1931 All-America college football team

Consensus All-Americans

Following the death of Walter Camp in 1925, there was a proliferation of All-American teams in the late 1920s. For the year 1931, the NCAA recognizes seven published All-American teams as "official" designations for purposes of its consensus determinations. The following chart identifies the NCAA-recognized consensus All-Americans and displays which first-team designations they received. The only unanimous All-America selections in 1931 were Tulane's Gerald "Jerry" Dalrymple and Notre Dame's Marchmont Schwartz.

Proliferation of All-American teams

In 1931, Damon Runyon wrote a column about the proliferation of "All-America" teams. He noted: "The 'All' boys are it, tooth and nail. They are 'All'-ing North, South East, and West. They will wind up 'All'-Americaing, the most virulent form of the 'All' plague that besets us every Winter. The late Walter Camp little realized what he was bringing upon the country. ... At the moment, Mr. Camp probably had no idea that he was sowing the seed of a fearful pestilence." Runyon noted that Camp's word was viewed as gospel. Still, with his passing "the rush to fill his shoes was prodigious," and the "'All' business became a national obsession."

All-Americans of 1931

Ends

• Jerry Dalrymple, Tulane (AP–1; UP–1; COL–1; CP–1; NEA–1; INS–1; WCFF; LIB; HSM; CH-1; LP; AAB)
• Vernon Smith, Georgia (AP-1; COL–1; NEA–2; INS–2; HSM; CP–1; CH-2; LP; UP-2)
• Henry Cronkite, Kansas State (AP–2; UP–1; NEA–1; INS-2; CP–3; CH-1)
• John Orsi, Colgate (AP–2; CP–2; NEA–2; INS-1; WCFF; CH-2; AAB)
• Paul Moss, Purdue (NEA–3; INS-3l CP–2; LIB; UP-3)
• George Koontz, SMU (CP-3)
• Bill Hewitt, Michigan (NEA-3)
• Garrett Arbelbide, USC (AP-3)
• Fred Felber, North Dakota (AP-3)
• Herster Barres, Yale (INS-3)
• Ray Sparling, USC (UP-2)
• Ralph Stone, California (UP-3)

Tackles

• Dallas Marvil, Northwestern (AP–1; NEA–3; INS-1; CP–1; CH-2; HSM; UP-2)
• Jesse Quatse, Pittsburgh (UP–1; COL–1; CP-2; WCFF; CH-1; AAB)
• Jack Riley, Northwestern (NEA–1; INS-2; WCFF; AAB; LIB)
• Paul Schwegler, Washington (AP–1; COL–1; INS-3; CP–2; UP-3)
• Joe Kurth, Notre Dame (AP–2; UP–1; NEA–1; INS–2; CP–3; LIB; LP)
• John "Jack" Price, Army (AP–3; CP–1; NEA–2; INS-1; CH-2; UP-3)
• Jim MacMurdo, Pittsburgh (AP–2; NEA–3; INS-3; HSM)
• Ira Hardy, Harvard (NEA–2; CH-1; LP)
• Hugh Rhea, Nebraska (AP-3)
• Ray Saunders, Tennessee (CP-3)
• Richard Tozer, California (UP-2)

Guards

• Biggie Munn, Minnesota (AP–1; UP–1; COL–1; NEA–1; INS–1; CP–1; HSM; CH-1; LP; WCFF; AAB)
• Johnny Baker, USC (AP–2; UP–1; NEA–1; INS–1; CP–2; WCFF; LIB; HSM; CH-2; LP; AAB)
• Herman Hickman, Tennessee (AP–3; COL–1; NEA–3; INS-3; CP–1; CH-1; UP-2)
• Frank "Nordy" Hoffman, Notre Dame (AP-1; NEA–2; INS-2; LIB)
• Joe Zeller, Indiana (NEA-2)
• Jim Zyntell, Holy Cross (CP-2)
• James Evans, Northwestern (AP–2; CP-3)
• Maurice Dubofsky, Georgetown (NEA-3)
• Greg Kabat, Wisconsin (AP–3; CP-3)
• Milton Leathers, Georgia (INS-2; UP-3)
• H. R. Myerson, Harvard (INS-3)
• Bill Corbus, Stanford (CH-2; UP-2)
• Aaron Rosenberg, USC (UP-3)

Centers

• Tommy Yarr, Notre Dame (AP–1; NEA–2; INS-1; WCFF; HSM; CH-2; AAB; UP-2)
• Maynard Morrison, Michigan (AP–3; COL–1; NEA-1; CP–3)
• Ralph Daugherty, Pittsburgh (AP–2; NEA–3; INS–3; CP–1; LP; UP-3)
• Ookie Miller, Purdue (UP-1; CH-1)
• Stan Williamson, USC (LIB)
• Clarence Gracey, Vanderbilt (CP-2)
• McDuffie, Columbia (INS-2)

