Allegany County, New York

History

For centuries, Allegany County was the territory of the Seneca people, at the westernmost nation of the Five Nations of the Haudenosaunee, a confederacy of Iroquoian languages-speaking peoples. European-American permanent settlement did not take place until after the American Revolutionary War and the forced cession by the Seneca of most of their lands in western New York. New York State sold off the lands cheaply to attract new European-American settlers and agricultural development.

Allegany County was created by the state legislature on April 7, 1806, when Genesee County, New York, was partitioned to set aside some 1570 sqmi to the new county. The first County Seat was established at Angelica, New York, where it remained for half a century. It was later moved to Belmont, a village located along the Genesee River. On March 11, 1808, the borders were adjusted so that 230 sqmi of Steuben County passed to Allegany County, and 600 mi of Allegany County passed to Genesee County. This established the current border between Genesee and Steuben counties, and reduced the size of Allegany County to 1200 sqmi.

On June 12, 1812, the legislature authorized the attachment of Cattaraugus County, New York, to Allegany County for administration reasons, but for practical reasons this action did not take place at that time. However, on April 13, 1814, the eastern half of Cattaraugus County was so attached and administered from Belmont. This attachment was ended on March 28, 1817. With continued settlement through the mid-nineteenth century, the legislature periodically adjusted county borders as new counties were organized in western New York. On April 1, 1846, Allegany County lost 120 sqmi to Wyoming County, reducing the size of Allegany County to 1140 sqmi, and establishing the current border between Allegany and Wyoming counties. On May 11, 1846, Allegany County lost 50 sqmi to Livingston County, reducing the total to 1090 sqmi, and establishing the western portion of the current border with Livingston County. On March 23, 1857, Allegany County lost another 40 sqmi to Livingston County, passing the Ossian, New York, area to Livingston County, and establishing the current border between them.

Geography

According to the U.S. Census Bureau, the county has a total area of 1034 sqmi, of which 1029 sqmi is land and 5.1 sqmi (0.5%) is water.

Allegany County is in the southwestern part of New York State, along the Pennsylvania border. Allegany County does not lie along the Allegheny River, as its name would suggest. The highest point in the county is Alma Hill, with an elevation of 2,548 ft above sea level. This is the highest point in the state west of the Catskill Mountains. The highest point of Interstate 86 is located in the town of West Almond with an elevation of 2,110 feet. This is also believed to be the highest point of any interstate in New York. The county is unique from a watershed perspective as it is providing water to three major watersheds of North America: The eastern part near Alfred has Canacadea Creek that goes into the Canisteo River, Susquehanna River and eventually to Chesapeake Bay.

The Genesee River bisects the county from south to north, flowing north out of the County through Letchworth State Park with its three waterfalls on to Rochester over three more waterfalls to its mouth on Lake Ontario and then on to the St. Lawrence River and Atlantic Ocean. The southwestern part of the County flows into the Allegheny River that flows into the Ohio and then to the Mississippi River basin to the Gulf of Mexico.

In June 1972 the remnants of Hurricane Agnes stalled over the area, dropping more than 20 in of rain. Flooding took place in the valley communities of Wellsville, Belmont, Belfast, and others in the county.

Long a necessary transportation waterway for the Seneca and other Native Americans, and successive European-American settlers, since the late 20th century, the Genesee River has been extremely popular with canoeists. The river is also favored by fishermen as it abounds in smallmouth bass, trout and panfish.

Adjacent counties

• Livingston County – northeast
• Steuben County – east
• Potter County, Pennsylvania – southeast
• McKean County, Pennsylvania – southwest
• Cattaraugus County – west
• Wyoming County – northwest

Major highways

• [[File:I-86.svg|20px]] Interstate 86 (Southern Tier Expressway)
• [[File:NY-17.svg|20px]] New York State Route 17 (Southern Tier Expressway)
• [[File:NY-19.svg|20px]] New York State Route 19
• [[File:NY-21.svg|20px]] New York State Route 21
• [[File:NY-305.svg|25px]] New York State Route 305
• [[File:NY-417.svg|25px]] New York State Route 417

Demographics

|align-fn=center 1790-1960 1900-1990 1990-2000 2010-2020

2020 census

2000 census

As of the census of 2020, there were 46,456 people. Based on earlier (2000) censuses, there were 18,009 households, and 12,192 families residing in the county. The population density was 48 /mi2. There were 24,505 housing units at an average density of 24 /mi2. The racial makeup of the county was 97.03% White, 0.72% Black or African American, 0.28% Native American, 0.72% Asian, 0.37% from other races, and 0.88% from two or more races. 0.91% of the population were Hispanic or Latino of any race. 22.3% identified as being of German, 16.6% English, 13.8% Irish, 11.9% American and 7.0% Italian ancestry according to Census 2000. 96.5% spoke English and 1.3% Spanish as their first language.

