Bruce Castor

Statewide profile

After serving stints beginning in 1981 with, respectively, the Philadelphia District Attorney's Office, the Northampton County (PA) District Attorney's Office, as an LBJ Congressional Scholar (Washington, DC) and defending Federal prisoners at FCI-Alderson (WV), Castor began his professional career as an assistant district attorney in 1985 before becoming district attorney of Montgomery County from 2000 to 2008. He next took a seat on the Montgomery County Board of Commissioners, an elected position he held until January 4, 2016, when he was succeeded by Joe Gale. Castor was defeated for re-election as Montgomery County's District Attorney in November 2015. Castor completed a nearly three-year term as a special assistant district attorney of Centre County, Pennsylvania on December 31, 2017, followed by an appointment as a special assistant district attorney of Susquehanna County, Pennsylvania on January 6, 2018. On March 29, 2016, Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane announced Castor's appointment (back-dated to March 21, when he actually took office) to the newly created position of Solicitor General of Pennsylvania. While he operated freely as the de facto Attorney General and was widely recognized as such, Castor formally became the state's Acting Attorney General, replacing Kane, who resigned on August 17, 2016, following a conviction of a third degree felony perjury charge and several related misdemeanors. Governor Tom Wolf later nominated Bruce Beemer to fulfill the remaining balance of Kane's term which expired in January 2017. Castor is the cousin of Steve Castor, who represented Trump during his first impeachment.

Career

Montgomery County District Attorney

After serving in the office since 1985, Castor was twice elected district attorney for Montgomery County, in which he is a lifelong resident, assuming office in January 2000. After his second term ended, he was succeeded by Risa Vetri Ferman. When she sought (and won) election as judge in November 2015, Castor sought to return to that office, but lost to Ferman's first assistant, Kevin Steele, who ran an 11th-hour campaign contending Castor should have charged entertainer Bill Cosby in 2005. Castor countered that Steele could have arrested Cosby himself in the intervening years if he believed credible evidence existed to do so. A week before the election, Andrea Constand, who had accused Cosby of sexual assault in Montgomery County, sued Castor, claiming he defamed her by intimating she was not credible. The Washington Post said that this suit contributed to Castor's defeat. In November 2017, Castor sued Constand and her lawyers for defamation, charging that the lawsuit and its timing were retaliatory and ruined his political career. In 2017, Cosby stood trial, but the trial ended in a hung jury with jurors unable to agree on Cosby's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, as Castor had predicted in 2005 would happen if he had elected to charge Cosby. However at Cosby's retrial he was convicted on all three counts and he was sentenced to serve 3 to 10 years in prison. After two years of time served the Pennsylvania Supreme Court overturned the sentence, ruling that Castor's pledge to not prosecute Cosby was binding on all other prosecutors.

