2012 Mangalore homestay attack

Government response

Karnataka Home Minister R. Ashok condemned the attack and said police would take strict action and would not tolerate such incidents.

Police

The government sent a senior police officer, Bipin Gopalakrishnan to visit the spot and investigate. Based on his extensive investigation, Gopalakrishnan made it clear that the boys and girls were colleagues. He also said that there was no use of drugs or any other illegal material at the party and the group of youngsters wanted to leave the home stay by 7:30 pm.

Karnataka State Women's Commission

The Women's Commission, which is not an investigating agency, contradicted the police findings. Its chairman, C. Manjula, continued to insist that it was a rave party, despite police confirming no drugs were involved. She asked the home ministry to investigate the victims, and claimed they were involved in human trafficking.

Manjula also blamed "pseudo-feminists" for allegedly not raising their voice over other instances of atrocities against women.

She claimed that people at the homestay were consuming drugs, and blamed the "irresponsible" district administration "for such behaviour of youths". The chairperson also demanded unlicensed homestays in Mangalore be shut down and asked home ministry to "initiate an inquiry into the antecedents of the two boys" who were victimized.

Commission report

The Commission submitted a report to the Home Ministry on 29 July.

The report recommends investigation into whether the 'boys who organised the birthday party had misled the girls'. In direct contradiction to the police investigation, chairman Manjula claimed that people at the homestay were consuming drugs, and blamed the "irresponsible" district administration "for such behaviour of youths".

The Commission also recommended the use of a separate cell for missing trafficked women.

It also demands that the father of one of the girls at the party, who is a police official, should be transferred out of the district.

Legality of Homestay

Loretta Rebello is the proprietor of the homestay 'Morning Mist'. One of the victims claimed that they paid a sum of Rs 10,000 for five hours (2.30 pm to 7.30 pm) to party in the 'Morning Mist,' a bungalow with many bedrooms.

Mangalore City Corporation Officer Manjunath Shetty said Loretta Rebello did not possess any commercial licence to run the homestay. Deccan Herald reports Rebello started renting it out on hourly basis about two years ago.

Public reaction

Prohibitory order were immediately slapped on the city. Colleges in the city stayed closed for a day in protest.

Seminar of C Manjula

Kannada thinker M Chidananda Murthy, senior advocate Pramila Nesargi, Women's Commission head C Manjula and KSTB chairperson Sacchinanda Hegde said the victims were under the influence of alcohol.

They claimed alcohol was the main reason for attack at the Morning Mist Homestay in Mangalore. Sacchinanda Hegde insisted that the 5 girls and 2 boys were part of a rave party. He further claimed media portrayed it as a birthday bash as a daughter of a police official was present at the party and claimed officials had found beer bottles at the homestay.

References

References

1. (5 August 2012). "The rise of a moral vigilante in Karnataka". Indian Express.
2. "Hindu Jagaran Vedike (HJV) south regional chief not keen on electoral role". The Times Of India.
3. (15 August 2012). "NCW to probe attack on birthday party". Times of India.
4. Mangalore. (2012-07-28). "'Moralists' molest women". Deccanherald.com.
5. (28 July 2012). "Mangalore: Girls thrashed for partying, 4 arrested". News18.
6. "Karnataka Deputy CM confirms arrest of eight alleged rave party attackers in Mangalore".
7. [http://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/Mangalore/article3700530.ece ''Mangalore Homestay Attack''.] The Hindu. Retrieved 4 August 2012.
8. [http://www.thesundayindian.com/en/story/a-reporters-tale-of-mangalore-incident/14/38393/ ''A Reporter's Tale of Mangalore Incident''.] {{Webarchive. link. (4 September 2021 The Sunday Indian. Retrieved 4 August 2012.)
9. Jaideep Shenoy. (2012-08-02). "Morning Mist Home Stay attack arrests now goes up to 22 - Times Of India". Articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com.
10. (2012-08-09). "Welcome". Bellevision.com.
11. [https://archive.today/20130117213336/http://daily.bhaskar.com/article/BAN-wc-chairperson-demands-inquiry-into-antecedents-of-boy-victims-3608085-NOR.html ''BAN wc Chairperson Demands Inquiry into Antecedents of Boy Victims.''] Retrieved 4 August 2012.
12. (2012-08-10). "A sham report by women's commission on the Mangalore home stay attack". The Asian Age.
13. "Neighbours came to know from TV".
14. (2012-07-31). "Mangalore students protest; say city is unsafe - Bangalore - DNA". Dnaindia.com.
15. "Alcohol blamed for homestay attack".