Annihilationism

History

Old Testament

Proponents of annihilationism agree that the Bible teaches that the wicked are punished eternally, but they believe that punishment is complete destruction for eternity as opposed to eternal life in torment. Appealed to here are references to an "unquenchable fire" and "undying worm" in the Old Testament (Isaiah 66:24; cf. 2 Kings 22:17; Isaiah 17:2–7; 51:8; Jeremiah 4:4; 7:20; 21:12; Ezekiel 20:47–48; Malachi 4:1-3), which refer to the finality of judgement (and not its duration). Similarly, the New Testament teaches that the wicked will justly suffer for their sins, but the result will be their destruction (cf. Luke 16:19–31; Romans 2:8; 2 Thessalonians 1:9).

Church Fathers and later

Christian writers from Tertullian to Luther have held to traditional notions of Hell. However, the annihilationist position is not without some historical precedent. Early forms of annihilationism or conditional immortality are claimed to be found in the writings of Ignatius of Antioch (d. 108/140), Justin Martyr (d. 165), and Irenaeus (d. 202), among others. However, the teachings of Arnobius (d. 330) are often interpreted as the first to defend annihilationism explicitly. One quote, in particular, stands out in Arnobius' second book Against the Heathen:

Dr. Graham Keith of Scotland, in his article "Patristic Views on Hell", notes the following: "Indeed, a century or so after Constantine [i.e. the 4th–5th centuries] we have a surprising amount of evidence indicating widespread denial of eternal punishment within the church."

Eternal torment has been "the semiofficial position of the church since approximately the sixth century", according to Pinnock.

Additionally, at least one of John Wesley's recorded sermons is often reluctantly understood as implying annihilationism. Contrarily, the denominations of Methodism which arose through his influence typically do not agree with annihilationism.

Roman Catholicism

As much as certain Church Fathers and Catholic theologians have advocated qualified forms of universalism, some Catholic theologians have advocated qualified forms of annihilationism as being in line with Catholic teaching. Concerning the typical doctrinal presentation of Hell, the Catechism of the Catholic Church, 2nd Edition, states:

1035 The teaching of the Church affirms the existence of hell and its eternity. Immediately after death, the souls of those who die in a state of mortal sin descend into Hell, where they suffer the punishments of hell, "eternal fire". The chief punishment of hell is eternal separation from God, in whom alone man can possess the life and happiness for which he was created and for which he longs.

1038 The resurrection of all the dead, "of both the just and the unjust," (Acts 24:15) will precede the Last Judgment. This will be "the hour when all who are in the tombs will hear (the Son of man's) voice and come forth, those who have done good, to the resurrection of life, and those who have done evil, to the resurrection of judgment." (Jn 5:28–29) Then Christ will come "in his glory, and all the angels with him... . Before him will be gathered all the nations, and he will separate them one from another as a shepherd separates the sheep from the goats, and he will place the sheep at his right hand, but the goats at the left... . And they will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life." (Mt 25:31,32,46)}}

Anglicanism

Although the Church of England has through most of its history been closer to John Calvin's doctrine of conscious continuation of the immortal soul, the doctrine of annihilation of the "wicked" following a judgment day at a literal return of Christ has had a following in the Anglican Communion. In 1945 a report by the Archbishops' Commission on Evangelism, Towards the conversion of England, caused controversy with statements including that "Judgment is the ultimate separation of the evil from the good, with the consequent destruction of all that opposes itself to God's will."

Millerite and Adventist movement

Recently the doctrine has been most often associated with groups descended from or with influences from the Millerite movement of the mid-19th century. These include the Seventh-day Adventist Church, the Church of God (7th day) – Salem Conference, the Bible Students, Jehovah's Witnesses, the Christadelphians, the followers of Herbert Armstrong, and the various Advent Christian churches. (The Millerite movement consisted of 50,000 to 100,000 people in the United States who eagerly expected the soon return of Jesus, and originated around William Miller.)

George Storrs introduced the belief to the Millerites. He had been a Methodist minister and antislavery advocate. He was introduced to annihilationism when in 1837 he read a pamphlet by Henry Grew. He published tracts in 1841 and 1842 arguing for conditionalism and annihilation. He became a Millerite, and started the Bible Examiner in 1843 to promote these doctrines. However most leaders of the movement rejected these beliefs, other than Charles Fitch who accepted conditionalism. Still, in 1844 the movement officially decided these issues were not essential points of belief.

The Millerites expected Jesus to return around 1843 or 1844, based on Bible texts including Daniel 8:14, and one Hebrew calendar. When the most expected date of Jesus' return (October 22, 1844) passed uneventfully, the "Great Disappointment" resulted. Followers met in 1845 to discuss the future direction of the movement, and were henceforth known as "Adventists". However, they split on the issues of conditionalism and annihilation. The dominant group, which published the Advent Herald, adopted the traditional position of the immortal soul, and became the American Evangelical Adventist Conference. On the other hand, groups behind the Bible Advocate and Second Advent Watchman adopted conditionalism. Later, the main advocate of conditionalism became the World's Crisis publication, which started in the early 1850s, and played a key part in the origin of the Advent Christian Church. Storrs came to believe the wicked would never be resurrected. He and like-minded others formed the Life and Advent Union in 1863.