There were 18,009 households, out of which 31.50% had children under the age of 18 living with them, 54.20% were married couples living together, 9.00% had a female householder with no husband present, and 32.30% were non-families. 26.00% of all households were made up of individuals, and 11.30% had someone living alone who was 65 years of age or older. The average household size was 2.53 and the average family size was 3.04.

In the county, the population was spread out, with 24.40% under the age of 18, 15.50% from 18 to 24, 23.90% from 25 to 44, 22.20% from 45 to 64, and 14.00% who were 65 years of age or older. The median age was 35 years. For every 100 females there were 99.80 males. For every 100 females age 18 and over, there were 98.10 males.

The median income for a household in the county was $32,106, and the median income for a family was $38,580. Males had a median income of $30,401 versus $21,466 for females. The per capita income for the county was $14,975. About 10.50% of families and 15.50% of the population were below the poverty line, including 19.20% of those under age 18 and 7.50% of those age 65 or over.

Government and politics

Allegany County is part of New York's 23rd congressional district and is represented by Republican Nick Langworthy. In the New York State Senate, it is part of the 57th district and is represented by Republican George M. Borrello, and the 58th district is represented by Thomas F. O'Mara. In the New York State Assembly, the county is in the 148th Assembly District represented by Republican Joseph Sempolinski.

Allegany County is divided into five districts, delineated by town borders. The Allegany County Board of Legislators consists of 15 members, three from each of the five legislative districts:

District 1: Angelica, Belfast, Caneadea, Centerville, Granger, Hume, Rushford, and the village of Angelica.

District 2: Amity, Clarksville, Cuba, Friendship, New Hudson, Ward, and the villages of Belmont and Cuba.

District 3: Alma, Bolivar, Genesee, Independence, Scio, Willing, Wirt, and the villages of Bolivar and Richburg.

District 4: Andover, Wellsville, and the villages of Andover and Wellsville.

District 5: Alfred, Allen, Almond, Birdsall, Burns, Grove, West Almond, and the villages of Alfred, Almond, and Canaseraga.

The current chairperson of the legislature is W. Brooke Harris. The County Administrator is Carissa M. Knapp.

Allegany County is considered to be a strongly Republican county. In 2004, it voted for George W. Bush over John Kerry 63% to 34%, and in 2008 it voted for John McCain over Barack Obama 59% to 39%. It has been reported that in the last 170 years, the only Democratic candidates to win were Franklin Pierce in 1852 and Lyndon B. Johnson in 1964. Even in 1964, when Republican nominee Barry Goldwater lost the county by 14 points, he still managed to carry the towns of Centerville, Caneadea, Granger, Hume, and Rushford. In 2006, neither Democrat Eliot Spitzer nor Hillary Clinton carried it in their otherwise landslide elections for governor and US senator, respectively. Eliot Spitzer lost 48.98% to John Faso's 49.03%. Hillary Clinton lost the county by 3 points. In 2010, Andrew Cuomo lost by a wide margin while Senator Chuck Schumer carried it by a narrow margin of 49.46% to Jay Townsend's 48.86% a margin of 78 votes. It was one of only two counties that Senator Kirsten Gillibrand lost to Wendy Long in 2012. In the 2016, 2020, and 2024 presidential elections, Republican Donald Trump received over two-thirds, the first for a Republican since 1988.

Education

Primary Education

The county has twelve school districts with their buildings in the county and parts of an additional seven districts located outside the county. Districts include: Alfred-Almond Central and Canaseraga Central that are part of the Greater Southern Tier BOCES with a facility in Hornell. Districts in association with the Cattaraugus-Allegany BOCES include: Andover Central, Whitesville Central, Wellsville Central, Bolivar-Richburg Central, Scio Central, Genesee Valley Central, Belfast Central, Fillmore Central, Friendship Central, and Cuba-Rushford Central. Districts with their buildings outside the County include Arkport, Hinsdale, Portville, Yorkshire-Pioneer, Letchworth, Canisteo-Greenwood, and Keshequa. There are two private schools: Immaculate Conception in Wellsville and Houghton Academy in Houghton. There are also two Montessori Schools which are located in Wellsville and Alfred

Secondary Education

• Alfred University
• Houghton University
• The New York State College of Ceramics (a member of SUNY)
• Alfred State College, with a main campus in Alfred, NY and the School of Applied Technology located at the Wellsville campus.