Notable cases

• Bill Cosby – Castor declined to prosecute Cosby for sexual assault in 2005 after he found "insufficient, credible and admissible evidence exists upon which any charge against Mr. Cosby could be sustained beyond a reasonable doubt". In November 2014 and through the November 2015 election, Castor's decision was heavily criticized, especially when other women came forward to accuse Cosby. Castor, however, assessed that none of these women known to him at the time would have been allowed to testify, making them legally irrelevant to the question of whether Castor should have arrested Cosby. On December 30, 2015, with the statute of limitations about to expire, Cosby was charged with felony sexual assault. At a preliminary hearing on February 2, 2016, Castor testified that he made a promise to never prosecute Cosby for the incident, but Judge Steven T. O'Neill ruled that the promise was not legally binding on the current district attorney, and ordered that the criminal case proceed.{{cite news|url=https://www.inquirer.com/philly/business/20160204_Legal_observers_puzzled_by_Castor_no-prosecute_pledge.html
• Dillon Cossey – Planned a Columbine-style attack on a local high school. Cossey was convicted in juvenile court.
• John Eichinger – The most prolific arrested serial killer documented in Montgomery County history. Eichinger murdered three young women and a small child. Two of the women had rejected his sexual advances and the other woman and child were witnesses. Eichinger received three death sentences and one sentence of life in prison. The case formed the basis for the production of a demo video for a proposed television show based on Castor's career called "Probable Cause", written and produced in 2007 by then Times Herald reporter Keith Phucas in Norristown, Pennsylvania.
• Caleb Fairley – Fairley sexually assaulted and murdered a mother and her child in his parents' shop, earning a double life sentence. The case was the first time DNA evidence was used to convict a killer in Montgomery County. The Fairley case formed the basis for the book Vampire Trap by Katherine Ramsland. Castor is featured on the episode of Forensic Files ("Shopping Spree") devoted to the case.
• Bruce Godschalk – Godschalk was convicted of rape in 1987 (before Castor was elected) and was freed in 2002 after DNA tests cast doubt on his guilt. Castor had fought against DNA testing, arguing that Godschalk did not have the legal right to it. Godschalk filed a lawsuit against the county, which was settled for approximately $1 million. In 2009, the United States Supreme Court ruled 5–4 in a similar case that convicts did not have a constitutional right to DNA testing.
• Craig Rabinowitz – Rabinowitz murdered his wife, Stefanie Newman, for the life insurance money to pay debts arising from a pyramid scheme, and to leave him free to pursue his obsession with a stripper. The case was front-page news for months and became the subject of multiple television programs and a book by Ken Englade called Everybody's Best Friend. He pleaded guilty to first degree murder and is serving a life sentence.
• Rafael Robb – Robb, a University of Pennsylvania professor of game theory, was accused of murdering his wife in a rage. Pleaded guilty to voluntary manslaughter and was sentenced to 5–10 years in prison, a sentence many believe was too lenient, with Castor arguing for a 20-year prison term.
• Guy Sileo – Sileo murdered his business partner in the General Wayne Inn, serving a life sentence for first degree murder. A highly circumstantial case, the "General Wayne Inn murder" has been the subject of numerous television portrayals.

Attorney General race

Main article: Pennsylvania Attorney General election, 2004

Castor ran for the GOP nomination for Pennsylvania Attorney General in 2004 against Republican Tom Corbett. Furious that he had lost endorsements of the southeastern GOP chairmen, Castor attacked Corbett and the county chairmen with allegations of backroom deals with Bob Asher, the state's national GOP committeeman. Castor and Asher had feuded for several years due to Asher's prior felony convictions for perjury, bribery, racketeering, and conspiracy in 1986 in the context of a political corruption scandal which also involved the State Treasurer, R. Budd Dwyer, leading to Dwyer's committing suicide at a press conference before his sentencing. Asher had been state GOP Chair during the scandal and was convicted for participating in the bribery of Dwyer. Asher's criminal past, connected to a political bribery scheme while he was the Republican state chair, became a subject of the campaign for the state's top law enforcement post.

Castor was unable to produce proof of any conspiracy against him and ran without the party endorsement in all but two counties, his home base in Montgomery County and Monroe County. Castor lost 52.8% to 47.2%, despite winning overwhelmingly the same southeastern counties whose chairmen had repudiated him, and his home in Montgomery County, where he took nearly 82.5% of the vote.

Private practice

When his term as district attorney expired in January 2008, Castor took a position at the litigation firm of Elliott, Greenleaf & Siedzikowski in Blue Bell, Pennsylvania as a shareholder and director. One of his notable clients was professional basketball player Marko Jaric of the Memphis Grizzlies, who was accused of sexual assault in Philadelphia. Jaric was not charged in the case. In 2009, Castor represented Mark Sargent, who was investigated (but not charged) for patronizing a brothel while he served as dean of the Villanova University School of Law. In 2010, Castor represented his former boss, attorney Michael D. Marino, whose nephew accidentally shot and killed a man while hunting. Marino, a former Montgomery County D.A., was present when the shooting occurred, despite knowing that his nephew was prohibited from owning and using firearms, owing to a felony conviction. Marino was not charged in the case. On July 1, 2013, Castor joined the law firm of Rogers & Associates (subsequently renamed Rogers Castor) as a civil-litigation lawyer in Ardmore, Pennsylvania, with former Lower Merion Commissioner and former Republican state senate nominee, Lance Rogers. Castor and Rogers Castor, renamed as Rogers Counsel, parted ways on December 31, 2020, and Bruce J Castor joined the personal injury law firm of van der Veen, Hartshorn, Levin & Lindheim. In 2017, Castor led the investigation into the Death of Tim Piazza at Pennsylvania State University.

