2000 Dharmapuri bus burning

Background

Soon after coming to power in Tamil Nadu in 1996, the Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (DMK) party filed a series of corruption cases against former chief minister and AIADMK general secretary Jayalalithaa and other ministers and bureaucrats in her government. In the Pleasant Stay hotel case, a special-court ruling by Justice V. Radhakrishnan convicted Jayalalithaa and sentenced her to one year of "rigorous imprisonment". The ruling led to statewide protests and violence, including damage to public property by AIADMK members. Protests in Elakiyampatti, Dharmapuri were led by AIADMK Dharmapuri Union Secretary D. K. Rajendran and other AIADMK party workers, including former Dharmapuri secretary Nedu (Nedunchezhiyan), MGR Forum functionary Madhu (Ravindran), and former panchayat president P. Muniappan.

{{anchor|Incident}}Burning

Seventy students from Tamil Nadu Agricultural University, returning from a study tour, were separated by gender on two buses. During their trip, they learned about Jayalalithaa's conviction in the Pleasant Stay hotel case. Latha (a lecturer accompanying the students) called TNAU's vice-chancellor, who recommended that they go to a safe place and return to Coimbatore when it was safer. They tried to drive to the district collector's office, but were unable to reach it due to traffic obstruction. The party workers threw petrol bombs into the bus containing 44 female students and two lecturers. The front of the bus caught fire, and the flames spread backward. Since the bus's back door was locked and the keys were unavailable, lecturers Latha, Akila, and several students left the other bus and broke through the back door to pull out the students. Three female students (Hemalatha from Chennai, V. Gayathri from Virudhachalam and Kokilavani from Namakkal) were burned to death, and 16 others were injured. The bus burning was broadcast the following day on Sun TV.

Aftermath

By 6 November 2001, all eleven witnesses had become hostile during cross-examination in Krishnagiri. The witnesses included three Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation drivers and people working in, or owning, establishments near the incident location. Drivers Saleem Basha of the Coimbatore-Hosur bus and Kamaraj recanted initial statements made to the CB-CID that they could identify the persons involved; they drove buses which were damaged that day in Erapatti and near the Patchaiamman temple, respectively.

The burning angered the student community. Schools and colleges were asked to close for a week, and students statewide held silent protest marches condemning the act. Chief Minister M. Karunanidhi ordered a CB-CID investigation, and Jayalalithaa demanded a CBI probe to ensure a fair trial. During the initial trial at Krishnagiri Court, 20 witnesses became hostile. N. P. Veerasamy, Kokilavani's father, appealed to the Madras High Court for a change of venue; AIADMK had returned to power in Tamil Nadu, the case prosecutor was appointed by the party, and the accused were AIADMK functionaries and party activists. The high court halted the trial; Judge V. Kanagaraj called it a "colossal failure and eyewash", and ordered a retrial at Salem Court. After a series of delays in appointing a special public prosecutor and problems with missing case bundles, the trial progressed. Seven years after the burning, on 15 February 2007, the Salem court sentenced three AIADMK members to death and 25 others to seven years' imprisonment. Two others were acquitted, and one died during the investigation. The judgment (including the three capital sentences) was upheld by Madras High Court on 6 December 2007, and the Supreme Court on 30 August 2010. However, the sentences were commuted to life imprisonment after defence lawyers L. Nageswara Rao and Sushil Kumar said that the AIADMK mob only aimed to damage buses, not kill; they had acted impulsively. The Supreme Court of India then accepted their argument of diminished responsibility. It was learned that Dharmapuri AIADMK leader D. K. Rajendran, the first suspect in the case which organized the road protest (with a seven-year conviction which was reduced to two years), held four positions in a cooperative milk society become known. Rajendran later resigned after the Madras High Court expressed "deep anguish and displeasure" that a convict could hold positions despite being disqualified. A granite memorial with the names of the three victims was built at the Tamil Nadu Agricultural University hostel; all were 20 years old at the time of their deaths.

The AIADMK-ruled Tamil Nadu government attempted to release the three suspects in the bus burning. According to prison sources, at least 1,500 prisoners would benefit from the government's general amnesty, which included the three convicts and was seen as a tactical move by the party. On 19 November 2018, the AIADMK members convicted in the bus burning were released. Veerasamy the father of Kokilavani one of the girls burnt alive criticized the release of the convicts and called it a "Murder of Justice".