Seventh-day Adventist Church

The Seventh-day Adventist Church view of Hell is held to be as annihilation and it is one of its distinctive tenets. They hold that the wicked will be lost eternally as they are consumed in the lake of fire rather than eternal suffering, and they will perish and cease to exist in the fire. The church formed from a small group of Millerite Adventists who kept the Saturday Sabbath and today forms the most prominent "Adventist" group.

Ellen G. White rejected the immortal soul concept in 1843. Her husband James White, along with Joseph Bates, formerly belonged to the conditionalist Christian Connection, and hinted at this belief in early publications. Together, the three constitute the primary founders of this denomination.

Articles appeared in the primary magazine of the movement in the 1850s, and two books were published. Annihilationism was apparently established in the church by the middle of that decade. (In the 1860s, the group adopted the name "Seventh-day Adventist" and organized more formally.) D. M. Canright and Uriah Smith produced later books.

A publication with a noticeable impact in the wider Christian world was The Conditionalist Faith of our Fathers (2 vols, 1965–1966) by Le Roy Froom. It has been described by Clark Pinnock as "a classic defense of conditionalism". It is a lengthy historical work, documenting the supporters throughout history.

Robert Brinsmead, an Australian and former Seventh-day Adventist best known for his Present Truth Magazine, originally sponsored Edward Fudge to write The Fire that Consumes.

Samuele Bacchiocchi, best known for his study From Sabbath to Sunday, has defended annihilation. Pinnock wrote the foreword.

The Seventh-day Adventist Church's official beliefs support annihilation. They hold that the doctrine of Hell as defined by mainstream Christianity is incompatible with the concept that God is love. They believe that God loves humans unconditionally, and has no destructive intentions for human beings. Seventh-day Adventists believe that the destructive force of Gehenna is eternal, rather than an indication of eternal conscious torment.

Church of God (7th day) – Salem Conference

According to the Church of God (7th day) – Salem Conference, the dead are unconscious in their graves and immortality is conditional. When God formed Adam out of the dust of the ground, and before Adam could live, God breathed the breath of life into his body: "And man became a living soul" (Genesis 2:7). See also Ezekiel 18:4, 20. Psalm 146:4 says, "His (man's) breath goeth forth, he returneth to his earth (dust); in that very day his thoughts perish." No man has ascended to heaven except Jesus Christ (John 3:13).

Others

Other supporters have included Charles Frederic Hudson (1860), Edward White (1878), Emmanuel Petavel-Olliff (1836–1910, in 1889) and others. Early Pentecostal pioneer Charles Fox Parham taught annihilationism.

1900s onwards

Annihilationism is gaining as a legitimate belief within modern, conservative Protestant theology since the 1960s, and particularly since the 1980s. It has found support and acceptance among some British evangelicals, although it is viewed with greater suspicion by their American counterparts. Recently, a handful of evangelical theologians, including the prominent evangelical Anglican author John Stott, have offered at least tentative support for the doctrine, touching off a heated debate within mainstream evangelical Christianity.

The subject really gained attention in the late 1980s, from publications by two evangelical Anglicans, John Stott and Philip Hughes. Stott advocated annihilationism in the 1988 book Essentials: A Liberal–Evangelical Dialogue with liberal David Edwards, the first time he publicly did so. However, five years later he said that he had been an annihilationist for around fifty years. Stott wrote, "Well, emotionally, I find the concept [of eternal suffering] intolerable and do not understand how people can live with it without either cauterizing their feelings or cracking under the strain. But our emotions are a fluctuating, unreliable guide to truth ... my question [is not] what does my heart tell me, but what does God's word say?"

Stott argued that the biblical descriptions of Hell only state that Hell itself is eternal, not necessarily that sinners damned to Hell will live eternally in suffering, pointing also to several biblical references to the "destruction" of sinners. Fundamentally, though, Stott argues that an eternal punishment for finite crimes would be incompatible with "the belief that God will judge people 'according to what they [have] done' (e.g. Revelation 20:12), which implies that the penalty inflicted will be commensurate with the evil done." However, despite Stott's personal belief in annihilationism, he cautions, "I do not dogmatize about the position to which I have come. I hold it tentatively... I believe that the ultimate annihilation of the wicked should at least be accepted as a legitimate, biblically founded alternative to their eternal conscious torment."

Philip Hughes published The True Image in 1989, which has been called "[o]ne of the most significant books" in the debate. A portion deals with this issue in particular.