Montgomery County commissioner

In 2007, Castor challenged incumbent County Commissioner Tom Ellis, a one-time friend who had chaired Castor's campaigns in 1999 and 2003 but endorsed Corbett in 2004. Early in the campaign, Castor commissioned a poll showing that Ellis, who had been hobbled by negative press surrounding alleged domestic violence incidents, would lose in a general election. Ellis released his own poll to try to refute Castor's charges that he was unelectable. In a six candidate field, Castor won the party endorsement on the first ballot, but his preferred running mate, former State Representative Melissa Murphy Weber, was narrowly defeated by incumbent Jim Matthews on the second ballot.

Initially, Castor was reluctant to run with Matthews saying he believed Matthews was "untrustworthy". However, amid widespread pressure that he would be splitting the party, Castor relented and ran with Matthews against former Democratic Congressman Joe Hoeffel and incumbent commissioner Ruth Damsker in the general election. During the campaign, some of Castor's earlier criticism of Matthews was raised by the Democrats, including financial support to Matthews from Bob Asher. Over Castor's objections who would not accept funds from a convicted felon, Matthews set up a separate campaign account from the Matthews/Castor account in order to collect contributions from Asher. On election day, Castor won, taking first place in the general election setting an electoral record at the time for the position. His running mate placed third, giving the GOP control of the commission. This was the first time in at least 140 years that a Republican failed to capture both the first and the second spot. Castor and Matthews served with Hoeffel, who finished second. It was immediately a rocky relationship with all Castor's earlier predictions about Matthews being "untrustworthy" coming true. Matthews and Hoeffel sided against Castor shutting him out of setting county policy. Castor responded by repeatedly making allegations of corruption against his fellow commissioners charging mismanagement of county finances, the hiring of unqualified people, and in the conduct of county business. A subsequent grand jury report found questionable behavior on Hoeffel's part for his participation in discussing county business at private breakfast meetings held with Matthews and senior aides–an alleged violation of state "sunshine" laws. However, unlike Matthews, who was later arrested for allegedly perjuring himself while testifying to the grand jury, Hoeffel was never charged with criminal wrongdoing. Nevertheless, Matthews and Hoeffel were unable to achieve endorsement for re-election and dropped out of the race, while GOP voters easily re-nominated Castor who was thus vindicated in his allegations of government corruption and mismanagement by Hoeffel and Matthews.

On November 8, 2011, St. Rep. Josh Shapiro, Whitemarsh Twp. Supervisor Leslie Richards, and Castor were elected, marking the first time in county history Democrats controlled two of the three seats on the Board of Commissioners. Shapiro was elected chairman unanimously on nomination from Castor. All three members of the commission later noted the improved level of civility and functionality on the board, with Castor expressing pride in working with Shapiro and Richards whom he considered "honest". The relationship amongst the three commissioners later prompted one columnist of The Philadelphia Inquirer to note that she owed Castor an apology for considering his complaints about the prior county administration "sour grapes". On November 3, 2015, Castor was defeated in his effort to return to the district attorney's post and Joe Gale was elected to succeed Castor as county commissioner. Upon retiring from county service after 30 years on January 4, 2016, Castor began practicing law full-time as a trial lawyer.

Solicitor general and acting attorney general

On March 21, 2016, Castor took the oath of office as the first Solicitor General of Pennsylvania. Being summoned to her Scranton office by Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen G. Kane on March 4, 2016, without explanation, Castor met General Kane expecting her to request him to represent her in a private capacity. Instead, Kane offered him the newly created position of Solicitor General of Pennsylvania (later merged into the job of first deputy attorney general), and Castor accepted. The move was necessitated because the Attorney General had her license to practice law suspended by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court. Castor was supposedly subordinate to Kane in all matters except for making legal decisions on behalf of Pennsylvania, though most observers considered him the de facto attorney general, a fact later confirmed upon Kane's resignation. In practice, Castor operated as a bridge between Kane and the remainder of the office of attorney general, in addition to being the final word on legal matters, in order to make the executive portion of the office function properly.

However, following Democrat Kathleen Kane's sudden resignation, Republican Castor was sworn in as Acting Attorney General of Pennsylvania, no longer simply de facto attorney general, though later that week Democratic Governor Tom Wolf nominated Democratic Inspector General Bruce Beemer to serve the remainder of Kane's term. The Pennsylvania Senate confirmed the nomination quickly. After Castor assumed the office of Acting Attorney General, he was the subject of criticism, and on August 30, 2016, Bruce Beemer succeeded Castor as attorney general. Castor resigned from the office of attorney general on September 9, 2016, reverting to first deputy attorney general and, finally, solicitor general.

