Age of criminal responsibility

Terminology

The terminology regarding such a defense varies by jurisdiction and sphere. "Defense of infancy" is a mainly US term. The "age of criminal responsibility" is used by most European countries, the UK, Australia, New Zealand and other Commonwealth of Nations countries. Other instances of usage have included the terms age of accountability, age of responsibility, and age of liability.

The term minimum age of criminal responsibility (MACR) is a term commonly used in the literature.

The rationale behind the age of accountability laws are the same as those behind the insanity defense, insinuating both the mentally disabled and the young lack apprehension.

The age of criminal responsibility

Governments enact laws to label certain types of activity as wrongful or illegal. Behavior of a more antisocial nature can be stigmatized in a more positive way to show society's disapproval through the use of the word criminal. In this context, laws tend to use the phrase, "age of criminal responsibility" in two different ways:

1. As a definition of the process for dealing with an alleged offender, the range of ages specifies the exemption of a child from the adult system of prosecution and punishment. Most jurisdictions develop special juvenile justice systems in parallel to the adult criminal justice system. Here, the hearings are essentially welfare-based and deal with children as in need of compulsory measures of treatment and/or care. Children are diverted into this system when they have committed what would have been an offense as an adult.
2. As the physical capacity of a child to commit a crime. Hence, children are deemed incapable of committing some sexual or other acts requiring abilities of a more mature quality.

Discussion

This is an aspect of the public policy of parens patriae. In the criminal law, each state will consider the nature of its own society and the available evidence of the age at which antisocial behaviors begins to manifest itself. Some societies will have qualities of indulgence toward the young and inexperienced, and will not wish them to be exposed to the criminal law system before all other avenues of response have been exhausted. Hence, some states have a policy of doli incapax (i.e. incapable of wrong) and exclude liability for all acts and omissions that would otherwise have been criminal after reaching a specified age. Hence, no matter what the child may have done, there cannot be a criminal prosecution. However, although no criminal liability is inferred, other aspects of law may be applied. For example, in Nordic countries, an offense by a person under 15 years of age is considered mostly a symptom of problems in child's development. This will cause the social authorities to take appropriate administrative measures to secure the development of the child. Such measures may range from counseling to placement at a special care unit. Being non-judicial, the measures are not dependent on the severity of the offense committed but on the overall circumstances of the child.

The policy of treating minors as incapable of committing crimes does not necessarily reflect modern sensibilities. Thus, if the rationale of the excuse is that children below a certain age lack the capacity to form the mens rea of an offense, this may no longer be a sustainable argument. Indeed, given the different speeds at which people may develop both physically and intellectually, any form of explicit age limit may be arbitrary and irrational. Yet, the sense that children do not deserve to be exposed to criminal punishment in the same way as adults remains strong. Children have not had experience of life, nor do they have the same mental and intellectual capacities as adults. Hence, it might be considered unfair to treat young children in the same way as adults.

In Scotland, the age of criminal responsibility was raised from 8 to 12 by the implementation of the Age of Criminal Responsibility (Scotland) Act 2019, which came into force on 31 March 2020. In England and Wales and Northern Ireland, the age of responsibility is 10 years, and in the Netherlands and Canada the age of responsibility is 12 years. Sweden, Finland, and Norway all set the age at 15 years. In the United States, the minimum age for federal crimes is 11 years. State minimums vary, with 24 states having no defined minimum age, and defined minimums ranging from 7 years in Florida to 13 years in Maryland and New Hampshire.

As the treaty parties of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court could not agree on a minimum age for criminal responsibility, they chose to solve the question procedurally and excluded the jurisdiction of the Court for persons under eighteen years.

Some jurisdictions do not have a set fixed minimum age, but leave discretion to prosecutors to argue or the judges to rule on whether the child or adolescent ("juvenile") defendant understood that what was being done was wrong. If the defendant did not understand the difference between right and wrong, it may not be considered appropriate to treat such a person as culpable. Alternatively, the lack of real fault in the offender can be recognized by rulings that avoid criminal sentences and/or address more practical matters of parental responsibility by adjusting the rights of parents to unsupervised custody, or by separate criminal proceedings against the parents for breach of their duties as parents.

By country

The following are the minimum ages at which people may be charged with a criminal offence in each country:

Juvenile courts

In some countries, a juvenile court is a court of special jurisdiction charged with adjudicating cases involving crimes committed by those who have not yet reached a specific age. If convicted in a juvenile court, the offender is found "responsible" for their actions as opposed to "guilty" of a criminal offense. Sometimes, in some jurisdictions (such as the United States of America), a minor may be tried as an adult.