John Wenham's 1974 book The Goodness of God contained a chapter that challenged the traditional church doctrine, and it was the first book from an evangelical publishing house to do so. It was republished later as The Enigma of Evil. He contributed a chapter on conditionalism in the 1992 book Universalism and the Doctrine of Hell. He later published Facing Hell: An Autobiography 1913–1996, which explores the doctrine through an autobiographical approach. His interest in the topic stemmed from the 1930s as a student at the University of Cambridge, where he was influenced by Basil Atkinson. (Wenham is best known for his The Elements of New Testament Greek, which has been a standard textbook for students.) He wrote:

The Fire that Consumes was published in 1982 by Edward Fudge of the Churches of Christ. It was described as "the best book" by Clark Pinnock, a decade later. John Gerstner called it "the ablest critique of hell by a believer in the inspiration of the Bible." Clark Pinnock of McMaster Divinity College has defended annihilation. Earlier, Atkinson had self-published the book Life and Immortality. Theologians from Cambridge have been influential in supporting the annihilationist position, particularly Atkinson.

Annihilationism is also the belief of some liberal Christians within mainstream denominations.

There have been individual supporters earlier. Pentecostal healing evangelist William Branham promoted annihilationism in the last few years before his death in 1965.

The Church of England's Doctrine Commission reported in February 1995 that Hell is not eternal torment. The report, entitled "The Mystery of Salvation" states, "Christians have professed appalling theologies which made God into a sadistic monster. ... Hell is not eternal torment, but it is the final and irrevocable choosing of that which is opposed to God so completely and so absolutely that the only end is total non-being." The British Evangelical Alliance ACUTE report (published in 2000) states the doctrine is a "significant minority evangelical view" that has "grown within evangelicalism in recent years". A 2011 study of British evangelicals showed 19% disagreed a little or a lot with eternal conscious torment, and 31% were unsure.

Several evangelical reactions to annihilationism were published. Another critique was by Paul Helm in 1989. In 1990, J. I. Packer delivered several lectures supporting the traditional doctrine of eternal suffering. The reluctance of many evangelicals is illustrated by the fact that proponents of annihilationism have had trouble publishing their doctrines with evangelical publishing houses, with Wenham's 1973 book being the first.

Some well respected authors have remained neutral. F. F. Bruce wrote, "annihilation is certainly an acceptable interpretation of the relevant New Testament passages ... For myself, I remain agnostic." Comparatively, C. S. Lewis did not systematize his own beliefs. He rejected traditional pictures of the "tortures" of hell, as in The Great Divorce where he pictured it as a drab "grey town". Yet in The Problem of Pain, "Lewis sounds much like an annihilationist." He wrote:

The Catechism of the Catholic Church (1992) describes Hell as "eternal death" (paragraph 1861) and elsewhere states that "the chief punishment of hell is that of eternal separation from God" (paragraph 1035). The question is what "eternal" means in this context. Thomas Aquinas, following Boethius, states that "eternity is the full, perfect and simultaneous possession of unending life" (Summa Theologica I, question 10), so apparently eternal separation from God is a "negative eternity", a complete and permanent separation from God. In the Collect (opening prayer) for the eighth Sunday after Pentecost in the Tridentine missal, we find the words "qui sine te esse non possumus", meaning "we who without Thee cannot be (or exist)".

Conditional immortality

Main article: Christian conditionalism

The doctrine is often, although not always, bound up with the notion of "conditional immortality", a belief that the soul is not innately immortal. They are related yet distinct. God, who alone is immortal, passes on the gift of immortality to the righteous, who will live forever in Heaven or on an idyllic Earth or World to Come, while the wicked will ultimately face a second death.

Those who describe or believe in this doctrine may not use "annihilationist" to define the belief, and the terms "mortalist" and "conditionalist" are often used. Edward Fudge (1982) uses "annihilationist" to refer to both the "mortalists" and "conditionalists" who believe in a universal resurrection, as well as those groups which hold that not all the wicked will rise to face the New Testament's "resurrection of the dead, both of the just and unjust".

Justifications

Interpretation of scripture

Some annihilationists insist that words like "destroy, destruction, perish, death" must refer to "non-existence". While this interpretation of those terms does not imply the non-existence of Hades or the lake of fire, this interpretation does require that the souls that inhabit it get reduced to non-existence. Adventists, and perhaps others, then understand the term "Hell" (Hades or lake of fire) to refer to the process of destruction, not a permanently existing process.

Some annihilationists believe there will be suffering in the death process, but ultimately the wages of sin is death, not eternal existence. Some affirm that Jesus taught limited conscious physical sufferings upon the guilty: Other annihilationists, who believe that a loving God would not gratuitously cause the dead to suffer, believe this verse refers to those living through the tribulation(https://www.studylight.org/commentary/luke/12-47.html#:~:text=The%20followers%20of%20Jesus,they%20meet).

