his mother, Virginia, who died at an undisclosed-to-the-public time in 2022. "Under You", released as the album's second single, has been described as melodic punk.

Release and promotion

The album was released on June 2, 2023. The first single, "Rescued", was released concurrently with the announcement of the album on April 19. A second song, "Under You", was released ahead of the album on May 17. Over 25 live shows in support of the album have been announced across North America and Europe. On May 21, Josh Freese was announced as the band's new drummer, and during the livestream they debuted the song "Nothing at All". Freese made his live concert debut on May 24, where the band debuted the album's title track. Another song, "Show Me How", was released on May 25 and features Grohl harmonizing with his daughter Violet.

Reception

Critical

But Here We Are received critical acclaim from critics. At Metacritic, the album has an average score of 86 out of 100, which indicates "universal acclaim" based on 22 reviews. Spin described it as "one of the strongest albums of the band's career" and concluded that "if you don't have a big, fat lump in your throat or head-to-toe goosebumps all over your body while listening to But Here We Are, you may not have a pulse." Kerrang! praised the album's emotional content, noting that "It's a miracle not only that it was made, but also that it boasts the mesmeric lyrical and musical qualities it does. Somehow Dave Grohl found a way to wrap words around the enormity of his grief as he surrendered to his own impossible circumstances." Clash's Emma Harrison described it as "Heartbreaking, but hopeful - this is a masterclass...with its heady hooks and exuberant riffs, But Here We Are is ambitious, poignant, and vivid in equal measure." Maura Johnston, writing for Rolling Stone, said that the album "depicts grief in immediate terms" and "possesses a vitality", describing it as "one of their best records ever".

In June 2023, Alternative Press published an unranked list of the top 25 albums of the year to date and included this release, calling it "nothing short of miraculous in the sense and sound of mastery and of hope that can be heard from the top track to the very last note".

Accolades

Numerous critics and publications listed But Here We Are in their year-end ranking of the best albums of 2023.

Commercial performance

But Here We Are debuted at number 1 on the UK Albums Chart with 44,500 chart units sold after an intense chart battle with Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds album Council Skies, giving Foo Fighters their sixth UK number 1 album. The album tops the Billboard Top Alternative Albums and Top Hard Rock Albums charts, and debuts at number eight on the all-format Billboard 200 chart, moving 62,000 equivalent album units. Concurrently, "Rescued", topped the Hot Hard Rock Songs chart.

Track listing

Personnel

Foo Fighters

• Dave Grohl – vocals, guitar, drums, production
• Nate Mendel – bass, production
• Chris Shiflett – guitar, production
• Pat Smear – guitar, production
• Rami Jaffee – keyboards, production

Additional musicians

• Violet Grohl – vocals on "Show Me How"

Additional personnel

• Greg Kurstin – production, string conducting on "The Teacher"
• Mark "Spike" Stent – mixing
• Randy Merrill – mastering
• Morning Breath, Inc. – art direction, design