Notes

Footnotes

References

References

1. Academy, The British. (2022-04-01). "Age of Criminal Responsibility".
2. "Doctrine of 'Doli Incapax' {{!}} Office of Justice Programs".
3. "Crime and Disorder Act 1998".
4. Department, Law Lords. "House of Lords - R v JTB (Appellant) (on appeal from the Court of Appeal (Criminal Division))".
5. "6.2 Infancy, Intoxication, Ignorance, and Mistake".
6. Stattin, Hekan, and [[David Magnusson]]. "Stability and change in criminal behaviour up to age 30." British Journal of Criminology 31.4 (1991): 327-346.
7. Papadodimitraki, Yanna. (2016). "Minimum Age of Criminal Responsibility (MACR) – Comparative Analysis International Profile – New Zealand". Centre for Youth & Criminal Justice.
8. Sharma, Vishnu D.. (1970). "The Age of Criminal Responsibility in India". Journal of the Indian Law Institute.
9. Ranson, Stewart. "Public accountability in the age of neo-liberal governance." J. Education Policy 18.5 (2003): 459-480.
10. [[Anthony Platt. Platt, Anthony]], and [[Bernard L. Diamond]]. "The origins of the right and wrong test of criminal responsibility and its subsequent development in the United States: An historical survey." Cal. L. Rev. 54 (1966): 1227.
11. Ferreira, Nuno. "Putting the age of criminal and tort liability into context: A dialogue between law and psychology." The International Journal of Children's Rights 16.1 (2008): 29-54.
12. (19 June 2017). "Raise the Age? Children's Attitudes Towards the Minimum Age of Criminal Responsibility".
13. Roberts, Caton F., [[Stephen L. Golding]], and Frank D. Fincham. "Implicit theories of criminal responsibility: Decision making and the insanity defense." Law and Human Behavior 11.3 (1987): 207.
14. Dalby JT.. (1985). "Criminal liability in children". Canadian Journal of Criminology.
15. KKIENERM. "Crime Prevention & Criminal Justice Module 13 Key Issues: Topic four - Justice for children in conflict with the law".
16. (7 May 2019). "Youth justice: Raising the age of criminal responsibility".
17. (11 March 2020). "The Age of Criminal Responsibility (Scotland) Act 2019 (Commencement No. 2) Regulations 2020".
18. "Young people and the law".
19. (July 2023). "Minimum Age Laws for Juvenile Court Jurisdiction and Confinement". National Juvenile Justice Network.
20. "Afghanistan Juvenile Code, Article 10".
21. "Criminal Code of the Republic of Albania, Article 12.".
22. "Algerian Penal Code, Article 49".
23. "Criminal Code of Andorra, Article 2".
24. "Angola".
25. "Juvenile Act, Article 8".
26. "Debates Over Lowering the Criminal Responsibility Age". The Argentina Independent.
27. "Ley 22.278 Régimen Penal de la Minoridad Articles 1–2".
28. "Criminal Code (2003) Article 24".
29. "CRIMES ACT 1914 s 4M".
30. (27 February 2021). "Council of Attorneys-General – Age of Criminal Responsibility Working Group Review".
31. "Crimes Act 1914 s 4N".
32. "Jugendgerichtsgesetz (1988) §1(1–2) and 4".
33. "Criminal Code of the Azerbaijan Republic (2000) Article 20 (1–2). [Note: unofficial translation.]".
34. "Bahrain - International Centre for Missing & Exploited Children".
35. "Criminal Code of the Republic of Belarus (1999). [Note: unofficial translation.]".
36. "Juvenile Justice Information Portfolio - Committee on the Rights of the Child - 3. State Party Reports: Belize".
37. "Juvenile Justice Information Portfolio - Committee on the Rights of the Child - 3. State Party Reports: Benin".).
38. "Rige Ley donde se reduce la edad de imputabilidad de los menores".
39. "Bolivia – Edad de responsabilidad penal ordinaria es desde los 18 años – JORNADA".
40. "Botswana National Child Protection Legislation".
41. [http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/constituicao/ConstituicaoCompilado.htm Federal Constitution (in Portuguese)] {{Webarchive. link. (5 May 2016 , Article 228. Retrieved 2 January 2011.)
42. [http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/leis/l8069.htm Estatuto da Criança e do Adolescente (pt)] {{Webarchive. link. (7 December 2019 , Seção V. Retrieved 2 May 2013)