Second impeachment trial of Donald Trump

On January 31, 2021, Castor was appointed to take the lead for Donald Trump's defense team for his 2021 impeachment trial, alongside criminal law practitioner David Schoen. Castor's opening arguments on February 9, 2021, were widely reported to be confusing and rambling, and famously included the statement "Nebraska, you’re going to hear, is quite a judicial thinking place" that became an online meme. Trump was reportedly "furious" about Castor's "rambling, almost somnambulant defense". Texas Republican U.S. Senator John Cornyn commented, "The president's lawyer just rambled on and on" and "I've seen a lot of lawyers and a lot of arguments, and that was not one of the finest I've seen."

References

References

1. [https://books.google.com/books?id=vT9OAQAAIAAJ&q=Bruce+Lee+Castor+Jr Pennsylvania state reports - Volume 591, 2007]
2. Hubbell, Martindale. (April 1997). "Martindale-Hubbell Law Directory: Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, South Dakota (Volume 14 - 1997)". [[Martindale-Hubbell]].
3. Hubbell, Martindale. (December 1, 2016). "Martindale-Hubbell Law Directory 2017: Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Vermont, Virginia, Washington, West Virginia". [[Martindale-Hubbell]].
4. (February 1, 2021). "Trump names two new lawyers for impeachment trial a day after his defense team collapsed".
5. Angela Couloumbis and Jeremy Roebuck. (2016-03-30). "A.G. Kane hires Castor as a top aide". [[The Philadelphia Inquirer]].
6. (August 16, 2016). "Attorney General Kathleen Kane to resign". [[Philadelphia Media Network]].
7. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v. Kathleen Granahan Kane (2015) CP-46-CR-0006239-2015
8. Marcovitz, Hal. (January 3, 2000). "County Commissioners, Others to be Sworn In". The Allentown Morning Call.
9. Savage, Charlie. (February 8, 2021). "Who Are David Schoen and Bruce Castor, Trump's Impeachment Trial Lawyers?". The New York Times.
10. (November 3, 2015). "Steele tops Castor in contentious Montco D.A. race".
11. Moyer, Justin Wm.. (February 4, 2016). "The prosecutor undone by a 'secret agreement' with Bill Cosby". [[The Washington Post]].
12. (2017-11-03). "Former Pennsylvania district attorney sues Cosby accuser for alleged defamation".
13. "CNN.com - Prosecutors end Cosby investigation - Feb 22, 2005".
14. (October 27, 2015). "Bill Cosby accuser files lawsuit against Montco DA candidate Bruce Castor".
15. (November 3, 2015). "A Pennsylvania Election Reached A Flash Point Over Bill Cosby".
16. (2015-12-30). "Bill Cosby Is Charged With Felony Sex Crime Over 2004 Case". [[NPR]].
17. [https://www.inquirer.com/news/bruce-castor-trump-impeachment-senate-trial-cosby-20210201.html Pa. Republicans are stumped by Trump's pick of Bruce Castor for his impeachment defense], ''[[Philadelphia Inquirer]]'', Remy Roebuck, Andrew Seidman and Laura McCrystal, February 1, 2021. Retrieved February 9, 2021.
18. McCrystal, Laura. (30 Jun 2021). "Bill Cosby's release from prison again shines a light on Bruce Castor. And Castor feels 'vindicated.'". [[Philadelphia Inquirer]].
19. "PA Supreme Court ruling p.61, footnote 24".
20. Dale, MarieClaire. (2007-10-26). "Teen Admits School-Assault Plot". The Oklahoman.
21. Dale, MarieClaire. (2007-10-26). "Teen Admits School-Assault Plot". Associated Press, Carried at abcnews.com.
22. [http://www.crimelibrary.com/serial_killers/weird/vampires/18.html Caleb Fairley Case, Crimelibrary.com Caleb Fairley case at crimelibrary.com] {{webarchive. link. (July 5, 2007)
23. "Maurice Possley and Steve Mills, In depth: Crimes go unsolved as DNA profiles not sent to FBI, ''Chicago Tribune'', Reprinted in St. Augustine Record, 10/6/04".
