Steelers–Titans rivalry

History

Origins

When the American Football League (AFL) completed its merger with the National Football League (NFL) in 1970, three NFL teams were offered a $3 million payment to join the former AFL clubs in forming the newly established American Football Conference (AFC). While the Baltimore Colts and Cleveland Browns agreed to the move, the Pittsburgh Steelers were initially hesitant. Steelers owner Art Rooney ultimately agreed to the transition after discussing the matter with his son, Dan Rooney, noting that the financial compensation and the opportunity to preserve the rivalry with the Browns were significant factors.

While the teams that would form the National Football Conference (NFC) struggled to agree on a realignment proposal, the AFC teams quickly found an alignment. The Oilers, who were part of the AFL East before the merger simply because it was further east than the Kansas City Chiefs, were placed in the AFC Central with the Bengals, Browns, and Steelers, being the only team in the division that wasn't in or near Ohio. The Oilers were placed in the division at the insistence of Dan Rooney, much to the chagrin of Al Davis. The Oilers and Steelers became acquainted with each other right away, when the two teams met in the season opener of the 1970 NFL season in Pittsburgh, a 19–7 Oilers victory in the first-ever NFL game at Three Rivers Stadium. The two teams met again four weeks later at the Astrodome in Houston, a 7–3 Steelers victory. The opening season win would be the only time the Oilers would be ahead in the overall series; the series would be tied again in 1971, but since then the Steelers have had the overall series lead, currently at 43–31 in the regular season. At 78 meetings overall, the Oilers/Titans franchise has played the Steelers more than any other team in its history.

1970s

The rivalry initially lacked intensity, as the Steelers were emerging as a dominant force in the NFL during the 1970s, while the Oilers struggled significantly. However, the dynamic shifted in the latter part of the decade, when the Oilers developed into a competitive team and began challenging the Steelers for both division and conference supremacy. Unlike rivalries such as that between the Steelers and Browns, which were fueled largely by geographic proximity and fan engagement, the rivalry between the Steelers and the Oilers was characterized by a strong mutual dislike between the teams.

The two teams met in the AFC Championship Game two years in a row at Three Rivers Stadium, with the Steelers dominating the "Luv Ya Blue" Oilers 34–5 in 1978. The Steelers were expecting a closer encounter in the 1979 AFC Championship Game, which was marred by a controversial call in the third quarter when quarterback Dan Pastorini threw a pass to wide receiver Mike Renfro in the end zone. It was ruled incomplete, despite television replays clearly showing Renfro having possession of the ball with both feet in the end zone; even Steelers radio commentator Myron Cope thought it was a touchdown. The Oilers had to settle for a field goal, and the Steelers would go on to win 27–13; the game itself would spark the debate on whether or not the NFL should have instant replay, which would go into effect for the 1986 NFL season.

1980s

Both teams hit hard times once the 1980s hit, with the Oilers quickly sinking to the bottom of the division and the Steelers hit with the retirement of several key players from the dynasty years, only remaining competitive due to the AFC Central as a whole being weak during this time. By 1987, the Oilers began to have sustained playoff appearances again under quarterback Warren Moon and controversial coach Jerry Glanville while the Steelers were still rebuilding from their mid-1980s dropoff.

However, the two teams would clinch a wild card spot in the playoffs in 1989, the only year Chuck Noll would win NFL Coach of the Year. During a regular season matchup in Pittsburgh earlier in the year, following the game the usually stoic Noll in post game handshake grabbed Glanville and told him he'd better watch out or he'd get jumped on. This was in reaction to Glanville's earlier comments on how the Oilers field was the 'house of pain' and his prediction that his players would intentionally hurt the Steelers; bounties are now outlawed in the NFL. In the Wild Card round, the Steelers, despite having been swept by the Oilers in the regular season, defeated the Oilers in overtime 26–23. Glanville would be fired from the Oilers after the game.

1990s

The Oilers were the class of the division during the early 1990s, winning two division championships, while the Steelers gradually re-emerged as contenders under head coach Bill Cowher. The two would exchange division titles in 1992 and 1993 before the Steelers became the dominant team in the AFC Central due to Oilers owner Bud Adams going through with his threats to blow up the team and rebuild if it didn't go to the Super Bowl.

During this time, both teams were fighting for new stadiums in order to remain competitive. While the Steelers would eventually get one in Heinz Field (although they would've stayed in a refurbished Three Rivers Stadium if the financing plan for Heinz Field fell through), the Oilers couldn't get a new stadium built in Houston and announced they were moving to Nashville for the 1998 NFL season. The Steelers (along with the Bengals) were one of six teams to vote against the proposal out of respect to Houston fans due to the rivalry as well as having recently encountered similar issues with the Browns. The Oilers ended up moving to Tennessee for the 1997 season instead due to lame duck status in Houston; Houston would receive a new NFL team in 2002 when the Houston Texans started play.