43. "Progress of Nations 1997 Special Protections – Progress and Disparity".
44. "Folha de S.Paulo".
45. "Inhuman sentencing of children in Brunei Darussalam".
46. "Bulgarian Criminal Code (in Bulgarian). Accessed 13 January 2021".
47. "Juvenile Justice Information Portfolio - Committee on the Rights of the Child - 3. State Party Reports: Burkino Faso".
48. "Minimum Ages of Criminal Responsibility in Africa".
49. [[Criminal Code (Canada). Criminal Code]], RSC 1985, c C-46, s. 13; may receive reduced sentencing under the [[Youth Criminal Justice Act]] until age 18.
50. "EL NUEVO SISTEMA DE JUSTICIA PENAL PARA ADOLESCENTES".
51. (28 March 2012). "Ministro de Justicia descarta rebaja en edad de responsabilidad penal adolescente". Emol.
52. (1 March 2021). "China's amended law lowering criminal liability age to 12 takes effect".
53. (22 April 2009). "La mayoría de los países de América latina ya tiene un régimen penal juvenil". La Nación.
54. "Zakon o sudovima za mladež".
55. "Cuba - Factsheets - Youthpolicy.org".
56. (12 August 2009). "Klaus podpisem stvrdil trestní odpovědnost i legální sex od 15 let".
57. [https://www.logir.fo/Lovbekendtgorelse/215-af-24-06-1939-af-Straffeloven-som-senest-aendret-ved-anordning-nr-1139-af-4 Faroese Criminal Code] {{Webarchive. link. (26 October 2020 (2020), § 15)
58. "At what age?... ...are school-children employed, married and taken to court?".
59. "Adolescentes infractores, en la mira de Código Penal". El Telegrafo, telegrafo, diario, Ecuador, noticias, noticias de Ecuador, decano de la prensa nacional.
60. [http://www.finlex.fi/en/laki/kaannokset/1889/en18890039.pdf Penal Code] {{Webarchive. link. (19 May 2021 3:1 § (39/1889, as changed by 515/2003). Retrieved 31 October 2007.)
61. "Juvenile justice in Georgia".
62. "Criminal Code (Strafgesetzbuch, StGB)".
63. Section 3 of the Juvenile Offenders Ordinance 2003 (Chapter 226, Laws of Hong Kong)
64. "Justice ministry rejects UNICEF criticism of new criminal code provisions on youthful offenders". Politics.hu.
65. "Minimum Ages of Criminal Responsibility in Asia".
66. Pramesti, Tri Jata Ayu. (August 25, 2014). "Hal-Hal Penting yang Diatur dalam UU Sistem Peradilan Pidana Anak".
67. "Iran Human Rights Documentation Center – Criminal Responsibility of Children in the Islamic Republic of Iran's New Penal Code".
68. (17 March 2014). "Iran urged to increase age of criminal responsibility for children".
69. "Children and the criminal justice system".
70. (20 December 2018). "Situation analysis of juvenile justice system in Jordan".
71. [https://www.legislationline.org/download/id/8260/file/Kazakhstan_CC_2014_2016_en.pdf Penal Code of the Republic of Kazakhstan] {{Webarchive. link. (22 April 2021 (2014), Art. 15)
72. "Kosovo Factsheet". youthpolicy.org.
73. [https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/applic/ihl/ihl-nat.nsf/0/705a3f3b34f0090ec12577440047742c/$FILE/Criminal%20Code_en.pdf CRIMINAL CODE OF THE KYRGYZ REPUBLIC] {{Webarchive. link. (22 April 2021 (2006), Art. 18)
74. "Juvenile Justice Information Portfolio - Committee on the Rights of the Child - 3. State Party Reports: Lebanon".
75. [https://www.ilo.org/dyn/natlex/docs/ELECTRONIC/97659/134630/F-1373419708/LBY97659%20Eng.pdf Penal Code of Libya] {{Webarchive. link. (22 April 2021 (2014), Art. 80/81)
76. "Luxembourg Factsheet". youthpolicy.org.
77. "UNICEF Malaysia – Child Protection – Justice for Children". [[UNICEF]].
78. "Minimum Ages of Criminal Responsibility in Asia".
79. "Juvenile Justice Information Portfolio - Committee on the Rights of the Child - 3. State Party Reports: Maldives".
80. "Decreto por el que se expide la Ley Nacional del Sistema Integral de Justicia Penal para Adolescentes (art. 5)". Diario Oficial de la Federación.
81. "Criminal Code of Mongolia".
82. "Jeugdstrafrecht".
83. "Sections 21–22, Crimes Act 1961 No 43". Parliamentary Counsel Office (New Zealand).
