Haliburton—Kawartha Lakes—Brock (provincial electoral district)

2009 by-election

The 2009 by-election in Haliburton—Kawartha Lakes—Brock unfolded as one of the more contentious and politically charged events in Ontario's recent electoral history. On February 4, 2009, a writ was issued for a by-election to be held on March 5, 2009. The contest was triggered by the resignation of sitting Progressive Conservative MPP Laurie Scott, who stepped down to make way for PC leader John Tory's return to the Ontario legislature—a controversial political maneuver that quickly became the focal point of the campaign.

Tory, a former leader without a seat, was attempting yet again to win elected office after losing his own seat in the 2007 provincial election. However, his attempt to return through Haliburton—Kawartha Lakes—Brock was fraught with challenges. Many local voters expressed strong opposition to Scott's resignation, with a February 9 local poll from the Lindsay Post showing that nearly 70 percent of respondents disapproved of her stepping down solely to enable Tory's candidacy. Almost half of those polled stated they were less inclined to vote PC as a result.

Tory's outsider status—he was based in Toronto and perceived as disconnected from rural concerns—only deepened local skepticism. His moderate stance on certain issues, including public funding for religious schools, further alienated parts of the traditionally conservative base, leading to decreased enthusiasm among PC voters and lower turnout for his campaign.

Challenging Tory was Rick Johnson, the Ontario Liberal Party candidate and former president of the Ontario Public School Boards' Association. Johnson had previously contested the riding in 2007 and resigned his presidency to oppose Tory's education policy, particularly his push for extending public funding to religious schools. In 2009, he returned with solid backing—the local Liberal riding association endorsed him unanimously.

The riding also saw interest from smaller parties. Brad Harness, leader of the marginal Reform Party of Ontario, criticized Tory as an "urbanite" unfit for rural representation, and declared plans to contest the by-election. However, despite the strong rhetoric, the party ultimately failed to register a candidate in time.

The Green Party of Ontario nominated Mike Schreiner, a well-regarded local food advocate, sustainable community champion, and entrepreneur, who would later become leader of the provincial Green Party.

In a surprising political upset, Rick Johnson defeated Tory, ending the latter's tenure as party leader shortly thereafter. The by-election is often remembered as a potent example of local voter backlash against perceived political opportunism and underestimation of rural political sentiment in Ontario.

Members of Provincial Parliament

| Assembly#=37 | PartyTerms#=2 | RepTerms#=1 | Assembly#=38 | RepTerms#=1 | Assembly#=39 | PartyTerms#=1 | RepTerms#=1 | #ByElections=1 | PartyTerms#=1 | RepTerms#=1 | Assembly#=40 | PartyTerms#=4 | RepTerms#=4 | Assembly#=41 | Assembly#=42 | Assembly#=43

Election results

--

|

2007 electoral reform referendum

References

Sources

• Elections Ontario Past Election Results
• Map of riding for 2018 election

References

1. (February 4, 2009). "Provincial Byelection Called in Haliburton-Kawartha Lakes-Brock". Office of the Premier of Ontario press release via Canada Newswire.
2. (February 9, 2009). "Poll shows Conservatives unhappy with Tory". Lindsay Post.
3. (January 19, 2009). "Liberal to challenge John Tory in by-election". The Globe and Mail.
4. Benzie, Robert. (January 14, 2009). "Reform to test 'urbanite' Tory in rural riding". Toronto Star.
5. Riley, Mary. (2009-01-15). "Green Party candidate steps forward". myKawartha.com.
6. "Summary of Valid Votes Cast for each Candidate". Elections Ontario.
7. "35 - Haliburton—Kawartha Lakes—Brock".
8. Elections Ontario. (2014). "Official result from the records, 029 Haliburton-Kawartha Lakes-Brock".
9. Elections Ontario. (2011). "Official return from the records / Rapport des registres officiels - Haliburton—Kawartha Lakes—Brock".
10. "By-Election 2009: Haliburton-Kawartha Lakes-Brock".