Annihilationists declare eternal existence and life is a gift gotten only from believing the gospel; (John 3:16) Paul calls this gift (immortality) an integral part of the gospel message: "who hath abolished death, and hath brought life and 'immortality' to light through the gospel." (2 Timothy 1:10). If all souls are born immortal, then why is humanity encouraged to seek it by Paul? "To them who by patient continuance in well doing 'seek' for glory and honour and immortality, eternal life:" (Romans 2:7) And also, why would Jesus offer humanity an opportunity to "live forever", if all live forever? "If any man eat of this bread, he shall live forever:" (John 6:51).

Annihilationism is based on passages that speak of the unsaved as perishing (John 3:16) or being destroyed (Matthew 10:28). Annihilationists believe that verses speaking of the second death refer to ceasing to exist. Opponents of annihilationism argue that the second death is the spiritual death (separation from God) that occurs after physical death (separation of soul and body). Annihilationists respond by pointing out that spiritual death happens the moment one sins and that it is illogical to believe further separation from God can take place. In addition, annihilationists claim that complete separation from God conflicts with the doctrine of omnipresence in which God is present everywhere. Some annihilationists accept the position that Hell is a separation from God by taking the position that God sustains the life of his creations: when separated from God, one simply ceases to exist.

Cited texts

• James 4:12 "God alone, who gave the law, is the Judge. He alone has the power to save or to destroy."
• Hebrews 10:39 "But we are not like those who turn away from God to their own destruction..."
• Philippians 3:18-19 "For I have told you often before, and I say it again with tears in my eyes, that there are many whose conduct shows they are really enemies of the cross of Christ. 19 They are headed for destruction."
• Psalm 92:7 "Though the wicked sprout like weeds and evildoers flourish they will be destroyed forever."
• Psalm 37:20 "But the wicked will die... they will disappear like smoke."
• Psalm 1:6: "... For the Lord watches over the path of the godly, but the path of the wicked leads to destruction."
• Hebrews 10:26-27 NLT "There is only the terrible expectation of God's judgment and the raging fire that will consume his enemies."
• 2 Peter 3:7 "...for the day of judgment, when ungodly people will be destroyed."
• Romans 2:7 "He will give eternal life to those who keep on doing good, seeking after the glory and honor and immortality that God offers."
• Genesis 3:19 "For you were made from dust, and to dust you will return."
• Psalm 146:4 "When they breathe their last, they return to the earth, and all their plans die with them."
• Ecclesiastes 9:5 "For the living know that they shall die: but the dead know not any thing, neither have they any more a reward; for the memory of them is forgotten."
• Ezekiel 18:20 "The person who sins is the one who will die."
• 2 Chronicles 28:3 "He burned incense in the Valley of the Son of Hinnom, and burned his children in the fire, according to the abominations of the nations whom the Lord had cast out before the children of Israel." (the Valley of Ben Hinnom is where the concept of Gehenna or Hell comes from)
• Jeremiah 19:5 "They have built pagan shrines to Baal, and there they burn their sons as sacrifices to Baal. I have never commanded such a horrible deed; it never even crossed my mind to command such a thing!" (the Valley of Ben Hinnom is where the concept of Gehenna or Hell comes from)
• Malachi 4:1, 4:3 "The day of judgment is coming, burning like a furnace. On that day the arrogant and the wicked will be burned up like straw. They will be consumed—roots, branches, and all... On the day when I act, you will tread upon the wicked as if they were dust under your feet", says the Lord of Heaven's Armies."
• Matthew 10:28 "And fear not them which kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul: but rather fear him which is able to destroy both soul and body in hell."
• John 3:16 "For God so loved the world that he gave his only Son, so that everyone who believes in him may not perish but may have eternal life."
• John 6:51 "I am the living bread that came down from heaven. Anyone who eats this bread will live forever" (the offer to live forever only makes sense if it were possible to not live forever.)
• 2 Thessalonians 1:9 "They will be punished with eternal destruction, forever separated from the Lord and from his glorious power."
• Romans 6:23 "For the wages of sin is death."
• 2 Peter 2:6 "and turning the cities of Sodom and Gomorrah into ashes condemned them with an overthrow, having made them an example unto those that should live ungodly"
• Revelation 20:14-15 "And death and Hades were cast into the lake of fire. This is the second death, even the lake of fire. And if any was not found written in the book of life, he was cast into the lake of fire."

John Wenham, a prominent annihilationist, has classified the New Testament texts on the fate of the dead:

• 10 texts (4%) "Gehenna"
• 26 (10%) to "burning up"
• 59 (22%) to "destruction, perdition, utter loss or ruin"
• 20 (8%) to "separation from God"
• 25 (10%) to "death in its finality" or "the second death"
• 108 (41%) to "unforgiven sin", where the precise consequence is not stated
• 15 (6%) to "anguish"

Wenham claims that just a single verse (Revelation 14:11) sounds like eternal torment to him. This is out of a total of 264 references. Ralph Bowles argues the word order of the verse was chosen to fit a chiastic structure, and does not support eternal punishment. Opponents of annihilationism, however, say that there are in fact many bible verses supporting their view.