Due to the size of Vanderbilt Stadium in Nashville (only 41,000 seats), the now-Tennessee Oilers decided to play at the Liberty Bowl Memorial Stadium in Memphis as an interim home until what would become LP Field was ready to open in 1999. Ironically, most of the crowds in Memphis were more than small enough that Vanderbilt Stadium would've been able to accommodate them. Despite that, the Oilers were planning on playing there again for 1998. That changed after the final game of the season, when the Oilers faced the Steelers in front of 50,677 fans—the only crowd that could not have been reasonably accommodated at Vanderbilt. However, Steeler fans made up the great majority of the crowd (at least three-fourths, by one estimate), despite the fact that it was a meaningless game for both teams (the Steelers already clinched the AFC Central and a first-round bye in the playoffs, Oilers were already eliminated from the playoffs) and the Steelers were resting several starters. The Oilers won 16–6 against mostly Steelers backup players. Adams was so embarrassed that he abandoned plans to play the 1998 season in Memphis and ended up moving to Vanderbilt after all. Adams would rename the team the Titans in 1999 when Adelphia Coliseum (now LP Field) opened.

In their final season as divisional rivals, the Steelers and Titans met on October 29 in Pittsburgh. The Steelers crushed the Titans 34–7, capitalizing on four turnovers and scoring 27 unanswered points.

Since realignment

The NFL realigned its teams for the 2002 season, placing the Titans in the new AFC South while the Steelers remained in the now-renamed AFC North. Although the two teams wanted to remain together in the same division, they were not able to because the Titans' vote was controlled by the NFL since it recently relocated while the Steelers (along with the Bengals) were required to remain in the same division with the Browns as a result of the NFL's settlement with the city of Cleveland in 1996. Additionally, there was some sentiment to keep the Ravens in the same division as the Steelers, although at least one realignment proposal did have the Titans in the AFC North. Despite that, the Steelers and Titans have still played each other rather frequently, having only not played each other four times. Despite no longer being divisional rivals, players from both the Titans and Steelers have not forgotten the intensity of their past matchups.

The Steelers and Titans first met as non-divisional opponents in the 2002 season on November 17. Entering the game, both teams were in first place in their respective divisions. The Titans would win 31–23. However, controversy arose after the game when Steelers linebacker Joey Porter accused Titans strength and conditioning coach Steve Watterson of throwing coffee on him following a tackle on Titans quarterback Steve McNair. Watterson later claimed it was soup, not coffee, and that the incident was accidental. Additionally, Steelers quarterback Tommy Maddox suffered a temporary paralysis after a hit by Titans linebacker Keith Bulluck and was rushed to the hospital for evaluation.

The two teams later met in the playoffs, with the Titans serving as the home team for the first time in the history of the rivalry. The game was closely contested and went back and forth before heading into overtime. In overtime, Titans kicker Joe Nedney kicked the game-winning 26-yard field goal to secure a 34–31 victory for Tennessee.

Perhaps the most notable matchup since realignment came in 2008, when the two met in Nashville in a game that determined home-field advantage in the AFC playoffs and a possible preview of the AFC Championship Game. LenDale White and Keith Bulluck stepped on a Terrible Towel after the Titans' 31–14 victory. Pittsburgh's Larry Foote responded, "They deserved to do that, they whooped us, they deserve to celebrate and, hopefully, we'll see them again," Former Steelers head coach Bill Cowher, by this point working for CBS as an analyst on The NFL Today, mentioned on The NFL Today (while clearly showing bias in favor of his former team) that such antics can come back to haunt teams. Tennessee proceeded to lose eight consecutive games, including their playoff game against the Ravens and their 2009 Week 1 game against the Steelers, capped off by a 59–0 blowout to the New England Patriots, the Titans' worst loss ever.

The Steelers edged the Titans 13–10 to open the 2009 season and won again 38–17 in 2010. In 2012, Matt Hasselbeck led the Titans to a close 26–23 win, and in 2013, Jake Locker led a 16–9 win over the Steelers. On January 13, 2014, the Titans hired former Steelers' tight end coach Ken Whisenhunt as their new head coach.

The two teams met on November 16, 2017 at Heinz Field, in primetime on NBC and NFL Network. The game, part of the NFL Color Rush and the Steelers first color-on-color game since World War II, was won by Pittsburgh, 40–17.