Quarterbacks

• Barry Wood, Harvard (AP–1; COL–1; NEA–1; INS-1; CP–1; HSM; CH-2; UP-3)
• Austin Downes, Georgia (UP-2; CP-3)
• Bill Morton, Dartmouth (AP–2; NEA–2; INS-3; CH-1)
• Carl Cramer, Ohio State (AP-3)

Halfbacks

• Marchmont Schwartz, Notre Dame (College Football Hall of Fame) (AP–1; UP–1; COL–1; NEA–1; INS–1; WCFF; LIB; HSM; CH-1; LP; AAB)
• Ernie Rentner, Northwestern (College Football Hall of Fame) (AP-1; UP–1; COL–1; NEA–1; INS–1 [named as fullback by Hearst]; CP–1; WCFF; HSM [named as fullback]; CH-1; LP; AAB)
• Don Zimmerman, Tulane (AP–2; NEA–2; INS-1; CP–1; CH-2; UP-2)
• Bob Monnett, Michigan State (CP-1)
• Eugene McEver, Tennessee (AP–2; NEA–2; INS-2; CP–2; UP-3)
• Bud Toscani, St. Mary's (NEA-2)
• Cornelius Murphy, Fordham (CP-3; CH-2) {Murphy died from a ruptured blood vessel in the brain in December 1931}
• J. W. Crickard, Harvard (NEA-3)
• Albert J. "Mighty Atom" Booth, Jr., Yale (AP–3; INS-2)
• Weldon Mason, SMU (AP-3; UP-3)
• Ray Stecker, Army (UP-2; INS-3)

Fullbacks

• Gaius Shaver, USC (COL–1 [selected as fullback]; UP–1 [selected as quarterback]; NEA–3 [selected as quarterback]; INS–2 [selected as quarterback]; CP–1 [selected as fullback]; WCFF [selected as quarterback]; LIB; LP [selected as quarterback]; AAB)
• Erny Pinckert, USC (College Football Hall of Fame) (AP–1; NEA–1; INS–3 [picked as halfback]; LIB; HSM [named as halfback]; CH-1; UP-3)
• Johnny Cain, Alabama (UP–1; NEA–3 [picked as halfback]; INS-3; WCFF; CH-2; AAB)
• Ralston "Rusty" Gill, California (NEA–3; LIB; LP; UP-2)
• Orville Mohler, USC (AP-3; CP-2 [picked as quarterback])
• Jack Manders, Minnesota (CP-2)
• Bart Viviano, Cornell (AP-2)
• Clarke Hinkle, Bucknell (INS-2)
• Nollie Felts, Tulane (CP-3)

Key

Bold – Consensus All-American

Selectors recognized by the NCAA in consensus determinations

• AAB = All America Board
• AP = Associated Press
• COL = Collier's Weekly as selected by Grantland Rice
• INS = International News Service, the wire service of the Hearst newspapers
• LIB = Liberty magazine
• NEA = Newspaper Enterprise Association
• UP = United Press

Other selectors

• CP = Central Press Association, also known as the Captain's Poll, selected by a poll of the captains of the major football teams
• WCFF = Walter Camp Football Foundation
• HSM = All-American team selected by 18,006 fans through nationwide contest sponsored by clothier Hart, Schaffner and Marx
• CH = College Humor magazine
• LP = selected by Lawrence Perry, a former Princetonian who wrote a nationally syndicated sports column called For The Game's Sake

References

References

1. Runyon, Damon. (1931-12-03). "Runyon Makes One Selection for 'All' Eleven". Chester Times.
2. (2016). "Football Award Winners". National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA).
3. (December 6, 1931). "Shaver, Baker Picked on the All-American". The Los Angeles Times.
4. (December 6, 1931). "Grid Experts Select Cast Of All-Stars". The Salt Lake Tribune.
5. (December 5, 1931). "The 1931 All-America Team". The Daily Inter Lake.
6. (December 18, 1931). "Collier's Announces Its 1931 All America". Lincoln Evening Journal.
7. (December 5, 1931). "Stecker and Hinkle Get Grid Honors". The Evening News.
8. (2005). "ESPN College Football Encyclopedia". ESPN Books.
9. (December 14, 1931). "NEA Board Names All-America". The Anniston Star.
10. (December 4, 1931). "All-American Eleven Picked By U.P. Critics". The San Bernardino County Sun.
11. (December 4, 1931). "Second, Third Grid Teams on United Press All-Star Listing". The San Bernardino County Sun.
12. Bitt. (1931-12-09). "Real 1931 All-American Team Selected by College Captains". The Evening Independent ([[Massillon, Ohio]]).
13. "Walter Camp Football Foundation All-American Selections". Walter Camp Football Foundation.
14. (1931-12-11). "Mythical Team Nominated by Fans Announced". The Muscatine Journal and News-Tribune.
15. (1932-12-31). "All-America Selected by Coll. Humor". The Greeley Daily Tribune.
16. Perry, Lawrence. (1931-12-05). "Gill Named on Perry's U.S. Star Eleven: Baker and Shaver Also Honored by Eastern Grid Expert". [[Oakland Tribune]].