Opposing texts

Proponents of the traditional Christian doctrine of Hell, such as Millard Erickson, identify the following biblical texts in support of their doctrine:

• "Surely God will bring you down to everlasting ruin: He will snatch you up and pluck you from your tent; he will uproot you from the land of the living."
• "He beat back his enemies; he put them to everlasting shame."
• "The sinners in Zion are terrified; trembling grips the godless: 'Who of us can dwell with the consuming fire? Who of us can dwell with everlasting burning?
• "And they will go out and look on the dead bodies of those who rebelled against me; the worms that eat them will not die, the fire that burns them will not be quenched, and they will be loathsome to all mankind."
• "I will bring on you everlasting disgrace—everlasting shame that will not be forgotten."
• "I will completely destroy them and make them an object of horror and scorn, and an everlasting ruin."
• "Multitudes who sleep in the dust of the earth will awake: some to everlasting life, others to shame and everlasting contempt."
• "... where there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth."
• "... it will be more bearable for Sodom and Gomorrah on the day of judgment.."
• "It is better for you to enter life maimed or crippled than to have two hands or two feet and be thrown into eternal fire."
• "Then he will say to those on his left, 'Depart from me, you who are cursed, into the eternal fire prepared for the devil and his angels.
• "And the smoke of their torment will rise for ever and ever. There will be no rest day or night for those who worship the beast and its image, or for anyone who receives the mark of its name."
• "And the devil, who deceived them, was thrown into the lake of burning sulfur, where the beast and the false prophet had been thrown. They will be tormented day and night for ever and ever." (This verse leads some annihilationists to conclude that while ordinary human unbelievers will be annihilated, demons will be tormented forever.)

Traditionalist Christians point to biblical references to eternal punishment, as well as eternal elements of this punishment, such as the unquenchable fire, the everlasting shame, the worm that never dies, and the smoke that rises forever, as consistent with the doctrine of eternal, conscious torment. An annihilationist response is that the eternal nature of the fire, worms, and disgrace do not imply eternal conscious torment, only that the punishment has eternal consequences.

Christians who believe in universal reconciliation have also criticized annihilationism using Biblical references. Books of the Bible argued to possibly support the idea of full reconciliation include the First Epistle to the Corinthians. The sections of 1 Corinthians 15:22, "As all die in Adam, so all will be made alive in Christ", and 1 Corinthians 15:28, "God will be all in all", are cited. Verses that seem to contradict the tradition of complete damnation and come up in arguments also include Lamentations 3:31–33 (NIV), "For no one is cast off by the Lord forever. Though he brings grief, he will show compassion, so great is his unfailing love", and 1 Timothy 4:10 (NIV), "We have put our hope in the living God, who is the Savior of all people, and especially of those who believe."

Advocates

• John Stott
• John Wenham
• Michael Green
• Philip Edgecumbe Hughes
• Roger Forster
• Richard Bauckham
• Basil F. C. Atkinson
• Ian Howard Marshall
• Anthony Buzzard
• Clark Pinnock
• Edward Fudge
• Greg Boyd
• Harold Camping
• Homer Hailey
• E. Earle Ellis
• Ellen G. White
• Charles Taze Russell
• Herbert Armstrong
• John G. Stackhouse, Jr.
• Joel B. Green
• Kirk Cameron

Agnostic

Others have remained "agnostic", not taking a stand on the issue of hell.

• F. F. Bruce, who described himself as "agnostic" on this issue

Critics/opponents

• John H. Gerstner
• John Piper
• J. I. Packer
• James R. White
• Steven Anderson
• David Pawson
• Wayne Grudem
• R. C. Sproul
• Albert Mohler
• Tim Keller
• William Lane Craig
• Millard Erickson
• Francis Chan
• Franklin Graham
• Rick Warren
• John F. MacArthur
• Mark Driscoll
• C. J. Mahaney
• Heidi Baker
• Reinhard Bonnke