The two teams met on October 25, 2020, in Nashville, with both clubs entering with identical 5–0 records. During a game rescheduled from its previous start date due to a COVID-19 outbreak within the Titans organization, Pittsburgh jumped to a 24–7 halftime lead before Tennessee rallied in the second half. The game was decided when Titans kicker Stephen Gostkowski missed a potential game-tying field goal at the end of regulation, allowing the Steelers to win 27–24 and attain its first 6–0 start since 1978.

Season-by-season results

|- | | Tie 1–1 19–7** 7–3** | Tie 1–1

| | Tie 1–1 23–16** 29–3** | Tie 2–2 | |- | 24–7** 9–3** | Steelers 4–2 | |- | 33–7** 36–7** | Steelers 6–2 | |- | | Tie 1–1 13–10** 13–7** | Steelers 7–3

| 24–17** 32–9** | Steelers 9–3

| 32–16** 21–0** | Steelers 11–3 | |- | | Tie 1–1 27–10** 27–10** | Steelers 12–4 | |- | | Tie 1–1 24–17** 13–3** | Steelers 13–5 | Oilers' win handed the Steelers their first loss of the season after a 7–0 start and would also be their only home loss that season. Following the loss, the Steelers went on a 18-game home winning streak. |- style="font-weight:bold; background:#f2f2f2;" | 1978 playoffs 34–5 | | Steelers 14–5 | AFC Championship Game. Steelers win Super Bowl XIII. |- | | Tie 1–1 38–7** 20–17** | Steelers 15–6 | |- style="font-weight:bold; background:#f2f2f2;" | 1979 playoffs 27–13 | | Steelers 16–6 | AFC Championship Game. The game was marked by controversy over the Mike Renfro no-touchdown call. Steelers win Super Bowl XIV.

| | Tie 1–1 31–17** 6–0** | Steelers 17–7

| | Tie 1–1 26–13** 21–20** | Steelers 18–8 | |- | | no game 24–10** | Steelers 19–8

| 17–10** 40–28** | Steelers 21–8 | |- | | Tie 1–1 35–7** 23–20 (OT)** | Steelers 22–9

| 20–0** 30–7** | Steelers 24–9 | |- | 21–10** 22–16 (OT)** | Steelers 26–9

| 23–3** 24–16** | Steelers 26–11 | Game in Pittsburgh was the first win for Warren Moon in the series. Oilers record their first season series sweep against the Steelers. |- | | Tie 1–1 34–14** 37–34** | Steelers 27–12

| 23–16** 27–0** | Steelers 27–14 | |- style="font-weight:bold; background:#f2f2f2;" | 1989 playoffs | 26–23 (OT) | Steelers 28–14

| | Tie 1–1 20–9** 34–14** | Steelers 29–15 | |- | | Tie 1–1 26–14** 31–6** | Steelers 30–16 | |- | 21–20** 29–24** | Steelers 32–16

| 26–17** 23–3** | Steelers 32–18 | |- | 30–14** 12–9 (OT)** | Steelers 34–18 | |- | 21–7** 34–17** | Steelers 36–18

| | Tie 1–1 30–16** 23–13** | Steelers 37–19

| | Tie 1–1 37–24** 16–6** | Steelers 38–20

| 41–31** 23–14** | Steelers 38–22

| 47–36** 16–10** | Steelers 38–24

| |- 34–7** |Heinz Field 40–26

| 31–23** | Adelphia Coliseum | Steelers 40–27 | Tommy Maddox was knocked out with temporary paralysis and had to sit out several games in the ensuing weeks; he returned late in the season. |- style="font-weight:bold; background:#f2f2f2;" | 2002 playoffs 34–31 (OT) | Adelphia Coliseum | Steelers 40–28

| 30–13** | Heinz Field | Steelers 40–29 | |- | 34–7** | Heinz Field | Steelers 41–29

| 31–14** | LP Field | Steelers 41–30

| 13–10 (OT)** | Heinz Field | Steelers 42–30

| 19–11** | LP Field | Steelers 43–30

| 38–17** | Heinz Field | Steelers 44–30

| 26–23** | LP Field | Steelers 44–31 | |- | 16–9** | Heinz Field | Steelers 44–32

| 27–24** | LP Field | Steelers 45–32

| 40–17** | Heinz Field | Steelers 46–32 |

| 27–24** | Nissan Stadium | Steelers 47–32

| 19–13** | Heinz Field | Steelers 48–32

| 20–16** | Acrisure Stadium | Steelers 49–32 |

| |- | Postseason | Steelers 2–0 | Tie 1–1 | AFC Wild Card: 1989 AFC Divisional: 2002 AFC Championship: 1978, 1979 |- | Regular and postseason | Steelers 29–12 | Tie 20–20 | |-