24. [http://www.crimlaw.org/defbrief183.html Sara Rimer, Convict's DNA Sways Labs, Not a Determined Prosecutor, ''The New York Times'', Reprinted at www.crimlaw.com, 10/6/02] {{webarchive. link. (2007-09-29)
25. "Supreme Court denies DNA test to rapist".
26. Anne Barnard, Steve Ritea and Ralph Vigoda, Rabinowitz Admits Killing Wife - A dream urged him to 'do the right thing', ''[[The Philadelphia Inquirer]]'', October 10, 1997-10-31.
27. Husband guilty of murder - obsession with stripper led to strangulation, Associated Press, 1997-10-31
28. (2007-11-27). "Ex-Penn Professor Pleads Guilty In Wife's Death". cbs3.com.
29. link. (2007-09-30)
30. Gibbons, Margaret. (2004-06-04). "Castor backs Corbett in attorney general race". The Colonial.
31. Patel, Mary. (2004-01-22). "Castor Roiled". Philadelphia City Paper.
32. Erdley, Debra. (2004-04-22). "Most still undecided on Corbett, Castor". Pittsburgh Tribune-Review.
33. (2004-02-06 }}{{dead link). "Editorial: A rare public dispute in ranks of the GOP". Delco Times.
34. "Pennsylvania Elections - Summary Results".
35. "Corbett, Eisenhower win in attorney general race".
36. Chris Mannix. (2009-03-13). "Grizzlies' Jaric not charged after probe into alleged sexual assault". Sports Illustrated, SI.com.
37. "Villanova Dean Resigned Over Prostitution".
38. "It took 9 days for former D.A. to come clean on hunter's shooting death, affidavit says - Philly". Philly.com.
39. "Castor Splits With Longtime Firm, Joining Phila. Personal Injury Practice".
40. (2017-04-28). "Prosecutor: Charges likely in deadly fall at Penn State frat".
41. Shields, Jeff. (2004-02-07). "Castor formalizes run for Montco seat". The Philadelphia Inquirer.
42. "Poll Commissioned by Castor Campaign". [[PoliticsPA.com]].
43. William Mulgrew. (2007-01-31). "Ellis Backs Candidacy With Poll Numbers". The Bulletin.
44. William Mulgrew. (2007-02-27). "Montco GOP Tries To Make Up". The Bulletin.
45. Margaret Gibbons. (2007-09-24 }}{{dead link). "Dems want Asher money returned". [[Pottstown Mercury]].
46. Jacob Fenton. (2007-11-07). "Montco Republicans are winners". [[The Intelligencer (Doylestown, Pennsylvania).
47. Coughlin, Matt. (July 18, 2012). "Ex Montco commissioner to serve probation on false swearing charge, but unrepentant". PhillyBurbs.com.
48. Gibbons, Margaret. (May 25, 2012). "Matthews' day in court could come on May 31". PhillyBurbs.com.
49. DeHuff, Jenny. (December 6, 2011). "Commissioner Matthews arrested, resigns as chairman". The Times Herald.
50. Rawlins, John. "Democrats historically gain control of Montgomery County". ABC News.
51. Roebuck, Jeremy. (April 16, 2012). "Peace has come to the Montco commission". The Philadelphia Inquirer.
52. Heller, Karen. (March 21, 2012). "Karen Heller: What's great for Montco also bit of a bummer". The Philadelphia Inquirer.
53. (19 August 2016). "Governor nominates former state prosecutor Beemer to replace Kane".
54. (August 19, 2016). "Everybody hates Bruce Castor, and the acting AG couldn't care less". [[The Patriot-News]].
55. Broadwater, Luke. (February 9, 2021). "'The president's lawyer just rambled on and on.' Trump defense lawyer leaves some senators scratching their heads.". The New York Times.
56. Rupar, Aaron. (February 9, 2021). "Even right-wing pundits had no clue what Bruce Castor was doing during his impeachment trial speech".
57. Chait, Jonathan. (February 9, 2021). "Trump's Lawyer Rambles Through Hilariously Incoherent Impeachment Defense".
58. "Even right-wing pundits had no clue what Bruce Castor was doing during his impeachment trial speech". Vox.
59. "The best memes from Bruce Castor's bizarre impeachment speech". The Independent.
60. Haberman, Maggie. (February 10, 2021). "Meandering Performance by Defense Lawyers Enrages Trump". The New York Times.
61. (February 12, 2021). "Lawyer defending Trump accustomed to political disaster". Los Angeles Times.