References

References

1. (1913). "Bible Student and Religious Outlook".
2. (23 May 2017). "Revelation 20:10...a Devil of a Dilemma for Advent Christians".
3. (30 December 2015). "A PRIMER ON REVELATION 20:10".
4. "In Defense of the Faith".
5. (6 June 2013). "Punishment of the Wicked in Light of the Cross".
6. "Signs of the Times".
7. "Seventh-day Adventists Believe... The Millenium and the End of Sin: 27-26.HTM".
8. David A. Reed, Answering Jehovah's Witnesses: Subject by Subject, electronic ed. (Grand Rapids, Michigan: Baker Book House, 1997).
9. [[L. E. Froom]], [https://documents.adventistarchives.org/Books/CFOOF1966-V01.pdf ''The Condionalist Faith of our Fathers''] (Washington, D.C.: Review and Herald, 1965–1966). PART IV.
10. Glenn Peoples. (26 May 2013). "History of Hell: Hell before Augustine".
11. Edwards, D. L. & Stott, J. ''Essentials: A Liberal–Evangelical Dialogue'' London: Hodder & Stoughton, 1988, pp. 313–320.
12. Gore, ''The Religion of the Church'' Oxford: Mowbray, 1916, pp. 91f.
13. Temple, W., ''Christus Veritas'' London: Macmillan, 1924, p. 209
14. Quick, O. C., ''Doctrines of the Creed'' London: Nisbet, 1933, pp. 257f.
15. Simon, Ulrich, ''The End is Not Yet'' Welwyn: Nisbet, 1964, pp. 206f.
16. Caird, G. B., ''The Revelation of St John the Divine'' London: A. and C. Black., 1966, pp. 186f., 260
17. "England: Doctrine Commission Report on the Mystery of Salvation".
18. Crockett, ''Four Views on Hell'', pp. 52–53 (he accepts the traditional view){{page needed. (January 2014)
19. Gregory A. Boyd and Paul R. Eddy, [https://www.google.ca/books/edition/Across_the_Spectrum/4tj2N1QaaO4C?hl=en&gbpv=1&pg=PA286&printsec=frontcover Across the Spectrum: Understanding Issues in Evangelical Theology, 2nd ed]. (Grand Rapids, Michigan: Baker Academic, 2009), pp. 286–287.
20. St. Ignatius. "Epistle to the Magnesians".
21. (13 June 2013). "Justin Martyr and the Immortality of the Soul".
22. St. Justin Martyr. "Dialogue with Trypho".
23. Arnobius, Against the Heathen: Book II, paragraph 61, last sentence.
24. (2017-09-27). "Introduction to Evangelical Conditionalism: The Doctrine of Eternal Torment Was Not Universal in the Early Church {{!}} Rethinking Hell".
25. Pinnock, "Fire then Nothing", p. 40.
26. "John Wesley, Sermon 128: FREE GRACE".
27. Wild, Robert. (2015). "A Catholic Reading Guide to Universalism". Wipf and Stock Publishers.
28. von Balthasar, Hans Urs. (1988). "Dare We Hope: "that All Men be Saved"?; With, A Short Discourse on Hell". Ignatius Press.
29. Wild, Robert. (2016). "A Catholic Reading Guide to Conditional Immortality – The Third Alternative to Hell and Universalism". Wipf and Stock Publishers.
30. Griffiths, Paul. (2014). "Decreation: The Last Things of All Creatures". Baylor University Press.
31. United States Catholic Conference. (2000). "Catechism of the Catholic Church". Libreria Editrice Vaticana.
32. ''Towards the conversion of England'' Church of England Commission on evangelism – 1946 "... but gives the idea that 'everyone goes to heaven when he dies'. 198 During their earlier years children have to learn how to discriminate between the world of experience and the world of imagination."
33. Storrs, George. (1842). "Six Sermons By George Storrs – The Harvest Herald".
34. It had the motto "No immortality, or endless life except through Jesus Christ alone." Sources: ''Lest We Forget'' [http://www.aplib.org/LWFV1N4.pdf 1:4 (1991)]. "[http://www.harvestherald.com/storrs_sermon_biography.htm George Storrs: 1796–1879: A Biographical Sketch] {{Webarchive. link. (2010-10-09 ". HarvestHerald.com. Retrieved June 2010.)
35. Letter from Fitch to Storrs, January 25, 1844
36. Gary Land, "Conditional Immortality" entry in ''Historical Dictionary of the Seventh-day Adventists''. Scarecrow, 2005, pp. 68–69
37. Roswell F. Cottrell, ''Review and Herald'' 1853 – the first clear statement. James White, "Destruction of the Wicked" series, ''Review and Herald'' 1854 [http://www.adventistarchives.org/docs/RH/RH18540613-V05-20__B.pdf]?. D. P. Hall, articles in 1854, republished as the book ''Man Not Immortal'', 1854. [[J. N. Loughborough]] series; republished as ''Is the Soul Immortal?'', 1856
38. D. M. Canright, ''History of the Doctrine of the Immortality of the Soul'', 1871.{{page needed. (January 2014)
39. Uriah Smith, ''Man's Nature and Destiny'', 1884{{page needed. (January 2014)
