Bruce effect

Discovery

In an experiment published in 1959, zoologist Hilda Bruce of the National Institute for Medical Research in London housed pregnant mice with male mice that were not the father of the carried embryo. As a result, the rate of miscarriages increased, followed by mating with the new male. No increased rate of miscarriages occurred when pregnant mice were paired with castrated or juvenile male mice. The effect remained when the male mice were kept out of sight or hearing of the females. This suggested that females were distinguishing the males by smell. To test this hypothesis, Bruce and her colleague Alan Parkes recruited perfumers to smell pieces of cloth from the mouse cages. The perfumers could distinguish the smells of different mouse strains.

Mechanisms of action

Detection of pheromones

The vomeronasal system serves as a "vascular pump" that, stimulated by the presence of a novel male, actively draws in substances. Male mouse urine contains MHC class I peptides that bind to receptors in the female's vomeronasal organ, a mucus-filled structure in the nasal septum. These chemical signals, which are specific to each male, are learned by the female during mating, or shortly after.

Recognizing familiar males

Exposure to a male's urinal pheromones will activate a neuroendocrine pathway leading to pregnancy failure. However, if the pheromones correspond with those memorized by the female (usually the male mating partner), a release of noradrenaline will lower the receptivity of the accessory olfactory bulb to these pheromones.

Neuroendocrine pathway

The activation of vomeronasal neuron receptors by male pheromones triggers a complex neuroendocrine pathway. The pheromonal information travels via nerves to the accessory olfactory bulb, and then to the corticomedial amygdala, accessory olfactory tract, and stria terminalis. which thus prevents the secretion of prolactin from the anterior pituitary. In the absence of prolactin, an essential hormone for maintaining the corpus luteum, luteolysis takes place. As the corpus luteum can no longer release progesterone, the uterus remains unprimed for embryo implantation, and the pregnancy fails.

Role of estrogens

Androgens and estrogens, particularly estradiol (E2), are also crucial chemosignals regulating the Bruce effect. Castrated males are incapable of terminating female pregnancies, except when castrated males are given testosterone. estradiol, a metabolic product of testosterone, is known to disrupt pregnancy in females, and is present in male urine.

Timing

The incidence of the Bruce effect depends on the timing of pheromone exposure. Post-mating, females experience twice-daily surges of prolactin. Pregnancy is only terminated if exposure to novel male scent coincides with two prolactin surges, one of these occurring in a daylight period.

Evolutionary benefits

In order to have evolved and persisted in the population, the Bruce effect must afford individuals a fitness advantage. The possible advantages of pregnancy block are widely debated.

Males

When given the opportunity, male mice tend to direct their urine in the female's direction. This allows males to improve their fitness success by "sabotaging" the pregnancy of a male competitor, The Bruce effect can also aid in maintaining social status, with dominant males leaving more urinal scent markings, and so blocking the pregnancies initiated by subordinate males.

Females

Females can control their likelihood of terminating pregnancy by pursuing or avoiding novel male contact during their most susceptible periods. In this way, females can exert a post-copulatory mate choice, reserving their reproductive resources for the highest-quality male. Certainly, females are more likely to seek proximity to dominant males. The Bruce effect is most common in polygynous rodent species, for which the risk of infanticide is highest.

References

References

1. (1984). "Pregnancy interruption in Microtus ochrogaster: Laboratory artifact or field phenomenon?". Biology of Reproduction.
2. (1987). "Effect of Multiple Short-Term Exposures of Pregnant Microtus ochrogaster to Strange Males". Journal of Mammalogy.
3. (2008). "Chemical Signals in Vertebrates 11". Chemical Signals in Vertebrates.
4. (1959). "An Exteroceptive Block to Pregnancy in the Mouse". Nature.
5. (1981). "Pregnancy Blocking in Rodents: Adaptive Advantages for Females". The American Naturalist.
6. (1962). "Interaction of Olfactory and Other Environmental Stimuli on Implantation in the Deer Mouse". Science.
7. (1971). "Pregnancy-Block in the Meadow Vole, Microtus Pennsylvanicus". Reproduction.
8. MALLORY, F. F.. (1980). "Infanticide and Pregnancy Failure: Reproductive Strategies in the Female Collared Lemming (Dicrostonyx groenlandicus)". Biology of Reproduction.
9. (1983). "Adaptations of Female Lions to Infanticide by Incoming Males". The American Naturalist.
10. (2012). "A Bruce Effect in Wild Geladas". Science.
11. MRC National Institute for Medical Research. (2014). "A Century of Science and Health". MRC National Institute for Medical Research.
12. (2013). "Physiology of behavior". Pearson.
13. (2009). "Excretion and binding of tritium-labelled oestradiol in mice (Mus musculus): Implications for the Bruce effect". Reproduction.
14. (2007). "Mammalian pheromone sensing". Current Opinion in Neurobiology.
15. (2009). "Outstanding issues surrounding vomeronasal mechanisms of pregnancy block and individual recognition in mice". Behavioural Brain Research.
16. (2006). "Pheromonal communication in vertebrates". Nature.
17. (2008). "Brain Oxytocin: A Key Regulator of Emotional and Social Behaviors in Both Females and Males". Journal of Neuroendocrinology.
18. (1989). "Restricted exposure of mice to primer pheromones coincident with prolactin surges blocks pregnancy by changing hypothalamic dopamine release". Reproduction.
19. (2001). "Increasing levels of estradiol are deleterious to embryonic implantation because they directly affect the embryo". Fertility and Sterility.
20. (2003). "Estrogen is a critical determinant that specifies the duration of the window of uterine receptivity for implantation". Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
21. (1965). "Effect of Castration on the Reproductive Pheromones of Male Mice". Reproduction.
22. (2009). "Exposure to developing females induces polyuria, polydipsia, and altered urinary levels of creatinine, 17β-estradiol, and testosterone in adult male mice (Mus musculus)". Hormones and Behavior.
23. (1973). "Social Rank in House Mice: Differentiation Revealed by Ultraviolet Visualization of Urinary Marking Patterns". Science.
24. (2009). "Female behaviour plays a critical role in controlling murine pregnancy block". Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.
25. (1979). "The Bruce Effect: An Evaluation of Male/Female Advantages". The American Naturalist.
26. (2009). "Mating strategy predicts the occurrence of the Bruce effect in the vlei rat ''Otomys irroratus''". Behaviour.