Alternative R&B

Etymology

"Alternative R&B" was once used by the music industry during the late 1990s to market neo soul artists, such as D'Angelo, Erykah Badu, and Maxwell. There has been a variety of discussion about the differing genre terms, with several critics describing the music under the broad category of "alternative R&B" or "indie R&B". The term "hipster R&B" has been commonly used, as has the term "PBR&B"—a combination of "PBR" (the abbreviation for Pabst Blue Ribbon, a beer most recently associated with the hipster subculture) and R&B. The first use of "PBR&B" was on Twitter by Sound of the City writer Eric Harvey in a 2011 post. Three years later, amazed and distressed at how far the term—meant as a joke—had traveled, Harvey wrote an extensive essay about it for Pitchfork. Slate suggests the name "R-Neg-B", as a reference to "negging". The genre has sometimes been called "noir&B". However, the terms are often criticized for "pigeonholing" artists into hipster subculture and being used in a derisive manner.

Characteristics

Barry Walters of Spin characterizes the unconventional style as an "exchange between EDM, rock, hip hop, and R&B's commercial avant-garde", and cites Kanye West's 808s & Heartbreak, Frank Ocean's Nostalgia, Ultra, and Channel Orange, the Weeknd's 2011 trilogy of mixtapes, Drake's Take Care, Miguel's Kaleidoscope Dream, Holy Other's Held, and How to Dress Well's Total Loss as works associated with alternative R&B. AllMusic's Andy Kellman cites the early albums of Bilal—1st Born Second and Love for Sale—as antecedents to the "left-field R&B" that developed in the late 2000s. According to Jim Farber of the New York Daily News, the Soulquarians collective of the late 1990s and early 2000s, which Bilal was a part of, "corral[ed] leaders of the alternative R&B movement like the Roots and D'Angelo". Janet Jackson's sixth studio album The Velvet Rope (1997) is cited as one of the genre's stylistic origins. Dee Lockett from Slate credits Aaliyah's musical style on her second studio album "One in a Million" for "giving rise to a new subgenre, loosely referred to as experimental R&B (or "PBR&B")". While NPR writer Stasia Irons stated Aaliyah's self-titled album "became a catalyst and bridge that created a smooth transition from '90s style R&B into Modern PBR&B".

Brandon Neasman of The Grio observes a "changing of the guard in R&B, from the smooth, cool heartthrobs to these vulnerable, off-kilter personalities" amid the prevalence of social media in society. Neasman finds the subject matter of "these new-wave artists" to be more "relatable" and writes of alternative R&B's characteristics:

Hermione Hoby of The Guardian writes that "the music is quietly radical" and observes "an ongoing, mutually enriching dialogue between indie and electronic musicians and R&B artists". Gerrick D. Kennedy of the Los Angeles Times feels that "the new movement feels like the most significant stylistic change in R&B since neo soul rolled around in the 1990s".

Response

There are two predominating opinions regarding alternative R&B as a classifier of sonic and lyrical characteristics within the larger R&B genre, the first of the two being a reluctant acceptance of its existence—if only for the sake of marketability.

Stereogum described the genre as a group of "co-conspirators, not a unified movement". Similarly in thought, How to Dress Well, while not offended by the term "PBR&B", finds it "tacky"; in an interview with Complex, he points out that "if you put records [released by other alternative R&B artists] side-by-side, me and whoever, like you're just not going to [hear] the same sounds, period", before proceeding to cite Miguel as an example. Miguel himself has said that he is "comfortable" with the term "indie R&B" because it "insinuates a higher art. Or a deeper or somehow more artistic delivery of rhythm and blues music. It suggests there's more artistry within a genre that has become more of a cliché of itself."

Frank Ocean, when first asked in an interview with The Quietus, whether he considers "Novacane" to be an R&B song, responded, "You're limiting it. And that's why I always say that about the genre thing, because that's what it does. When you say 'it's that', you listen to it in a certain way. And you might not necessarily miss it, but it's just inaccurate, and you'll miss a couple of things, contextually." He proceeds to point out that race and vocal delivery are stereotypical signifiers of R&B music, in turn forcing himself and his peers into a category they may not identify within; when considering Nostalgia, Ultra Ocean argues that if he were a different complexion, "People would listen to it and be like 'Yeah, he borrowed from R&B', but it's just not R&B, it's a lot of things, and you can't just call it 'R&B.'" Ocean also uses alternative R&B for challenging norms in hegemonic masculinity. Channel Orange has prevalent queer-coded lyrics and scenarios within the characters he portrays.

In an interview with The Guardian, FKA Twigs rejected the term by declaring, "Fuck alternative R&B!" She further explained: "It's just because I'm mixed race. When I first released music and no one knew what I looked like, I would read comments like: 'I've never heard anything like this before, it's not in a genre.' And then my picture came out six months later, now she's an R&B singer.'" The Fader echoes her sentiment, stating, "By adding the prefix, it sidelines R&B itself by implying it's not experimental, boundary-pushing or intellectual. It throws side-eye at the genre, while at the same time claiming to have discovered something worthy within it."