40. Le Roy Froom [and team], ''The Conditionalist Faith of our Fathers'', 2 vols. Washington, D.C.: Review and Herald, 1965–66; [http://www.adventistarchives.org/documents.asp?CatID=172&SortBy=0&ShowDateOrder=False online link]. See also [https://archive.today/20120630213555/http://jewel.andrews.edu:82/search~S0/?searchtype=t&searcharg=Conditionalist+faith+of+our+fathers&SORT=D&extended=0&SUBMIT=Search&searchlimits=&searchorigarg=tConditionalist+faith+of+our+fathers+:+Part+8 article series] in the ''Review''. One pair of reviews is [[Alfred Vaucher|Alfred-Félix Vaucher]], "[http://www.adventistarchives.org/docs/AUSS/AUSS19660701-V04-02__B.pdf#view=fit#page=93 The History of Conditionalism]". ''[[Andrews University Seminary Studies]]'' 4:2 (July 1966), pp. 193–200 [Vol. II]. He considers it of "greatest use" to theologians and other readers, and presents only "few reservations" for such a "voluminous work". It is aimed at English readers, and thus focuses on Great Britain and America; Vaucher expounds on continental European supporters. He disagrees with the inclusion of the [[Waldensians|Waldenses]] as conditionals, and other descriptions of their history. Vaucher, [http://www.adventistarchives.org/docs/AUSS/AUSS19670701-V05-02__B.pdf#view=fit#page=120 review] in ''[[Andrews University Seminary Studies]]'' 5 (1967), pp. 202–204 [Vol. I]. Vaucher praises Froom's "erudition"; as a "monumental work" without "rival". He questions whether several individuals should be claimed for conditionalism, or that the [[Pharisees]] taught an immortal soul. He challenged the preaching tone of books, and related artwork
41. Clark Pinnock, "The Conditional View", p. 147 footnote 21; in William Crockett, ed., ''Four Views on Hell''. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Zondervan, 1992
42. Vaucher, Alfred-Félix. (1966). "The History of Conditionalism". Andrews University Seminary Studies.
43. Samuele Bacchiocchi, "[http://www.biblicalperspectives.com/books/immortality_resurrection/6.htm Hell: Eternal Torment or Annihilation?] {{Webarchive. link. (2015-02-16 " chapter 6 in ''Immortality Or Resurrection?''. [[Biblical Perspectives]], 1997; {{ISBN). 1-930987-12-9, {{ISBN. 978-1-930987-12-8{{page needed. (January 2014)
44. "[http://www.adventist.org/beliefs/fundamental/index.html Fundamental Beliefs] {{Webarchive. link. (2006-03-10 " (1980) webpage from the official church website. See "25. Second Coming of Christ", "26. Death and Resurrection", "27. Millennium and the End of Sin", and "28. New Earth". The earlier 1872 and 1931 statements also support conditionalism)
45. 1 John 4:8; 1 John 4:16
46. The ''Handbook of Seventh-day Adventist Theology'' (2000) from the [[Seventh-day Adventist Commentary Reference Series. Commentary Reference Series]]{{page needed. (January 2014)
47. http://www.churchofgod-7thday.org/Publications/Doctrinal%20Points%20Final%20Proof.pdf{{full citation needed. (January 2014{{Dead link). (June 2020)
48. White, Edward. (1878). "Life in Christ: A Study of the Scripture Doctrine On the Nature of Man, the Object of the Divine Incarnation, and the Conditions of Human Immortality". E. Stock.
49. Howell, Greg A.. "CHARLES FOX PARHAM'S THEOLOGICAL UNDERBELLY: ANNIHILATIONISM, 8TH-DAY CREATIONISM AND PRE-MILLENIAL ZIONISM".
50. ''John Stott: A Global Ministry'' by [[Timothy Dudley-Smith]], p. 353
51. [[J. I. Packer]]. (Spring 1997). "Evangelical Annihilationism in Review". Reformation & Revival.
52. ''Essentials: A Liberal-Evangelical Dialogue'' by David L. Edwards with a response from John Stott. 1988, p. 314 [313{{ndash320]
53. In 1993. ''John Stott: A Global Ministry'', p. 354
54. ''Essentials'', p. 314.
55. ''Essentials'', pp. 316–318.
56. ''Essentials'', pp. 315–316.
57. ''Essentials'', p. 318.
58. ''Essentials'', p. 320.
59. Philip Edgcumbe Hughes, ''The True Image: The Origin and Destiny of Man in Christ''. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans; and Leicester, United Kingdom: Inter-Varsity Press, 1989, pp. 398–407. As cited by Packer (and Pinnock).
60. Brian P. Phillips, "[http://www.ministrymagazine.org/archive/1996/August/annihilation-or-endless-torment Annihilation or endless torment?]". ''[[Ministry (magazine). Ministry]]'' 69:8 (August 1996), pp. 15, 17–18.
61. John Wenham, ''The Goodness of God''. London: InterVarsity Press, 1974
62. John Wenham, ''The Enigma of Evil'', Britain: InterVarsity Press, 1985; a 2nd edition. A new edition with an extended chapter on the debate was published by Eagle books in 1994, from Guilford, England. As cited by Phillips