Charts

Weekly charts

Year-end charts

Certifications

References

References

1. Schnoor, Collette. (October 9, 2023). "Foo Fighters- But Here We Are".
2. (May 25, 2023). "Hear FOO FIGHTERS' mesmerizing new song "Show Me How" featuring Violet Grohl".
3. Corcoran, Nina. (May 30, 2023). "Foo Fighters Share Video for 10-Minute New Song “The Teacher”: Watch".
4. Johnston, Maura. (2023-06-05). "Foo Fighters Power Through Pain on One of Their Best Records Ever".
5. (2023-05-26). "Foo Fighters' But Here We Are is Their Best LP in Years: Review".
6. ""For Virginia and Taylor": Foo Fighters dedicate new album But Here We Are to Dave Grohl's mother and Taylor Hawkins".
7. "Dave Grohl opens up about his mother's death: "We were best friends"".
8. Graves, Wren. (September 14, 2021). "Foo Fighters Tease "Insane Prog-Rock Record"".
9. Childers, Chad. (March 25, 2023). "One Year Ago: Foo Fighters Drummer Taylor Hawkins Died". [[Loudwire]].
10. Blum, Jordan. (January 1, 2023). "Foo Fighters Issue Statement on Future Without Taylor Hawkins". [[Loudwire]].
11. Williams, Stuart. (February 7, 2023). "Foo Fighters are releasing new album in March, according to Radio X's Chris Moyles". [[MusicRadar]].
12. Qureshi, Arusa. (February 10, 2023). "Chris Moyles apologises to Dave Grohl after unofficially announcing a new Foo Fighters album". [[NME]].
13. Trendell, Andrew. (April 19, 2023). "Foo Fighters return with new single 'Rescued' and announce album 'But Here We Are'".
14. Kreps, Daniel. (April 19, 2023). "Foo Fighters return with new album 'But Here We Are".
15. Kaufman, Gil. (April 19, 2023). "Foo Fighters Announce 'Brutally Honest' 11th Album 'But Here We Are'".
16. Carter, Emily. (May 22, 2023). "Dave Grohl confirms that he played drums on the new Foo Fighters album".
17. Monroe, Jazz. (April 19, 2023). "Foo Fighters Announce New Album ''But Here We Are'', Share Song: Listen".
18. Carter, Emily. (April 19, 2023). "Foo Fighters announce new album But Here We Are, release lead single Rescued".
19. (May 17, 2023). "Foo Fighters Share 'Under You' Single From Upcoming 'But Here We Are' Album".
20. (April 19, 2023). "Foo Fighters Announce New Album But Here We Are, Share "Rescued": Stream".
21. Blistein, Jon. (May 17, 2023). "Foo Fighters Grapple With Grief on New Song 'Under You".
22. Harrison, Scoop. (May 21, 2023). "Foo Fighters Reveal Josh Freese As New Live Drummer".
23. Dunworth, Liberty. (May 25, 2023). "Watch Foo Fighters debut four new songs and new live drummer as they kick off 2023 comeback tour". [[NME]].
24. "Dave Grohl Harmonizes With Daughter Violet On Foo Fighters' Moving 'Show Me How'".
25. "''But Here We Are'' by Foo Fighters reviews".
26. Erlewine, Stephen Thomas. "Foo Fighters – ''But Here We Are'' Album Reviews, Songs & More".
27. McCormick, Neil. (26 May 2023). "The Foo Fighters find purpose in tragedy, Lola Young is a rare talent – the week's best albums". [[The Daily Telegraph]].
28. Sylvester, Daniel. "Foo Fighters Scratch the Surface of Loss on 'But Here We Are' - Exclaim!".
29. Petridis, Alexis. (1 June 2023). "Foo Fighters: ''But Here We Are'' review – a raw, unapologetic act of mourning". [[The Guardian]].
30. O'Connor, Roisin. (June 1, 2023). "Foo Fighters review, ''But Here We Are'': Band's 11th album is a poignant reflection on grief". [[The Independent]].
31. Garner, George. "Album review: Foo Fighters – ''But Here We Are''".
32. Shutler, Ali. (May 26, 2023). "Foo Fighters – ''But Here We Are'' review: Grohl and the gang work through their grief". [[NME]].
33. Mongredien, Phil. (4 June 2023). "Foo Fighters: But Here We Are review – grieving, route-one stadium rock - Foo Fighters - The Guardian". [[The Observer]].
34. Cohen, Ian. (June 5, 2023). "But Here We Are Foo Fighters". [[Pitchfork (website).
35. Hodgkinson, Will. (June 1, 2023). "Foo Fighters review, ''But Here We Are'': Band's 11th album is a poignant reflection on grief". [[The Times]].
36. "''But Here We Are'' by Foo Fighters Reviews and Tracks".
37. Cohen, Jonathan. (May 26, 2023). "Foo Fighters Give Their Loved Ones a Cathartic Rock'N'Roll Sendoff On Revelatory ''But Here We Are''".
38. (May 31, 2023). "Foo Fighters – But Here We Are". [[Clash (magazine).
39. (2023-06-05). "Foo Fighters Power Through Pain on One of Their Best Records Ever". [[Rolling Stone]].
40. (2023-06-23). "25 best albums of 2023 so far".
41. (2023-12-12). "50 best albums of 2023".
42. (2023-12-04). "50 Best Albums of 2023: Consequence Annual Report".
43. (2023-12-11). "The 50 best albums of 2023".
44. (2023-12-06). "The 20 best albums of 2023".
45. Loudwire Staff. (2023-11-27). "The 25 Best Rock + Metal Albums of 2023".
46. (2023-12-13). "The 40 Best Albums of 2023".
47. NME. (2023-12-08). "The best albums of 2023".
48. Smith, Carl. (June 9, 2023). "Foo Fighters pip Noel Gallagher's High Flying Birds to Number 1 with But Here We Are after intense race". officialcharts.com.
49. "Foo Fighters' 'But Here We Are' Leads Alternative, Hard Rock Album Charts".
50. (December 20, 2023). "Episode 265: Foo Fighters "The Teacher"".
51. "Top-75 Albums Sales Chart (Combined) – Week 25/2023". [[IFPI Greece]].
52. "Oricon Top 50 Digital Albums: June 7, 2023". [[Oricon]].
53. "Billboard Japan Hot Albums: Week of June 21, 2023".
54. (June 6, 2023). "Weekly ROCK Album Ranking". [[Oricon]].
55. "Jaaroverzichten 2023". [[Ultratop]].
56. Griffiths, George. (3 January 2024). "The Official Top 20 biggest cassettes of 2023". [[Official Charts Company]].
57. Ainsley, Helen. (January 4, 2024). "The Official best-selling vinyl albums and singles of 2023". [[Official Charts Company]].
58. "Year-End Charts: Top Current Album Sales (2023)".
59. "Year-End Charts: Top Rock Albums (2023)".