84. "Children, Young Persons, and Their Families Act 1989".
85. "Legal Rights".
86. [http://www.lovdata.no/all/tl-19020522-010-005.html#46 Penal Code] {{Webarchive. link. (3 August 2021 Almindelig borgerlig Straffelov (Straffeloven) § 46 (changed of law 12 June 1987 nr. 51). Retrieved 19/7 – 2007.)
87. ""Making Their Own Rules" Police Beatings, Rape, and Torture of Children in Papua New Guinea".
88. "Los Sistemas de Justicia Penal Juvenil en América Latina Análisis Comparado".
89. (28 April 2006). "RA9344: Juvenile Justice and Welfare Act of 2006". Chan Robles Law Library.
90. (8 October 2013). "PNoy signs law retaining minimum age of criminal liability". [[Yahoo News]].
91. (28 February 2002). "En Banc Supreme Court resolution on Proposed Rule on Juveniles in Conflict With the Law". Chan Robles Law Library.
92. (28 January 2019). "House OKs bill lowering criminal responsibility to 12 on final reading". The Philippine Star.
93. (November 26, 2020). "The decade in review: Child rights advocates present 'NGO Alternative Report' on status of children's rights in PH". ChildFund International.
94. "Article 10 of Polish Penal Code of 1997".
95. "Przepisy ogólne".
96. Ana Cristina Pereira. (14 June 2012). "Responsabilidade criminal deve passar dos 16 para os 18 anos de idade". PÚBLICO.
97. "СТ 20 УК РФ. Статья 20. Возраст, с которого наступает уголовная ответственность".
98. [https://www.consigliograndeegenerale.sm/on-line/documento17088264.html Sanmarinese Penal Code] {{Webarchive. link. (28 October 2020 (2019), Art. 10 par. 1)
99. [https://www.consigliograndeegenerale.sm/on-line/documento17088264.html Sanmarinese Penal Code] {{Webarchive. link. (28 October 2020 (2019), Art. 10 par. 2, 3)
100. (2023-05-03). "Belgrade shooting: Teen made 'kill list' for Serbia school attack". BBC News.
101. "Penal Code".
102. (2020-02-08). "Juvenile Crimes in Singapore: Spare the Rod, Spoil the Child".
103. (14 November 2018). "Parliament adopts Child Justice Amendment Bill". Parliament of South Africa.
104. (4 June 2020). "Child Justice Amendment Act, 2019".
105. [https://www.boe.es/buscar/pdf/1995/BOE-A-1995-25444-consolidado.pdf Spanish Penal Code] {{Webarchive. link. (8 May 2020 (2019), Art. 19)
106. [https://www.boe.es/buscar/pdf/2000/BOE-A-2000-641-consolidado.pdf Spanish Regulation Law on the Penal Responsibility of Minors] {{Webarchive. link. (23 July 2020 (2012), Art. 1 par. 1)
107. [https://www.boe.es/buscar/pdf/1995/BOE-A-1995-25444-consolidado.pdf Spanish Penal Code] {{Webarchive. link. (8 May 2020 (2019), Art. 69)
108. "Sudan: New Law Amending Penal Code Takes Effect".
109. Riksdagsförvaltningen. (17 November 2021). "Slopad straffrabatt för unga myndiga vid allvarlig brottslighet Justitieutskottets Betänkande 2021/22:JuU5 - Riksdagen".
110. "Minimum Ages of Criminal Responsibility in Europe".
111. "Criminal Code of the Republic of China". Laws & Regulations Database of The Republic of China (Taiwan).
112. "Juvenile Justice Act". Laws & Regulations Database of The Republic of China (Taiwan).
113. [https://www.legislationline.org/download/action/download/id/1707/file/207b8150765af2c85ad6f5bb8a44.htm/preview CRIMINAL CODE OF THE REPUBLIC OF TAJIKISTAN] {{Webarchive. link. (22 April 2021 (2006), Art. 23)
114. "Mevzuat Bilgi Sistemi".
115. link. (3 August 2021)
116. "Age of criminal responsibility".
117. "Report on the Draft Justice (NI) Bill of the Northern Ireland Assembly's official website".
118. Interstate Commission for Juveniles. (2023-03-15). "Age Matrix".
119. (2021-08-12). "Age Boundaries in Juvenile Justice Systems".
120. Juvenile Justice GPS. (2016). "Jurisdictional boundaries".
121. (27 October 2014). "Uruguayans reject constitutional reform on criminal responsibility". GlobalPost.
122. UNICEF. "Análisis comparativo de la legislación nacional sobre justicia juvenil con la de otros países y revisión de experiencias latinoamericanas sobre programas de atención de adolescentes en conflicto con la ley penal entre 12 y 14 años.".