Communities

Allegany County comprises 29 towns and 10 villages.

† - County seat

‡ - Not wholly in this county

Towns

• Alfred
• Allen
• Alma
• Almond
• Amity
• Andover
• Angelica
• Belfast
• Birdsall
• Bolivar
• Burns
• Caneadea
• Centerville
• Clarksville
• Cuba
• Friendship
• Genesee
• Granger
• Grove
• Hume
• Independence
• New Hudson
• Rushford
• Scio
• Ward
• Wellsville
• West Almond
• Willing
• Wirt

Villages

• Alfred
• Almond
• Andover
• Angelica
• Belmont
• Bolivar
• Canaseraga
• Cuba
• Richburg
• Wellsville

Census Designated Places (CDP)

• Belfast
• Fillmore
• Friendship
• Houghton
• Rushford
• Scio
• Stannards

Hamlets

In New York, the term hamlet, while not defined in law, is used to describe an unincorporated community and geographic location within a town. The town in which each hamlet is located is in parentheses.

• Alfred Station (Alfred)
• Tinkertown (Alfred)
• Tip Top (Alfred)
• Allen Center (Allen)
• Aristotle (Allen)
• West Allen (Allen)
• Allentown (Alma)
• Alma (Alma)
• Petrolia (Alma)
• Pikeville (Alma)
• Bishopville (Almond)
• Karrdale (Almond)
• North Almond (Almond)
• Belvidere (Amity)
• Withey (Amity)
• Elm Valley (Andover)
• Rockville (Belfast)
• Hiltonville (Birdsall)
• Scholes (Birdsall)
• Bowler (Bolivar)
• Hoben (Bolivar)
• Kossuth (Bolivar)
• Little Genesee (Bolivar)
• Sawyer (Bolivar)
• South Bolivar (Bolivar)
• Vosburg (Bolivar)
• Garwoods (Burns)
• Gas Spring (Burns)
• Houghton (Caneadea)
• Oramel (Caneadea)
• Centerville (Centerville)
• Fairview (Centerville)
• Higgins (Centerville)
• Germantown (Clarksville)
• Obi (Clarksville)
• West Clarksville (Clarksville)
• North Cuba (Cuba)
• South Cuba (Cuba)
• Hardy Corners (Farmersville)
• Higgins (Friendship)
• Nile (Friendship)
• Ceres (Genesee)
• Sanford (Genesee)
• Short Tract (Granger)
• Swain (Grove)
• Fillmore (Hume)
• Mills Mills (Hume)
• Rossburg (Hume)
• Wiscoy (Hume)
• Fulmer Valley (Independence)
• Spring Mills (Independence)
• Whitesville (Independence)
• Bellville (New Hudson)
• Black Creek (New Hudson)
• Lyons Corners (New Hudson)
• Marshall (New Hudson)
• Rawson (New Hudson)
• Balcom Beach (Rushford)
• Hillcrest (Rushford)
• McGrawville (Rushford)
• Rushford (Rushford)
• Knight Creek (Scio)
• Norton Summit (Scio)
• Scio (Scio)
• Phillips Creek (Ward)
• Stannards (Wellsville)
• Bennetts (West Almond)
• Hallsport (Willing)
• Mapes (Willing)
• Paynesville (Willing)
• Shongo (Willing)
• Inavale (Wirt)
• West Notch (Wirt)

Indian reservations

• Oil Springs Reservation (part)

The Oil Springs Reservation is an Indian reservation of the Seneca Nation shared with Cattaraugus County having a total area of only 1 sqmi. This is the site of the famed spring described by the Franciscan Missionary Joseph DeLa Roch D'Allion in 1627, the first recorded mention of oil on the North American Continent. In 1927, the New York State Oil Producers Association sponsored the dedication of a monument at the site describing the history of the oil industry in North America. There is a small park with parking and a footbridge to the monument. The remainder of the reservation is mostly utilized for cottages on Cuba Lake, Seneca-run gas stations, and woodlands.