63. Wenham, "The Case for Conditional Immortality" in N. M. S. Cameron, ed., ''Universalism and the Doctrine of Hell''. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Baker Book House, 1992. A report on the Fourth Edinburgh Conference on Christian Dogmatics.
64. John Wenham, ''Facing Hell: An Autobiography 1913–1996''. Paternoster Press: 1998
65. Wenham in ''Universalism and the Doctrine of Hell'', p190,191; as quoted by Phillips
66. Edward W. Fudge, ''The Fire that Consumes: A Biblical and Historical Study of Final Punishment''. Houston: Providential, 1982. [http://www.edwardfudge.com/written/fire.html Author's webpage] {{webarchive. link. (March 25, 2010 . Fudge is a member of the [[Churches of Christ]])
67. ''Four Views on Hell'', p. 137 footnote 5.
68. As cited by Phillips
69. An early article was Pinnock, "Fire, then Nothing". ''Christianity Today'' (March 20, 1987), pp. 40–41. He lists the evangelical authors who persuaded him as: Stott, Fudge, Hughes, and Green (as cited elsewhere in this article), and Stephen Travis, ''I Believe in the Second Coming of Christ''. Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans, 1982, pp. 196–199. Listed in ''Four Views on Hell'', p. 137 footnote 5.
70. Basil F. C. Atkinson, ''Life and Immortality: An Examination of the Nature and Meaning of Life and Death as They Are Revealed in the Scriptures''. Taunton, England: printed by E. Goodman, pp. 196–?. As cited by Phillips, and [[WorldCat]].
71. ''John Stott: A Global Ministry'', p. 353.
72. ''An Exposition of the Seven Church Ages'' (1965), pp. 133–135; ''The Revelation of the Seven Seals'' (1967), p. 487.
73. Church of England, "The Mystery of Salvation: The Doctrine Commission of the General Synod" (1995), p. 199; published by Church House Publishing, London, 1995; copyrighted by The Central Board of Finance of the Church of England, 1995, {{ISBN. 0-7151-3778-6
74. (2000). "The Nature of Hell". Paternoster Publishing.
75. ''[http://www.eauk.org/snapshot/ 21st Century Evangelicals: A snapshot of the beliefs and habits of evangelical Christians in the UK] {{Webarchive. link. (2011-01-16''. Evangelical Alliance and Christian Research, 2011, p. 9.)
76. [[Eryl Davies]], ''The Wrath of God'', [[Evangelical Movement of Wales]].[[William Greenough Thayer Shedd. W. G. T. Shedd]], ''The Doctrine of Endless Punishment'', was reissued by [[Banner of Truth Trust]]. As cited by Phillips
77. [[Paul Helm]], ''The Last Things: Death, Judgment, Heaven and Hell''. Banner of Truth, 1989
78. Letter from F. F. Bruce to John Stott in 1989, as quoted in ''John Stott: A Global Ministry'', p. 354.
79. According to F. F. Bruce, in his foreword to Edward Fudge, ''The Fire That Consumes'', p. viii.
80. Pinnock, "The Conditional View", in Crockett; p. 150 including footnote 28.
81. C. S. Lewis, ''The Problem of Pain''. London and Glasgow: Collins, 1940, p114–115; emphasis in original
82. ''Essentials'', p. 316.
83. {{bibleverse. Rev. 2:11, {{bibleverse. Rev. 20:6. 20:6, {{bibleverse. Rev. 20:14. 20:14, {{bibleverse. Rev. 21:8. 21:8
84. Edward Fudge, The Fire That Consumes: A Biblical and Historical Study of Final Punishment (Houston, Texas: Providential Press, 1982).
85. Crockett. (1992). "Four Views on Hell". Zondervan.
86. Chapter 6, "Hell: Not Endless" in ''The Enigma of Evil'' by John Wenham, pp. 68–92; esp. pp. 81–83. Quotations are Wenham's terms, not the Bible's necessarily. The first edition of the book was titled, ''The Goodness of God'', but contained little or none of this discussion.
87. Bowles, Ralph G.. (2000). "Does Revelation 14:11 Teach Eternal Torment? Examining a Proof-text on Hell". [[Evangelical Quarterly]].
88. Ortlund, Gavin. (16 June 2017). "J. I. Packer on Why Annihilationism Is Wrong".
89. [[Millard Erickson]], Christian Theology, 2nd Ed. (Grand Rapids, Michigan: Baker Academic, 1998), pp. 1242–1244.
90. Sotak, Max H.. (1996). "Damning assumptions: What advocates of endless torment take for granted".
91. "Universalism: a historical survey by Richard Bauckham".
92. Fisher, David A.. (December 2011). "The Question of Universal Salvation: Will All Be Saved?". The Maronite Voice, Volume VII, Issue No. XI..
93. "Lamentations 3:31–33 NIV – Bible Gateway".
94. "1 Timothy 4:10 NIV – Bible Gateway".
95. (1989). "Evangelical Essentials: A Liberal-evangelical Dialogue". InterVarsity Press.
96. Michael Green, ''Evangelism Through the Local Church''. London: Hodder and Stoughton, 1990, pp. 69–70.
97. Pidcock, Rick. (December 11, 2025). "Heads spin as Kirk Cameron gives up eternal conscious torment". [[Baptist News Global]].
98. (16 June 2017). "J. I. Packer on Why Annihilationism Is Wrong".