References

References

1. Flanagin, Jake. (October 7, 2014). "R&B 2.0". [[The New York Times]].
2. (25 November 2012). "What's that Racket?".
3. "Emo/New Wave Songs from Jordin Sparks, Mariah Carey & Jhene Aiko Lead Top 10 Most Popular R&B Singles of the Week. – Singersroom.com".
4. (2 November 2022). "How Hip-Hop and R&B Became One Genre".
5. Abebe, Nitsuh. (August 14, 2011). "PBR&B Ten Pack". [[New York (magazine).
6. Murray, Nick. (December 21, 2011). "Underwhelmed and Overstimulated, Part IV: The Joys lf Nicola Roberts and the Problem with Odd Future". [[The Village Voice]].
7. Beasley, Corey. (December 8, 2011). "The Best Producers of 2011". [[PopMatters]].
8. Holbrook, Emma. (November 11, 2014). "Sex, Race and Alternative R&B". [[Concrete (student newspaper).
9. Mitchell, Gail. (June 3, 2000). "Reinventing The Real: R&B Gets Its Groove".
10. Richards, M.T.. (August 19, 2013). "10 Unconventional R&B Acts You Should Listen To". [[Vibe (magazine).
11. (April 6, 2011). "Discussion: Hipster R&B Or Alternative R&B – Should The Genre Exist?". ThisIsRnB.
12. Fennessey, Sean. (March 23, 2011). "Love vs. Money: The Weeknd, Frank Ocean, and R&B's Future Shock". The Village Voice.
13. Harvey, Eric. (March 22, 2011). "Okay, so out of the nascent PBR&B thing of Weeknd, How to Dress Well, Frank Ocean, it's not even a question that Ocean is the best, right?".
14. Barshad, Amos. (March 24, 2011). "Hilarious New Subgenre Alert!". [[Vulture (blog).
15. Harvey, Eric. (October 7, 2013). "I Started a Joke: "PBR&B" and What Genres Mean Now". Pitchfork.
16. Wilson, Carl. (December 28, 2011). "Why was there so much whistling in pop this year?". [[Slate (magazine).
17. Merchand, Francois. (June 22, 2015). "Weekend Extra: On the road again to B.C.'s summer music festivals". [[The Vancouver Sun]].
18. Hudson, Alex. (August 28, 2015). "The Weeknd 'Beauty Behind the Madness' (album stream)". [[Exclaim!]].
19. Cummings, Jozen. (March 30, 2011). "You Say Hipster R&B, I Say Nappy-Headed Pop. Either Way, It's Offensive.". [[The Awl]].
20. Macpherson, Alex. (March 29, 2011). "Ready for the Weeknd? Most R&B fans have better things to listen to". The Guardian.
21. Walters, Barry. (August 22, 2012). "Frank Ocean, Miguel, and Holy Other Usher in PBR&B 2.0". [[Spin (magazine).
22. Kellman, Andy. (n.d.). "Airtight's Revenge – Bilal".
23. Farber, Jim. (June 24, 2001). "Bilal Set to Wow". [[New York Daily News]].
24. DJ Louie XIV. (June 16, 2015). "Can Janet Get a Hit?". [[The Huffington Post]].
25. (2022-10-07). "The Impact Of Janet's Creatively Liberating Album, 'The Velvet Rope'".
26. Lockett, Dee. (May 23, 2014). "Where Do I Start With Aaliyah?". [[Slate (magazine).
27. Stasia Irons. (July 24, 2017). "The 150 Greatest Albums Made By Women". [[NPR]].
28. Neasman, Brandon. (October 4, 2012). "Changing of the guard: How Frank Ocean, Miguel and more helped R&B find its soul again". [[The Grio]].
29. Hoby, Hermione. (November 8, 2012). "The Weeknd: Sounds and sensibility". [[The Guardian]].
30. Kennedy, Gerrick D.. (November 11, 2012). "Miguel helps lead the charge for an edgier kind of R&B artist". [[Los Angeles Times]].
31. DeVille, Chris. (April 30, 2014). "Indie Rock's R&B Movement Reaches Its Saturation Point". [[Stereogum]].
32. Diep, Eric. (September 18, 2012). "His Thoughts on the Term "PBR&B" – Who is How To Dress Well?". Complex.
33. Jonze, Tim. (February 8, 2013). "Miguel: the slow-burn success of a new R&B superstar". The Guardian.
34. Bradshaw, Melissa. (November 22, 2011). "'Imagery, And A Little Bit Of Satire': An Interview With Frank Ocean". [[The Quietus]].
35. (June 2015). "Resistant masculinities in alternative R&B? Understanding Frank Ocean and The Weeknd's representations of gender". European Journal of Cultural Studies.
36. Beaumont-Thomas, Ben. (August 9, 2014). "FKA twigs: 'Weird things can be sexy'". The Guardian.
37. Cliff, Aimee. (September 12, 2014). "FKA Twigs Is Right, "Alternative R&B" Must Die". [[The Fader]].