References

References

1. "All Matchups, Pittsburgh Steelers vs. Houston Oilers/Tennessee Oilers/Tennessee Titans".
2. (June 7, 2018). "Pittsburgh's Forgotten Classics: Titans vs. Steelers, 2005".
3. (September 18, 2005). "Houston-Pittsburgh rivalry one of NFL's best".
4. "Creating the NFL Schedule". NFL Enterprises, LLC.
5. Davis, Scott. (2018-04-19). "The NFL schedule is created with the help of a simple formula".
6. (2009-03-23). "NFL gives East teams a break traveling West".
7. Trapasso, Chris. "How Is the NFL Schedule Created?".
8. "How Does Scheduling Work In The NFL? {{!}} Understanding NFL Scheduling Formula".
9. Sherrington, Kevin. (February 1, 2011). "Dallas meeting in '66 saved Steelers from stinking". Dallas Morning News.
10. (October 22, 1977). "Steelers–Oilers Renew Rivalry".
11. (January 2, 1980). "Steelers, Oilers renew rivalry for AFC title".
12. (October 22, 2020). "Steelers-Titans: Looking back at the series' most memorable moments".
13. (October 21, 1978). "Steelers, Oilers Renew AFC Rivalry Tonight".
14. (September 18, 1983). "A new era: Something's missing from rivalry as Steelers, Oilers tangle".
15. (October 21, 1996). "Oilers inflict pain on Steelers".
16. (October 3, 1994). "Old rivalry wears a new look".
17. (November 13, 1998). "Oilers, Steelers NFL rivals once more".
18. (October 21, 1996). "Oilers rally way into tie for first".
19. (September 10, 1995). "Steelers–Oilers rivalry unchanged".
20. Cook, Ron. (June 22, 1998). "Plan B Flawed; Option Is Worse". [[Pittsburgh Post-Gazette]].
21. [https://www.nytimes.com/1996/05/01/sports/pro-football-nfl-owners-approve-move-to-nashville-by-the-oilers.html PRO FOOTBALL;N.F.L. Owners Approve Move To Nashville By the Oilers]. ''The New York Times''. Retrieved January 13, 2012.
22. Bouchette, Dan. [http://www.post-gazette.com/Steelers/20011029steele1029p3.asp Steelers-Oilers/Titans rivalry plays its final act in Pittsburgh under the Monday night spotlight]. [[Pittsburgh Post-Gazette]], 2001-11-29.
23. (October 26, 2001). "Titans, Steelers renew old rivalry Monday before switching divisions".
24. (November 25, 2001). "Steelers' big win motivates Titans".
25. [https://www.courant.com/2001/05/21/nfl-vote-on-realignment-nears/ Hartford Courant]
26. [https://www.nashvillepost.com/blogs/postsports/2013/9/4/titans_steelers_matchup_nothing_new_then_or_now Titans-Steelers matchup nothing new, then or now] ''[[Nashville Post]]'' (09/04/2013)
27. (September 6, 2005). "NFL report".
28. (September 28, 2003). "Different Divisions, same old Titans–Steelers rivlary".
29. (November 17, 2002). "New divisions, same old rivalry for Steelers, Titans".
30. (November 16, 2002). "Titans Beat Steelers 31-23". Associated Press.
31. (January 11, 2003). "Steelers–Titans rivalry heats up".
32. (July 17, 2025). "Tennessee Titans' best moments: Joe Nedney hits game-winning FG in NFL playoffs vs Steelers".
33. Bouchette, Ed. (December 22, 2008). "Steelers Notebook: Sacks record doesn't ease sting of loss". Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.
34. (22 December 2008). "Fisher unfazed but Cowher irked by Terrible Towel stomp".
35. (2014-01-13). "Ken Whisenhunt on Board with Titans".
36. (November 16, 2014). "Ken Whisenhunt's ties to Steelers make tonight's game different".
37. (17 November 2017). "Titans vs. Steelers RECAP, score & stats | NFL Week 11".
38. (2020-10-25). "Steelers Hold Off Titans, 27-24, Remain Undefeated – CBS Pittsburgh".
39. [https://www.espn.com/nfl/recap?gameId=400554421 Le'Veon Bell rumbles for 204 yards as Steelers rally past Titans] [[ESPN.com]] (11/18/2014)