{{anchor|Timeline}}Case timeline

:On 2 February, AIADMK chief Jayalalithaa was sentenced by a special court to a one-year imprisonment for her role in the Kodaikanal Pleasant Stay hotel case. AIADMK protesters set fire to the Tamil Nadu Agricultural University bus. Three students were burned to death, and 16 others were injured. Tamil Nadu Chief Minister M. Karunanidhi ordered a CB-CID investigation, and Jayalalithaa insisted on a CBI probe. On 3 February, three AIADMK members and 25 others were convicted. :Up to 20 witnesses turned hostile before the trial in Krishnagiri, and the Madras High Court transferred the case to Salem District Court. Missing case files and the appointment of a special prosecutor delayed the trial. :The Salem court sentenced the three AIADMK men to death on 16 February, a verdict upheld by the Madras High Court on 6 December. :On 30 August, the Supreme Court upheld the Madras High Court ruling. :On 4 March, the three convicts filed a review petition in the Supreme Court seeking to commute their death sentences. Seven days later, the court commuted their sentences to life imprisonment. :The Tamil Nadu government issued an orders to release over 1,600 long-time prisoners, including the Dharmapuri bus-burning convicts, on 1 February to mark the birth centenary of former Chief Minister M. G. Ramachandran (MGR). In October, the governor rejected the recommendation to release the three convicts. The following month, however, the Tamil Nadu government reiterated its recommendation to release the trio; the governor approved the recommendation this time, and they were released from Vellore Central Prison on 19 November.

In popular culture

The Tamil language film Kalloori was released in December 2007, days before the Madras High Court upheld the Salem court judgment. The film's climax was the bus-burning incident and, after public and media demands, its ending was changed.

References

References

1. (12 March 2016). "TN bus burning case: SC commutes death sentence of 3 to life". [[The Times of India]].
2. (15 February 1007). "28 AIADMK men convicted in bus burning case". DNA.
3. (3 February 2000). "3 burnt alive". [[The Hindu]].
4. Rajasekaran, Ilangovan. (13 November 2019). "Premature release of all Melavalavu murder convicts sparks outrage in Tamil Nadu".
5. (17 February 2007). "Death for 3 AIADMK men in Dharmapuri bus burning case". The Hindu.
6. S., Vijay Kumar. (20 November 2018). "Dharmapuri bus burning case T.N governor explains why he agreed to set free life convicts".
7. Suchitra Vijayan. (15 July 2016). "Wait, Murderous Bus-Burning AIADMK Members Were 'Victims' Of Mob-Think? The Apex Court Thinks So". Huffington Post.
8. (11 March 2016). "Dharmapuri bus burning: SC commutes death sentence to life imprisonment". [[Business Standard]].
9. K M Vijayan. (23 March 2016). "SC ruling on Dharmapuri bus burning a misinterpretation". [[The Times of India]].
10. (11 March 2016). "SC commutes death penalty of Dharmapuri bus burning convicts to life". The Hindu.
11. Shanmughasundaram J. (19 November 2018). "Dharmapuri bus burning case: Three life convicts released from Vellore Jail". [[The Times of India]].
12. (3 February 2000). "Jayalalitha convicted in hotel case". The Hindu.
13. (3 February 2000). "Hotel Case Verdict: AIADMK volunteers go berserk". [[The Hindu]].
14. Sanjay K Singh. (7 September 2010). "SC upholds death for Amma's boys 3 AIADMK Workers Who Burnt Alive College Girls During Protest Against Jaya's Conviction Join Death Row". [[The Times of India]].
15. (29 April 2000). "AIADMK members among 31 chargesheeted". [[The Hindu]].
16. J Venkatesan. (4 March 2016). "Was upset with Jaya conviction, plead 3 AIADMK men on death row for burning bus". Deccan Chronicle.
17. (22 June 2005). "Sun TV news editor deposes in bus-burning trial". [[The Hindu]].
18. D., Sivarajan. (6 November 2001). "10 more witnesses turn hostile in bus burning case".
19. "Schools and colleges ordered shut in Tamil Nadu".
20. (4 February 2000). "Bus burning incident: Jayalalithaa demands CBI inquiry". The Hindu.
21. (April 2021). "HC scraps 'eyewash' of bus burning trial". [[The Hindu]].
22. A Subramani. (31 August 2010). "How the bus burning case victims got justice HC Shifted Trial From Dharmapuri to a Salem Court". [[The Times of India]].
23. (7 December 2004). "Bus burning case: court directive to investigating agency". [[The Hindu]].
24. (18 February 2005). "Bus burning case bundles missing?". [[The Hindu]].
25. (16 February 2007). "Death for three AIADMK members". [[CNN IBN]].
26. (6 December 2007). "Madras HC upholds death penalty to AIADMK men". CNN IBN.
27. (30 August 2010). "Dharmapuri bus burning case: SC upholds death for three AIADMK workers". [[The Times of India]].
28. (28 January 2011). "Dharmapuri bus burning: SC stays execution of 3". Zee news.
29. A Subramani. (4 November 2013). "First accused in Dharmapuri bus burning case quits posts". [[The Times of India]].
30. (17 February 2007). "TNAU students pay homage to bus burning victims". The Hindu.
31. (19 November 2019). "AIADMK men convicted in Dharmapuri college bus burning case set free". The Hindu India.
32. (20 November 2018). "A murder of justice, says father of victim". [[The Times of India]].
33. "In the Supreme Court of India – Criminal Appellate Jurisdictional Criminal Appeal Nos. 127–130 of 2008". Supreme Court of India.
34. A G Nadar. "They burnt to death in front of our eyes'". Rediff News.
35. (22 May 2005). "Witnesses recall Dharmapuri bus burning incident". [[The Hindu]].
36. (19 December 2007). "Kalloori, with a different climax!". Yahoo Movies India.