Notes

References

References

1. "Allegany County, New York".
2. "U.S. Census Bureau QuickFacts: Allegany County, New York". United States Census Bureau.
3. "US Census 2020 Population Dataset Tables for New York". United States Census Bureau.
4. "Find a County". National Association of Counties.
5. New York. ''Laws of New York; 1806; 29th Session; Chapter 162; Section 1; Page 605.''
6. New York. ''Laws of New York; 1808; 31st Session, Chapter 38; Page 263.''
7. New York. ''Laws of New York; 1808; 31st Session; Chapter 40; Sections 1—2; Page 266.''
8. New York. ''Laws of New York; 1812; 35th Session; Chapter 38; Page 263 .''
9. New York. ''Laws of New York; 1814; 37th Session; Chapter 123; Page 146.''
10. New York. ''Laws of New York; 1816; 40th Session; Chapter 115; Section 1; Page 107.''
11. New York. ''Laws of New York; 1846; 69th Session; Chapter 51; Page 53.''
12. New York. ''Laws of New York; 1846; 69th Session; Chapter 197; Section 1; Page 235.''
13. New York. ''Laws of New York; 1857; 80th Session; Chapter 166; Page 366.''
14. (August 22, 2012). "2010 Census Gazetteer Files". United States Census Bureau.
15. "U.S. Decennial Census". United States Census Bureau.
16. "Historical Census Browser". University of Virginia Library.
17. "Population of Counties by Decennial Census: 1900 to 1990". United States Census Bureau.
18. "1950 Census: Population of New York by Counties: April 1, 1950". United States Census Bureau.
19. "Census 2000 PHC-T-4. Ranking Tables for Counties: 1990 and 2000". United States Census Bureau.
20. "1980 Census of Population - General Population Characteristics - New York - Table 15 - Persons by Race and Table 16 - Total Persons and Spanish Origin Persons by Type of Spanish Origin and Race (p. 34/29-34/70)".
21. "1990 Census of Population - General Population Characteristics - New York - Table 3 - Race and Hispanic Origin".
22. "P004: Hispanic or Latino, and Not Hispanic or Latino by Race – 2000: DEC Summary File 1 – Allegany County, New York".
23. "P2: Hispanic or Latino, and Not Hispanic or Latino by Race – 2010: DEC Redistricting Data (PL 94-171) – Allegany County, New York".
24. "P2: Hispanic or Latino, and Not Hispanic or Latino by Race – 2020: DEC Redistricting Data (PL 94-171) – Allegany County, New York".
25. included in the Asian category in the 1980 Census
26. included in the Asian category in the 1990 Census
27. not an option in the 1980 Census
28. not an option in the 1990 Census
29. "U.S. Census website". [[United States Census Bureau]].
30. Leip, David. "Dave Leip's Atlas of U.S. Presidential Elections".
31. . (2025-04-03). ["Our District"](https://www.nysenate.gov/senators/george-m-borrello/district). *New York State*.
32. . (2025-04-03). ["Our District"](https://www.nysenate.gov/senators/thomas-f-omara/district). *New York State*.
33. . (2025-04-03). ["Joe Sempolinksi Assembly District 148"](https://nyassembly.gov/mem/?ad=148&sh=map). *New York State*.
34. . (2025-04-03). ["County Districts"](https://www.alleganyco.gov/government/legislators/county-districts/). *Allegany County, NY*.
35. . (2025-04-03). ["Legislators"](https://www.alleganyco.gov/government/legislators/). *Allegany County, NY*.
36. "County Results - Election Center 2008 - Elections & Politics from CNN.com".
37. "Presidential election of 1852 - Map by counties".
38. "Presidential election of 1964 - Map by counties".
39. (November 4, 1964). "Allegany County, NY presidential election results, 1964". Wellsville Daily Reporter.
40. (April 2016). "NYSVoter Enrollment by County, Party Affiliation and Status". New York State Board of Elections.
41. . (2025-04-22). ["Profile"](https://hs.ocfs.ny.gov/dcfs/Profile/Index/220200). *NY State Office of Children and Family Services*.
42. . (2025-04-22). ["Education/Schools"](https://www.alfredny.org/alfred-montessori-school). *Village of Alfred*.
43. . (2025-04-03). ["NYS Place Points"](https://data.gis.ny.gov/datasets/ffcdc0d1a4474d34be48e24376510216_0/explore). *New York State*.